The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutF A E CONSULTING PAPERWORKFebruary 02, 2011 Planning & Development Services Building 7 Code Regulations Division 2300 Virginia Ave. Fort Pierce, Florida 34982 Attn: Mr. Ken Arnold RE: Permit # 1012-0226 Navy Seal Museum Dear Mr. Arnold, RMN CONSULTING SCANNED BY St. Lucie County Below please find our response to your building department comment for Navy Seal Museum, permit number 1012-0226. 1) The jurisdiction in the project summary (energy codes) must be stated as "St. Lucie County, Florida" (66100). FAE Consulting's response: Please refer to revised energy calculation document. Should you have any questions, please contact us. Sincerely, Harold R. Tussler, PE FAE Consulting 1640 N.W. 2nd Avenue I Boca Raton, FL 33432 1 Phone 561.391.9292 1 Fax 561.391.9898 tip PROJECT #1 ❑396 NATIONAL NAVY UOT-SEAL MUSEUM CONTENTS: REVISED ENERGY CALCULATION DATE: ❑ 2/❑2/ 1 1 PREPARED BY: m m CONSULTING 1 6413 NW 2ND AVE BOLA RATON, FL 33432 Florida Energy Efficiency. Code For -Building Construction Florida Department of CommunityAffai�s -Energy-Gauge Summit® Fla/Com-2008'Ff ective:-,March 1, 2009 Form'400A-2008, - Method A: Whole Building,Performance:Method for.Commercial Buildings, ,t PROJECT SUMMARY Short Dese: Navy Seal Museum Description: ........ Owner: .... Addressl: 3300 North Highway AIA City: Fort Pierce Address2: State: Fl Zip: 34949 Type: Museum Class: New Finished building Jurisdiction: FORT PIERCE, ST LUCIE COUNTY, FL (661100) Conditioned Area: 8400 SF Conditioned & UnConditioned Area: 8400 SF No of Stories: 1 Area entered from Plans 8400 SF Permit No: 0 Max Tonnage 5 If different, write in: a EnergyGauge Summit® Fla/Com-2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/2011 Page 1 of 9 Component Design Criteria Result Gross Energy Cost (in $) 5,955.0 8,529.0 PASSED LIGHTING CONTROLS EXTERNAL LIGHTING HVAC SYSTEM PLANT WATER HEATING SYSTEMS PIPING SYSTEMS Met all required compliance from Check List? PASSES PASSES PASSES None Entered PASSES None Entered Yes/No/NA IMPORTANT MESSAGE Info 5009 -- — --An input report of this design building must be submitted along with this Compliance Report EnergyGauge Summit@ Fla/Com-2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/2011 Page 2 of 9 CERTIFICATIONS I hereby certify that the plans and specifications covered by this calculation are in compliance with the Florida Energy Code Prepared By: Harold R. Tussler Building Official: Date: l_�1 Date: I certify that this building is in complianccwith the FLorida Energy Efficiency Code Owner Agent: Date: If Required by Florida law, I hereby certify (') that the system design is in compliance with the FLorida Energy Efficiency Code Architect: Electrical Designer: Harold R. Tussler Lighting Designer: Harold R. Tussler Mechanical Designer: Harold R. Tussler Reg No: Reg No: 19315 Reg No: 19315 Reg No: 19315 Plumbing Designer: Harold R. Tussler Reg No: 19315 (') Signature is required where Florida Law requires design to be performed by registered design professionals. EnergyGauge Summit@ Fla/Com-2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/20l I Page 3 of 9 Project: Navy Seal Museum Title:........ Type: Museum (WEA File: FL ST LUCIE Total EL ECTRICITY(MBtulkWhl$) AREA LIGHTS Building End Uses 1) Proposed 2) Baseline 381.30 635.40 $5,955 $10,035 381.30 635.40 111724 186170 $5,955 $10,035 68.60 89.50 20090 26214 $1,071 $1,413 MISC EQUIPMT 126.00 126.00 36922 36922 $1,968 $1,990 PUMPS & MISC 0.10 0.10 22 23 $1 $1 SPACE COOL 141.70 279.00 41520 81754 $2,213 $4,407 SPACE HEAT 5.00 11.90 1474 3497 $79 $188 VENT FANS 39.90 128.90 11696 37760 $623 $2,035 Passing requires Proposed Building cost to be at most 85% PASSES if Baseline cost. This Proposed Building is at 59.3% EnergyGauge Summit@ Fla/Com-2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/2011 Page 4 of 9 Project: Navy Seal Museum t itle:........ Type. Museum (WEA File: FL ST_LUCIE_CO INTL.tm3) External Lighting Compliance Description Category Tradable? Allowance Area or Length ELPA CLP (W/Unit) or No. of Units (W) (W) (Sgft orft) Ext Light I Walk way less than 10 feet wide Yes 1.00 1,826.0 1,826 1,500 Ext Light 2 Main entries Yes 30.00 144.0 4,320 200 Ext Light 3 Walk way less than 10 feet wide Yes 1.00 335.0 335 200 Tradable Surfaces: 1900 (W) Allowance for Tradable: 6805.05 (W) PASSES All External Lighting: 1900 (W) Complicance check includes a 5% excess allowance of 324.05(W) Project: Navy Seal Museum Title:........ Type: Museum (WEA File: FL ST LUCIE_CO tNTL.tm3) Lighting Controls Compliance Acronym Ashrae Description Area Design Min Compli- ID (sq.ft) CP CP ance Gallery#1 17,001 General Exhibition (Museum) 4,200 2 2 PASSES Gallery #2 17,001 General Exhibition (Museum) 2,600 2 2 PASSES OffBathrm 16 Office -Open Plan 1,600 2 1 PASSES PASSES EnergyGauge SummitO Fla/Com-2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/2011 Page 5 of 9 Project: Navy Seal Museum Title:........ Type: Museum (WEA File: FL_ST_LUCIE_CO_INTL.tm3) System Report Compliance AHU-1 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled No. of Units Split System < 65000 Btu/hr l Component Category Capacity Design Eff Design IPLV Comp- Eff Criteria IPLV Criteria liance Cooling System Air Conditioners Air Cooled 16.00 12.23 8.00 PASSES Split System < 65000 Btu/h Cooling Capacity Heating System Electric Furnace 1.00 1.00 PASSES Air Handling Air Handler (Supply) - 0.35 0.90 PASSES System -Supply Constant Volume Air Distribution ADS System 6.00 3.50 PASSES System AHU-2 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled No. of Units Split System < 65000 Btu/hr 1 Component Category Capacity Design Eff Design IPLV Comp- Eff Criteria IPLV Criteria liance Cooling System Air Conditioners Air Cooled 16.00 12.23 8.00 PASSES Split System < 65000 Btu/h Cooling Capacity Heating System Electric Furnace 1.00 I.00 PASSES Air Handling Air Handler (Supply) - 0.35 0.90 PASSES System -Supply Constant Volume Air Distribution ADS System 6.00 3.50 PASSES System AHU-3 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled No. of Units Split System < 65000 Btu/hr 1 Component Category Capacity Design Eff Design IPLV Comp- Eff Criteria IPLV Criteria fiance Cooling System Air Conditioners Air Cooled 16.00 12.23 8.00 PASSES Split System < 65000 Btu/h Cooling Capacity Heating System Electric Furnace 1.00 1.00 PASSES Air Handling Air Handler (Supply) - 0.35 0.90 PASSES System -Supply Constant Volume Air Distribution ADS System 6.00 3.50 PASSES System EnergyGauge Summit® Fla/Com-2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/2011 Page 6 of 9 AHU-4 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled No. of Units Split System < 65000 Btu/hr 1 Component Category Capacity Design Eff Design IPLV Comp- Eff Criteria IPLV Criteria liance Cooling System Air Conditioners Air Cooled 16.00 12.23 8.00 PASSES Split System < 65000 Btu/h _ Cooling Capacity Heating System Electric Furnace 1.00 1.00 PASSES Air Handling Air Handler (Supply) - 0.35 0.90 PASSES System -Supply Constant Volume Air Distribution ADS System 6.00 3.50 PASSES System AHU-5 Split System Constant Volume Packaged No. of Units System-902 1 Component Category Capacity Design Eff Design IPLV Comp- Eff Criteria IPLV Criteria liance Cooling System Air Conditioners Air Cooled 16.00 12.23 8.00 PASSES < 65000 Btu/h Cooling Capacity Heating System Electric Furnace 1.00 1.00 PASSES Air Handling Air Handler (Supply) - 0.35 0.90 PASSES System -Supply Constant Volume Air Distribution ADS System 6.00 3.50 PASSES System PASSES Plant Compliance Description Installed Size Design Min Design Min Category Comp No Eff Eff IPLV IPLV liance None EnergyGauge SummitO Fla/Com-2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/2011 Page 7 of 9 Project: Navy Seal Museum Title:........ Type: Museum (WEAFile: FL_ST_LUCIE_CO_INTL.tm3) Water Heater Compliance D Description Type Design Min Category Eff Eff Design Max Comp Loss Loss liance Water Heater I Electric water heater <= 12 [kWJ 0.90 0.88 PASSES PASSES Piping System Compliance Category Pipe Dia Is Operating Ins Cond Ins Req Ins Compliance [inches] Runout? Temp [Btu-in/hr Thick [inl Thick [in] [FJ SF.FJ None EnergyGauge Summit® Fla/Com•2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/2011 Page 8 of 9 Navy Seal Museum Museum . File: FL_ST_LUCIE_CO_INTL.tm3) Category Report Operations Manual Windows & Doors Section 13-101 13-102.1, 13-410, 13-413 13406.AB.1.1 Joints/Cracks 13406.AB.1.2 Dropped Ceiling Cavity 13406.AB.3 System Reheat HVAC Efficiency HVAC Controls Ventilation Controls ADS HVAC Ducts Balancing Piping Insulation Water Heaters Swimming Pools Hot Water Pipe Insulation Water Fixtures Motors Lighting Controls 13-407 Other Required Compliance Requirement (write N/A in box if not applicable) Input Report Print -Out from EnergyGauge FlaCom attached Operations manual provided to owner Glazed swinging entrance & revolving doors: max. 1.0 cfm/ft2; all other products: 0.4 cfm/ft2 To be caulked, gasketed, weather-stripped or otherwise sealed Vented: seal & insulated ceiling. Unvented seal & insulate roof & side walls HVAC Load sizing has been performed 13-407.13 Electric resistance reheat prohibited 13-407, 13408 Minimum efficiences: Cooling Tables 13407.AB.3.2.IA-D; Heating Tables 13407.AB.3.2.IB, 13-407.AB.3.2. I D, 13408.AB.3.2.1E, 13408.AB.3.2F 13407.AB.2 Zone controls prevent reheat (exceptions); simultaneous heating and cooling in each zone; combined HAC deadband of at least 5°F (exceptions) 13-409.AB.3 Motorized dampers reqd, except gravity dampers OK in: 1) exhaust systems and 2) systems with design outside air intake or exhaust capacity:5300 cfm 13-410 Duct sizing and Design have been performed 13410.AB Air ducts, fittings, mechanical equipment & plenum chambers shall be mechanically attached, sealed, insulated & installed per Sec. 13-410 Air Distribution Systems 13410.ABA HVAC distribution system(s) tested & balanced. Report in construction documents 13-41 LAB In accordance with Table 13-41 LAB.2 13412.AB Performance requirements in accordance with Table 13-412.AB.3 Heat trap required 13412.AB.2.6 Cover on heated swimming pools: Time switch (exceptions); Readily accessible on/offswitch 1341 LAB.3 Table 1341 LAB.2 for circulating systems, first 8 feet of outlet pipe from storage tank and between inlet pipe and heat trap 13-412.AB.2.5 Shower hot water flow restricted to 2.5 gpm at 80 psi. Public lavatory fixture how water flow 0.5 gpm max; if self -closing valve 0.25 gallon recirculating, 0.5 gallon non recirculating 13414 Motor efficiency criteria have been met 13415.AB Automatic control required for interior lighting in buildings >5,000 s.f.; Space control; Exterior photo sensor; Tandom wiring with 1 or 3 linear fluuorescent lamps>30W Check EnergyGauge Summit@ Fla/Com•2008. Effective: March 1, 2009 2/2/201l Page 9 of 9 Project Name: Navy Seal Museum Project Title: ........ Address: 3300 North Highway AlA State: Fl Zip: 34949 Owner: EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 I I INPUT DATA REPORT Proiect Information Orientation: North Building Type: Museum Building Classification: New Finished building No.of Stories: 1 GrossArea: 8400 SF Zones No Acronym Description Type Area Multiplier [sf] Total Area (sf] 1 Gallery Zone 1 CONDITIONED 8400.0 1 8400.0 ❑ Spaces No Acronym Description Type Depth [ft] Width Height Multi Total Area [it] [it] plier [sf] Total Volume [cf] 2/2/2011 EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 1 In Zone: Gallery I Gallery #1 ........ General Exhibition 70.00 60.00 12.00 1 4200.0 50400.0 ❑ (Museum) 2 Gallery #2 ........ General Exhibition 74.29 35.00 12.00 1 2600.0 31200.0 El (Museum) 3 Off/Bathrm ........ Office - Open Plan 64.00 25.00 12.00 1 1600.0 19200.0 ❑ Lighting No Type Category No. of Watts per Power Control Type No.of Luminaires Luminaire fW] Ctrlpts In Zone: Gallery In Space: Gallery #1 1 Recessed Fluorescent - General Lighting 12 240 2880 Manual On/Off 2 ❑ No vent In Space: Gallery #2 1 Recessed Fluorescent - General Lighting 8 240 1920 Manual On/Off 2 ❑ No vent In Space: OffBathrm I Recessed Fluorescent - General Lighting 17 96 1632 Occupancy sensor without 1 No vent Daylighting 2 Recessed Fluorescent - General Lighting 2 64 128 Occupancy sensor without I No vent Daylighting Walls No Description Type Width H (Effec) Multi Area DirectionConductance Heat Dens. R-Value [ft] [ft] plier [sf] [Btu/hr. sC F] Capacity flb/cf] [h.sf.FBtu] [Btu/sf.F] In Zone: Gallery I ......•• 6"CMU with 2" 119.00 12.00 1 1428.0 North 0.0621 14.212 79.12 16.1 ❑ rigid insulation in both side 2 ........ 6"CMU with 2" 119.00 12.00 1 1428.0 North 0.0621 14.212 79.12 16.1 ❑ rigid insulation in both side 2/2/2011 EuergyGauge Summit® v3.22 3 ........ 6"CMU with 2" 70.59 12.00 1 847.1 North 0.0621 14.212 79.12 16.1 ❑ rigid insulation in both side 4 ........ 6"CMU with 2" 70.59 12.00 1 847.1 North 0.0621 14.212 79.12 16.1 ❑ rigid insulation in both side Windows No Description Type Shaded U SHGC Vis.Tra W H (Effec) Multi Total Area [Btu/hr sf F] IN [ft] plier [sf] In Zone: In Wall: Doors No Description Type Shaded? Width H (Effec) Multi Area Cond. Dens. Heat Cap. R-Value [ft] [ft] plier [sf] [Btu/hr. sf. F] [Ib/cf] [Btu/sC F] [h.sf.FBtu] In Zone: Gallery In Wall: North Wall 1 .... Solid core flush No 6.00 8.00 1 48.0 0.3504 0.00 0.00 2.85 ❑ (2.25) In Wall: South Wall 1 .... Solid core flush No 6.00 8.00 1 48.0 0.3504 0.00 0.00 2.85 ❑ (2.25) In Wall: East Wall 1 .... Solid core flush No 6.00 8.00 1 48.0 0.3504 0.00 0.00 2.85 (2.25) In Wall: West Wall 1 .... Solid core flush No 6.00 8.00 1 48.0 0.3504 0.00 0.00 2.85 (2.25) 2/2/2011 EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 Roofs No Description Type Width H (Effec) Multi Area Tilt Cond. Heat Cap Dens. R-Value [ft] [ft] plier [sf] [deg] [Btu/hr. SE F] [Btu/sf. F] [lb/cf] [h.sLF/Btu] In Zone: Gallery 1 ............. Mtl Bldg Roof/R-19 70.59 119.00 1 8400.0 0.00 0.0492 1.34 9.49 20.3 ❑ Batt Skylights No Description Type U SHGC Vis.Trans W H (Effec) Multiplier Area Total Area [Btu/hrAF] Vt] [ft] [Sf] [Sf] In Zone: In Roof: Floors No Description Type Width H (Effec) Multi Area Cond. Heat Cap. Dens. R-Value [ft] [ft] plier fsf] [Btu/hr. sL F] [Btu/st F] [Ib/cf] [h.sLF/Btu] In Zone: Gallery I ........ 1 ft. soil, concrete 119.00 70.59 1 8400.0 0.2681 34.00 113.33 3.73 ❑ floor, carpet and rubber pad Systems ARU-1 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled Split No. Of Units 1 System < 65000 Btu/hr Component Category Capacity Efficiency IPLV 1 Cooling System 60000.00 16.00 8.00 ❑ 2 Heating System 34120.00 1.00 ❑ 2/2/2011 EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 3 Air Handling System -Supply 2000.00 0.35 ❑ 4 Air Distribution System 6.00 El AHU-2 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled Split No. Of Units 1 System < 65000 Btu/hr Component Category Capacity Efficiency IPLV 1 Cooling System 60000.00 16.00 8.00 El 2 Heating System 34120.00 1.00 ❑ 3 Air Handling System -Supply 2000.00 0.35 El 4 Air Distribution System 6.00 El AHU-3 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled Split No. Of Units 1 System < 65000 Btu/hr Component Category Capacity Efficiency IPLV 1 Cooling System 47550.00 16.00 8.00 ❑ 2 Heating System 34120.00 1.00 3 Air Handling System -Supply 1600.00 0.35 El 4 Air Distribution System 6.00 AIIU4 Split System Constant Volume Air Cooled Split No. Of Units 1 System < 65000 Btu/hr Component Category Capacity Efficiency IPLV 1 Cooling System 47550.00 16.00 8.00 2 Heating System 34120.00 1.00 3 Air Handling System -Supply 1600.00 0.35 4 Air Distribution System 6.00 2/2/2011 EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 AHU-5 Split System Constant Volume Packaged System- -902 No. Of Units 1 Component Category Capacity Efficiency IPLV 1 Cooling System 2 Heating System 3 Air Handling System -Supply 4 Air Distribution System 42600.00 23884.00 1400.00 16.00 8.00 1.00 0.35 6.00 ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ Plant Equipment Category Size Inst.No Eft 1PLV Water Heaters W-Heater Description CapacitlCap.Unit I/P Rt. Efficiency Loss 1 Electric water heater 40 [Gal] 5 [kW] 0.9000 [Ef] []3tu/h] ❑ Ext-Lighting Description Category No. of Watts per Area/Len/No. of units Control Type Wattage Luminaires Luminaire [sf/ft/No] M 1 Ext Light 1 Walk way less than 10 feet 6 250 1826.00 Astronomical Timer Coi 1500.00 ❑ wide 2 Ext Light 2 Main entries 2 100 144.00 Astronomical Timer Coi 200.00 ❑ 3 Ext Light 3 Walk way less than 10 feet 2 100 335.00 Astronomical Timer Coi 200.00 ❑ wide 2/2/2011 EuergyGauge Summit® v3.22 6 t Piping No Type Operating Insulation Nomonal pipe Insulation Is Runout? Temperature Conductivity Diameter Thickness [F] [ Btu-in/h.sLF] [in] [in] Fenestration Used Name Glass Type No. of Glass SHGC VLT Panes Conductance [Btu/h.sLF] Materials Used Mat No Acronym Description Only R-Value RValue Thickness Used [h.sLFBtu] [ft] Conductivity [Btu/h.fLF] Density [Ib/cf] SpecificHeat [Btu/lb.F] Yes 265 Mat1265 Soil, 1 ft No 2.0000 1.0000 0.5000 100.00 0.2000 ❑ 48 Mat148 6 in. Heavyweight concrete No 0.5000 0.5000 1.0000 140.00 0.2000 ❑ 269 Mat1269 .75" ISO BTWN24" oc No 2.2321 0.0625 0.0280 4.19 0.3000 ❑ 23 Mat123 6 in. Insulation No 20.0000 0.5000 0.0250 5.70 0.2000 ❑ 11 Mad11 2 in. Insulation No 6.6800 0.1670 0.0250 2.00 0.2000 ❑ 94 Mat194 BUILT-UP ROOFING, No 0.3366 0.0313 0.0930 70.00 0.3500 ❑ 3/81N Constructs Used No Name Simple Massless Conductance Construct Construct [Btu/h.sLF] Heat Capacity [Btu/sf.F] Density [Ib/cfj RValue I[h.sf.FBtu] 2/2/2011 EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 1056 Mtl Bldg Roof/R-19 Batt No No 0.05 1.34 9.49 20.3 ❑ Layer Material Material Thickness Framing No. [ft] Factor 1 94 BUILT-UP ROOFING, 3/8IN 0.0313 0.000 ❑ 2 23 6 in. Insulation 0.5000 0.000 ❑ No Name Simple Massless Conductance Heat Capacity Density RValue Construct Construct [Btu/h.sf.F] [Btu/sEF] [lb/cf] [h.sf.F/Btu] 1057 1 ft. soil, concrete floor, carpet and rubber pad No No 0.27 34.00 113.33 3.7 ❑ Layer Material Material Thickness Framing No. [ft] Factor 1 265 Soil, 1 ft 1.0000 0.000 ❑ 2 48 6 in. Heavyweight concrete 0.5000 0.000 ❑ 3 178 CARPET W/RUBBER PAD 0.000 ❑ No Name Simple Massless Conductance Heat Capacity Density RValue Construct Construct [Btu/h.sf.F] [Btu/sEF] [lb/cf] [h.SEF/Btu] 1058 Solid core flush (2.25) No Yes 0.35 2.9 ❑ Layer Material Material Thickness Framing No. [ft] Factor 1 279 Solid core flush (2.25") 0.000 ❑ 2/2/2011 EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 8 Simple Massless Conductance Heat No Name Construct Construct [Btu/h.sLF[ [B 1060 6"CMU with 2" rigid insulation in both side No No 0.06 Layer Material Material Thickness Framing No. [ftl Factor 1 11 2 in. Insulation 0.1670 0.000 2 48 6 in. Heavyweight concrete 0.5000 0.000 3 269 .75" ISO BTWN24" oc 0.0625 0.000 4 11 2 in. Insulation 0.1670 0.000 Capacity Density RValue to/s£F[ [Ib/cf[ [h.sf.F/Btu[ 14.21 79.12 16.1 ❑ 2/2/2011 EnergyGauge Summit® v3.22 9