The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About06.22.2021 HISTORICAL COMMISSION AGENDA ST. LUCIE COUNTY Regular Meeting Tuesday, June 22, 2021 4:00 PM St. Lucie County Commission Chambers 2300 Virginia Avenue 3rd Floor of Roger Poitras Building Fort Pierce, Florida 34982 BOARD MEMBERS CHAIRMAN Anthropology, Archaeology, History RICHARD MCAFOOS Land Use Planning or Historic Preservation Planning KRISSTA KING Architecture MIKE MENARD Layperson BETTY JO STARK VICE-CHAIR Layperson MELANIE TREWYN Conservation/Curation MIKE MIDDLEBROOK Construction JUDY BIGLIN Mission Statement Page 1 of 47 Historical Commission Tuesday, June 22, 2021, 4:00 PM 2 | P a g e To provide service, infrastructure and leadership necessary to advance a safe and sustainable community, maintain a high quality of life, and protect the natural environment for all our citizens Page 2 of 47 Historical Commission Tuesday, June 22, 2021, 4:00 PM 3 | P a g e GENERAL RULES AND PROCEDURES – Attached is the agenda, which will determine the order of business conducted at today’s Board meeting. REGULAR AGENDA – Proclamations, Presentations, Public Hearings, and Department requests are items, which the Commission will discuss individually, usually in the order listed on the agenda. As a general rule, when issues are scheduled before the Commission under department request or public hearing, the order of presentation is: (1) County staff presents the details of the Board item (2) Commissioners comment (3) if a public hearing, the Chair will ask for public comment, (4) further discussion and action by the Board. ADDRESSING THE COMMISSION – Please state your name and address, speaking clearly into the microphone. If you have backup material, please have eight copies ready for distribution. NON‐AGENDA ITEMS – These items are presented by an individual Commissioner or staff as necessary at the conclusion of the printed agenda. PUBLIC COMMENT – Time is allotted at the beginning of each meeting for general public comment. Comments may pertain to any matter related to the Board’s duties as the County’s governing body. General comments in support or opposition to candidates for public office are not pertinent to the Board’s duties. DECORUM – Please be respectful of others’ opinions. MEETINGS – All Board meetings are open to the public and are held quarterly on the third Tuesdays of month at 4 p.m. and on the Meetings are held in the Planning Conference Room in the Planning and Development Services Department at 2300 Virginia Ave., Fort Pierce, Fla. 34982. Anyone with a disability requiring accommodation to attend this meeting should contact the St. Lucie County Community Services Manager at 772‐462‐1777 or TDD 772‐462‐1428 at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. Page 3 of 47 Historical Commission Tuesday, June 22, 2021, 4:00 PM 4 | P a g e 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. ROLL CALL 4. ANNOUNCEMENTS 5. PUBLIC COMMENT 6. MINUTES A. Approval of the April 6, 2021 Historical Commission Meeting Minutes 7. ITEMS FOR ACTION / CONSIDERATION A. OLD BUSINESS B. NEW BUSINESS 1. Request for Demolition of the Wood Frame Structure situated at 1103 W Midway Road, Fort Pierce, for a proposed Redevelopment Project. 8. MEMBER MATTERS 9. DISCUSSION 10. ADJOURNMENT Page 4 of 47 HISTORICAL COMMISSION ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Regular Meeting April 6, 2021 Convened: 4:02 pm Adjourned: 4:35 pm 1.CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 4:02 pm by Chair McAfoos. 2.PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Chair McAfoos. 3.ROLL CALL Commission Secretary. Present Chair Richard McAfoos, Vice Chair Melanie Trewyn (arrived at 4:07pm) Commission Member Betty Starke, Commission Member Mike Middlebrook, Commission Member Krissta King, Commission Member Judy Biglin, Excused Commission Member Mike Menard Others Present Heather Young, Asst. County Attorney (virtual), Caroline Valentin, Asst. County Attorney, Kori Benton, Historic Preservation Officer, Nadege Pierre, Acting Staff Secretary, Jeremiah Johnson, Fort Pierce City Commissioner, Wendy Browning. 4.ANNOUNCEMENTS Chair McAfoos announced that the official name of the commission remains the St. Lucie County Historical Commission. 5.PUBLIC COMMENT None. Page 5 of 47 Historical Commission Tuesday, April 6, 2021 4:00 PM 2 | Page 6.MINUTES A.Approval of the February 2, 2021 Historical Commission Meeting. RESULT:APPROVE MOVER:Commission Member Judy Biglin SECONDER:Commission Member Mike Middlebrook AYES: Chair Richard McAfoos, Commission Member Betty Starke, Commission Member Mike Middlebrook, Commission Member Krissta King, Commission Member Judy Biglin NAYS:None EXCUSED:None 7.ITEMS FOR ACTION / CONSIDERATION A.OLD BUSINESS None B.NEW BUSINESS 1.Review application to rename the St. Lucie County Lawnwood Softball Complex @ Quincy Avenue & 13th Street STAFF PRESENTATION Kori Benton, Historic Preservation Officer, SLC gave a presentation. The request is to rename the St. Lucie County Lawnwood Softball Complex, at the northeast corner of the John B. Park Sporting Complex adjacent to Quincy Ave & 13th St., as the “Layne Chesney Softball Complex”. The Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) approved Resolution 15-098 to establish a Public Facilities Naming Policy that updated and consolidated prior naming policies for County facilities. The Resolution provides criteria for St. Lucie County to use when it desires to confer a specific name on a County owned property. This policy affects County owned property including, but not limited to, buildings, structures, and real property, including open space, parks, and recreational facilities. This policy does not apply to the naming of streets, historically registered properties with a recognized name on a nomination form, or public art installations that have been commissioned with a title, and is not applicable to federal, state, or municipal facilities. In October 2019, the BOCC adopted Resolution 19- 201 to include referral of applications to Name Public Facilities to the St. Lucie County Historical Commission for review and recommendation. Criteria includes the following: Context and geographical location: Sites and facilities should be given names that directly Page 6 of 47 Historical Commission Tuesday, April 6, 2021 4:00 PM 3 | Page reflect or are contextually related to the history of the site. Common usage names that have developed over time shall be favored. Natural or geological features: Names may be based on distinctive, predominant, and defining natural features of an area. Historical significance: The name may be one associated with a historically significant event or for events reflecting broad patterns of County history. The name may be one associated with the lives of persons of countywide significance in St. Lucie County's past. The name may reflect a distinctive architectural, engineering, or technological achievement. The name may be related to an existing or proposed registered historic property or district. The proposed namesake, Layne Chesney, 16, attended Lincoln Park Academy and is recognized as a softball standout. Layne was severely injured in a horrific accident in 2017, and unfortunately succumbed to her injuries in May 2019. Layne is displayed as being the epitome of strength and determination, taking pride in being an outstanding athlete, working tirelessly to pursue a dream of becoming a middle infielder for the Florida Gators, and beyond including becoming an environmental scientist. She graduated from Fairlawn Elementary and attended Lincoln Park Academy. She played softball for TCAA Wildcats and for Lincoln Park Academy. Not only was she a great ball player, and a dedicated scholar. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommend the St. Lucie County Historical Commission find a position of no objection to the naming request based upon the criteria and the history. PUBLIC COMMENT Jeremiah Johnson, Fort Pierce City Commissioner presented. He described Layne Chesley as a student athlete and was her coach in elementary school. She had goals of becoming an environmental scientist. Her coach, Roger Matthews from Lincoln Park Academy, requested that something be done in recognition of Layne. 2021 would have been her senior year in high school which makes the request even more momentous. Wendy Browning, lifelong Fort Pierce resident in support of renaming after Layne. She had strength, courage bravery and perseverance, all qualities of a great ball player. She touched the lives of family, friends, teammates, community, and country that heard her story. Her story brought awareness to the dangers of gasoline and fire. Her story should continue so that it is not forgotten. The community came together for her and now requesting come together again in remembrance of her. COMMISSION DISCUSSION Commission Member King inquired on the difference between finding of no objection and an approval recommendation. Mr. Benton responded that it is based upon the criteria. The BOCC Page 7 of 47 Historical Commission Tuesday, April 6, 2021 4:00 PM 4 | Page is requesting recommendation from Historical Commission. COMMISSION MOTION Chair McAfoos recommendation to motion of no objection as per staff recommendation, presentation, and the speaker’s testimonies. Motion was made by Commission Member Starke and seconded by Vice-Chair Trewyn. Comment made by Vice-Chair Trewyn regarding her son being in the same school and her tragedy was used to remind her son of those dangers. RESULT:NO OBJECT MOVER:Commission Member Member Betty Starke SECONDER:Commission Member Melanie Trewyn AYES:Chair Richard McAfoos, Betty Starke, Mike Middlebrook, Melanie Trewyn, Krissta King, Judy Biglin NAYS:None EXCUSED:None 8.MEMBER MATTERS Mr. Benton announced an agenda item for the next meeting which is a demolition or partial demolition along Midway Rd and the structure may be a Historic Resource, but it is to be determined at the moment. Staff have separate text amendment to the Board of County Commissioners for Historical Commission. 9.DISCUSSION 10.ADJOURNMENT Motion to adjourn: RESULT:APPROVE MOVER:Commission Member Krissta King SECONDER:Commission Member Mike Middlebrook AYES:Chair Richard McAfoos, Betty Starke, Mike Middlebrook, Vice-Chair Melanie Trewyn, Krissta King, Judy Biglin NAYS:None EXCUSED:None Meeting Adjourned at 4:35 pm. Page 8 of 47 Historical Commission Tuesday, April 6, 2021 4:00 PM 5 | Page Page 9 of 47 June 22, 2021 Owner Jeffrey Wood, Georgia Wood & Jeremy D Parson 4696 Palomar Ave Fort Pierce, FL 34946 Historic Status Non-Designated Structure Eligible for Local Designation Applicant Request Demolition for Redevelop- ment as a Commercial Es- tablishment Staff Recommendation Evaluate the historic signifi-cance and condition of the subject structure, and consider whether to pursue designation of the structure as historic or release of the request for demo-lition. Staff Kori Benton, AICP Historic Preservation Officer S t . L u c i e C o u n t y H i s t o r i c a l C o m m i s s i o n H i s t o r y c. 1917 Date of construction per Florida Master Site File (8SL150 / Stetcher House) 1950s Porch Alterations S t r u c t u r e O v e r v i e w Historical Significance: The Stetcher House is located in the White City Subdivision, platted by the Florida Cosmopolitan and Immigration Company. According to local sources, Stetcher moved from Chicago before the 1920s, commissioning the build and occupying the structure. This structure is associated with the developmental history of White City and represents the archi- tectural trends of the era. This building is eligible for location designation, and could contribute to a potential local historic district comprised of the historic buildings within White City. This structure is not considered individually eligible for listing in the NRHP. Architectural Significance: This one-and-a-half-story wood Frame Vernacular residential building is located at 1103 Midway Road. Notable architectural features include a gable roof (predominantly metal shingle), gable dor-mer, exposed rafter tails, and an enclosed entrance porch with hip roof. Clad in asbestos shingle, this building has one over one sash windows and rests on concrete block piers. Alterations to the build-ing include the enclosure of the porch and the application of asbestos siding. The building was surveyed through 2010, and noted with fair condition. In Spring 2021, Staff toured the structure with the Building Official, reporting the structure in fair to poor condition. Request: The applicant is seeking demolition of the structure, to provide for redevelopment with a Whit’s Frozen Custard Café building. Originally, the applicant explored approaches to incorporate the 1,064 sq. ft. residence, as an office or for interim storage, however after structural evaluation and insurance proposals, the request is to demolish this structure. Agenda Item 7 New Business B. 1 Location 1103 W Midway Road Parcel ID 3404-501-0242-000-5 1103 W Midway Road, White City—Fort Pierce Zoning CN, Commercial Neighborhood Planning and Development Services Department Historic Preservation Subject Site Midway Road 25 t h S t r e e t Applicant Chris & Natalie Mass Second Heaven, LLC (dba Whit’s Frozen Custard) Parcel Size 0.58 acres Page 10 of 47 2 Photo Date 2016 Photo Date Unknown Page 11 of 47 3 Site Aerial—2019 with Property Boundaries White City Redevelopment Concept Plan Snapshot Midway Road Su n r i s e B l v d . Prior to the Midway Road reconstruction project launched, along the White City Segment, a conceptual redevelop- ment plan was developed. The concept considered future street design, infill possibilities and improvement poten- tial. The subject parcel is highlighted in the snapshot above. Page 12 of 47 4 Location Exhibit—Adjacent Historic Resources Page 13 of 47 5 Redevelopment / Infill Proposal The applicants are proposing a new Whit’s Frozen Custard franchise. Their request stated the pro-ject’s financial guidelines require the original structure to be removed with the cost to relocate and/or salvage the structure stated as cost prohibitive. Proposed Design Theme The request packet provided conceptual architectural designs, intended for “visionary” purposes, to display a com-mitment to designing the replacement structure around the site and established White City themes. The final design will take into account property characteris-tics, county codes and other applicable requirements. Site design, functionality, access, interior vehicular movement and customer experience are design variable to be considered as the proposal advanc-es. Use of a Florida vernacular design, broad entry porch and patio, intends to provide continuity with preserved historic re-sources, while setting the stage for new infill projects. The design further builds on operational success, and need, to provide for guests to gather in front and on our patio—providing space for kids to celebrate birthdays, host fundraisers, and support families making memories together. Structural placement, scale and architectural design are critical to preserve existing oak trees on site, support traditional form, embrace the corridor and encourage pedestrian activity. Page 14 of 47 6 The applicant has not provided an Inspection Report, but supplied photos and first-hand assessment of the structure’s condition. The Building Official toured the structure, and will be present for the Historic Commission’s meeting at Staff’s request. S t a f f R e c o m m e n d a t i o n Staff recommends the Commission evaluate the historic significance and current condition of the subject structure, and consider wheth-er to pursue designation of the structure as historic or release the request for demolition. Various motion options are detailed on the next page to assist in the Commission’s consideration. Attachments Florida Master Site File 8SL150 Application Authorization & Request Packet Demolition Request Highlights Is the structure of such interest or quality that it would reasonably meet national, state, or local criteria for designation as a significant historic or architectural site or structure? The subject structure meets the local criteria for designation as signifi-cant historic, for Architectural Significance, context of development in contributing to White City. • LDC Section 4.11.06. Criteria 1. Is the structure of such design, craftsmanship or material that it could be reproduced only with great difficulty or expense? The structure displays a Wood Frame Vernacular styling expressed by a by a rectangular plan, drop siding, and gable roof with composition shingles, and simple-exposed rafter tails. The structural condition has not been well documented prior to the current assessment provided by the applicant’s design professional. A remote site visit performed in January 2020 revealed the structure is in poor condition with limited maintenance. Is the structure one of the last remaining exam-ples of its kind in the county or region? This structure displays an architectural style that is commonly found throughout South Florida, with some unique and detailed features. It exhibits some modification modifications (siding, porch, and minor addition). Would retention of the structure promote the general welfare of the County by providing an opportunity for study of local history, architec- ture and design or by developing an understand-ing of the importance and value of a particular culture and heritage? The structure’s history, architecture and craftsmanship contribute to the White City community. The structure’s development context is linked to White City’s continued growth after the turn of the century, the railroad provided a direct link to northern markets for fishing, beef, citrus products, and provided access to the region for prospective settlers. Extensive drainage projects undertaken during the 1910s and 1920s by the Fort Pierce Farms Investment Company reclaimed vast areas of land and expanded the county's agricultural base. By 1920 St. Lucie County had established itself as one of Florida's chief agricul-tural regions while entering an exuberant period of historic develop- ment. The Great Florida Land Boom brought thousands of tourists and new settlers to the area. The architecture and craftsmanship are adversely affected by the cur- rent condition and limited maintenance., Are there definite plans for re-use of the property if the proposed demolition is carried out, and what will be the effect of those plans on the char-acter of the surrounding area The applicant has presented preliminary concepts for redevelopment, but has not engaged in a Pre-application Meeting with the County’s Development Review Committee. Architectural compatibility is of significant importance for infill along Midway Road. As the site is located within the CN, Commercial Neighborhood Dis- trict, the County’s Community Architectural Standards contained in Land Development Code (LDC) Section 7.10.24 would apply to any new development. The guidelines require review of conceptual design drawings, which include a site plan, architectural elevations of front and sides of the proposed building(s), sign plan and elevation, and exterior lighting locations and standards. Evaluation includes but is not limited to roof form, windows, doors, materials/colors, and all other architectural details and elements. S t a f f A n a l y s i s Page 15 of 47 7 Potential Motions AFTER CONSIDERING THE APPLICATION DOCUMENTS, THE STAFF REPORT, STAFF COMMENTS & TES- TIMONY PRESENTED DURING THE PUBLIC MEETING AND THE STANDARDS SET FORTH IN SECTIONS 4.11.06. - DESIGNATION PROCESS AND PROCEDURE AND 4.11.07. - EMERGENCY ACTIONS OF THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, I HEREBY MOVE THAT THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY HISTORI- CAL COMMISSION APPROVE THE DEMOLITION REQUEST (NOT INITIATING AN EMERGENCY ACTION) BECAUSE... AFTER CONSIDERING THE APPLICATION DOCUMENTS, THE STAFF REPORT, STAFF COMMENTS & TES- TIMONY PRESENTED DURING THE PUBLIC MEETING AND THE STANDARDS SET FORTH IN SECTIONS 4.11.06. - DESIGNATION PROCESS AND PROCEDURE AND 4.11.07. - EMERGENCY ACTIONS OF THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, I HEREBY MOVE THAT THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY HISTORI- CAL COMMISSION APPROVE THE DEMOLITION REQUEST (NOT INITIATING AN EMERGENCY ACTION) ON THE PREMISE THE PRESENTED INFILL PROJECT RECEIVES PRELIMINARY APPROVAL / CERTIFICA- TION FROM THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE (DRC), INCLUDING STRICT ADHERENCE WITH THE COMMUNITY ARCHITECTURAL STANDARDS OF LDC SECTION 7.10.24 PRIOR TO THE DEMOLITION ACTION, AND FURTHER REQUESTING A METHOD TO COMMEMORATE THE SUB- JECT STRUCTURE WITHIN THE NEW ESTABLISHMENT BECAUSE… AFTER CONSIDERING THE APPLICATION DOCUMENTS, THE STAFF REPORT, STAFF COMMENTS & TES- TIMONY PRESENTED DURING THE PUBLIC MEETING AND THE STANDARDS SET FORTH IN SECTIONS 4.11.06. - DESIGNATION PROCESS AND PROCEDURE AND 4.11.07. - EMERGENCY ACTIONS OF THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, I HEREBY MOVE THAT THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY HISTORI- CAL COMMISSION DISAPPROVE THE DEMOLITION REQUEST, IN FAVOR OF INITIATING AN EMER- GENCY ACTION TO DESIGNATE THE SUBJECT STRUCTURE WITH A RECOMMENDATION THAT THE OWNER IS ABLE TO SPLIT THE SUBJECT PARCEL TO PARTITION THE SITE TO ALLOW THE PROPOSED INFILL PROJECT WHILE PRECLUDING DEMOLITION TO THIS HISTORIC RESOURCE IN THE WHITE CITY HERITAGE AREA. THE MOTION INTENDING TO SUPPORT REASONABLE DIMENSIONAL AND DESIGN CRITERIA CONCESSIONS NECESSARY TO PRESERVE THE STRUCTURE AND SUPPORT THE INFILL PRO- JECT BECAUSE... Conceptual Site Mark-up—Splitting the Structure from the parent parcel to allow independent sale and/or, preservation & reuse while supporting new infill adjacent. Page 16 of 47 Historical Commission Demolition Request Applicant: Christopher Mass, developer/operator Property Owner: Jeffrey & Georgia Wood 4696 Palomar Ave, Fort Pierce FL 34946 Subject Property: 1103 W Midway Rd Parcel ID: 3404-501-0242-000-5 Request: Demolition of existing wood frame structure Page 17 of 47 Page (2) Overview: Subject property has been for sale “as is” for over 600 days. Chris Mass has identified this location and the “heritage district” of White City for potential expansion of his growing Whit’s Frozen Custard franchises. In order for this project to make financial sense, the original structure must be removed. The cost to relocate and/or salvage the existing structure is anticipated to be too costly. Additionally, there seems to be minimal historically valuable components of the structure worth saving and the owner has given her consent (attached letter at the end) to have it removed. Our Story: Chris & Natalie Mass, Owners Second Heaven, LLC (dba Whit’s Frozen Custard) We began this journey in 2016 with the idea that we could bring this fabulous treat to Martin County. Our intent was to be generous contributors within the community that we serve and establish ourselves as the premier destination for families to build memories for generations. During our first 4 years in operation, Whit’s has been voted “MOST LOVED” frozen dessert in the Treasure Coast, every year. We have been recognized by local schools and the MC School District as Most Valued Partners each year and continue to serve our children through various programs and donations. Because of our success in Stuart, we were able to open our second location, in 2019 (Wellington) and our 3rd location in 2020 (Port St. Lucie). Not only do we focus our efforts on families, youth and churches, we also contribute and support various charities throughout the year. Place of Hope, Project Lift, Christ Fellowship Church, New Beginnings Church, Little Smiles, Toys for Tots and Operation 300 are a few of the dozens of folks we love to support. Our philosophy is to give with a grateful heart for the blessings we receive from our loyal community. Lastly, we employ anywhere from 10-15 employees throughout the year. Most of these folks are “first time job seekers”, which we love. It gives us great pleasure knowing we can mentor and train the young folks in more than just fun ways to serve custard. There are many life skills that come with a “service” job and our goal is to help them develop these skills to make them more valuable contributors in LIFE and to those around them as they grow into upstanding community citizens. We would enjoy, very much, the opportunity to grow in Fort Pierce and the surrounding area. The “Heritage District” is perfectly suited for us to be a foundational partner in the future expansion and we feel strongly that we could be used as a barometer for which all others could be measured, to ensure the vision on the district is met. Page (3) Page 18 of 47 Subject Property Photos: Front Elevation: Significant decay is visible throughout exterior. Expansion of Midway Rd has encroached on proper “set-backs” and severely impacts its use in the current location Property has been vacant/uninhabited for years. Currently used for storage Mechanical/Plumbing: All mechanical apparatus is in disrepair and possibly not in working order. Comments from County Building Inspector during walk through, brought into question the proper permitting and licensing held by contractors who did interior work and/or installation of HVAC, Plumbing, Etc. Asbestos: It’s apparent that given the period of construction of this home, the siding is most likely asbestos and clearly presents a hazard. Addition (non-original construction): The back 3rd of the dwelling was added later and seems to be sagging, leaning away from original structure, and ceiling height is less than 8’ in much of the addition. Page 19 of 47 Page (4) Subject Property Photos: (cont’d) Front Porch: This photo shows the proximity of the structure to the frontage road (Midway) and the sagging of the foundation. Structural Integrity: There is considerable termite damage to the front structural corner of the house. While other locations were not visible without removal of facia/shingles, it’s likely to have spread as this seemed like an active area of concern. Page (5) Page 20 of 47 Subject Property Photos: (cont’d) Foundation Questionable: During our sight visit, the questionable foundation was of noticeable concern to all county officials. The house is not “tied down” or attached in any way to the ground. It is resting on cinder blocks, bricks, pavers and lumber that look to be sagging, leaning or all together useless for support. Overview of Subject Property (summary of concern): The property sits too near the roadway to be of any use whatsoever The cost to repair FAR exceeds the value of the property There is no “historical value” or “heritage” within the home that deems it necessary to restore or save. The existing owner has made no claim to saving it and has no objection to it’s removal The “in fill” proposed project will add SIGNIFICANTLY more value to the community and will serve as a benchmark for future development plans within the Heritage District. Page (6) Page 21 of 47 Propose “IN FILL” design: (our vision) The following photos are for “visionary” purposes only. The final design will take into account usable space on the property after consideration of county codes and requirements, functionality, proper traffic flow and overall enjoyment for our patrons. These provide a “LOOK” that we plan to adhere to and develop. Page (7) Page 22 of 47 Whit’s Photos: Product and Lifestyle We love seeing the crowds gather in front and on our patio. Kids celebrating birthdays, families making memories together! This is a typical evening at our Stuart location. Sometimes this lasts an hour, sometimes it last 4 hours… Page (8) Page 23 of 47 Whit’s Photos: Product and Lifestyle (cont’d) Scooper Stars: This is our signature program with all elementary and middle schools. We deliver these cards to every school in our community FREE of charge. We ask that the administrators award them to students who display kindness, thoughtfulness, generosity or accountability to others that is “out of the norm”. These acts are typically overlooked in our school systems and have proven to help change the culture in the schools that use them well. Kids try to compete for the awards by being well behaved and better “citizens” within their school communities. Students receive a FREE SCOOP in any of our stores and there is NO obligation to the family for purchase. We have been recognized by multiple schools and the MCSD for our contributions to the learning environment. Last year we redeemed over 5,000 scooper star awards in our stores. Page (9) Page 24 of 47 Whit’s Photos: Product and Lifestyle (cont’d) FIRST RESPONDERS receive 50% the menu while on duty, every day, all day. We encourage our dedicated community hero’s to “take a break” and enjoy a treat. We, as owners and residents, are extremely grateful for their service. Page 25 of 47 Page (10) Whit’s Photos: Product and Lifestyle (cont’d) We love to give back!! Pictured here: Cleveland Clinic: “Thank you Frontliners” We provided free scoops to over 300 nurses and staff Little Smiles: deliver 50-100 scoops a few times a year to pediatric rehabilitation clinics for youth who are recovering from major trauma or therapies. Operation 300 and local Church Groups come to our store and enjoy discounted rates for their friends and family. Page 26 of 47 (Page 11) Letter of consent for demolition as separate attachment. Remainder of this page left blank. Page 27 of 47 Page 1 Original D Update ~ HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Consult Gulde To Hlatorical Structure Forms for detailed Instructions Site # SSL 150 Recorder# .0~1..;;..o __ _ Recorder Date 08/2002 Site Name ...;S;...;;te"'-t'-'"c'""'"he;;..;.r__.H"'"'"o'"""u ..... s..;;..e _____________ Other Names ------------------ Project Nam St. Lucie County Historic Resources Survey Historic Contexts _w_w_l_a_n_d_A_ft_e_nn_a_t_h __________ National Register Category _B ...... u_il_d1_·n_g ________ _ Address Vicinity of City LOCATION and IDENTIFICATION 1103 West Midway Road Southwest comer of W Midway Road and Cypress Avenue _F_o_rt_P_i_er_c_e_G_.v_·---------------~County Ownership _P_riv_a_te _____ Subdivision _W_hi_te_C_ity..__ ______ Block# MAPPING St. Lucie USGS Map Quarter Easting Latitude Ankona Township 36S Range D 40E Section 04 Irregular Section UTM Zone __ 1_7_ 0565495 Qtr Qtr Northing Longitude 3028079 LandGrant _U~n_k..;;..n..;;..ow_n _____________ ~ Plat or Other Map _A_e_ri_al_M_a_p_#_1_2_7 ________ _ HISTORY Architect/Builder _u_n_k_n_ow_n ___________________ _ Construction Date 1917 Circa D Alterations ~ Date ....;1...;;.9..;;.50=s:;,..__ __ _ Type/Location _P_o_rc_h_e_n_c_lo_s_e_d ___________________ _ Additions D Date ------Type/Location Moved D Original Location ---------------------------------- Original Use(s) -'-P-'-n'-'-·v=at=e__.r"""es=i""'"de=n"'"'c;...;;e __________ _ DESCRIPTION Style Frame Vernacular Exterior Plan Rectan ular Interior Plan Unknown Stories 2 Structural System Wood frame Exterior Fabric Asbestos-shingles or siding Foundation Piers Foundation Materials Concrete block Foundation Infill -'-N""'o_n_e ______ _ No. of Porches _o_ Locations/Features _N_/_A ____________________________ _ Dormers ~ Number/Location ...;G;;;..;a""b'""le;;_..;;;.do=nn.;.;..;;.;.e""r/..;..;fr..;;;.o""nt"'-c;;;..;e'""n;.;;,;te'""r------------------------ Outbldgs. ~ Number 1 Nature/Location (Describe below) S/gabled metal shed RoofType ....;G~a~b....;le;._ _____________ _ Roofing Materials ...;T;..;.;in..;...;;;;sh..;..;i"""ng""l..;;.es.;;;.._ ___________ _ Secondary Structures D Comments _N_o_t_a.._p.._pl_ica_b_le ____________ Location Chimneys ~ Number Orientation North Location Slo e, Exterior Material _M_e_ta_I ____ _ Wood Windows ~ Type OHS Light #-'1"'-/1'"'-=2/=2 ____ _ Metal Windows D Type Light# _______ _ ExteriorOrnament ~R~a_ft_e_r ~ta=il.;;..s ___________________________________ _ Condition _G_o ...... o....,d~----------------Surroundings Residential/Commercial Narrative (general, interior, landscape, context; 3 lines only) The Stetcher House is located in the White City Subdivision, platted by the Florida Cosmopolitan and Immigration Company. According to local sources, Stretcher moved from Chicago. Archaeological Remains Present D None observed. FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes, attach) D Printed Thursday, May 0 I, 2003 Page 28 of 47 Page2 Eligible for National Register? Significant as Part of District? Significant at Local Level? Areas of Significance HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Consult Gulde To Historical Structure Fonns for detailed Instructions Yes D Yes ~ Yes ~ No ~ No D No D Likely, Need Information D Likely, Need Information D Likely, Need Information D Community planning & development, Architecture Summary of Significance Site # SSL 150 Insufficient Information D Insufficient Information D Insufficient Information D This building is associated with the developmental history of White City and represents the architectural trends of the era. Consequently, this building could contribute to a potential local historic district comprised of the historic buildings within White City. However, this building is not considered individually eligible for listing in the NRHP. OHR USE ONLY DATE LISTED ON NATIONAL REGISTER KEEPER DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY SHPO EVALUATION OF ELIGIBILITY LOCAL DETERMINATION OF ELIGIBILITY LOCAL OFFICE OFFICIAL EVALUATIONS DATE DATE DATE DATE DOCUMENTATION YES YES YES DHRUSE ONLY NO NO NO Research Methods Florida Site File for past architectural surveys; Libraries searched locally-county histories etc.; Local building permits; Pedestrian; Windshield Bibliographic Reference Historic Pro e Associates, 1990. Interview with Andrew Jor ensen. ________________ Negative Numbers _#_70_,,c_F_a_c_in_,,,g,_S_W _________ _ """""",,,,__,...,_,,...,,,,,.,,,,,,, AJ'JO~ ... Recorder Name S. Daniel, A. De La Torre, E. Rogers, A. Flynt, S. Sustaita Recorder Affiliation JANUS RESEARCH, 2935 First Avenue North, St. Petersburg, Florida 33713 Telephone 727-821-7600 REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP 3. PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, PREFERABLY B&W, AT LEAST 3x5 Printed Thursday, May 01, 2003 Page 29 of 47 PHOTOGRAPH SKETCH MAP W Midwa Road "C 8SL0150 • ""' "' r > Cl> Cl> ::::s -c ::::s 0 Cl> al ~ Cl> "' former location of "' ::::s ·-1107 Midway ""' oD o ""' c ~ ::::s (.) CJ) ~ en sheds Page 30 of 47 USGS QUADRANGLE MAP 070 8SL150 1103 West Midway Road Zone 17 Easting: 0565495 Northing: 3028079 Page 31 of 47 ·-RECORD NUMBER: 71 Page 1 x original update HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE --150 site a SL tit SITE NAME: Stetcher House HISTORIC CONTEXTS: WWI and Aftermath NAT. REGISTER CATEGORY: Building OTHER NAMES OR MSF NOS: COUNTY: St. Lucie OWNERSHIP TYPE: Private, indi vidual PROJECT NAME: Survey of St. Lucie County: s+ p DHR NO. -2 3 6 9 LOCATION: ADDRESS: 1103 West Midway Road CITY: VICINITY OF/ROUTE TO: See attached maps SUB: White City Subdivision BLOCK 41 PLAT OR OTHER MAP: TOWNSHIP: 36 S RANGE: 40 E SECTION: 4 1/4: IRREGULAR SEC? y X n LAND GRANT: None USGS 7.5 MAP: Ankona 1948 PR 1983 UTM: ZONE: EASTING: NORTHING: COORDINATES: LATITUDE: D M S LONGITUDE: HISTORY ARCHITECT: BUILDER: CONSTRUCTION DATE: 1917 RESTORATION DATE(S): MODIFICATION DATE(S): MOVE: DATE: ORIG. LOCATION: ORIGINAL USE (S): PRESENT USE (S): Private Residence Private Residence DESCRIPTION STYLE: Frame Vernacular PLAN: EXTERIOR: Rectangular PLAN: INTERIOR: Unknown LOT 1-3 1/4-1/4: D M NO. STORIES: 1.5 OUTBLDGS: 0 PORCHES: 1 DORMERS: 0 STRUCTURAL SYSTEM(S): Wood, Balloon EXTERIOR FABRIC(S): Asbestos shingle FOUNDATION: TYPE: Piers MATERIALS: Concrete block INFILL: PORCHES: N/entrance/hip roof/enclosed/3 bays/access 2nd ROOF: TYPE: Gable SURFACING: Metal, pressed SECONDARY STRUCS: Gable dormer CHIMNEY: NO.: 0 MATERIALS: LOCATIONS: WINDOWS: Double hung sash 1/1 EXTERIOR ORNAMENT: Exposed rafter ends CONDITION: Fair SURROUNDINGS: Residential NARRATIVE: See Continuation Sheet s Page 32 of 47 Page 2 FMSF HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM site a S LI So ARCHAEOLOGICAL REMAINS AT THE SITE FMSF ARCHAEOLOGICAL FORM COMPLETED? y X n ARTIFACTS OR OTHER REMAINS: None observed RECORDER'S EVALUATION OF SITE AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE: Architecture ELIGIBLE FOR NAT. REGISTER? SIGNIF. AS PART OF DISTRICT? SIGNIFICANT AT LOCAL LEVEL? SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANCE See continuation sheet y y x y X n x n n likely, need info likely, need info likely, need info insf info insf info insf info * * * * DHR USE ONLY * * * * * * * DHR USE ONLY * * * * * * * DATE LISTED ON NR * * KEEPER DETERMINATION OF ELIG.(DATE): YES NO * * SHPO EVALUATION OF ELIGIBILITY (DATE): YES NO * * LOCAL DETERMINATION OF ELIG. (DATE): YES NO * * OFFICE * * * * * * * DHR USE ONLY * * * * * * * OHR USE ONLY * * * * * * RECORDER INFORMATION: NAME: Robert Bennett and Carol Henderson DATE: 06/15/90 AFFILIATION: Historic Property Associates, Inc PHOTOGRAPHS LOCATION OF NEGATIVES: HPA, PO Box 1002, St Augustine, FL 32085 NEGATIVE NUMBERS: Roll 3, Frame 3 PHOTOGRAPH M A P See Attachments Page 33 of 47 RN 71 Continuation Sheet Statement of Significance: Architectural Narrative: This one-and-a-half-story wood Frame Vernacular residential building is located at 1103 Midway Road. Notable architectural features include a gable roof, gable dormer, exposed rafter ends, and an enclosed entrance porch with hip roof. Oad in asbestos shingle, this building has 1I1 sash windows and rests on concrete block piers. Alterations to the building include the enclosure of the porch and the use of asbestos siding. The building is in fair condition. Architectural Context: Frame Vernacular, the prevalent style of residential architecture in Florida, refers to the common wood frame construction technique employed by lay or self-taught builders. Before the Civil War, residents relied upon local materials and their own methods and designs to construct buildings. The Industrial Revolution permitted standardization of building materials and parts and exerted a pervasive influence over vernacular house design. Popular magazines helped to make architectural trends universal throughout the country. The railroad provided cheap and efficient transportation for manufactured building materials. Ultimately, individual builders had access to a myriad of finished architectural products from which to create their own designs. Frame Vernacular houses are typically one or two stories in height, with wood balloon frame structural systems and brick pier foundations. Plans are usually rectangular, though L-shaped plans were often used to maximize cross-ventilation. Gable or hip roofs usually have steep pitches which accommodate attic space. Horizontal drop siding and weatherboard are the most common exterior wall surface materials. Wood shingles were often used to cover the roofs, but they have nearly always been replaced by composition shingle. Porches, most commonly simple entrance or end porches, are common features of the style. Fenestration is regular, but not always symmetrical. Wrndows are generally double-hung sash with multi-pane glazing and doors contain recessed wood panels. Exterior decoration is sparse and limited to ornamental woodwork. Historical Narrative: The Stetcher House, built in 1917, is located in the White City Subdivision, platted by the Florida Cosmopolitan and Immigration Company in 1907. According to local sources, Stetcher moved to St. Lucie County from Chicago. (Interview with Andrew Jorgensen by William Adams, 6/90). Historical Context: Located near the midway point of Florida's East Coast, St. Lucie County lies within one of the oldest continually settled regions in the United States. Prehistoric Indians were drawn to the area by the abundance of fish and game in and along the scenic Indian River. European contact with the area occurred during the Colonial period of Florida's history, but permanent settlement did not occur until the 1840s, when Fort Pierce was constructed as a military outpost during the Second Seminole War. Beginning with the establishment of St. Lucie Village in 1842, a number of small settlements developed along the west bank of the Indian River during the late 19th century. Construction of the Florida East Coast Railway in the 1890s ended the relative isolation of the area. Whistle stops were located at Ankona, now Indrio, St. Lucie, Fort Pierce, White City, and Eden, the larger settlements along the Indian River. The railroad provided a direct link to northern markets for fishing, beef, citrus products, and provided access to the region for prospective settlers. Extensive drainage projects undertaken during the 191 Os and 1920s by the Fart Pierce Farms Investment Company reclaimed vast areas of land and expanded the county's agricultural base. By 1920 St. Lucie County had established itself as one of Florida's chief agricultural regions while entering an exuberant period of historic development. The Great Florida Land Boom brought thousands of tourists and new settlers to the area. Early subdivision activity was centered around San Lucie Plaza and Regina Palms. The development that the boom fostered was spectacular, but short-lived. The speculative bubble burst near the end of 1926, throwing the Florida economy into a depression three years in advance of the rest of the nation.:. Although development in St. Lucie County was slowed significantly, the area fared better than many of its neighbors, because of Fort Pierce harbor, the primary shipping point for citrus products for the central Florida. The buildings surveyed in the unincorporated areas of St. Lucie County accurately reflect its rich historical and architectural past. Page 34 of 47 ER I OR r ... ... 0 ~;-·--~;;; .. -~ I' :: .: . c." 1\ II Tra i ler ~ ·a Park ); • __Jc __ -~----t 0 >< ·~ I DEPARTMENT OF COMM ERC ~OAST AND GEODET IC S URV 49J8 IV '1£ !FORT Pl£RC£J ': .. l ... ,:.J1':i\·; I ·1 .ll II I ' ... € ~lin~ Park ., :_1 ~· • :1 · J. :~ ~ f.atc. 1,. ·11.~::1: i·:11 1 1 : ' 'j1' • ' ' : 1= !I • ··1 • •' . ! .1,·.. i .11 .i'i '11· ·i .. :;' ~'---"'~-ll---'--1!---ll-~JI 'I, ·I 'I . 01. x'6 ' I I I • , .. ·:·. 1 • . . 0 ; Ii: ·i!: .r II l · \1 J. ·I, : • : i • I I·., .... I I 'I 1: ,, • •I . Ii 11= :i; = :·· I iii I I'! I~ := T 'i\ I: • 'Ji· lj • 'i ': ; 11 •. · 11 )= I;= 1· ·1" ' '1· 1' I • I: 'j ' • i1 I . 'I I I • I I jo I I' '' .. 17 x lf" I! .:1: ·I· 1"·:, I · 1· :·1· i· • I • 1' I :I ;!; '.1!~ ' I ··2~. .. ~--/\ )"~\' / ,, ( . \ \ \ I . 18 -.J, ' ) I ''\ I Page 35 of 47 Page 1 ---------- Original i I Update 1~ Site Name HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Con•ult Gulde To Hlstorleal Structure Forms for detailed Instructions Site# ~SL 150 ~ Recorder # -"-'------ Recorder Date _?/11/2006 Project Name _C<B,6§2LMJ9.lllaLRQ~Q_k<Ll11_iL?5th §trn.eH<:l~as,t of_l)§J _____ . -----· ------·-- Historic Contexts WWLand1'-ft'!tr!'ath --------_________ National Register Category J3.~llqillil _______________ _ Address Vicinity of City 11()3 W Midway Road _. _?_Vl£f>!'J!~_9.f_M,idw~¥_!3o<!!~L~!l~LQYE~X~ss AY~riue ___ , _fort Pierce G.V. -~------~------~-~~----------------------County Qtr Qtr Irregular Section UTM Zone ---.1L_ Quarter Easting Latitude .. .3Q?8079 ___ , ___ _ Land Grant _l)nkl}Q"'.!' __________ ···------····----...... --------···-- Longitude Plat or Other Map _Aerial£.bplQ91:fill_~_s ------------___ _ Architect/Builder _lJl}kngy;_[l _______________ -------·-----------------__________________ _ Construction Date __ .1217 __ Circa I Alterations iv' Date J2§.~---------_ Type/Location pp[ch en_<:_l()~~_Q__ __ Additions I l Date Type/Location Moved Style £rn111"..Y!!i:!'a£"laL_______ _ ________ . Exterior Plan Bec:>.~!'9~la'. Interior Plan _l)_11_k_QQ'!>'.'!.... . _________ Stories ..• L Structural System _Wood Ira'!'.!'_~-------··------· Exterior Fabric _i>,§Q!'.StoS:§.hingles or_s,i!J[rig____ ___________ _ Foundation Foundation Materials Gon.qete blc:>_c_k ______ . Foundation Infill ·"""----------------···-- No. of Porches __ Q__ Locations/Features .1'.!l~----------· Main Entrance (stylistic details): Outbldgs. I.ti Number 1 Nature/Location (Describe below) _5_/ga,lll!>.d me~L•h.!'<l__ _ ···---___ . Roof Type -"'-'='c·-· ·---------------····---------------Roofing Materials l!'1!>.~1 s,hin91e~ Secondary Structures I · ------· ---------·-----------Location Chimneys li11 Number Wood Windows IY' Type Orientation .• N.q_r\_h _____________ Location __ §lgp_eli;Oxjerior _____ . Material _Metal_------·---- _DH§.... Light#_ 1/1_1~2 __ _ Metal Windows 1 · Type Light •. ----·-------------- Exterior Ornament _i;;WQ§.8-d . .rnft_er tailL .• Condition _Q_()g_cl_ .• Narrative (general, interior, landscape, context; 3 lines only) The Stretcher House is located in the White City Subdivision, platted by the Florida Cosmopolitan and Immigration Company. According to ,)Qf __ ~L~~IC~!?L~tret9J}~r,_,rnoved fr,Qrn, ,Qbl9!1~Q--~ , Archaeological Remains Present __ I FMSF Archaeological Site Form Completed (if yes, attach) I Printed Wednesday, June 27, 2007 Page 36 of 47 P;1ge 2 I HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site# SSL 150 Consult Gulde To Hlstorleal Structure Fonns for detailed Instructions Individually Eligible for National Register? Yes No l.i'1 Likely, Need Information Insufficient Information 1 Potential Contributor to Nat. Reg. District? Yes 'I No '"1 Likely, Need Information II Insufficient Information I l Areas of Significance ,Communi~ni11fl§t develgpment -"~-- Summary of Significance This building has undergone non-historic modifications which limits its architectural significance. While it is sited in an area comprised of a contiguous collection of historic resources, the historic physical integrity of the area has been significantly compromised and does not meet the strict requirements for inclusion in the NRHP. Therefore, this building is considered ineligible for listing in the NRHP, on an individual basis or as part of a historic district. However, the building is associated with the developmental history of White City and represents the architectural trends of the era. Consequently, this building is considered a contributing resource to the potential locally eligible White City J:!l~!Q!Jt? .QJ~l!i«?!:. NRDATE KEEPER·NR ELIGIBILITY 0 yes 0 no Date _J_j_ _}_)_ SHPO-NR ELIGIBILITY: 0 yes ~?f no 0 potentially elig. 0 insufficient info Date 10l/J.§] DELISTDATE LOCAL DESIGNATION: Date _J_j_ _j_J_ Local office National R ister Crkeria for Evaluation Oa b c Od See National R isler Bulletin 15, .2 Research Methods Florida Site File for past architectural surveys; Local library; Local building permits; Pedestrian; Windshield; Florida ~~!!File se~EL--~····~ .. -·-··-._--~··~·------- Bibliographic References .Historic Properties Associate.• .• 1990 Recorder Name .Mil<e!Sen.neally ............... , .. ·····-· REQUIRED: 1. USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURES PINPOINTED IN RED 2. LARGE SCALE STREET OR PLAT MAP 3. PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, PREFERABLY B&W, AT LEAST 3x5 Printed Wednesday, June 27, 2007 Page 37 of 47 PHOTOGRAPH SKETCH MAP W Midwa Road I 8SL0150 I C'CS 1 > Q) Q) ::::s -c: ::::s Q) 0 ~ al G) "' former location of U) ::::s •t:: oDo .... 1107 Midway c: .:!::: ::::s 0 "' "1/ "' sheds Page 38 of 47 070 8SL150 ffOO Wee! Mtcfway Road Zone l7 Eullno: 056.5405 1'4onhlno: 302S07ll Page 39 of 47 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Page1 Cl Original fi! Update HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE Version 4.0 1/07 Shaded Fields represent the minimum acceptable level of documentation. Consult the Guide to Historical Structure Forms for detailed instructions. Site#8 SL150 ___ _ Field Date .JLJ .1_1.2filQ_ Form Date .. 1£.J ..LJ.2filQ_ Recorder# _____ _ Site Name(s) (address ifnooe) Stetcher House Survey Project Name CR 712 Midway Ponds Multiple Listing (OHR only) Survey # (OHR only) ) £'.l I 0 'ii National Register Category (please check ooe) 611 building D structure D d~trict D site D object Ownership: Dplivate-prolit Dprivate-nooprofit li'lprivate-indi~dual Dplivate-ooospecilic Doty Dcounty Dstate Dfederal DNative American Dforeign Dunknown LOC \I 10'\ 8, \I \l'l'I'\(; Address (Include N,S,E,W; It. St., Ave., elc.) 1103 w Midway Road Cross Streets (nearest I between) Citrus Ave and Cvoress Ave USGS7 .5' Map Name & Date Ankona. Fla. 1948 IPR1983l Plat or Other Map ___________ _ City /Town (wilhin 3 miles) White Citv In City Limits? Dyes Ono 611unknown County ,.St._. ,,,Lu,,,ci,,,·e"'Co"""un"'ty,_ ____ _ Township 36 S Range 40 E Section 4 y, section: DNW DSW 0SE ONE Dlrregular-name: _____ _ Tax Parcel # 3404-501-0242-000-5 Landgrant Subdivision Name . .....,,,,.Wh=lte~C,,,i,,ty ___ :-:------,-,--,-,-----,,.,..,-~,---Block 41 ______ Lot UTM: Zone 016 61117 Easting 565493 Northing 3028052 1,2.3.4.5.6.7.8 Other Coordinates: X: Y: ______ Coordinate System & Datum ,.UT..,M"""N"'A"'D-"8"3 _______ _ Name of Public Tract(e.g., park) _____________________________ _ lllSIOR\ Construction Year. 1917 Dapproximately Dyear listed or earlier Dyear listed or later Original Use* residence From (year): 1917 To (year): ___ _ Current Use* residential From (year): To (year): current Other Use' From (year): To (year):. ___ _ Moves: Dyes li'lno Dunknown Dates Original address (if movad) Alterations: Dyes li'lno Dunknown Dates Nature* Additions: Dyes li'lno Dunknown Dates Nature* Architect (last name first): Builder (last name first): -------------- Ownership History (especially original owner, dates, professioo, etc.) Harold J Parsons 11997 -oresentl Is the Resource Affected by a Local Preservation Ordinance? Oyes Ono lilunknown Describe ____________ _ DES( RIPTIO'li Style' Craftsman____________ Exterior Plan• Rectangular ______ Number of Stories Exterior Fabric(s) • Asbestos shingle RoolType(s)• =C=ro=ss~G=a=ble~-----------Roof Material(s)• ~Pr=es=s=ed~m=e=ta=I _________ _ Roof secondary strucs. (dooners etc.)• .,,G,,ab.,le=do"'nn"'e"'r·------------------------- Windows (types, materi~s. etc)' OHS 1/1 ----------------------------- Distinguishing Archltectural Features (exterior or interior omamenls) Rectangular massing. side gable roof. pressed metal shingles. asbestos siding. enclosed front oorch and gable dormer. Ancillary Features I Outbuildings (record outbuildings, major landscape features: use continuation sheet~ needed.) Associated outbuilding. modem clad in corrugated metal. ~Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions (coded fields at the Stte File). ,-------------------------- l ___ D_H_R_':JSE~ _ OFFICIAL EVALUATION ----~EO~~ NR List Date __)__) __ D Owner Objection SHPO -Appears to meet criteria for NR l~ting: Oyes ,)iliio Dinsuflicient info Date fu_.5_12o/ ~ lnit GA;J"' KEEPER -Determined eligible: Dyes Dno Date_/__) __ NR Criteria for Evaluation: Da Db De Dd (see National Register Bulletin 15, p. 2) HR6E046R0107 Florida Master Site File I Division of Historical Resources IR. A. Gray Building f 500 South Bronough Street, Tallahassee, FL 32399-0250 Phone (850) 245-6440 I Fax (850)245-6439 I E-mail SlteFlle@dos.state.fl.t.IS Page 40 of 47 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Page2 HISTORICAL STRUCTURE FORM Site #8 SL 150 l>l:SCRll' I 10\ 1rn11t11111ed1 Chimney: No._1_ Material(s)•metal ----------------------------- Structural System(s) • W.u=ood=lr~a~e~-----------,-,c-c------c---------------- Foundation: Type(s) • Piers Material(s) • Concrete block __________ _ Main Entrance (stylistic details) N. fagade. single leaf --------------------------- Porch Descriptions (types. locations. roof types, etc.) N. fagade, enclosed---------------------- Condition (overall ""°"rce cooditioo): Oexcellent Dgood li'lfair Odeteriorated Oruinous Narrative Description of Resource A fairly intact example of an early twentieth centurv Craftsman structure. Archaeological Remains ---------------------0 Check if Archaeological Form Completed ~Consult Guide to Historical Structure Forms for preferred descriptions (coded fields at the Site File). Ii'! FMSF record search (sites/surveys) D FL State Archives/photo collection Ii'! property appraiser I tax records Ii'! cultural resource survey Rl:SE \I{( H \IFTIIOllS (ehecl, all 111.11.1pp1,1 0 library research 0 city directory 0 newspaper files 0 historic photos 0 building permits 0 occupanUowner interview 0 neighbor interview 0 interior inspection 0 Sanborn maps 0 plat maps 0 Public Lands Survey (DEP) 0 HABS/HAER record search D other methods (descrile) ________________________________ _ Bibliographic References (give FMSF manuscript# W relevant use cootinuation sheet if needed) 2011. Wallace. Jelane: Mahar. Kelly. A Cuftural Resource Reconnaissance SutVey of the Prooosed CR 712 Midway Road Ponds Project Area in Whfte City. st. Lucie Countv. Florida. Panamerican Consultants Inc. Brandon FL. 01'1\IO'\ OF RESCH RCE Sl(;\IFIC \\( E Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing individually? Dyes li'lno Dinsufficient information Appears to meet the atteria for National Register listing as pat of a district? Dyes Ono li'linsufficient information Explanation of Evaluation (required, whether s~nfficant or not use separate sheet W needed) Previously inventoried 7/2006. SHPO determination of not eligible for listing on the NRHP (12/21/2007). Area(s) of Historical Significance (see National Register BuHetin 15, p. 8 for categories: e.g. "architecture". "ethn~ heritage", "community ~anning & devetopmenr, etc.) 1>0( l \IE\ I A 1101\ Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Stte File -inciuding fie~ & analyso notes, photos, plans, other important dooJments that are permanentiy acces~ble: For each separately maintained collection, describe (1) document type(s), * (2) maintaining organization,* (3) file or accession nos., and (4) descriptive information._~~- Field notes. maps. and digital photooraphs will be on file in the office of Panamerican Consultants. Tampa under accession number 30582. RECORDER I'IFORi\L\ TIO!\ Recorder Name Kelly Mahar Recorder Contact Information (address/ phone /fax I e-mail)) 2390 Clinton Street Buffalo NY. (716) 821-1650 Recorder Affiliation Panamerican Consultants. Inc. Use a Supplement for Sfte Forms or other continuation sheet for descriptions that do not frt in the spaces provided. Required Attachments 0 USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION PINPOINTED IN RED 8 LARGE SCALE STREET, PLAT OR PARCEL MAP (8"'1ablefroml00Slproperty_web_) 8 PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, ARCHIVAL B&W PRINT OR DIGITAL IMAGE FILE If submitting an image file, it must be included on disk or CD AND in hard copy format (p1a1n _, 1s ""'..-). Diaital image must be at least 1600 x 1200 pixels. 24-btt color, jpeg or tiff. Page 41 of 47 I I I I I I I I I Photograph 1. North facade, facing south (PCI 2010). I I PerCN&I St 0 .., l '\,. .. Augusta St ~ Pf .. I I 15: :;. "' Cnarfona St a: • ~ :;. 'O c: .. W Midway Rd !I! 'O lU 0 ~ • V\tilo ID UV ... I "' ·c: § W 1st St V1 Whit I Cll)r F'.wk ... W 2nd St ~ .E I • 8SL150 w ~ itS 1103 Midway Roa<> W 3n! SI W..te Oly FL 34982 ... .l'C Whllotay Enders Nursery Rd Stl>oOIP•ll -.. • ~ I < :;. ... .., 2 :i ·""' .!! I I Page 42 of 47 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I • Legend: o historic structure • • • • • • • • •• • • • • • • .. • • • • • • • •• • •• .. '""" .... • •• • I • I ,_ • i • • • • • • •• • 11111 • ~· • • ~ 8SL 150 • • -· a • __ :.:.J • • • . .. •••••• .... Midway Ponds t N St. Lucie County, Florida Township 36 South, Range 40 East Base map: Ankona, Fla. 1948 (PR 1983). Fort Pierce, Fla. 1949 (PR 1983) USGS 7.5' topographic quadrangle o 0.07 0.14 0.21 0.28 Miles --------~--1....--- Page 43 of 47 Page 44 of 47 Page 45 of 47 Page 46 of 47 Page 47 of 47