Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMISC EMAILJoe Cicio From: Joe Cicio Sent: Thursday, April 13, 2017 8:16 AM 6GHNNED To: 'Rledgister@gmail.com' BY Cc: 'upfmtrinity@gmail.com'; Joe Cicio St. Lucie Count, Subject: Review Comments for permit number 1703-0686 Attachments: Report_FL_Review_Comments_Noncompliantjrf.pdf Dear St. Lucie County Permit Applicant, Thank you for choosing to do business and invest in St Lucie County. St Lucie County is committed to assisting you navigate the Building review process. Please know that County staff is committed to customer service and part of that service is providing assistance and guidance with our processes. Please do not hesitate to contact us to further discuss your building project as needed. Please seethe attached plan review comments which have been generated for your permit. As soon as we receive 'the modified plans and any additional required documentation back from the design professional, contractor or owner we will perform to permitting for permit issuance. Thank You Plans Examiner Standard Building Inspector Building Plans Examiner One and Two Family Dwelling Inspector One and Two Family Plans Examiner Sf Lt ,ci.,e� Co wvty Ka*wt i v� a vcd Develo w a K Serv+�s H&%w way your serv"today ** PLeaS&cowFue�Carl. Pefersow, r3wi.ldi,K.g offU_i4t af- ogder a @Pttatizc Ora to-S,�your wggeoi,~, acL4 fuAbacic Please Note: Florida has very broad public records laws. Most written communications to or from County officials regarding County business are public records available to the public and media upon request. It is the policy of St. Lucie County that all County records shall be open for personal inspection, examination and / —or copying. Your e-mail communications will be subject to public disclosure unless an exemption applies to the communication. If you-received.this. email in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete all materials from all computers. Joe Cicio From: Joe Cicio Sent: Wednesday, April 19, 2017 10:18 AM �galjitz �I.HNNED To: 'Rledgister@gmail.com' �,� BY Cc: 'upfmtrinity@gmail.com'; Joe Cicio Subject: Review Comments for permit number 1703-0686 [ revised ] St. Lucie Countv Attachments: Report_FL_Review_Com ments_Noncom pliant jrf.pdf Dear St. Lucie County Permit Applicant, Thank you for choosing to do business and invest in St Lucie County. St Lucie County is committed to assisting you navigate the Building review process. Please know that County staff is committed to customer service and part of that service is providing assistance and guidance with our processes. Please do not hesitate to contact us to further discuss your building project as needed. Please see the attached plan review comments which have been generated for your permit. As soon as we receive the modified plans and any additional required documentation back from the design professional, contractor or owner we will perform to permitting for permit issuance. Thank You Plans Examiner Standard Building Inspector Building Plans Examiner One and Two Family Dwelling Inspector One and Two Family Plans Examiner St'LucL. C&I Pla g avtal ServeezY 11 H&vr wa Y your serv" foAa y ** Pl eat covvta t t- Carl- Pe4ersovw, f v-Ud A%g O f fi,ci al, a�, er�owj@s f{ uc i eco org fa- PA4.* Lt' your wggev�, a.vL& faedbia.ck.. Please Note: Florida has very broad public records laws. Most written communications to or from County officials regarding County business are public records available to the public and media upon request. It is the policy of St. Lucie County that all County records shall be open for personal inspection, examination and / or copying. Your e-mail communications will be subject to public disclosure unless an exemption applies to the communication. If you received this email in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete all materials from all computers. Joe Cicio From: Ledgister, Roger <RLEDGISTER@simplexgrinnell.com> SCANNED Wednesday, pril 19, 2017 11:46 AM To: Joe Cicio; upfmtrinity@gmail.com BY Cc: r edgister2@gmai .com St. Lucie Counts Subject: FW: Review Comments for permit number 1703-0686 [ revised ] Attachments: Report_FL_Review_Comments_Noncompliant jrf.pdf; ATT00001.htm This is going to the incorrect email address. Please make sure the County make the correction moving forward Regards Roger Ledgister / Fire Sprinkler Division - Project Management / SimplexGrinnell Direct: 954-862-5272 / Fax: 954-862-5277 10550 Commerce Parkway / Miramar, FL 33025 / USA redgister(a�simplexgrinnell.com / tycosimplexgrinnell.com SimplexGrinnell This email (including any attachments) may contain information that is private or business confidential. If you received this email in error, please delete it from your system without copying it and notify sender by reply email so that our records can be corrected. Tyco's vision is Zero Harm to people and the environment. Please consider the environment before printing this message. From: Roger Ledgister [mailto:rledgister24@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, April 19, 2017 11:36 AM To: Ledgister, Roger Subject: Fwd: Review Comments for permit number 1703-0686 [ revised ] Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Ruth L <rledeister@amail.com> Date: April 19, 2017 at 11:11:16 AM EDT To: rledeister24@email.com Subject: Fwd: Review Comments for permit number 1703-0686 [ revised ] - - " Sent from my Phone Begin forwarded message: From: Joe Cicio <cicioi@stlucieco.ore> Date: April 19, 2017 at 10:18:09 AM EDT To: "'Rledgister@email.com"' <Rledaister@email.com> Cc: "'upfmtrinity@smail.com"' <uofmtrinity@amail.com>, Joe Cicio <cicioi(@stlucieco.ore> Subject: Review Comments for permit number 1703-0686 [ revised ] Dear St. Lucie County Permit Applicant, Thank you for choosing to do business and invest in St Lucie County. St Lucie County is committed to assisting you navigate the Building review process. Please know that County staff is committed to customer service and part of that service is providing assistance and guidance with our processes. Please do not hesitate to contact us to further discuss your building project as needed. Please see the attached plan review comments which have been generated for your permit. As soon as we receive the modified plans and any additional required documentation back from the design professional, contractor or owner we will perform to permitting for permit issuance. Thank You lfoae d W. ecua Plans Examiner Standard Building Inspector Building Plans Examiner One and Two Family Dwelling Inspector One and Two Family Plans Examiner St Lf cci,, Cou�ftfy PL4*vw." a*L& DeYeiopvKe*vFServtce How way your servLu, foolay ** Pl vay� cowfar� Carl Pe¢ersow, 13u4ld;,hg OH-ici,aLa4- o�vtj@yHucieco org ¢a yubvwi,F your P"gex fi , cowwwewly a*L& �. Please Note: Florida has very broad public records laws. Most written communications to or from County officials regarding County business are public records available to the public and media upon request. It is the policy of St. Lucie County that all County records shall be open for personal inspection, examination and / or copying. Your e-mail communications will be subject to public disclosure unless an exemption applies to the communication. If you received this email in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete all materials from all computers. This e-mail contains privileged and confidential information intended for the use of the addressees named above. If you are not the intended recipient of this e- mail, you are hereby notified that you must not disseminate, copy or take any action in respect of any information contained in it. If you have received this e-mail in -_- error, please notify the sender immediately by e-mail and. immediately destroy this e-mail and its attachments. ,i H. STEVE CLARK, ARCHITECT ALTAMONTE SPRINGS, FLORIDA 6 May 2017 St Lucie County Planning & Development Services Building & Code Regulation Division 2300 Virginia Avenue Ft Pierce, FL 34982 Re: Permit Number: 1703-0686 6UA YNED Commercial Renovation: Religious 8243 Business Park Drive 't CUCI@ COUO Ft. Pierce. FL ty To Whom It May Concern: Eme41: Glen60flaftman.com Phone: (772) 924-5439 RECEIVED MAY U 1 2017 PERMIT; ING St. Lucie Bounty, FL This document shall serve as an attempt to answer the review comments as were presented by St Lucie County to this office, dated 04/13/2017.... Item No. 1 - a I i-Lo Drinking fountain has been added to the plans. Although in the past and as allowed by the plumbing code when only one drinking fountain is required by occupancy, a rental bottled water system with cup dispenser was proper. Item No. 2 - It was this offices assumption that a above the ceiling WH unit was existing and there was a coffee bar with sink unit in the existing layout, nevertheless, a low boy WH with pan has been noted to be verified or added as needed to provide hot water to the lavatories and mop basin location. Item No. 3 rtligbM use refers to sanctuary are primarily. In this case that space being 19ft x 31.5ft = (43 men & 43 women) = 2 church staff, making a total maximum occupancy oft9pag5a. A sign within the sanctuary shall indicate that number. Even though, an unfixed chair layout with shown aisle widths indicated shall be 56 seats, 6 persons at the pulpit platform plus 3 front office persons. This gives us a occupancy as was noted on plans of 65, we ask that the Building Official accept this as our working occupancy (actual) FPC 2014 requires 1 WC/150 men / 1 WC / 75 women, Lays at 1 / 200 (m&w), DF at 1 / 1000, SS; 1 Layout as shown is within Code requirements (43m & 43w). exception eliminates the 2:1 ratio W to M. Item No. 4 - A janitors Closet with a Mop Basin has been indicated on the plans. Item No. 5 - A second WC for women is not required, Refer Item No 3 above 476 SPANISH TRACE DRIVE ALTAMONTE SPRINGS, FLORMA 32714 ARCm1ECMULnEGiSTRATION: AR0011463 4 Page 2 PermitNo: 1703-0686 Review Comments Response, cont'd Item No 6 - This is an existing commercial strip center and the units are not sprinkled an it is noted on the Interior Demolition Plan. Existing layout has a lhr separation wall between all units - a 2 hr rated partition is virtually impossible to provide when working on only one face of the separator wall. A second layer of 5/8" type X fire rock was added to the face of the existing within the sanctuary proper but this is not a tested 2 hr rated construction. In my 31 years of practice in St Lucie county on dozens of such temporary church facilities this was accepted. The only other solution and this is now shown in detail on the drawings, is to use the two layers of 5/8" as was intended as one side of the wall then add a framework of 21/2" metal studs at 16"OC on that face tying it to the wood studs then adding two more layers of 5/8" on the sanctuary face per the tested wall constructionga. This provides and over all wall thickness of 9 3/<"on each side wall of the sanctuary which should be more than adequate for 65 people to exit the space. Item No 7 - Construction type of this particular strip center is noted on the plans and highlighted under the title for the Interior Demolition Plan Item No 8 - As noted in the plumbing response, Item No 3, a breakdown of the occupancy load as it pertains to an (A3) religious assembly is given and shown as max 88 persons. This will be shown by signage within the space as required. But again, unfixed seating layout is for 56 chairs, actual added staff bring that to our previous noted 65 persons, an exemption to use this actual number has been requested prior. Item No 9 - egress door sizes are 3068, one front and one rear. FBC allows 0.2"/ occupancy load (88 x .2"=17.6"), we have 72" existing Item No 10 - Life safety travel distances are shown on the Plumbing plan with travel paths noted. Well within the FBC maximum allowed of 75ft. The building itself is only 69ft interior depth. F/ Item No 11 - I have no idea to what you are referring here and all work is interior renovation, y No work is required to the exterior of the building... and no use of a "Maltese Cross" is mentioned. Item No 12 - The choir platform level is a non essential element and has been eliminated. Item No 13 - This is not a stage but an elevated Pulpit platform with a step used for parishioners to come forward and kneel. We ask that the Building Official grant an exemption for a ramp access and is found in so many existing worship places in the county, at least a dozen of which I have designed myself. To do so renders the platform useless for musical instruments ,I Page 3 Permit No 1702-0686 Plan review response cont' d Item No 13 cont'd due to clearances required and also will lose about 6 seats. A space for any guest speaker that may be in be in a wheelchair has a dedicated location, everything to be televised on a big screen. Item No 14 - A required clearance diagram has been added to the plan showing code required clear spaces for water closet, lavatories and door, indicating our layout is within code requirements. This is the first time in 31 years of practice in this county have I ever put such on a sheet of the drawings out of thousands submitted! Item No 15 - Both toilet spaces are identical as is evident, a chart for mounting heights for all items within such toilets was included on the plans. " Item No 16 - 50" high ceramic the finish is noted on plan for each toilet and in the jan closet over water resistant green board or tile backer board. Item No 17 - I find this to be a little insulting to those licensed contractors that are schooled on such applications but I noted the ASTM standard on the wall section. Item No 18 - The designation signage for HC accessible toilets is noted on plans and was referenced in item 7 of the `Scope of Work'. As for wall stenciling, I have never seen it on a project anywhere before but I noted that it be added on the plans. Item No 19 - This too is a little ridiculous to those that hang ceiling 40 hours a week, week after week. But as you requested I put the note on the wall section. Item No 20 - Flame spread and SDI for all insulation utilized has been added by note on the floor plan. Item No 21 - My code does not have a 808.9 section, nor does the one accessed on the state site. I have not added a finish schedule to a set of plans since Interior Designers became state licensed Ours has been to provide a finish surface that is paint ready. All interior specialty is determined between contractor and Owner with a cost for such provided by the Contractor. I did my last finish schedule for an IRCC project in 1990 and was chastised for intruding on another licensed professional works. Just as I don't do Site plans or Landscape plans any longer. Item No 22 - doors mentioned although manned by the ushers in 2 uses of the space per week, have been changed from 2668 to 2868 double doors without mullion and has closers with hold open attachments. Joe Cicio From: Joe Cicio Sent: Monday, May 15, 2017 11:33 AM To: 'rlegister2@gmail.com' °LHNNE® Cc: Joe Cicio; Gregory Smyth BY Subject: Second Review * Comments for Permit Number 1703-0d8d_UCje County Attachments: Report -FL Review_Comments_Noncompliantjrf.pdf Dear St. Lucie County Permit Applicant, Thank you for choosing to do business and invest in St Lucie County. St Lucie County is committed to assisting you navigate the Building review process. Please know that County staff is committed to customer service and part of that service is providing assistance and guidance with our processes. Please do not hesitate to contact us to further discuss your building project as needed. Please see the attached plan review comments which have been generated for your permit. As soon as we receive the modified plans and any additional required documentation back from the design professional, contractor or owner we will perform to permitting for permit issuance. Thank You n \ 0� Plans Examiner &.eel Standard Building Inspector Building Plans Examiner ;�f One and Two Family Dwelling Inspector One and Two Family Plans Examiner St Lt cci,& C4u.vt,1-y Plate i,wg a.wd. DeveL&p4wev4- ServUzP How -way your Serv"faday ** PU4-ywco"*1t -Garb Pefers.vw, 13aitaliA%g OffU, al.af- er o�wj@yllocieto org fa.y�your Wggeyfivwy, cow�w>ewlyastill feedback Please Note: Florida has very broad public records laws. Most written communications to or from County officials regarding County business are public records available to the public and media upon request. It is the policy of St. Lucie County that all County records shall be open for personal inspection, examination and f or copying. Your e-mail communications will be subject to public disclosure unless an exemption applies to the communication. If you received this email in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete all materials from all computers.