HomeMy WebLinkAboutMISC EMAILATLAS
Structural Engineering, LLC
July 25, 2016
Sutter Roofing Co of SWFL
Mr. Jason Mills
4085 L.B. McLeod Road, Suite B
Orlando, FL 32811
Re: Tropicana Fort Pierce
Micro Lab Building — Steel Deck Pull Tests
Atlas Job No. 15002.05
Dear Jason:
12610 World Plaza Lane I Building 61, Suite 2
Fort Myers, Florida 33907
phone 239.274.68201 fox 239.274.68211 CA #28380
SCANNED
BY
St. Lucie County
As per your request, Atlas Structural Engineering, LLC has reviewed the fastener withdrawal test results
provided for the Tropicana Micro Lab Building located at,6500 Glades Cut Off Road in Fort Pierce, Florida.
The Micro Lab is located along the northern edge of the ATF East Campus Building.
On -site withdrawal tests were performed at random locations to determine the average ultimate pullout value.
The withdrawal tests achieved an average ultimate pullout value of 739.1 Ibs per fastener. The fastener
patterns provided in the Engineering Letter titled 'Tropicana Fort Pierce - Micro Lab Building" were determined
using an average ultimate pullout value of 180 Ibs per fastener, with a margin of safety for uplift resistance
equal to 2.0.
The fastening patterns. provided in the Engineering Letter were determined using various tested assemblies
provided in Florida Product Approval (FPA) No. FL14083-R9, and do not exceed the force per fastener
determined using the above stated FPA and tested pullout value. See Engineering Letter for additional
information.
After reviewing the fastener withdrawal test provided by Roof Leak Detection Company, Inc., it is our opinion
the fastening patterns provided in the Engineering Letter are structurally adequate to resist the wind uplift
pressures required when installed in accordance with the above stated FPA and Engineering Letter.
Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you have any questions.
=Atlas_StructuraLEngineering; LLC--=
Robin W. Stephan, P.E. #66525
President
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 1 of 1
Micro Lab Building — Steel Deck Pull Tests
ATLAS
Structural Engineering, LLC
July 25, 2016
Sutter Roofing Cc of SWFL
Mr. Jason Mills
4085 L.B. McLeod Road, Suite B
Orlando, FL 32811
Re: Tropicana Fort Pierce
Micro Lab Building — Steel Deck Pull Tests
Atlas Job No. 15002.06
Dear Jason:
12610 World Plaza Lane l Building 61, Suite 2
Fort Myers, Florida 33907
phone 239.274.6820 1 fox 239.274.68211 CA #28380
SCANNED
BY
';t Lucie County
REC21� V
SEP 9 9 2016
PERNUTING
St. Lucie County, FL
As per your request, Atlas Structural Engineering, LLC has reviewed the fastener withdrawal test results
provided for the Tropicana Micro Lab Building located at 6500 Glades Cut Off Road in Fort Pierce, Florida.
The Micro Lab is located along the northern edge of the ATF East Campus Building.
On -site withdrawal tests were performed at random locations to determine the average ultimate pullout value.
The withdrawal tests achieved an average ultimate pullout value of 739.1 Ibs per fastener. The fastener
patterns provided in the Engineering Letter titled 'Tropicana Fort Pierce - Micro Lab Building' were determined
using an average ultimate pullout value of 180 Ibs per fastener, with a margin of safety for uplift resistance
equal to 2.0.
The fastening patterns provided in the Engineering Letter were determined using various tested assemblies
provided in Florida Product Approval (FPA) No. FL14083-R9, and do not exceed the force per fastener
determined using the above stated FPA and tested pullout value. See Engineering Letter for additional
information.
After reviewing the fastener withdrawal test provided by Roof Leak Detection Company, Inc., it is our opinion
the fastening patterns provided in the Engineering Letter are structurally adequate to resist the wind uplift
pressures required when installed in accordance with the above stated FPA and Engineering Letter.
Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you have any questions.
—_ Sincerely—-—
w =Atlas Structural=Engineering;.LLC.-- ---
Robin W. Stephan, P.E. #66525
President
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 1 of 1
Micro Lab Building— Steel Deck Pull Tests
ATLAS 12610 World Plaza Lane I Building Suite 2
Fort Myers, Floridad 33907
phone 239.274.6820 I fox 239.274.68211 CA #28380
Structural Engineering, LLC
September 6, 2016
Sutter Roofing Co of SWFL
Mr. Jason Mills
4085 L.B. McLeod Road, Suite B
Orlando, FL 32811
Re: Tropicana Fort Pierce
Micro Lab Inspection
SCANNED
BY
St. Lucie Count\'
Atlas Job No. 15002.05 / Permit No. 1510-0507
To Whom It May Concern:
SEP 0 9 201E
PERMITTING
St. Lucie County, FL
As requested, a representative from Atlas Structural Engineering, LLC (Atlas) visited the Tropicana Micro .Lab
Building located at 6500 Glades Cut Off Road in Fort Pierce, Florida, on Thursday August 4, 2016 to conduct
an assessment of the roof covering installed by Sutter Roofing Company of Florida (Sutter Roofing). The
purpose of the visit was to visually observe the fastening patterns used to mechanically attach cover board
and insulation to an existing steel roof deck.
Cover Board and Insulation Attachment Findings
The cover board fasteners and plates were not visible from the roof at the time of inspection. Although some
of the plates could be located by touch, definitive patterns could not be determined. According to Sutter
Roofing, 4'x8' insulation boards were installed using 16 fasteners per board in Zone 1, 28 fasteners per board
in Zone 2 and 40 fasteners per board in Zone 3.
Sutter Roofing has stated that 1/2" DensDeck Prime cover board and 1.5" ISO insulation were simultaneously
fastened to existing 22 gauge steel roof deck using Carlisle Sure -Seal HP Fasteners with Carlisle Sure -Seal
Insulation Plates. This complies with the insulation attachment specified in the engineering letter. See
photographs on pages 2 and 3.
Summary and Limitations
- --
work ("As -Built Condition for Tropicana — Micro Lab Building" -by Sutter Roofing dated September 2, 2016) it
our opinion that the fastening patterns installed are structurally adequate to resist the design wind pressures.
The scope of this investigation does not include analysis of the load carrying capacity of the existing structure,
and the fastener patterns provided in this report are based on the materials and fasteners stated above,
provided by Sutter Roofing at the time of this investigation. See Engineering Letter "Tropicana Fort Pierce —
Micro Lab Building" by Atlas Structural Engineering, LLC dated October 22, 2015 for additional information.
The observations, discrepancies and comments included in this report are made on the basis of what was
visible and accessible on the day of the inspection. Representative photos are attached for your convenience
but do not indicate a summary of all items observed or concerns noted; please refer to report above.
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page f of 3
Micro Lab Building Inspection
ATLAS STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING, LLC
12610 World Plaza Lane, Suite 2 1 Fort Myers, Florida 33907
phone 239.274.6820 1 fax 239.274.6821 1 CA #28380
Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
Atlas Structural Engineehng, LLC
to
Robin W. Stephan, P; E. #66525
President -
Overview of Micro Lab Lower Roofs
Typical Roof Covering with Fasteners Circled
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 2 of 3
Micro Lab Building Inspection
ATLAS STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING, LLC
12610 World Plaza Lane, Suite 2 1 Fort Myers, Florida 33907
phone 239.274.6820 1 fox 239.274.68211 CA #28380
Typical Roof Covering with Fasteners Circled
Typical Roof Covering with Fasteners Circled
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 3 of 3
Micro Lab Building Inspection
-1i
ANDFLORIDASHE61ROOTING
t RSA I CO SHEET
CONTRACTORSS
A55C'::I0.TION
BUTTER
ROOFING
09/02/16
SCANNED
BY
Atlas Structural Engineering, LLC
St. Luce Countv
Ms. Robin Stephan
12610 World Plaza Lane
Building 61, Suite 2
Fort Myers, FL 33907
Re: As -Built Condition for Tropicana
— Micro Lab Building
St. Lucie County Permi # 1510-0507
To Whom It May Concern:
L
NATIONAL
ROOFING
CONTRACTORS
ASSOCIATION
The single -ply roof covering membrane, cover board and insulation on the Tropicana Micro Lab Building
located at 6500 Glades Cut Off Road in Fort Pierce, Florida were installed under my direct supervision and in
conformance with the permitted construction drawings.
Carlisle Sure -Seal HP Fasteners with Sure -Seal Insulation Plates were used to simultaneously fasten 1/2"
DensDeck Prime cover board and 1.5" thick POLYISO insulation to existing 22 gauge steel roof deck. Each 4'x8'
sheet of cover board was fastened with sixteen (16) fasteners in Zone 1, twenty-eight (28) fasteners in Zone 2
and forty (40) fasteners in Zone 3,
Carlisle Sure -Weld FleeceBACK TPO was adhered to the DensDeck Prime cover board with Carlisle FAST 100 or
FAST 100 LV Bonding Adhesive. Adhesive was applied as full coverage at a rate of 1 gallon per square (100 ft2).
Please do not hesitate to call with questions or for further assistance at (813)
rely,
Kenney
r Roofing Company of -Florida
E(aW
SEP - 9 M
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and seal this day of201�.
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF LEE
Personally appeared who is personally known to me.
My CommisOon Expires: — M.,�---
. .. BROOXEMARTZ
* MY COMMISSION /FF015M
NotaryPu;H c� EXPIRES: August 10, 2017
^' n. n�" BortdedTnru BudgetNaNryServices
"SAFE. SOLID AND SECURE SINCE 1902"
8811 MAISLIN DRIVE • TAMPA, FLORIDA 33637 • (813) 868-0800
FAX: (813) 868-0500 • www.sufferroofing.com LIC: #CC CO20599
,9 r
July 25, 2016
Sutter Roofing Co of SWFL
Mr. Jason Mills
4085 L.B. McLeod Road, Suite B
Orlando, FL 32811
Re: Tropicana Fort Pierce
Micro Lab Building — Steel Deck Pull Tests
Atlas Job No. 15002.05
Dear Jason:
As per your request, Atlas Structural Engineering
provided for the Tropicana Micro Lab Building Iota
The Micro Lab is located along the northern edge of
On -site withdrawal tests were performed at,random
The withdrawal tests achieved an average ultimal
patterns provided in the Engineering Letter, titled "Tr
using an average ultimate pullout value of180 Ibs
equal to 2.0.
The fastening patterns providedin the Engine
provided in Florida ProductApd ovr al (FPA) NoN
determined using the above'_�d FPA and test
information. \\\ /)1
After reviewing the fastener withdrawal test provide
the fastening patterns provided in\the&ngineenrjg
pressures required when ihstalled in accordance wif
Please do not hesitate to contact
Sincerely,
-- —Atlas-Structural Engine erg,- LC
Robin W. Stephan, P.E. #66525
President
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 1 of 1
Micro Lab Building — Steel Deck Pull Tests
�GANNE®
BY
I urie County
has reviewed the fastener withdrawal test results
8500 Glades Cut dff,Road in Fort Pierce, Florida.
F East Camous Building. i
fine the averag6,ult�mate pullout value.
739.1 Ibs per fastener. The fastener
- Micro Lab Building" were determined
a margin of safety for uplift resistance
Bdiusing various tested assemblies
not exceed the force per fastener
e Engineering Letter for additional
Leak Detection Company, Inc., it is our opinion
structurally adequate to resist the wind uplift
stated FPA and Engineering Letter.
any questions.
ATLAS
I
ructural Engineering, LLC
October 22, 2015
Sutter Roofing Co of SWFL
Mr. Jason Mills
4085 L.B. McLeod Road, Suite B
Orlando, FL 32811
Re: Tropicana Fort Pierce
Micro Lab Building
Atlas Job No. 15002.05
Dear Jason:
12610 World Plaza Lane I Building 61, Suite 2
Fort Myers, Florida 33907
phone 239.274.68201 fax 239.274.6821 1 CA #28380
SCANNED
BY
St. Lucie Counr
-�Tr-"MWR
.m
Atlas Structural Engineering, LLC (Atlas) is pleased to provide this report of the fastening patterns required for
the attachment of cover board, insulation and single ply roofing membrane to steel roof deck on the Tropicana
Micro Lab Building located at 6500 Glades Cut Off Road in Fort Pierce, Florida. The Micro Lab is located
along the northern edge of the ATF East Campus Building.
Factory Mutual Criteria and Design Wind Pressures
As requested, Factory Mutual (FM) recommendations for installing mechanically fastened roof insulation, and
design wind pressures determined in accordance with FM Data Sheet 1-28, were used to determine the
fastener patterns provided in this report. The following criteria were used:
Basic Wind Speed: V = 123 mph
Exposure: C
Internal Pressure Coefficient: +/- 0.18 (Enclosed Building / Protected Openings)
According to the FM 1-28 Table 4, the Roof Field Area (Zone 1) Uplift Design Pressure is equal to 45 psf. The
recommended roof ratings from Table 8 of FM 1-28 require an FM 1-90 rated system using the above criteria.
The corresponding design pressures are as follows:
Roof Field Area = -45.0 psf
Roof Perimeter Area _ -75.0 psf
Roof Corner Area = -112.5 psf
-----T.he_pressures-stated=above=meet=or_exceed_the. minimum recommended_FM-Lrati_ngs providgd_in FM 1-29-
Table_1_andihenominal Components -and Cladding uplift pressures -determined in accordance
10, Chapter 30, using the following criteria:
Ultimate Wind Speed: V „= 158 mph
Nominal Wind Speed: Vesd = 123 mph
Exposure: C
Risk Category: Category II
Internal Pressure Coefficient: +/- 0.18 (Enclosed Building / Protected Openings)
Pressures and edge distance were determined for a building with a flat roof, a maximum roof height of 30'-0"
and a minimum overall width of 264'-0". Perimeter and Comer Areas are defined as being within 12'-0" of the
edges and corners of the flat roof. Where the low roof of the Micro Lab intersects the ATF Building, Zone 3
may be treated as Zone 2 and Zone 2 may be treated as Zone 1.
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 1 of 3
Micro Lab Building
r
ATLAS STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING, LLC
12610 World Plaza Lane, Suite 2 1 Fort Myers, Florida 33907
phone 239.274.6820 1 fox 239.274.6821 1 CA #28380
Insulation Fastenino to Steel Roof Deck
Carlisle Sure -Seal HP Fastener with Sure -Seal Insulation Plates shall be used to attach 112" DensDeck Prime
cover board and 1.5" or thicker insulation to existing 22 gauge or thicker steel roof deck. Fasteners shall be
corrosion resistant and each fastener must penetrate through the top flange of the steel deck a minimum of
3/4". The attachment of the insulation to the steel roof deck shall be as follows:
Roof Zone
Board Size
Minimum No. of Fasteners
Max. Area per Fastener
Field
4'x8'
16
2.00
Perimeter
4'x8'
28
1.15
Corner
4'x8'
40
0.80
For 4'x4' boards, use half (0.5 x) the minimum number of fasteners stated above for 4'x8' boards. See below
for example insulation fastener patterns.
The fastening patterns provided above were determined using various tested assemblies provided in Florida
Product Approval (FPA) No. FL14083-Rg. The attachment of the DensDeck was determined using Systems
SC-61 and SC-82, and the adherence of the single -ply was verified using System C-45. Patterns were
extrapolated using Florida Building Code RAS117 and do not exceed the force per fastener determined using
the above stated Florida Product Approval. See Carlisle literature and details for additional information and
installation requirements.
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
12"
6"
12"
12"
12"
, ,, 12" 12" 6". 6" =-- . 6" _12"_ 6" 6" .12" r,,__ _ . �,6"� 12" 6't6" r �6
16 Fasteners 28 Fasteners 40 Fasteners
Sample Cover Board and Insulation Fastener Placement Patterns
Adhered TPO Attachment and Roof Covering Review
The proposed roof covering is as follows: FILE uvpy
1. DensDeck Prime and insulation shall be simultaneously fastened to the existing steel roof deck. (See
above for fastening patterns.)
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 2 of 3
Micro Lab Building
ATLAS STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING, LLC
12610 World Plaza Lane, Suite 2 1 Fort Myers, Florida 33907
phone 239.274.6820 1 fax 239.274.6821 1 CA #28380
2. Carlisle Sure -Weld FleeceBACK TPO shall be adhered to the DensDeck Prime cover board with
Carlisle FAST 100 or FAST 100 LV Bonding Adhesive. Adhesive shall be applied as full coverage at a
rate of 1 gallon per square (100 ft).
This proposed roof covering utilizes approved products listed in Florida Product Approval (FPA) No. FL14083-
R9. The attachment of the DensDeck was determined using Systems SC-61 and SC-82. According to
System C-45 of the above stated FPA, the adherence of the single -ply to DensDeck prime achieves a
maximum design pressure of -457.5 psf, which meets or exceeds the design wind pressures in all Roof Zones.
See Carlisle literature and details for additional information and installation requirements.
Limitations
The scope of this investigation does not include analysis of the load carrying capacity of these structures, and
the fastener patterns provided in this report are based on the materials and fasteners stated above, provided
by Sutter Roofing at the time of this investigation. Design wind pressures and edge distance were determined
using information regarding the location and overall dimensions of the structures provided by Sutter Roofing.
Follow all state, county and local codes and ordinances, and all manufacturer and roofing standard installation
requirements.
Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
Atlas Structural Engineering, LLC
Robin W: Stephan, P.E. #66525
President
NX-101:00-In
ncfl�"
, S. lJ>" \,�'' is �!
Tropicana Fort Pierce I Page 3 of 3
Micro Lab Building