Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation ReportFeb 26 08 04:02p 772461P--'9 p.8 EVALUATION REPORT FLORIDA DCA Title: Evaluation of Model DS-350 Commercial roll up door — alternate operation Report #: WD-2004-05R1 Manufacturer: Wayne Dalton 14512 Lincoln Way St. E Dalton, OH 44618 Technical Contact Dave Monsour, P.E. Manager, Wayne Dalton Rolling Steel Door Division Prepared by: Gordon Thomas, P.E. Florida # 46718 513-314-3653 Date: June 14, 2006 I. Introduction/ Scope Based on wind load test results & calculations from the direct drive chain operated DS-350 commercial roll up door, the following evaluation was conducted to estimate the wind load performance of the motor operated, manual push up and reduced drive chain operated DS-350 commercial roll up doors. II. Reference Material The following items were used to prepare the evaluation report: A. DS-350 Test Reports, Hurricane Engineering & Testing, Inc Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-90. - HETI-01-1113, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 12' wide - HETI-01-1110, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 16' wide B. DS-350 Test Reports, AT] Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-97. - Report # 01-46385.04, 10' wide, +1- 37 psf - Report # 01-46385.05, 12' wide, +/- 26 psf - Report # 01-46385.06, 16' wide, +/- 28 psf - Report # 01-46385.01, 10' wide, +!- 44 psf - Report # 01-46385.02, 12' wide, +/- 40 psf - Report # 01-46385,03, 16' wide, +/- 34 psf C. Installation Instructions — DS-350 Commercial Roll Up Doors WD PN 291341 (2002) Feb 26 08 04: 02p Garai�--�- 7724619 p. 9 III. Evaluation A. Product Comparison B. C. IV In summary, the only product design difference between the direct drive chain operated door and the reduced drive chain operated, manual push up and the motor operated DS 350 commercial roll up door, are the bracket plates and barrel assembly construction. DS-350 Wind Load Design The primary structural components during wind load for a mini roll door are the curtain construction (curtain material, profile & thickness; wind lock design & attachment) and guide design. This is supported with calculations and test reports. Since the direct drive chain operation, reduce drive chain operation, manual push up and motor operation use the exact same design in these areas, the wind load performance would be identical. Conclusion The reduced drive chain hoist, manual push up and motor operated DS-350 commercial roll up door will achieve equal wind load performance results as compared to the direct drive chain operated DS-350 commercial roll up door. Limitation of Use Commercial roll up door Model DS 350 with manual push, reduced drive chain hoist or motor operation may be substituted for any application where the direct drive chain operated DS 350 has been tested and approved. This would require that all of the door components (guide angles, bolts, windlock spacing, etc) are equal or better then the tested DS 350 configuration. Certification of Independence of Evaluation Entity I hereby certify that (1) 1 have no financial interest in Wayne Dalton Corporation; (2) 1 am an independent licensed Professional Engineer in the State of Florida and; (3) 1 comply with the criteria of independence as stated in 9B- 72.110 (3), F.A.C. and 9B-72.110(4), F.A.C. Feb 26 08 04:03p GaarSaIes 77246L"^',9 p.10 EVALUATION REPORT FLORIDA DCA Title: Evaluation of Bracket Types for Model DS-350 Commercial roll up door Report #: WD-2004-09R1 Manufacturer: Wayne Dalton 14512 Lincoln Way St. E Dalton, OH 44618 Technical Contact Dave Monsour, P.E. Manager, Wayne Dalton Rolling Steel Door Division Prepared by: Gordon Thomas, P.E. Florida # 46718 Date: June 14, 2006 1. Introduction! Scope Based on wind load test results & calculations from the DS-350 commercial roll up door with stamped bracket plates, the following evaluation was conducted to estimate the wind load performance of the DS- 350 commercial roll up doors with T-shaped bracket plate. II. Reference Material The following items were used to prepare the evaluation report: A. DS-350 Test Reports, Hurricane Engineering & Testing, Inc. Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-90. - HETI-01-1113, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 12' wide - HETI-01-1110, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 16' wide B. ATI Test Reports Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-97. 1. 01-46385.04, 10' wide, +/- 37 psf, DS-350 2. 01-46385.05, 12' wide, +l- 28 psf, DS-350 3. 01-46385.06, 16' wide, +1- 28 psf, DS-350 4. 01-46385.01, 10' wide, +!- 44 psf, DS-350 5. 01-46385.02, 12' wide, +/- 40 psf, DS-350 6. 01-46385.03, 16' wide, +/- 34 psf, DS-350 C. Installation Instructions — DS-350 Commercial Roll Up Doors WD PN 291341 (2002) Feb 26 08 04:03p III. Evaluation 10 Gara��TloorSa 1 es Product Comparison 772461 G',�'� 9 The stamped bracket plate is 1 piece triangular shaped stamping that supports the fixed shaft above the opening. The T-shaped bracket plate is a 3 piece angle weldment in a triangular shape that supports the fixed shaft above the opening. Wind Load Design- alternate bracket plate The primary structural components during wind load for a commercial roll door are the curtain construction (curtain material, profile & thickness; wind lock design & attachment) and guide design. This is supported with calculations and test reports. Since the bracket plates are above the opening and are not critical to the wind load design, the wind load performance would be identical for the two bracket plate configurations. C. Conclusion The DS-350 commercial roll up door with stamped bracket plate will achieve equal wind load performance results as compared to the DS-350 with T shaped bracket plate. IV Limitation of Use Commercial roll up door Model DS 360 with T-shaped bracket plate may be substituted for any application where the DS-350 with stamped bracket plate has been tested and approved. This would require that all of the door components (guide angles, bolts, windlock spacing, etc) are equal or better then the tested DS-350 configuration. Certification of Independence of Evaluation Entity I hereby certify that (1) 1 have no financial interest in Wayne Dalton Corporation; (2) 1 am an independent licensed Professional Engineer in the State of Florida and; (3)1 comply with the criteria of independence as stated in 9B- 72.110 (3), F.A.C. and 9B-72.110(4), F.A.C. Feb 26 08 04:03p Garo o r S a I e s 772461P7-19 p.12 EVALUATION REPORT FLORIDA DCA Title: Evaluation of Insulated Roll up Doors - Models DS-7511001350 Report #: WD-2004-10R1 Manufacturer: Wayne Dalton 14512 Lincoln Way St. E Dalton, OH 44618 Technical Contact Dave Monsour, P.E. Manager, Wayne Dalton Rolling Steel Door Division Prepared by: Gordon Thomas, P.E. Florida # 46718 Date: June 14, 2006 Introduction! Scope Based on wind load test results & calculations from the DS-75 & DS-350 roll up door, the following evaluation was conducted to estimate the wind load performance for the insulated roll up doors. II. Reference Material The following items were used to prepare the evaluation report: A. DS-75 Test Reports, Hurricane Engineering & Testing, Inc Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-90. 1. HETI-01-1115, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 9' wide, DS 75 2. HETI-01-1117, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 10' wide, DS 75 3. HETI-01-1113, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 12' wide, DS 350 4. HETI-01=1110, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 16' wide, DS 350 B. ATI Test Reports Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-97. 1. 01-46385.04, 10' wide, +/- 37 psf, DS-350 2. 01-46386.05, 12' wide, +/- 28 psf, DS-350 3. 01-46385.06, 16' wide, +1- 28 psf, DS-350 4. 01-46385.01, 10' wide, +/- 44 psf, DS-350 �5. 01-46385.02, 12' wide, +/- 40 psf, DS-350 6. 01-46385.03, 16' wide, +/- 34 psf, DS-350 C. Installation Instructions—.DS-350 Commercial Roll Up Doors WD PN 291341 (2002) D. Installation Instructions — DS-75/100 Commercial Roll Up Doors WD PN 299013 (2002) Feb 26 08 04:03p Garap!.,?DoorSales 772461P719 p.13 III. Evaluation A. Product Comparison The insulated versions of the DS-75/100/350 are identical to the doors tested except these doors have an insulated backer added behind the curtain panels. B. Wind Load Design — Insulated roll up doors The primary structural components during wind load for a commercial roll up door are the curtain construction (curtain material, profile & thickness; wind lock design & attachment) and guide design. This is supported with calculations and test reports. An insulated door panel is equal to a non -insulated door panel since they both use the same profile, steel thickness and grade. The insulated backer does not degrade the performance of the curtain panel and may actually improve it slightly. C. Conclusion Insulated DS-75/100/350 roll up doors will achieve equal wind load performance results as compared to the non insulated DS-75/100/350. Consequently, any wind load test conducted on the DS-75/1001350 roll up doors could be used to estimate minimum performance for the insulated roll up doors. IV Limitation of Use Insulated DS-75/1001350 may be substituted for any application where the non insulated DS- 75/100/350 has been tested and approved. This would require that all of the other door components (guide angles, bolts, windlock spacing, etc) are equal or better then the DS- 75/100/350 configuration. Certification of Independence of Evaluation Entity I hereby certify that (1) 1 have no financial interest in Wayne Dalton Corporation; (2) 1 am an independent licensed Professional Engineer in the State of Florida and; (3)1 comply with the criteria of independence as stated in 913- 72.110 (3), F.A.C. and 96-72.110(4), F.A.C. Feb 26 08 04:04p Gara'-�u-)oorSales 772461"19 p.14 EVALUATION REPORT FLORIDA DCA Title: Evaluation of Lock Types for Models DS-75/100/350 Commercial Roll up doors Report #: WD-2004-11 R1 Manufacturer: Wayne Dalton 14512 Lincoln Way St. E Dalton, OH 44618 Technical Contact Dave Monsour, P.E. Manager, Wayne Dalton Rolling Steel Door Division Prepared by: Gordon Thomas, P.E. Florida # 46718 Date: June 14, 2006 Introduction/ Scope Based on wind load test results & calculations from the DS-75/100 & DS-350 roll up doors with exterior curtain locks and interior slide bolts respectively, the following evaluation was conducted to estimate the wind load performance of the DS-75/100 & DS-350 roll up doors with alternate lock configurations. Il. Reference Material The following items were used to prepare the evaluation report: A. DS-75 Test Reports, Hurricane Engineering & Testing, Inc Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-90. 1. HETI-01-1115, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 9' wide, DS 75 2. HETI-01-1117, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 10' wide, DS 75 3. HETI-01-1113, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 12' wide, DS 350 4. HETI-01-1110, Uniform Static Air Pressure, 16' wide, DS 350 B. ATI Test Reports Tested in accordance to ASTM E330-97. 1, 01-46385.04, 10' wide, +/- 37 psf, DS-350 2. 01-46385.05, 12' wide, +/- 28 psf, DS-350 3. 01-46385.06, 16' wide, +/- 28 psf, DS-350 4. 01-46385.0110' wide, +/- 44 psf, DS-350 -5, 01-46385.02:12' wide, +/- 40 psf, DS-350 6. 01-46385.03, 16' wide, +1- 34 psf, DS-350 C. Installation Instructions — DS-350 Commercial Roll Up Doors WD PN 291341 (2002) D. Installation Instructions — DS-75/100 Commercial Roll Up Doors WD PN 299013 (2002) Feb 26 08 04:04p III. Evaluation A. _1 C L Gara � ,71oorSa 1 es Product Comparison 7724612,7' 9 i p.15 An interior curtain lock is a flat bar & cover assembly mounted on the outside of the curtain approximately 4 ft from the floor. To open the door, the lock bar is slid to the inside of the opening so the curtain can be rolled up. In the closed and locked position, the lock bar is slid to the outside of the opening and engages into the guide assembly. This prevents the curtain from rolling up and can be pad locked for security. The slide locks are similar to the curtain locks except they are located on the bottom bar assembly. The lock designs prevent the curtain from moving up but offer little strength into or away from the opening as experienced during a positive or negative wind load. Wind Load Design- alternate lock types The primary structural components during wind load for a roll up door are the curtain construction (curtain material, profile & thickness; wind lock design & attachment) and guide design. This is supported with calculations and test reports. Since the curtain locks provided little structural strength to curtain deflection, the wind load performance would be identical for lock types. Conclusion The DS-75/100 roil up doors with bottom bar slide locks will achieve equal wind load performance results as compared to the DS-75/100 doors with curtain locks. Likewise, the DS-350 roll up doors with curtain locks will achieve equal wind load performance results as compared to the DS- 350 doors with bottom bar slide locks. Limitation of Use Commercial roll up door Model DS-75/100 with bottom bar slide locks may be substituted for any application where the DS-75/100 with curtain locks has been tested and approved. This would require that all of the door components (guide angles, bolts, windlock spacing, etc) are equal or better then the tested DS-75/100 configuration. In addition, commercial roll up door Model DS-350 with curtain locks may be substituted for any application where the DS-350 door with bottom bar slide locks has been tested and approved. ' This would require that all of the door components (guide angles, bolts, windlock spacing, etc) are equal or better then the tested DS-350 configuration. Certification of Independence of Evaluation Entity I hereby certify that (1) 1 have no financial interest in Wayne Dalton Corporation; (2) 1 am an independent licensed Professional Engineer in the State of Florida and; (3) 1 comply with the criteria of independence as stated in 913- 72.110 (3), F.A.C. and 9B-72.110(4), F.A.C.