HomeMy WebLinkAbout0506 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
NINETEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN
AND FOR ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA
~ CIVIL DIVISION
CASE NO. 78 12 CA
JOHN M. MASCARA and °
SUSAN M. MASCARA, his wife, '~~,~~1415~~i~~~ f
Plaintiff s , ~ ~
~ ' '~AR r`~73
Vs. REtEIV:'p ~1 ~
~ D,.~;g~,} ~ ~ '
ALEXANDER J. SUBATCH and C;~cu;f J
d@`g°~ o'~," :
HAROLD H. GOLDMAN, r 9e .L~ j
Def endants ~~~«~~6~~ ~
/ . ~
~
~
~
~
ORDER DENYING MOTIONS TO DISMISS AND
GRANTING DEFENDANT, ALEXANDER J.
SUBATCH SUHII~iARY JUDGMENT
THIS MATTER came~on to be heard on March 13, 1978, on the
Motions to Dismiss of Defendants, ALEXANDER J. SUBATCH and
HAROLD H. GOLDMAN, and the Motions for Summary Judgment of the
Plaintiffs, JOHN M. MASCARA and SUSAN M. MASCARA, his wife, and ~ ~
L
~
,
. ,
the Defendant, ALLXANDER J. SUBATCH. The various Motions were
based on the file in this case, the Pleadings therein,~ the ~
Exhibits to the Pleadings and the Affidavit of ALEXANDER J. ~
. - ~
SUBATCH.
Plaintiffs appeared bytheir attorney, N. RICHARD SCHOPP, ~
and ALEXANDER J. SUBATCH appeared by his attorney, WILLIAM H.
E
. DIXON, and Defendant, HAROLD H. GOLDMAN, represented himself. -
3
- ,
On due consideration of the record and file and the arguments_ ¢
~
of counse], in this matter and~beinq otherwise duly advised in =
the premises, ,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Motion to Dismiss of Defendant, ~
$
HAROLD H. GOLDMAN, and the Motion to Dismiss of the Defendant,
ALEXANDER J: SUBATCH, is denied.
IT IS HEREBY FURTHER ORDERED that the Defendant, ALEXANDER
J. SUBATCH's, Motion for SwYUnary Judgment against the Plaintiffs,
~ JOHN M. MASCARA and SUSAN. M. MASCARA, his wife,~is granted and
that Summary Jud,gment be entered in favor of said Defendant,
~ ;
and against the Plaintiffs. ~
$
. - ~ f
~
f ~ ~
.
, _ ~~2
- ~
- " . _ . ~*,...a~'."~ ~ ~