HomeMy WebLinkAboutPRODUCT APPROVAL ASPHALT SHINGLES8/2/2021 Florida Building Code Online
Nt
Business & Professional Regulation
BCIS Home { Log In I User Registration I Hot Topics 1 Submit surcharge Stats & Facts Publications Contact Us .i BCIS Site Map' Links Search
H n(id
n Product Approval
USER: Public User
.�i'�sKvdi��uM
ProloctApproval Menu > Product or Application Search > Application List > Application Detail
FL # FL10674-R16
Application Type Revision
Code Version 2020
Application Status Approved
Comments
Archived
Product Manufacturer
Address/Phone/Email
Authorized Signature
Technical Representative
Address/Phone/Email
Quality Assurance Representative
Address/Phone/Email
Category
Subcategory
Compliance Method
Owens Corning
One Owens Corning Parkway
Toiedo, OH 43659
(740) 404-7829
greg.keel erOowenscorning.com
Greg Keeler
greg, keeler@owenscorning.com
Mel Sarcrant
1 Owens Corning PKWY
Toledo, OH 43659
(419)376-8360
Mel.sancrant@owenscornig.com
Roofing
Asphalt Shingles
Evaluation Report from a Florida Registered Architect or a Licensed Florida
Professional Engineer
Evaluation Report - Hardcopy Received
Florida Engineer or Architect Name who developed the Robert J.M. Nieminen
Evaluation Report
Florida License PE-59166
Quality Assurance Entity PRI Construction Materials Technologies, LLC
Quality Assurance Contract Expiration Date 01/01/2099
Validated By Sohn W. Knezevich, PE
Validation Checklist - Hardcopy Received
Certificate of Independence
Referenced Standard and Year (of Standard)
Equivalence of Product Standards
Certified By
FL_IG674 R16 CQI 2020 01 COI NIEMIN>wN.pdf
Standard
ASTM D1970
ASTM D3161
ASTM D3462
ASTM D7158
Year
2015
2016
2010
2019
Sections from the Code
https7/'floridabuilding.orglprlpr_app_dtl.aspx?param=wGEVXQwtDgtBNbEY5V%2boOT%2b6w7ahReglCQ8ucR6ixEAlpOjcK-FwWbw%3d%3d 1/2
8/2/2021
Florida Building Code Online
Product Approval Method
Date Submitted
Date Validated
Date Pending FBC Approval
Date Approved
Summary of Products
I
Method 1 Option D
12/11/2020
12/17/2020
12/26/2020
02/09/2021
FL #
Model, Number or Name
Description
10674.1
Owens Corning Asphalt Roofing
Shingles and Starters
3-tab, 4-tab, laminated, starter and hip & ridge shingles
Limits of Use
Approved for use in HVHZ: No
Approved for use outside HVHZ: Yes
Impact Resistant: N/A
Design Pressure: N/A
Other: Refer to ER, Section 5,
Installation Instructions
F 10674 R16 II 2020 12 11 FINAL ER OC ASPHALT
-SHINGLES FL10k74-R15 pdf
Verified By: Robert J, M. Nieminen PE - 59166
Created by Independent Third Party, Yes
Evaluation Reports
FL10674 R16 AE 2020 12 11 FINAL ER OC ASPHALT
SHINGLES FL10 74-R df
Created by Independent Third Party: Yes
Back Next
Contact Us :: 2601 Blair Stone Road, Tallahassee FL 32399 Phone: 850-487-1824
'rile State of Florida is an AA/EEO empfoyec Popes h 2 07-201 State of F orida.:: Privacy Statement :: Accessibility Statement :: Refund Statement
Under Florida law, email addresses are public records. if you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public -records request, do not send electronic
mail to this entity. Instead, contact the office by phone or by traditional mail. If you have any questions, please contact 850.487.1395. *Pursuant to Section 455,275(1),
Florida statutes, effective October 1, 2012, licensees licensed under Chapter 455, F.S. must provide the Department with an email address if they have one. The emails
provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record. If you do not wish to supply a personal address, please
provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public. To determine if you are a licensee under Chapter 455, F.S., please click here .
Product Approval Accepts:
Credit Card
Safe
https:/ifloridabuilding.orglprlpr_app_dt1.aspx?param=wGEVXQwtDgtBNbEY5V%2boQT%2b6w7ahReglCQ8ucR6ixEAIPOjcKTWWbw%3d%3d 2/2
NEMD I etc.
Certificate of Authorization 432455
353 Christian Street, Unit #13
Oxford, CT 06478
(203)262-9245
ENGINEER EVALUATE TEST CONSULT
REPORTEVALUATION
Owens Corning Evaluation Report 037940.02.12-Rll
One Owens Corning Parkway FL10674-R16
Toledo, OH 43659 Date of Issuance: 02/06/2012
(740) 404-7829 Revision 11: 12/11/2020
SCOPE:
This Evaluation Report is issued under Rule 61G20-3 and the applicable rules and regulations governing the use of
construction materials in the State of Florida. The documentation submitted has been reviewed by Robert Nieminen,
P.E. for use of the product under the Florida Building Code. The product described herein has been evaluated for
compliance with the 7" Edition (2020) Florida Building Code sections noted herein.
DESCRIPTION: Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles
LABELING. Labeling shall be in accordance with the requirements of the Accredited Quality Assurance Agency noted
herein and FBC 1507.2.7.1 / R905.2.6.1
CONTINUED COMPLIANCE: This Evaluation Report is valid until such time as the named product(s) changes, the referenced
Quality Assurance or production facility location(s) changes, or Code provisions that relate to the product(s) change.
Acceptance of our Evaluation Reports by the named client constitutes agreement to notify NEMD ETC, LLC of any
changes to the product(s), the Quality Assurance or the production facility location(s). NEMO ETC, LLC requires a
complete review of its Evaluation Report relative to updated Code requirements with each Code Cycle.
ADVERTISEMENT: The Florida Product Approval Number (FL#) preceded by the words "NEMO[etc. Evaluated" may be
displayed in advertising literature. If any portion of the Evaluation Report is displayed, then it shall be done in its
entirety.
INSPECTION: Upon request, a copy of this entire Evaluation Report shall be provided to the user by the manufacturer or
its distributors and shall be available for inspection at the job site at the request of the Building Official.
This Evaluation Report consists of pages 1 through 10.
Prepared by:
•�
Robert J.M. Nieminen, P.E. •cf The facsimile seal appearing was authorized by Robert
� ;�••.^, ?.�=
`'•. Nieminen, P.E. on 12/11/2020. This does not serve as an
Florida Registration Na, 591b6, Florida 1)C.4 ANE1983 '°'�''`'•`'' g d'm.e= +""' electrenicallysigned doeument.
CERTIFICATION OF INDEPENDENCE:
I. NEMD ETC, LLC does not have, nor does it intend to acquire or will it acquire, a financial interest in any company manufacturing or
distributing products it evaluates.
2. NEMD ETC, LLC is not owned, operated or controlled by any company manufacturing or distributing products it evaluates.
3. Robert Nieminen, P.E. does not have nor will acquire, a financial interest in any company manufacturing or distributing products for
which the evaluation reports are being issued.
4. Robert Nieminen, P.E. does not have, nor will acquire, a financial interest in any other entity involved in the approval process of the
product.
5. This is a building code evaluation. Neither NEW ETC, LLC nor Robert Nieminen, P.E. are, in any way, the Designer of Record for any
project on which this Evaluation Report, or previous versions thereof, is/was used for permitting or design guidance unless retained
specificallyfor that purpose.
02018 NEW ETC, LLC
NNEMOletc.
ROOFING SYSTEMS EVALUATION:
�•
Product Category; Roofing
Sub -Category: Asphalt Shingles
Compliance Statement: Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles, as produced by Owens Corning, have
demonstrated compliance with the following sections of the 71" Edition (2020) Florida Building Code through
testing in accordance with the following Standards. Compliance is subject to the Installation Requirements and
Limitations / Conditions of Use set forth herein.
STANDARDS:2.
Section Property Standard Year
1507.2.4, R905.2.3 Phys€cal Properties ASTM D1970 2015
1507.2.5, R905.2.4 Material standard ASTM D3462 2010
1507.2.7.1, R905.2.6.1 Wind Resistance ASTM D3161 2016
1507.2.7.1, R905.2.6.1 Wind Resistance ASTM D7158 2019
3. REFERENCES:
Entity Examination Reference Date
Owens Corning Declaration Equivalency Declaration 08/06/2019
PRI(TST5878) ASTM D1970 OCF-382-02-01 10/24/2017
UL LLC (CER9626) Physicals & Wind Resistance File R2453, Vol. 3 02/15/2007
UL LLC (CER9626) Physicals & Wind Resistance 20120516-R2453 05/16/2012
UL LLC (TST9628) Physical Properties OGCA20263 04/18/2006
UL LLC (TST9628) Wind Resistance 11CA34308 02/13/2012
UL LLC (TST9628) Physicals & Wind Resistance 4786093137 02/01/2014
UL LLC (TST9628) Wind Resistance 4786126532 02/10/2014
UL LLC (TST9628) Physical Properties Classification letter 02/13/2014
UL LLC (TST9628) Physical Properties Classification letter 10/02/2015
PRI (QUA911D) Quality Control Service Confirmation 04/05/2020
PRI (QUA9110) Quality Control Florida BCIS Current
4. PRODUCT DESCRIPTION:
TABLE 1: ASPHALT SHINGLE COMPONENTS
Type
Product
Plants
()
Material
Description
Standard
Starter Strip Shingle
H-TX, OR
Accessory
Starter Strip Plus
MN, OR
ASTM D3462
starter strips forasphalt roof shingles
SRS Top5hield Starter
MN, OR
Starter
Strips
Starter Shingle Roll
NH
ASTM D1970
mineral -surfaced, fiberglass -reinforced,
self -adhering SBS modified bitumen starter
Supreme'
GA, CA, CO, I -TX, NJ, OH,
ASTM D3462
fiberglass reinforced 3-tab asphalt
TN, OR, IL
roof shingles
Berkshire'
MN
ASTM D3462
fiberglass reinforced, 4-tab asphalt
roof shingles
Duration® Premium
CA, OR
Duration' Premium COOL
CA
Asphalt
TruDefinition° Duration'
Shingles
8
IN, CA, CO, I TX, FL, NJ, OH,
TruDefinition° Duration®
Designer Color Collection
MN, OR, GA, IL, TN
ASTM D3462
fiberglass reinforced, laminated
asphalt roof shingles
Oakridge®
GA, IN, CA, CO, H TX, I TX,
FL, NJ OH, TN
TruDefinition° Oakridge°
H-TX, I -TX
WeatherGuard® HP
TN
MEMO ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.02.12-Rli
Certificate of Authorizationt132455 7T" EDITION (2020) FBC NON•HVHZ EVALUATION FL10674-R16
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 2 of 10
ONEM01eft
TABLE 1: ASPHALT SHINGLE COMPONENTS
Type
Product
Plants
{
Material
Description
Standard
Berkshire' Hip and Ridge
Shingles with Sealant
MN
DuraRidgeO Hip and Ridge
Hip and
Ridge
Shingles with Sealant
MN
ASTM D3462
fiberglass reinforced, hi and rid e
P g
Shingles
a
asphalt roof shingles
ProEdgeg
GA, CA, OH, OR
WeatherGuard' HP Hip and
Ridge Shingles
TN
5.1 This is a building code evaluation. Neither NEMO ETC, LLC nor Robert Nieminen, P.E. are, in any way, the Designer
of Record for any project an which this Evaluation Report, or previous versions thereof, is/was used for permitting
or design guidance unless retained specifically for that purpose,
5.2 This Evaluation Report is not for use in FBC High Velocity Hurricane Zone jurisdictions (i.e., Broward and Miami -
Dade Counties).
5.3 This Evaluation Report pertains to above -deck roof components. Roof decks and structural members shall be in
accordance with FBC requirements to the satisfaction of the Authority Having Jurisdiction.
5.4 This Evaluation Report does not include evaluation of fire classification. Refer to FBC 1505 for requirements and
limitations regarding roof assembly fire classification. Refer to FBC 2603 for requirements and limitations
concerning the use of foam plastic insulation.
5_5 Wind Classification: Refer to Section 6 for installation requirements to meet wind classifications
I TABLE 2A: WIND CLASSIFICATIONS, ASPHALT SHINGLES
Product E FBC Table 1507.2.7.1 or R905.2.6.1
Berkshire'
Duration" Premium
Duration' Premium COOL
TruDefinitionW Duration'
TruDefinition' DuratiorY Designer Cofor Collection
Oakridge'
TruDefinition@ Oakridgea
WeatherGuard® HP
5.5.1 Classification by ASTM D7158:
ASTM D3161(F) & ASTM D7158(H)
ASTM D7158, Class H applies only to exposure category B or C and a building height of 60 feet or less. Calculations
by a qualified design professional are required for conditions outside these limitations. Contact the shingle
manufacturer for data specific to each shingle.
NEMO ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.02.12-1111
Certificate of Authorization #32455 7T" EDITION (2020) FBC NON-HVHZ EVALUATION FL10674-1116
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page a of 10
0(4NrIkAn10*r
TABLE 2113: WIND CLASSIFICATIONS, STARTER STRIPS AND HIP & RIDGE
Type
Product
FBC Table 1507.2.7.1 or R905.2.6.1
Starter Strips
Starter Strip Shingle
ASTM D3161, Class F
Starter Strip Plus
SRS TopShield Starter
Hip & Ridge
Shingles
Berkshire' Hip and Ridge Shingles with Sealant
ASTM D3161, Class F
DuraRidge' Hip and Ridge Shingles with Sealant
ProEdge�'
WeatherGuard' HP Hip and Ridge Shingles
5.5.2 Refer to Owens Corning published information on wind resistance and installation limitations.
5.6 All components in the roof assembly shall have quality assurance audit in accordance with F.A.C. Rule 61G20-3.
Refer to the Product Approval of the component manufacturer for components that are produced by a Product
Manufacturer other than the report holder on Page 1 of this Evaluation Report.
6.1.1 Roof deck, slope, underlayment and fasteners shad comply with FBC 1507.2 / R905.2 and the shingle
manufacturer's minimum requirements.
6.1.2 Underlayment shall be acceptable to the shingle manufacturer and shall hold current Florida Statewide Product
Approval, or be Localiy Approved per Rule 61G20-3, per FBC Sections 1507.2.3,1507.2.4 or R905.2.3.
6.1.3 Fasteners shall be in accordance with the shingle manufacturer's published requirements, but not less than FBC
1307.2.6 or R905.2.5. Staples are not permitted.
6A.4 Owens Corning asphalt shingles are acceptable for use in reroof (tear -off) or recover applications, subject to the
limitations set forth in FBC Section 1511 or R908 and published installation instructions.
6.2 ACCESSORY STARTERS:
6.2.1 Installation of Starter Strip Shingle, Starter Strip Pius and SIRS TopShield Starter shall comply with the Owens
Corning current published instructions, using minimum five (5) nails per strip.
feltlurderlayment Deck
Self•adheratl
` WesiherLote
underlaymeM
Drip
adA Drip edge
J+
- Nails located
.% 2'3"fromeave
bistali first' fir Self-sealing adhesive
Starter strip positioned along eave
shinglewitfl _ t
6" removed
Starter Star shingle Overhangs eaves and rakes'/i'-ki
Figure 1: Minimum Nailing, Starter Strip
Fakuade4aymant '--Dark SASadhered
WeathvLoeOl
uMl4rlayment
Olip
• Drip edge
edge
_ _ Na&s {ocsied
2"-3" from cave
kwaltfrat StarterS16P PLft % SeFsealing adhWvo
wirh 6' removed .�� posia"ned *ng eave
Starter Stag Plus Overhangs eaves and rakes 114"-314'
Figure 2: Minimum Nailing, Starter Strip Plus
NEW ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.0Z.1Z-R11
Certificate of Authori ation #32455 71" EDITION (2020) FBC NON-HVHZ EVALUATION F1.10674-1116
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 4 of 10
6.2.2
NEMO I etc.
Installation of Starter Shingle Roll shall comply with the Owens Corning current published instructions.
Drip
Deck
Underlayment
Drip edge
Starter Shingle Roll adhered
directly to underlayment and
primed drip edge
Self-sealing adhesive
positioned along eaves
Figure 3: Starter Shingle Roll
6.� ASPHALT SHINGLES:
6.3.1 Installation of asphalt shingles shall comply with the O�wensCorning
current puflished in using
minimum four (4) nails per shingle in accordance with F8C 1507.2.7 or R905.2.6, with the following exceptions:
Berkshire® shingles require minimum five (5) nails per shingle.
J, WeatherGuard® HP shingles require minimum six (6) nails per shingle.
Where the roof slope exceeds 21 units vertical in 12 units horizontal, special methods of fastening are required
Refer to Owens Corning published information on wind resistance and installation limitations.
6.3.1.1 Supreme:
Normal Mansard or Area pars
Wind Areas High Wind deavanes y
Area pare vientos normai'es Areas vientos fuertes
1. (A) VI
1i" 77-
5"Exposure
Exposicinn
ri" 2., tBl i 2" �., {
Figure 4: Minimum Nailing, Supreme
(Standard Size)
Normal Mansard or Area pars
Wind Areas High Wind desvanes y
Area pare vientos norrnales Areas vientos fuartes
2.
t_
55ia° Exposure
Erpaelc:dn
Figure 5: Minimum Nailing, Supreme
(Metric Size)
NEMO ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.02.12-R11
Certificate of Authorization #32455 1"' EDITION (2020) FBC NON-HVHZ EVALUATION F1.10674-1116
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 5 of 10
6.3.1.2 Berkshire; ONEMOjetc.
Sealant strip
La Lira de spJtador
81 z" 9 Vz 9 Vz" 8 Yz"
1" 1"
Figure 6: 5-Nail Pattern, Berkshire
Figure 7: 6-Nail Pattern, Berkshire
Figure 8: Mansard or Steep Slope Pattern, Berkshire
NEW ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.02.12-R11
Certificate of Authorization #32455 7T" EDITION (2020) FBC NON-HVHZ EVALUATION F1.10674-1116
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 6 of 10
ONEMOjetc.
6.3.1.3 Duration" Premium TruDefinition' Duration Duration® Premium COOL & TruDefinition` Duration® Designer Color
Collection:
4-Nail Fastening Pattern
SureNalIT fastening area width
Nail, Typical
12" 1"
•MvnsGorronA sur'aAm • 33. �!+j s�a,rq * tlwms Eommp SuretL� •
+wws�e
Figure 9: Standard 4-Nail Pattern, Duration
6-Nail Fastening Pattern
SureNaiM fastening area width
Nail, Typicai
1" IV 12" 1"
5.11g" S�Ig'�
Figure 10: 6-Nail Pattern, Duration
rlgure il: mansard or Steep Slope Pattern, Duration
NEW ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.02.12-1111
Certificate ofAuthonzatron #32455 7TH EDITION (2020) FBC NON-HVHZ EVALUATION FL10674-R16
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 7 of 10
6.3.1.4 TruDefinition'QakridgeO, Oakridge®:
4 Nail Pattern
Esquema con 4 clavos
1„
5515" Exposure
Exposreddn de 661E pull; ts
F � Chyas
5 51e" Exposure i
Expo SW4fr de 59/8 ping.
Figure 12: Standard 4-Nail Pattern, Oakridge
5.1 fe"
6.3.1.5 WeatherGuard® HP
fONEMOjetc.
6 Nail Pattern
Esquema eon 6 clavos
5518" - vjavP
Exposroion da gW pulg.
Expnslddn de 55/8pufa.
Figure 13: 6-Nail Pattern, Oakridge
Fastening for Slopes Greater Than 21:12
SureNaily Fastening area width
F
Nail, Typrcw
12' 1 12„
Four 1" Spats of Asphalt Roofing Cement
•-T2"
6 Nal Pattern
Esquerm con 6 clavos Nail 611'13" from hothm
of share
here a 6 11S jp�uga. de is
5 5W Exposure 6 fasteners perte inferior 11E ltAa
Exposci6n de 5 5S puig. 6 sujetarfnres
12, 1`
14 i Id1
� �' k '� I 1ap,�q ■ � . 14 IF
'iw�
6 5;B' %asd e 5 5r9: E Four 1 " Spots of ,4sphak BA, Cement
FWAasp de 5 5e pu y. Ex�a eifn do 5 contra pantos de camento de feafm do asfalto du 1 pr,�7ada
Figure 15: 6-Nail Pattern, WeatherGuard HP Figure 16. Mansard or Steep -Slope Pattern, WeatherGuard HP
NEMO ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.02.12-Rll
Certificate of Authorization #32955 7TN EDITION (2020) FBC NON-HVHZ EVALUATION F1.10674-1116
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 8 of 10
4&-lik
"FNEMOjetc.
6.4 HIP AND RIDGE SHINGLES.
6.41 Installation of asphalt shingles shall comply with the Owens Corning current published instructions.
➢ Berkshire' Hip and Ridge Shingles with Sealant and DuraRidge® Hip and Ridge Shingles with Sealant require
minimum two (2) nails per shingle.
➢ WeatherGuard® HP Hip and Ridge Shingles and ProEdge® require minimum four (4) nails per shingle.
Refer to Owens Corning published information on wind resistance and installation limitations.
6.4.1.1 BerkshireQ Hip and Ridge with Sealant and DuraRid el Hip and Ridge Shingles with Sealant:
Fig. A
Nails
Clavos
Prevailing Wind Direction
F` Direcci6n del viento predominante
I
i
8 Exposure
ros ien&Bpolg
4
Figure 1/: isometric View, Berkshire and DuraRidge
6.4.1.2 WeatherGuardO HP Hip and Ridge Shingles:
Fig. A T 4
PrevalN Wlnd
lreeifon � fi
Nails p
\\ 4q
I I
A I I
A i I
I I
I I
I I I
Exposure
ti
Fig, B
Top View
Vista superior
1„
Nail
25/a Clam
• Owens Coming SrueNag` •
r
f
i
I�
vl�
_=
�I
V I
J
i
I
12"
Figure 18: Plan View, Berkshire and DuraRidge
Fig. G Hip & Ridge Shingle Fastening
Top Vlew
Nails Naha
T
1" 1 �• 1
31
Exposure
12 �-
rlgure 1y: isometric view, WeatherGuard HP Hip and Ridge Figure 20: Plan View, WeatherGuard HP Hip and Ridge
NEMO ETC, LLC Evaluation Report 037940.02.11-R11
Certificate of Authorizotian #32455 7T11 EDITION (2020) FBC NON-HVHZ EVALUATION FL10674.1316
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 9 of 10
6.4.1.3 ProEdgeO:
Prevailing
Wind Direction sealant Ship
S" Exposure
7
Fasten 71h"
Dauer Expaed
Fasteners with
Roof Cement
Figure 21: Isometric View, Pro Edge
#ONEMOjetc.
Standard
Fastening—f
Pattern FfiE
t2" Sealant
'z
7 6 Expos, re
12"
!}
Figure 22: Plan View, ProEdge
REQUIREMENTS!7. BUILDING PERMIT
As required by the Building Official or Authority Having Jurisdiction to properly evaluate the installation of this
product.
MANUFACTURING PLANTS:
Contact the named QA entity for manufacturing facilities covered by F.A.C. Rule 61G20-3 QA requirements. Refer
to Section 4 herein for products and production locations having met codified material standards.
QUALITY ASSURANCE ENTITY'.
PRI Construction Materials Technologies, LLC— QUA9110 ; 813 621-5777; bwilson@pricmt.com
- END OF EVALUATION REPORT -
NEIVIO ETC' U-C Evaluation Report 037940-02.12-R11
Certif,cote of Authorization #32455 7Tw EDITION (2020) FBC NON-KV14Z EVALUATION FL10674-R16
Owens Corning Asphalt Roof Shingles Revision 11: 12/11/2020
Page 10 of 10