HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes 06.04.2019SLu2�[D
COUN
F L❑
RA
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA
Regular Meeting
June 4, 2019
1. CALL TO ORDER
The meeting was called to order at 06:01 PM by District No. 3, Chair Linda Bartz
Present
Convened: 6:01 PM
Adjourned: 8:36 PM
Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky, Commissioner District 2 Sean Mitchell, Commissioner District
3 Linda Bartz, Commissioner District 4 Frannie Hutchinson, Commissioner District 5 Cathy Townsend,
County Administrator Howard Tipton, County Attorney Dan McIntyre, Assistant County Attorney
Heather Young, Deputy County Administrator Jeff Bremer, Mosquito Control Director Glenn
Henderson, Facilities Manager Jeremiah Johnson, Coastal Resources Coordinator Jim Oppenborn, Sr.
Environmental Education Coordinator Wren Underwood, Housing Manager Jennifer Hance, Recording
Secretary Brittany Jones
2. INVOCATION
The County Administrator led the invocation.
3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A motion was made to approve all sets of minutes and it passed unanimously.
RESULT: APPROVE
MOVER: Commissioner District 4 Frannie Hutchinson
SECONDER: Commissioner District 5 Cathy Townsend
AYES: Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
Townsend
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
NAYS: None
EXCUSED: None
A. Board of County Commissioners minutes for the Regular meeting of Tuesday, April 16, 2019
B. Board of County Commissioners minutes for the Informal meeting of Tuesday, April 23, 2019
C. Board of County Commissioners minutes for the Regular meeting of Tuesday, May 7, 2019
D. Board of County Commissioners minutes for the Special meeting of Tuesday, May 14, 2019
5. PROCLAMATIONS APPROVAL
A. Supporting United States House Resolution 763, Impose Fee on Fuels Used To Emit Greenhouse
Gases Into The Atmosphere
(Item heard after Public Comment)
The County Attorney, Dan McIntyre presented this item. He gave some background and read a
brief summary of the House Bill.
Staff recommended the Board's approval of the resolution.
A motion was made to approve staff recommendation and it passed unanimously.
RESULT:
ADOPT
MOVER:
Commissioner District 2 Sean Mitchell
SECONDER:
Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
AYES:
Townsend
NAYS:
None
EXCUSED:
None
2 1 P a g e
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
6. PUBLIC COMMENT (excluding Public Hearing Items)
Chair Bartz opened the meeting for public comment at this time. The following individuals addressed
the Board:
• Clint Sperber, Administrator from the Florida Health Department of St. Lucie County, spoke of
Hepatitis A and provided information on the services available within St. Lucie County. He submitted a
document for the record and Commissioner Mitchell thanked him for speaking on this topic at his
request. Mr. Sperber stated the office number for those wanting more information,
• Stephen Moleski spoke of climate change and in support of the House Bill regarding greenhouse
gases,
• Anthony Bonna, 844 SW Tulip Blvd, spoke of high taxes and property values and advocated a county
charter form of government,
• Susan Izes spoke of the Humane Society and the wellness and treatment of animals including animal
abuse,
• Susan Parry, from United For Animals, spoke of the Humane Society, asked for an update on
ordinances relating to TNVR and shared a photo of kittens who need a foster home,
• Jerry Buechler, 1719 SW Leafy Rd, spoke in support of House Bill 763,
• Richard Silvestri, 5708 Buchanan Drive, spoke in support of House Bill 763,
• Kathy Norton, shelter reform advocate, spoke of a need for change in management and the board of
directors for the Humane Society,
• Ann Johnson, spoke in support of House Bill 763.
There being no one further wishing to address the Board, Chair Bartz closed public comment.
7. PRESENTATIONS
A. Recognition of Volunteer Contributions of MMPS Environmental and the Coastal Conservation
Association
This presentation was given by Jim Oppenborn, the Coastal Resources Coordinator. Both the
Coastal Conservation Association (CCA) and MMPS Environmental were recognized and given
thanks for all their hard work and efforts in assisting the County with the sinking of the Voici
Bernadette as an artificial reef. The Coastal Resources Coordinator presented Andy Steinberg from
the CCA and Katrina and her team from MMPS Environmental with plaques recognizing their
support. Mr. Steinberg announced the name of the reef will be "No Shoes Reef" in honor of Kenny
Chesney who is a huge supporter of CCA nationwide. Commissioner Dzadovsky asked the Coastal
Resources Coordinator to provide his contact information for anyone wishing to sponsor or help
with the artificial reef projects.
B. Mosquito Control Awareness Week
Glenn Henderson, the Mosquito Control Director, gave a presentation to provide important
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
information on mosquito awareness and ways for the community to protect itself against
mosquitos. He detailed mosquito and other insect related diseases and illnesses. He also gave the
history of the Mosquito Control District, which was first created in 1926 and stated their primary
goal is to protect public health. The Mosquito Control Director explained the role of the mosquito
impoundments around the County and the innovative ways the district is utilizing technology and
other means to find a better way to operate. Next, the Senior Education Coordinator Wren
Underwood promoted Mosquito Control Awareness Week, which will be June 23-29. She talked
about the level of participation within the community, the education and outreach provided, and
tips for the community to help "fight the bite". Lastly, she highlighted the Mosquito Control
Awareness Week's events, including a poster contest and contact information.
C. United Way Campaign
The Facilities Manager Jeremiah Johnson gave an update and presentation on the results of the
County employee driven campaign for the United Way. He invited Roxanne Hall from United Way,
the County Administrator who serves as the campaign chair, and employees from the Facilities
Department to join him. He thanked the Board for all their support and recognized the hard work
of the Facilities team as well as the ambassadors who worked with all of the County departments.
The Facilities Manager highlighted the employees donated a total of $62,233, which was a $6,900
increase from the year prior and an increase of 35 employees who donated. Continuing on, he
thanked all the local partners, sponsors, volunteers and staff that made the golf tournament a
success, raising over $34,000 in sponsorships. The Director of Campaign for United Way, Ms. Hall
thanked the Board and County employees for their leadership and dedication to United Way. To
wrap it up, the Facilities Manager proudly presented the United Way with a check in the amount
of $96,253.21.
D. FCCMA Award
Jeff Bremer, Deputy County Administrator, gave background of the Florida City and County
Management Association (FCCMA). The Deputy County Administrator stated he was honored to
nominate the County Administrator for the FCCMA Achievement Award. He spoke of Mr. Tipton's
tremendous impact, volunteer work and the leadership he has exhibited for St. Lucie County along
with three prior counties. He also talked about the event where Mr. Tipton won and was
presented with the FCCMA Lifetime Achievement Award. Then a video put together by the
Communications Director, Erick Gill, was shown in recognition of Howard Tipton, County
Administrator.
8. CONSENT AGENDA
Commissioner Hutchinson asked to discuss Items 8.K.3. (Camping World - Fee -in -Lieu of Sidewalk
Construction) and 8.K.5. (Approval of Work Authorization No. 10 with McCulley Marine Services to
Deploy the Voici Bernadette as an Artificial Reef). Commissioner Hutchinson asked the Board if they are
in agreement to add language to Item 8.K.3. that reflects "funds earmarked specifically for the Jenkins
Road corridor". The Board was in agreement and it was asked that staff add that language.
Item 8.K.5. was pulled for separate vote.
4 1 P a g e
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
A motion was made to adopt the consent agenda with the additional language added to Item 8.K.3. and
the motion passed unanimously.
RESULT:
ADOPT
MOVER:
Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky
SECONDER:
Commissioner District 5 Cathy Townsend
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
AYES:
Townsend
NAYS:
None
EXCUSED:
None
A. WARRANTS
1. Warrant Lists 33 & 34
Adopted by Consent Vote
B. ADMINISTRATION
1. Appointment to the Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy Board
Adopted by Consent Vote
2. Appointment to the Housing Finance Authority
Adopted by Consent Vote
C. AIR & SEA PORT
1. Budget Resolution - FWC Fisherman's Wharf Boat Ramp Design Grant
Adopted by Consent Vote
D. COUNTY ATTORNEY
1. Permission to Advertise Public Hearing - Abandonment of Huron Avenue and Chippewa
Avenue - San Lucie Plaza
5 1 P a g e
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
Adopted by Consent Vote
2. Permission to Advertise a Public Hearing to declare 809 N. 9th Street in Fort Pierce surplus
property
Adopted by Consent Vote
3. Permission to Advertise - Second Amendment to Development Agreement with FVP Miami
Lakes, LLC - Silver Oaks PUD
Adopted by Consent Vote
4. Animal Safety and Protection Services - Interlocal Agreement with St. Lucie Village
Adopted by Consent Vote
5. Resolution - Right -of -Way Donation - 20 feet on Hartman Road and
15 feet on South 37th Street - Parcel ID 2417-233-0001-000-9
Adopted by Consent Vote
6. Revocable License Agreement - Naco Road - Parcel ID 1433-142-0010-000-3
Adopted by Consent Vote
7. Revocable License Agreement - River Park - Ruth Roudebush
109 SE Placita Court - Parcel ID 3419-550-0144-000-6 - Fence
Adopted by Consent Vote
8. Fort Pierce FBO, LLC - Sublease Agreement with Byte Me Transportation, Inc.
Adopted by Consent Vote
9. Fort Pierce FBO, LLC -Second Amendment to Amended and Restated Lease Agreement
Adopted by Consent Vote
10. Permission to Advertise - Maverick Boat Group, Inc. Economic Development Ad Valorem
Tax Exemption Ordinance
Adopted by Consent Vote
1. Budget Resolution - Modification #2 of the Community Services Block Grant (CSBG)
Agreement.
6 1 P a g e
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
Adopted by Consent Vote
2. Budget Resolution - Western Union Settlement Grant Agreement
Adopted by Consent Vote
3. Amendment of Resolution No. 11-161
Adopted by Consent Vote
F. ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES
1. Walton Scrub Observation Tower Project Design and Engineering, Contract C15-02-091,
Work Authorization No. 3
Adopted by Consent Vote
2. Board approval of the Land Acquisition Selection Committee's (LASC) recommendation to
pursue acquisition of the Pursuit Boats 10-acre Parcel.
Adopted by Consent Vote
3. Board approval of the Land Acquisition Selection Committee's (LASC) recommendation to
pursue acquisition of the Lennard/Kitterman Parcel.
Adopted by Consent Vote
C��1�1��].�►�iI_t�[�]�ItLX�I:Ii!L�]��ZH'1
1. Interlocal Agreement between St. Lucie County and the St Lucie County Property Appraiser
for the Lease of Server Rack Space at the Information Technology Facility located at 101
North Rock Road
Adopted by Consent Vote
H. PARKS & RECREATION
1. Waiver for Night To Shine Prom
Adopted by Consent Vote
2. Recreational Accessories Pilot Program
7 1 P a g e
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
Adopted by Consent Vote
3. Parks, Parks Preserves, and Recreation Master Plan
Adopted by Consent Vote
4. Special Olympics' Request for Ravenswood Pool
Adopted by Consent Vote
5. Lakewood Regional Park Proposed Public Potable Water Connection (Plan and Design) 2nd
Amendment to Work Authorization No. 03 under contract C14-09-397
Adopted by Consent Vote
6. First Data Field (Mets Stadium) - Storage Shed Renovation
Adopted by Consent Vote
I. PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
1. Creekside Plat No. 4 - Final Plat (Replat) of Creekside Plat No. 3 (Parcel B) consisting of 129
Single -Family lots
Adopted by Consent Vote
J. PUBLIC SAFETY
1. Statewide Mutual Aid Agreement and Resolution
Adopted by Consent Vote
K. PUBLIC WORKS
1. Award Bid No. 19-038 - Subdivision 3 Mowing
Adopted by Consent Vote
2. Award Bid Nos. 19-034 and 19-035 - Midway Rd. @ NSLRWCD C-92 and Midway Rd. @
NSLRWCD C-93 Culvert Replacements
Adopted by Consent Vote
8 1 P a g e
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
3. Camping World - Fee -in -Lieu of Sidewalk Construction
Adopted by Consent Vote
(Please note: language added to staff recommendation. See text under "Consent Agenda"
heading.)
4. Award Bid No. 19-020 - Prima Vista Boulevard Milling & Resurfacing & Prima Vista
Boulevard Drainage West of US 1
Adopted by Consent Vote
5. Approval of Work Authorization No. 10 with McCulley Marine Services to Deploy the Voici
Bernadette as an Artificial Reef
It was requested that this item be pulled for a separate vote. Commissioner Hutchinson had
questions on this item that the County Administrator answered. Commissioner Townsend
stated she is abstaining from voting due to a conflict.
A motion was made to approve staff recommendation and upon roll call, the motion passed 4-
0.
RESULT:
MOVER:
SECONDER:
AYES:
NAYS:
RECUSED:
L. SHERIFF'S OFFICE
APPROVE
Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky
Commissioner District 2 Sean Mitchell
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson
None
Cathy Townsend
1. 2019 Youth Gang Suppression Grant
Adopted by Consent Vote
9. PUBLIC HEARINGS
A. COMMUNITY SERVICES
9 1 P a g e
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
1. County Owned Property Suitable for Affordable Housing
Jennifer Hance, Housing Manager presented this item. Florida Statute 125.379 requires each
county to prepare an inventory list of all real property within its jurisdiction to which the county
holds fee simple titles that are appropriate for use as affordable housing.
The properties identified as appropriate for use as affordable housing may be offered for sale and
the proceeds used to purchase land for the development of affordable housing or to increase the
local government fund earmarked for affordable housing, or may be sold with a restriction that
requires the development of the property as permanent affordable housing, or may be donated to
a nonprofit housing organization for the construction of permanent affordable housing.
Alternatively, the county may otherwise make the property available for use for the production
and preservation of permanent affordable housing.
Staff recommended Board approval of the list of properties owned by St. Lucie County suitable for
affordable housing, the Resolution establishing an updated list; and authorization for the Chair to
sign documents as approved by the County Attorney.
Chair Bartz opened the hearing for public comment at this time. There being no one wishing to
address the Board, Chair Bartz closed the public hearing.
A motion was made to approve staff recommendation and it passed unanimously.
RESULT:
APPROVE
MOVER:
Commissioner District 2 Sean Mitchell
SECONDER:
Commissioner District 4 Frannie Hutchinson
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
AYES:
Townsend
NAYS:
None
EXCUSED:
None
B. PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
1. Major Adjustment to Treasure Coast International Airport (TCIA) Conditional Use - Aviator
College — Expansion (FKA Pan Am International Flight School)
This item was presented by Kori Benton, Senior Planner. The applicant, B & E Houck Enterprises,
Inc., and representative, Ernesto Velasco, PE, of Velcon Engineering and Surveying, LLC, are
10 1 P a g
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
requesting a Major Adjustment to the existing Conditional Use for the Treasure Coast International
Airport (TCIA) and Major Site Plan. (It was noted this item in concurrent with Item 10.C.1.) Notice
of the public hearing was advertised in the St. Lucie Tribune, notice signs were placed on the
property and mail notices were sent to all property owners within 500 feet of the subject
property.
The proposed adjustment includes development of a 17,500 sq. ft., two-story, aviation classroom
building within the existing Aviator College (Formerly Pan Am International Flight School). The
10.42-acre site is zoned U, Utilities. The site is located at the northeast corner of the existing
campus, adjacent to the flight school apron, located at 4240 Aviator Way. Aviator College currently
operates an approximately 77,500 sq. ft. aviation college and flight school at the TCIA.
Staff recommended approval of the proposed Major Adjustment to Conditional Use Permit with
conditions.
It was noted that this public hearing was quasi-judicial and the commissioners made the following
disclosures regarding this item:
• Commissioner Hutchinson stated she met with staff
• Commissioner Mitchell stated he met with staff
• Commissioner Dzadovsky stated he met with staff
• Commissioner Townsend stated she met with staff
• Chair Bartz stated she met with staff
Chair Bartz opened the hearing for public comment at this time. There being no one wishing to
address the Board, Chair Bartz closed the public hearing.
A motion was made to approve staff recommendation and it passed unanimously.
RESULT: APPROVE
MOVER: Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky
SECONDER: Commissioner District 4 Frannie Hutchinson
AYES: Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
Townsend
NAYS: None
C. COUNTY ATTORNEY
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
1. Resolution - Authorizing Application of the District Utility Rates to Former Customers of the
South Hutchinson Island Municipal Services Benefit Unit (MSBU)
The County Attorney presented this item. He stated the draft Resolution would apply the 2019
District rates to the former customers of the South Hutchinson Island Municipal Services Benefit
(SHI MSBU).
On Friday, May 24, 2019 staff received an email requesting a deferral of the item until
September/October.
Staff recommended that the Board continue the public hearing to September 3, 2019 at 6:00 PM
or as soon thereafter as the item may be heard.
Chair Bartz opened the hearing for public comment at this time. There being no one wishing to
address the Board, Chair Bartz closed the public hearing.
A motion was made to continue the public hearing to September 3, 2019 at 6:00 PM or soon
thereafter as the item may be heard. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously.
RESULT: CONTINUED TO: SEPTEMBER 3, 2019 AT 6:00 PM
MOVER: Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky
SECONDER: Commissioner District 5 Cathy Townsend
AYES:
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
Townsend
NAYS: None
EXCUSED: None
10. REGULAR AGENDA
A. ADMINISTRATION
1. Request for Proposal (RFP) No. 19-001, Transportation Services
The County Attorney stated that as Chair Bartz is the Board's appointee for the Council on Aging's
board of directors he recommended that the Chair abstain from voting. Further, he recommended
12 1
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
that the Chair pass the gavel to Vice -Chair Townsend and therefore have no participation on the
item.
(Please note: At this time, Chair Bartz passed the gavel to Vice -Chair Townsend.)
The County Administrator stated there will be an overview of the item, time for questions from
the Board and then time allotted (10 minutes or longer at the Board's discretion) for the
protesting company and then for the recommended company. After, it will go back to the Board
for discussion and a vote.
Then, the County Administrator detailed the organizational structure and state statute that
designates the Board as the Community Transportation Coordinator. He explained the Federal
procurement requirement and provided background on the current provider Community Transit,
the St. Lucie County Transit Development Plan, and the St. Lucie County Transportation
Disadvantaged Service Plan. The County Administrator stated an operational analysis was
conducted during the summer of 2018. The County's internal auditor RSM subcontracted this
analysis to Sam Schwartz, a nationally ranked traffic, transportation planning and engineering firm.
The results were presented to the Board at the informal meeting October 9, 2018.
Continuing on, the County Administrator explained how the recommendations included in the
analysis were utilized in developing the RFP process including the ranking criteria and scoring
weights.
Next, the Purchasing Manager, Desiree Cimino, went over the procurement process which
includes the County procurement policy, legal requirements to advertise in the legal section of the
local newspaper, pre -bid meeting, and the extensive addendum issued during a Question &
Answer period that resulted in an extension of the deadline. She explained the selection
committee process, approval of the selection committee and what the selection committee
members were provided with and discussed at their meeting.
On February 28, 2019, the Selection Committee evaluated and ranked the proposals that were
received. Although not a requirement of the RFP, the opportunity to hold oral presentations with
the shortlisted proposers was given to the Selection Committee members, the Committee
unanimously decided presentations were not needed.
The short-listed firms for Transportation Services in order of ranking are as follows:
1. MV Transportation
2. Council on Aging of St. Lucie, Inc — Community Transit
On March 13, 2019 at 8:11 am, the Purchasing Manager received an e-mail from Robert Driscoll of
the Council on Aging. The e-mail contained a protest letter from the Council on Aging/Community
Transit in regard to the award of RFP 19-001-Transportation Services to MV Transportation. Per
Section 12.3 of the St. Lucie County Purchasing Manual, Stay of Procurement during Protest, staff
pulled the agenda item concerning RFP No. 19-001 from the March 2019 Board meeting.
13 1 P a g
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
Per Section 12.2 Resolution of Protest, the County Administrator met with the County Attorney
and discussed the letter of protest received from Council on Aging/Community Transit. There was
a difference of opinion on the strength of the appeal and that appeal is before the Board tonight
for their direction.
The County Administrator stated staff is available for questions. The Board did not have any
questions at this time.
Next, the appealing party, Community Transit was given the opportunity to speak. Darrell
Drummond, the President/CEO of Council on Aging/Community Transit, reiterated the three
reasons for the formal protest (as contained in the letter dated March 12, 2019). The reasons were
in regards to Base -Price models, the timeline of the RFP, and the appearance of undue weight
given to emerging technologies and assumptions made regarding familiarity with emerging
technologies. He addressed the working relationship for 27 years between the County and the
Council on Aging of St. Lucie, Inc. Mr. Drummond also addressed the timeframe given in order to
file an appeal.
Then, Steve Trinkle from MV Transportation, Inc., spoke. He addressed the two main reasons MV
Transportation decided to bid on St. Lucie County. The first being the changing population
demographic of St. Lucie County and the second being that they fit the criteria as outlined in the
RFP. Mr. Trinkle affirmed if the RFP is reissued MV Transportation will bid again. He stated they
firmly belief they are well suited and a good match for the County's transportation needs. He
concluded with saying MV Transportation will abide by the Board's decision and expressed their
appreciation to the Board for the opportunity to speak.
At this time, the County Administrator stated the two options available for the Board's
consideration. The first option would follow the County Administrator's recommendation for the
award of RFP which would include:
• Uphold the County Administrator's protest denial;
• Approval of the highest ranked company to provide public transportation services and
permission to:
• Conduct contract negotiations with highest ranked propser;
• If negotiations are successful, award contract, and authorization for the Chair to sign the
documents as prepared by the County Attorney;
• If staff is unable to negotiate a satisfactory contract with the highest ranked proposer,
negotiations with that company shall be terminated and staff shall attempt to negotiate a contract
with the second ranked firm. If these negotiations are not successful, they shall be terminated
with the second proposer and a new request for proposal shall be advertised.
• Contract extension with current transportation provided until transition is made to the awarded
provider.
The second option would follow the County Attorney's recommendation which is to reject the
Committee's recommendation on RFP No. 19-001 and re -advertise the RFP (if that is the Board's
desire) to correct the deficiency concern.
14 1 P a g
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
Commissioner Dzadovsky asked staff a few questions on if customer satisfaction level was
considered and for more detail on the cost -pricing aspect. Commissioner Dzadovsky asked the
County Administrator if he could address the 24-hour response timeframe for a party to file an
appeal and the County Administrator stated he could not address that matter. The Purchasing
Manager stated the cost component was not specifically addressed under the financial scoring
section; however it was asked for as part of the RFP process. Commissioner Dzadovsky further
asked if it is unusual to have that information requested in the RFP but not considered for the
scoring. The Purchasing Manager stated it would be typical to have that spelled out.
Commissioner Dzadovsky asked for the timeline of reissuing the RFP. The Purchasing Manager
stated the turnaround would be within the next 30 days and explained the 1-year extension. The
County Administrator added that the focus tonight is determining which way the Board would like
to proceed with the appeal and then the next steps would be addressed.
Commissioner Hutchinson asked the Purchasing Manager to explain the protest procedure. It was
explained that the current process is that the protest is brought to the County Administrator who
would discuss it with the County Attorney to decide further action.
Vice -Chair Townsend asked if the grant funding would be jeopardized in any way. The Purchasing
Manager responded that following the process as outlined in the Purchasing Manual of either
going with the Selection Committee's recommendation or the County Attorney's recommendation
should not cause funding to be jeopardized.
Both Commissioners Hutchinson and Dzadovsky expressed their thoughts on the highly valued but
different opinions and recommendations of both the County Administrator and the County
Attorney.
The County Administrator stated if the Board chooses to reject the Selection Committee's
recommendation, he suggests that the RFP go back out after the financial analysis audit is
completed and a discussion is had with the City of Fort Pierce and the City of Port St. Lucie
regarding transit services. He further recommended (if the Selection Committee's
recommendation is rejected) that no action be taken until the Board has been updated after 90
days. There was a discussion on the terms of the extension with Community Transit and the
County Administrator's recommendation.
Both Commissioner Dzadovsky and Vice -Chair Townsend spoke of the transportation service needs
of Port St. Lucie. Vice -Chair Townsend further commented on the two differing recommendations
and said this decision is important as St. Lucie County continues to grow and change.
There were no further comments or questions from the Board at this time.
A motion was made by Commissioner Hutchinson to follow the County Attorney's
recommendation to reject the Selection Committee's recommendation on RFP No. 19-001 and to
extend the contract with the current transportation provider for 1 year. It was clarified the
151Page
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
2
decision to re -advertise the RFP and when to do so, will be decided by the Board at a future
meeting. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Dzadovsky and upon roll call, the motion
passed 4-0.
(Please note: Vice -Chair Townsend passed the gavel back to Commissioner Bartz at this time.)
RESULT:
APPROVE
MOVER:
Commissioner District 4 Frannie Hutchinson
SECONDER:
Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky
AYES:
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy Townsend
NAYS:
None
RECUSED:
Linda Bartz
Appointment to Treasure Coast Health Council, Inc. - At -Large Member Vacancy
This item was presented by the County Administrator. There is currently one consumer vacancy
and one provider vacancy on the Treasure Coast Health Council, Inc. There were no applications
received for the provider vacancy.
Staff recommended that the Board vote and appoint one at -large member from the applications
submitted to fill the consumer vacancy on the Treasure Coast Health Council, Inc.
Using a ballot, Board members each voted for one applicant to fill the at -large member vacancy on
the Treasure Coast Health Council, Inc. By a majority of votes, Kathleen Burndette was appointed.
The County Administrator published each Commissioners' vote and it was suggested by the County
Attorney that the Board approve the appointment as two votes were cast for the aforementioned
appointee.
A motion was made to approve the appointment of Kathleen Burndette to fill the vacant seat on
the Treasure Coast Health Council, Inc. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously.
RESULT:
APPROVE
MOVER:
Commissioner District 2 Sean Mitchell
SECONDER:
Commissioner District 4 Frannie Hutchinson
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
AYES:
Townsend
NAYS:
None
EXCUSED:
None
16 1
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
3. Appointment to the Port of Fort Pierce Advisory Committee - At -Large Member Vacancy
There is currently one vacancy on the Port of Fort Pierce Advisory Committee due to the
resignation of Brad Currie.
Staff recommended that the Board vote and appoint one at -large member from the applications
submitted to fill the consumer vacancy on the Port of Fort Pierce Advisory Committee.
Using a ballot, Board members each voted for one applicant to fill the consumer vacancy on the
Port of Fort Pierce Advisory Committee. By a majority of votes, John Thompson was appointed.
The County Administrator published each Commissioners' votes.
B. COUNTY ATTORNEY
1. Aero Shade Technologies, Inc. - Mediated Settlement Agreement
Assistant County Attorney Heather Young presented this item. On May 17, 2019, County staff and
representative of Aero Shade Technologies, Inc. participated in mediation with regard to the
eviction of Aero Shade from 3104 and 3106 Industrial Avenue. At the conclusion of the mediation,
the representatives agreed to present the following settlement terms to their principals on or
before June 4, 2019.
The proposed settlement terms will permit Aero Shade to remain in the building and retain its
workforce while looking for an alternate site for its operations. In return, the County will receive
increased rent for the property in addition to funding to bring the building into compliance or such
other needs as the County deems appropriate.
Staff recommended the Board of County Commissioners approve the proposed settlement with
Aero Shade Technologies, and authorize the Chair to sign the settlement agreement as prepared
by the County Attorney.
Chair Bartz asked questions on how the no access to the mezzanine condition (unless a fire escape
is built) would be enforced. Both the Assistant County Assistant and the Director of Port & Airport,
Stan Payne, answered those questions. Chair Bartz emphasized her concern is one of public health
17 1 P a g
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
C
1.
and safety. Commissioner Townsend had a question related to another company within the
airport complex to which the Assistant County Attorney provided an answer.
A motion was made to approve staff recommendation and it passed unanimously.
RESULT:
APPROVE
MOVER:
Commissioner District 1 Chris Dzadovsky
SECONDER:
Commissioner District 2 Sean Mitchell
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
AYES:
Townsend
NAYS:
None
EXCUSED:
None
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
Major Adjustment to Major Site Plan Aviator College — Expansion (FKA Pan Am International
Flight School)
(This item was presented in conjunction with Item 9.13.1)
The applicant, B & E Houck Enterprises, Inc., and representative, Ernesto Velasco, PE, of Velcon
Engineering and Surveying, LLC, are requesting a Major Adjustment to the existing Site Plan,
concurrent with a Major Adjustment to Conditional Use for the Treasure Coast International
Airport (TCIA).
Staff recommended approval of the requested Major Adjustment to an existing Site Plan subject to
the conditions of approval contained within the Staff Report and Resolution.
A motion was made to approve staff recommendation and it passed unanimously.
RESULT: APPROVE
MOVER: Commissioner District 4 Frannie Hutchinson
SECONDER: Commissioner District 2 Sean Mitchell
AYES:
Chris Dzadovsky, Sean Mitchell, Linda Bartz, Frannie Hutchinson, Cathy
Townsend
NAYS: None
OR
BOCC Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 4, 2019 6:00 PM
EXCUSED: None
11. ANNOUCEMENTS
Commissioner Townsend requested the results or status of the space study that was done on the
judicial buildings. The County Administrator said that will be discussed during budget workshops.
A. The Board of County Commissioners will hold a Regular meeting on Tuesday, July 2, 2019 at 6pm
in the Commission Chambers of the Roger Poitras Administration Annex located at 2300 Virginia
Avenue, Fort Pierce, FL.
B. County Offices will be closed on Thursday, July 4, 2019 in observance of Independence Day.
C. The Board of County Commissioners will hold a Regular meeting on Tuesday, July 16, 2019 at gam
in the Commission Chambers of the Roger Poitras Administration Annex located at 2300 Virginia
Avenue, Fort Pierce, FL.
D. June marks the beginning of hurricane season (June 1 until Nov. 30) and St. Lucie County urges all
residents to make sure they have a plan and restock their hurricane kits. If you need to pre -
register for the Medical Special Needs Shelter or the Pet -Friendly Shelter - be sure to do so now.
Don't wait until a storm is approaching our area. Additionally, now is the time to trim trees and
vegetation. For more hurricane preparedness visit - www.stlucieco.gov/eoc.
12. MOTION TO ADJOURN
There being no further business to be brought before the Board, the meeting was adjourned.
Please note: Final minutes are recorded in the official minute books that are filed with the Clerk of the
Circuit Court and available for inspection upon request.
19 1
LIJLij
LLI
z z
0 1
0
L u-
L
0
(.)
LLI
LL
0
-i
> uj
0
Pf
0 w
0 ui
z
w
0
0 ~OIL
a.
a:
L 0
<
U
F-
D
<
w
0
13
z
z
0
<
0O
U)
z
ui
0 0.
2
Ou
U) r-
L,) z
0
F/5
C)
_j
0c)
-
0
2 �5; Lk: D
00 0
U
o
w
w
z 00
Ot's
Z
::D
U)
0
-::)
0
Z <
U W
t
U)
w
0
6
m a)
>
af
0 w
Q
0
0-
z
0
>
LL 0
w
<
0
in
0
U)
0
U-
"5
z u)
w L)
LU
< z
03:
M �-
Z Z
0 j
:D
z -j
0 4..;
U)
c)
uj
z
<
Mui
z
00
O
w
0
Lnu
<
0
w
z
>
<
I
0
zF-
(1)
!? C)
WW.CU
w C
>
0)
o—
0
wl 'S
C:
0—
0,5
C3
i C14-
2(l)
< (0)
Z C
(9 >Z (=)
2
. E)
z V,
0 0)
O 0
:5 C)
:�z (Y)
W
U-
0) a)0
w8
-Ea)
M
OL
0
0) E
0
.ff
--o
cu 0)
0
-0 0
cu !E
.o >
a) (u
16
a) s
2� 0
:t--
a)
CO > CO
C:
0
—.0
(D
2
a)
0)
U)
c
0 a)
(D
CL Q.
CL
c ca
0 o
cc 0
c -C
o
0
U)
0
0
.d)
(D
"a
m
E 0
ca
c
a)
>
a)
m 0
00
0 0
Z
0
0 cu >1
ca
0>
0
a)
0
LL
a) c:
cu
a)
Ujf6
r-
-jp
M
N CLL �
a) 0
(n co
>
'a
E V)
0 (D
cu
0
V)
0 0
a)
(3) LL
E
Q
0 a)
o E
>
a) o u)
0
C)
wO
a)
U)
CU
-0
0
C CL
a)
a)
C)-
-r- ca
c a) u
0 *�
0
C6
to a)
>
(D E
CL 0
a) �p
I--
-
C'J
a)
---o
a) a)
o
r- a)
CO A--
'0
0
cn
a)
cn 0
a) o c
O U)
0 Ca -
a)
L:) 0 C:
cu
0 c
0 a)
E F5 :3
(D
E 9)
"sQ
E a)
OBE
0
Q . -
c
0 0 0
.r- c 'a w --o
u o a) — a) (D
- (n r-
3: (0 0
2
a)
a)
w
ca
a)
3: c m fn z; --
(D �p
c ca
.- -
0)
-j
= - cn -9--
0 0 0 0
2 -,;�
I 0 0
M
0
C:
a) 6
:5 a)
'o
72
> ,cn < CL
>,
a)
I_- a)0
0
0
O
a)
w
8
UL)
to 0 Q� —
(a a) o
C)
42 C:
.
-C
0
p
E I;
p
E (n cu c
0 a)
3:
(D
0
F-
- -
0
0
>
m 0 o a) -q) m
c 0
—0
C) c
a)
w
(D
0 w
Fn cn
(D
T
O)o E 0)
co n(0
a) a ca
I-_ =
(n
cu
W
c
C,�
M
in
0
G
W-
'6 o U)
E
0
CL
% -
E
E P M> 2)
o U) 0 a)
w a)
6-0
a)
o)
—
c
0
t a)
a)
<
0
fn
CO a) o
>
a)
a)
M =
0)
�n
U) cc
>1
(D
�F)
o �o
C:
a)
4)
w
1�1
I c
z
Q.
U.
U) 1- Z) co m
cu a)
-0 a)
(D
CY)
P=
w
a)
(n.- �o
0
a)
w
r-
< 0 r-
a)
0
Ca
E E
a)
(D
>,
3:
0 E
w
U) E C:
Dow
-c-
0
E
C a)
0)
C4
0 > 8 0
0 a) - -0
0)
U)
mom
=$ 0
fn a)
M " -
a)
Zn
t 2
(D
0
.2
SQ
0 OL
a) 0 �c o a)
ca 0 (n
2
0
0
en
0
z
4-- M - -
0 0 c 0 0
>% EL
L)
Mn
0
W -0
0
0 m c
a)
0 c
M 0
-0
C
0 0
E
CL
�F a)
-c-
(D C 0
-0
cn
z
cc
UJ
O-c: E
-(a 00-
-r- co
a) >;
E
:3
E
a)
-a a)
c -�
- a)
(D c-
> —
0
—
a) 0
�� 0
Cf)
—'6 E
0 x
E E
0
CO0
Co
o- .
n 0 c
U)
-
C:
-
0 cu m mo m
—
I-:- 2(D CL
a) — 0
co
4)
o) E
c
4-- a)
ca
'0
C)
W
0 di
- (D
(D 0 0 CU
-0 c:
ca L)
>
0
a)
-a
a) (D
CU
0
-�L 5
_r_ .2-
o C: 0 q)
-
TWO
�o
co
0
-
E
-0
0
w
3:
E
E
w
0 .- 0 CL
0 t-, (n (n
cn
cn �3
CU
a) r-
0)
=
L
0
0 E
0
U) =
a) 0
W
ca a)
0 CU C%3
CO �c - w FD
0
0 U) Z!
iF- 6
'0 (D ;�,
(n ",t�
%.-,
z
z
0 0 010
Ca U) a)
0 r- c
0 a)
0
C/)
-2 -
.2 0
w
:D
m
cn E
.2 cL
0
(D CO
(D
D
1�
U)
m =
:3 -a
-J
U-
L2 -0
E u)
0 C: E �
" =
C: < x
I
0
Z
Ca a)
E
ns
0 0) M-6 -6
0 (D
>
o 2-
0
E -0
0
0 -i6 8 w
a) (a C)
C: 0
A
Z
W 0
a)
:3 -0
c 0 m
a) 0
0 0 D)o 0
a) c
a)
n a t6
-Fu
a)
w
�e
0
>
0) E
2
-0 CL
0
(D OL
> - cn -a o 0
c
.- .2 L-:, C:
a)
<
W 0
:,
a)
>
w
E 0
0
LL
>m a) -a
'C
a) Q) o
(D
> a)
fA
ca C:
0 0) m
-i6 a)
>
Z3 M
T -a cl
c
Z
0
o
E
<
z
m .- .2 i!� -
0 (D CU Cfj
�a
2, m 8
C:
w
6
Lu
2
- en C:
z
<
0
0
0 a) �5 Lj�
a) U) C: (n CL - 2:1
cn
E
0
LLJ 6)
C
U-
<
- - m
r a)
0)
w
F-
> -0 t-
D �6 LO
4-- =)
0
Co.
w
4=
0)
01-
> 0
(D
U) a)
LL
ca
y
<
C: CY)
()
cb . C)
0 -r- =s C.) CL
a) o a)
e c
U) 0
U-
-
>
W
< E
LL
-0 E
m
a)
(L) o 3: C: CL (0
a) U)
>,
C:
— Co
LL
0
— U)
U) a) C:
0
E
0).T = �a a) m
c -C 0
0 :f;
'6 cn r-
0
101
0 0)
LO
Z =
E
E a)
CO)
Z
0.1--
a— a) o (o c
-
LO
0
rn 70
cu 3:
m
ui
z
W
o
0
G a)c C')
0 CO
-, 2
0 C: w cn
uj
t
0
E
0 u) -6
>
c-
"=3 4L) c& -6
()
.2
:L-
13-
E
0) a a)
Z) :�;
=3
a) :2 (D
:3 6 E
0 E
c
C�:5
0 -c2: p)
Lu
_j
cc
CL
CL
0,5s
a)
OW
>- y
) •
c a) g
o
LL,
S
�c
<
w
0
a
0 0
O
E
a)
ac E
0,
C:5
Lp 0
0
o
Z
w
_0
w
2
70
N a)
w
7:
E
F-
E
-0
z
0
0
E2 >
2
c
So
C:
-Z�
C� a -0
ID a)
Z)
0
co
a)
E
E E
0
ca
(D
0
E2 E —
E2
~
0
o �2
(D
-0
b-
w
Q
0
0 4)
a)
E
0
E
c)
x
-
0 o m
E
"
0
uj
cn
> >, CD
a)
0
ca
a)
E
a) 0-.S;
0 —
L) (D
a)
0)
< E
4-
ca
C.)M
LUO
-C
cn
a) X
a)
w
(D
E
w
C
0
0
(D
E
E
c
Z
w
0>1
E wo
ri
—
-0
-J
:3
a) 0 CL
0,,.ca,D
cu
LL
z
N
-C
2
0
cu
c
(DCo
(ca:
W
a
a)O
Co—Q)
m
E -
- 0
CL
a.
2
>,
=
_p fl-
E
=3
E
,
CU
a)
UJ
ca
a)
�c 0
E
U.
0
E
<
(D
00
(D :3
o
o
z
-5
-a E Q)
E
W
a)
w
(n
70 .-
0
0 C:
z
0
E
<
4-
to cc
L
0
0
0E
E
CL
0.
0
<
a)
-C-
0
>-
Z
�P-
:3 (D
� E ca 0)
-
............... ...
.
. ..
U-
lie
(D
0
E
O
(D
0
0
a)
-C
a)
rn
cu
>1
E
a)
—0
a)
�Q
a)
E
0
0
a)
a) E
U) cc
c 0
3: ("D
0 :3
cn
u
a)
E
ca
>1
w [-.: <
Z cjf
N
w
is
cu
w 0
0
.() U
U)
0
C<L
C)-j () z
< <
W
cu �
0 0-
w w
D Z >:
a � (if
C') 0
w <
0
.s
c
ry -j
<
a) 4 Z,
U)
0
0 c
< LL Z
0)
W w z
0
c
0 D
fSo
UJ 0
w
X
w cr
0
m 0
m
D 2 Z
0
Of
U)
LL 0
0
a)
U)
o
< w 2
0 )
": 0 Q Z W
0
Cl)
C"i
co z
w
a)
0 E
w 5
LLJ 0
id
.p CY
-i
CL
W
F<-
C: O
0 0
U) w w
m 0
.C
0 t.
S2
M
<
0 >- W
m
.2 a)
ry
0 U- 0
>1
> -C 0
-j 0
LLOO -
Z
b
75
o
LL <
0 00
LL
0
.2 E
U) 0 U-w
Z U- w
0-6
0
z C)
U)
c
U) a 0 X
o.
Cl)
>1
—0 co
> z &5 w
0
co
0
E
0 z
w F-
0
c
0 CL
U) 0
:3
clj
(D 0 C)
OL
0 z
w
co
0 C
a w ct f-
Z 0
uj
Cc a)
0 ,0
U) >
'D
a)
<
Z
.
CC)
co
cn co 2
0)
=
w
.(n OL
'T o
U
Ocoo -1
z 2
02
Uf c.
ca
(0
ca
0
o o w >
z 0 Q� C)
LU 0
cr)
w
LUw
w
IZ
>-
0
z z
0 LU
cn
"
w 0
<—
0W
a)
c
r- <
U LL
o
C-)o
�R C)
U-
cc *Fn
U)
2 0 0
w
>
0
�0 f -E
C) Wz
F-
2 E
'o
0
5
00
C)
11
<
�--
Z) >1
0
M
2f C
07) C)
P
<
0
(150
2f
w
U (L
2 4—
2 0
00
0
-
?
2
0
>
w
Lr)
Z)- 0
0
00 C)
w
z M
D
(-) �- 'a
-J z
D
(n
z
0 >,
0—
Z)
L)
Z <
<
F-
d :3
w 0
::) (1)
OW
0
P: 0
&j
00
6c)
--::i c)
Z-
-j
M
W
0
a. a)
0
.(I)
LL
U)
LL Z
t
0
W
0 - i�:
M
0 :3
W
(1)
0
LL
uj
_j
w
<
cl
z U)
0 =
—
F-
0
am
Z z
Q
0
z -i
D
0.-;
2M
LU -
2r%
z2
W
<
z
w
W
002
n
(D
D
2I
>;
�
<
:3
c
a)
C)
0
0 z
z
U)
LIJ
t--
0
>
LL
w
Wig w
L M CD
0
W.9
a-
C)
CN
:E
<
z
<
CD
z C�l
a)
-
z
0
F- C
co
::j CD
Q (y)
t 0
Q)
W
I--
M
� C,4
c) LL
<
0--)
0
(L) 0
-0
cL E
co
0
-0 0
co
70 >
2 T
a) co
0) .0
t :s
a)
i� c
-�-)
M 0
> (n
C
.2
c U)
0 vcn
0- Q
0-
C
o
0
-C
0 3
QC:
0
CU)
a) . LD
-0
C.)
E o
c .0
> co
co
�) L-
CO (D
00
> 0
0 cn
_r_ (n
= 0
0) .5;
0
0
0
>
co
w
-1
LL
.2
(n 0
cc 0)
a) M
CO)
>
-
E T
0
Mcn
M
d�'8
c: :E
0
0
O E2
-
O)o
U-
E
0
a)
> 0
0 L
0
a) R o)
�: 0
2
:E Mn
a)
To
a)
co
M Fn
0
z t
CL
.0 M M
c 0
0 CL
cln
.0 CL
M
C: -LL
-
o
en 0 M
a)
MEN
CL
(
D = L)
0 CO
U C-�
-
0-
co
E-O
a) 0 t
(n - Ol
a) 75
cn (D
:3
U)
,2 M -
a)
- 0
(n :�,
-0
0 4i CY)
EFL
D-.,- C:
cn
E N
a)
TO E
L.
E
0
0
0
0 C.)
0 o 0 0
0
co
0
cn
E
:E . �� o
cm
M
0)
c co cn -F
- U)
0 0 2
8
0
a)
a)
'2
Mn
> < 0-
0)
0
-C
- 'D
0
0
M
T C 0
-2
a)
E
w
w
(o - --
4) co 0
E Z 0) c
M a)
C
a) 0
3:
0
0
0
0
>
au))
III 0 L)
c
0)
c 0
a)
Cl) a)
w
E 4)
0 0 2:
, Mn
� a)
�i
(0
a)
U)
F-
03
o)o a) oL m u)
a) M M
-C
M
0
o cu .0
Z E a)
E
0
> 0 E 0
E OL
0
15 (D
0
0 0
�
0
m a) Z a)
< > C
3: ID a)
0) =
a)
0
z a) o
o -a -
<
CO
0
>1
z
a)
O.
LL
U) a) a)
M
-0
C
M
w
a)
r-
co -0 .2;, m
M a)
C W
(n �>,:2
- 0
a)
0)
w
< 0 a
, - -i6 n r-
c E 0
- C: =
w a)
0
0
w
(D
E (0
Z5
a)
wc
0
:6 E
'F 4)
F-
0 0)
W 0 c
0 o 0
q--
C
0 a)
a)
E
0
0
a) (D - -0
Q) > 0
0 0 o 0,2
ccs e -
- a) 2
12
2� a)
a) c
-0 0
z
M a)- " 0
u M 0 a) a)
C- Q. 0
2-
-6
Mn
c
a)
En
X-
0-0
0
a) 'a
a)
0
o o a) Cc: Z
U) CO.
U) C: o
(13
-
COc
EE
:3
C) Co �c -�5 U)
Co-
� o
L-En -
a)
0)
z
4--
'E --
0
M -
E
E
(n
(D
-
0a)
>1
0
a) 0
LCJ,)
co
a) 'n
0 - .
co a - o
E E V-
D
a)
'6
0 0-0 >, x
0 M M co
a)
O.
5,
-
co
E
>
0 (D '2
w
ui
a)
M
,
0
C: 0)
-0 -
Co :3
.2 2
ir-C
.
o 10
0,0 a)
t .2 r- o
0 0
Mn
-0
M
0
E
�o
a)
w
E
(D E
LL,
0 -
CL fn
w
- M a)
c
a)
0
(D
o
Lu
= 0)
Co
a) Cc Co
C
CS -r cn (D
Q. 0 U) -0
0 U)
U)
a) 0
co
L>
>1
-0 (D
>,
-0 &n cc
C)
Z
rz
M
z
.5 0 a)
cc U) c
-E U)
c (D
0. C) -
U)
U)
U) 0 -
0 0
W
0) E
w O.0 a)
0 in Q
5 (D
(D
a)
o
0
_5
LL
0-
V;
E w o N Z 76
0 -
C C M c
0
-E < -�R x
0
OL
0
>,
(n >1
Z
-
Co a)
E
0
M
0 0) 2M '6 o
0 a) a)
Mn > -\c
0
-0
0 "
0
W 0
0 0
0
tU
2
0 w 0
'Ea T (1) -
0 0
'a
z
LLI
F- c
-
C -0
0 co
a) o
0 D)o 0)
op U
a) -
0 (n
'�6
a)
:E
�e
0'0
> -5
>,
-
-0 CL
00
0
(3) q..Q o 4--
2: v) 0
C: ': -
:a-)
c
<
F�
w 0
cm
C- >
w
E
"- c
LL
"0
C
0)
.2--)
> ::3 0)
�p cri co a)
0)
Z
U)
F-
0 a)
>
Ir- -
'n
OL M
C
M -0 0--
0
W cz
0
E T-
Z
J=
- o
z
M -U) , cc w 0
a) -0 Co 0
>
E
M M
w M
uj
LL
LU
o -0
vi c
<
(D
0 C) :3 - - U- -
- (n a Z,
a) -5
Co Co c
- "D .
LU
o
�=
q
0• -r--
r-
<
0)
_0 - r,:
> M U-) M
= -
.2
3: M L) t
0
c)
> 0
>
co a)
E
LL
LL
-U) E 7t---
<
�;
M
t-)
D
() -C 0 cl)
a) - o—(D c,5 m
o
LL
c
-
W E
< a)
mc
co a) 3:
0
0 a)
75 0 3: C: 0- (D 0
T cn
a) M
U-
Co
-�5
o
0 -C
Lo -
D
E
.Ln ZE 0
E- - Q. -r- o
0 EO
0
.0
0 0)
- 16
w
E 0
E 4)
o :E
U)
Z
o o 3: a) o (o c
0 - LO
- 3�
co"
W .,E
z U)
a)
7 -5
c
:3 -
0 0)
z
W
0-
U) 0
C? 0)
0 co c
CO
0 C 0 t5
W
0
2 B
0� U)
'E
Z
Z
:3
E
O -r- US
.0 M > >
D a) 2-0
'4'--
Q-.Q
M
a
0) a a)
D
-5 a) n
CL E Z J- (3 E
2- -C (D c
W
M
CL
=
0 w
>- �2
o a) 0
< �: M' 2 cn 4=
0 0
LL E w m
w
s
= M
< C,
LL
0—
U) 0
O
o
ui
W
CO
LU
E
uc-.E
2-0
a)
c-
Z
0.2
0
6
c
>
0
O
D
CL
U)
E E
E
CL
—
E E2 0
0
E2
O
N
0
—
0
= - (D
0 —0
-0
cn
CL
LIJ
0)
-0
0
c a)
E
a)
--
E
0
x
a)
(D —
0 m
E
-
0
LLJ
u)
CD
(D
"-
-
(D
-
Z
Cc
a)
-C 0 %P
— 0 a)
(D
- a)
< E
ca
W
Cc 4) oi X
ca
>,
w
-6 a)
(D
-Z6
'a
a)
0
E
Lu
CO
5
LO
a)
a)
o
-
:E C
E
a)
z
w
'o
5,
E :3
E
E
0
a)
=
_j
LL
0
a)
a)
>
cc
Z
—
R
-a — a)
CO
2
0
co
c a) "
m —E2 a)
LLJ
:6
0 u)
LL
-0
0
0 E
LL
E
W
lu--1
'OD
ri ri
E
o
Q
a.)
co 0
0
0
o
QE <D
a)
z
E o �
LU
cw:
LLJa
0 -0
0
E
<
(n
(A ca
0
r-L
0
D
E
CL
0
a)
-
0
:3
a)
a) 0)
(L
<
F-
>-
>
> E ca
cu
-6
CN
cu 0
0)
-4-
F-
(3
E
U)
> c
I-J
ui
LLJJ
ca
co
T
T -a
LLJ
<
E
N
U)
c
m .2
c
ai
2
:D
U)
U.
C:
0
CL
.5
S
m
:,
LL
0
'Z�
0
E
C
U)
0
0_.cn
(D
0
o
U)
a) 0
a)
U)
a)
0
C)
ca
—
0
2
.1:
C:
m
.�: 4
0
C:
1
?-'
CL (D
0
a)
Ca
E
a)
co
CD
LL
-0
0
0
Co
uiC
Q
OE
-6
(13
T
0 0
0—
0
0)
0
tTf
0
N
E
'Z6
U-
( U)
D 73
m
T
0
E
E
Co
p
c
0)
a) 0
E
0
0
0 0
0
0
0)
cn
(U
U) 0
> L)
'a a)
0
cn (n
0 w
U)
(n
0
a)
cn
m
o
O
0 0
0
0
U)
0
E
c
c C
c
0
O
.0)
i
E
0
0
M
E
En
0
E
4)
(D G)
a)
0
or
0
CL
Q-
OL CL
M
0-
E
E
a) 0
0
0
0 0
E
o
7
E
0
<O
6
O cu
cli
E
-M
E
cli
a)
E
a)
0
U-
0 .2
c
W es <
z w
W 0
U)
o
i UZ
U< <
co w
LIJ 7 w
(D W
:D Z >:
0
w
C)
<
z o U)
< LL Z
W W
V = z < 0
�- P:
LL
0 0
W w
Ww w w
O
2E Z
0
0
0
< w 2i
: Z W
,
—00
ce) -
z
W
W
U) T
w U) 0
F- — -i
D Z
C L
U) w
< 0
0 w < 0
ly a: c,
0 U- 0
i
LL Z 0 6
LL < :2 (,%
0 ry 0 0
U) 0 if W
Z LL LL W
0 z 0
a) 0 X
U) 0 w
5; Z
0 —ZO
0 C.L w
W 0
(D z
w V) COyy-
wz 0 -J
<
z
6i p W
0 (n 0
p
0 0 w
z 0 w C)
04
ui