The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutSUBMITTED PAPERS(3k�IGEI7�E ONL r: DATE FILED ' O PLAN REVIEW FE : - O RECEIPT NO.: 9 PERMIT NUMBER: 1001O l — CONCURRENCY FEE: RECEIPT NO.: CERT. ALL INFO MUST BE COMPLETE & FILLED IN TO BE ACCEPTED St. Lucie County Building; and Zoning w-QD, LW-- ►,OL• 2300 Virginia Avenue SCANNED Ft. Pierce, FL 34982-5652 ® y (. OS�S�a535 772-462-1553 Lucie County 2 `l`— az_ c APPLICATION for BUILDING PERMIT 7`QaoLc 1 CERTIFICATE of CAPACITY/ZON]NG COMPLIANCE PROJECT 1. LOCATION/SITE ADDRESS: / Z IC SA sI Qk u0 «v 2. PROJECT NAME: SITE PLAN NAME: 3. PROPERTY TAX ID #: 3 ? �'- .� L 00 " o 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION (attach extra sheets if necessary): S-AA 5. 9. 10 PLAT B OOK 6. PAGE NO. 7. BLOCK NO. 8. LOT NO. PARCEL SIZE (ACRES/SQ FT.): LOT DIMENSIONS: 7SE, DESCRIPTION OF CO TRUCTION PROM TOR WORK ACTIVITY .� w � o 11. 'SETBACKS (ACTUAL) FRONT: O BACK: RIGHT SIDE: LEFT SIDE: 12. TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION (Check all appropriate boxes) [ ] NEW CONSTRUCTION [ ] EXPANSION/ADDITION [ ] RESIDENTIAL [ ] COMMERCIAL [ ] OTHER (SPECIFY) 13. DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED USE: [ INTERIOR RENOVATION [ ] INDUSTRIAL 14. SQ. FT OF CONSTRUCTION: C) 15. SF. FT lst FLOOR: 16. VALUE OF CONSTRUCTION: $ l °2�� d U cJ The value of construction is used to determine the amount of permit fees to be assessed. St. Lucie County reserves the right to question and/or modify the indicated value of construction if it is demonstrated that the submitted figures are not consistent with similar types of construction activities. If the value is $2500 or more, a RECORDED Notice of Commencement must be submitted with this application. SLCCDV Form No.: 001-02 ar OWNER INFORMATION NAME: �U��-G e��S X"_KC'QA' ADDRESS- CITY: STATE: $= L ZIP: : • ` PHONE (DAYTIME): 5 •�j S _ `5�2� Email: IF THE FEE SIMPLE TITLEHOLDER (PROPERTY OWNER) IS DIFFERENT FROM THE OWNER LISTED ABOVE, PLEASE FILL IN NAME AND ADDRESS BELOW. :e FEE SIMPLE TITLEHOLDER: ADDRESS: CITY: ATE: ZIP: PHONE (DAYTIME): (_) CONTRACTOR INFORMATION ST. of FL REG.CERT #: —C C- C_ — ISb GSse I ST. LUCI NTY2YRT;,: CrP O BUSINESS NAME: u QUALIFIERS NAME: OQ J _ ADDRESS: 2 o n � / CITY: STATE: �-� ZIP: Z 3�% �� PHONE (DAYTIME): (� I FAX NO. / �1-tea. l: �,Cu gUls. 1 `M ARCHIT/ENGINEER: ADDRESS: CITY: STATE: ZIP: PHONE (DAYTIME): BONDING COMPANY: ADDRESS: CITY: STATE: ZIP: MORTGAGE LENDER: ADDRESS: CITY: STATE: ZIP: LVTORTANT NOTICE: When a permit is issued and it is not picked up within 60 days after notification it will be voided and returned to you by mail. CERTIFICATION: -� This application is hereby made to obtain a permit to do the work and installations as indicated, and to obtain a certificate of capacity, if applicable, for the permitted work. I certify that no work or installation has commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be performed to meet the standards of all laws regulating construction in this jurisdiction. I understand that separate permits may be required for ELECTRICAL, PLUMBING, SIGNS, WELLS, POOLS, FURNACES, BOILERS, HEATERS, TANKS, AND AIR CONDITIONERS, ETC., not otherwise included with this building permit application. St. Lucie County makes no representation that its granting of a permit will authorize the permit holder to build the subject structure which is in conflict with any applicable Homeowner Association rules, bylaws or any covenants that may restrict or prohibit such structure. Please consult with your Homeowner's Association and review your deed for any restrictions which may apply. The following building permit applications are exempt from undergoing a full concurrency review: room additions, accessory structures (all types), swimming pools, fences, walls, signs, screen rooms, utility substations & accessory uses to another non- residential use. NOTICE TO OWNER: FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. NOTICE TO APPLICANT: AS THE APPLICANT FOR THIS BUILDING PERMIT, IF IT IS NOT YOUR RIGHT, TITLE, AND INTEREST THAT IS SUBJECT TO ATTACHMENT; AS A CONDITION OF THIS PERMIT YOU PROMISE IN GOOD FAITH TO DELIVER A COPY OF THE ATTACHED CONSTRUCTION LIEN LAW NOTICE TO THE PERSON WHOSE PROPERTY IS SUBJECT TO ATTACHMENT. OWNER'S AFFIDAVIT: I certify that all the foregoing information is accurate and that all work will be done in compliance th all applicable laws regulating construction and 2ng. v OWNER OR A T tyGNATURE CONTRACT IG RE STATE OF FLOR A . COUNTY OFF(,- o . The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this o20 day o J20 10 , by kj_Oi: QMt.k h EC'elt-%U7) -A_ who is personally known or has produced �QW-Q� -5-10 19 1a "0 as identification. LORIE PER$TEMEIER Commission No. 4;' °'%r- �) , Y COMM . # DD 514317 EXPIRES: February 14, 2010 ?e ?N&, Bonded Thru Not2ry Public Under�v'r;erx STATE OF FLORIOA COUNTY OF �. The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this %00 day of , 20 , byAi2.(J who is personally known or has produced � identi 'cation. ORIEA. GERSTEMEIER(S DD 514317 EX IRES: February 14, 2010 Bonded Thtu Nolary Public Underwriters NOTE: TWO (2) SIGNATURES ARE REQUIRED. EACH SIGNATURE MUST BE NOTARIZED. IF APPLYING FOR THIS BUILDING PERMIT AS AN OWNER/BUILDER, THE OWNER MUST PERSONALLY APPEAR TO SIGN THIS APPLICATION IN THE OFFICE LISTED ON THE FRONT OF THIS APPLICATION. OWNER BUILDER AFFIDAVIT WILL BE REQUIRED FOR ALL OWNER/BUILDER APPLICANTS. For specific instructions see appropriate permit checklist. OFFICE USE ONLY BP #: SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE MAP NO. ZONING LAND USE LOT CVG % TAZ NO. FLOOD ZONE FIRM MAP # IT FLR ELV MAX HGT CONST TYPE OCCUP TYPE MAX OCCUP # OF FLRS WATER SEWER SPRINKLERS STORMWATER LOT OFREC LOT OF REC LOT SPLIT LOT SPLIT Before 1/1990 After 1/1990 REQUIRED APPROVED REPORT HABITABLE RADON PERMIT CODE AREA FEE FEE (RADON) LIBRARY PUBLIC BLD PUBIC BLD PARKS IMPACT IMPACTFEE IMPACT IMPACT FEE CORRECTION FEE FEE GENERAL SCHOOL ROAD CREDIT Y N LAW ENF IMPACT IMPACT IMPACT FEE FEE FEE FIRE/EMS DRIVEWAY, Y_ ' N DRIVEWAY ADMINISTRATIVE IMPACT REQUIRED FEE VARIANCE FEE FEE SPECIFY MECHANIC ROOF NON -CONFORMING MISCELLANEOUS SUBS ELECTRIC GAS LOT OF RECORD FEES REQUIRED PLUMBING. FEES DATE SENT TO ADDRESSING: / REVIEWS FRONT ZONING ' SUPERVISOR PLANS VEGETATION SEA TURTLE' MANGROVE COUNTER REVIEW REVIEW REVIEW REVIEW REVIEW REVIEW DATE RECEIVED - DATE COMPLETED INITIALS Code Compliance Divisionµ Permit 1 2300 Virginia Avenue Ft. Pierce, FL 34982 Phone: (772) 462-1553 Fax: (772) 462-1578 http://www.stiucieco.org/public—works/permiffing.htm Address 7960 1 SADDLEBROOK DR I Owner(s) Arif Shakoor PORT ST LUCIE 134986 Historic No Jurisdiction St. Lucie County Parcel # 3321-502-0026 000/4 S/D Sabal Creek Phase 2 Block Lot # 77 FLU RS Zoning AR-1 Flood Mal: 283F Flood Elevation I Flood Zone X Application Type Master Permit w/subs 1001 0178 Activity Type Renovation Other - Specify 651--^— Status Pending Expiration Date Applied 01/20/2010 Taken By gersteml Date Issued Issued By Date Finaled Posted By Date Voided Please explain in Additional Commen Job Address 796d SADDLEBROOK ' CONTACT•- • Category Type O C t t Property Owner Property Owner Property Owner Contractor Permit Type Building (Miscellaneous) Location Mainland 3 [at Fee Valuation Contractor Name Business Address Email ARIF SHAKOOR 8740 BALLY BUNION RD PORT ST LUCIE FL 34986 pen on rac o, . Registration Form Phone (863) 697-2277 ext Fax ( ) - Mobile ( ) Pager TRADESUB Sub -Trade Permit Permit Type Electrical Sub Trade Status Pending 1001-0178-01 Contractor Taken By gersteml 1001-0178-01 1001-0178-02 EP PP Company Date Applied 01/20/2010 1001-0178-03 ME Owner / Buildier Issued Issued By Sub -Trade Job Description ; Expiration Finaled Finaled By CONSTRUCTION INFO - • Units 1.00 Floors 1® Buildings ri� # Bedrooms # Bathrooms Total Sq. Ft. 0.00 Min Flood Elevation Flood Map 283E Flood Zone FCC NOC Required ® VOC Receivec ❑ NOC Expiration Setbacks Front Back Left Side Right Side Job Description Additional Info REMOVE AND REPLACE CHINESE DRYWALL THROUGH OUT THE HOUSE AND FIX ANY ELECTICAL , PLUMBING & HVAC WITHOUT THE HOUSE. Please include the date and your name when adding information. REFER: PERMIT # 0505-0535 1-20-10 PER CHRIS LESTRANGE THEY DID NOT NEED TO TURN IN SEALED ENGINEERING REPORTS OR FLOOR PLANS (L.GERSTEMEIER) St. Lucie County Building & Zoning (` 2300 Virginia Ave ;K; Fort Pierce, FL 34982 BUILDING PERMIT \ SUB -CONTRACTOR SUMMARY Q/l:c Lr Ui will be using the following sub -contractors for the (Company/Individual Name) project located at 53b2 pp 2.,F, OOo (Street address or Property Tax ID, It is understood that if there is any change of status regarding the participation of any of the sub -contractors listed below, I will immediately advise the Building and Zoning Department of St. Lucie County. Trade Name of Company/Contractor St. Lucie County/ State of Florida License Number Electrical -- �c ; C Plumbing HVAC/ 44 Mechanical Roofing Gas OFFICE USE ONLY: PERMIT ISSUE DATE: NUMBER: KHRAY ENGINEERING INC. Consulting Engineers February 24, 2010 Ms. Mary Doherty Florida Building & Remodeling, Inc. 3500 N.W. Boca Raton Blvd., Suite 614 Boca Raton, Florida 33431 RE: SHAKOOR RESIDENCE Dear Ms. Doherty: Via E-mail: matygobuild@bellsouth.net and regular mail Please be advised that I have inspected the referenced residence prior to the installation of the drywall and, it is my opinion, that all wiring is in good condition, new electrical switches and outlets have been installed and all stud guards are in place. In conclusion, the electrical was found to be in good condition with no problems observed. J. Steven W. Ray, j Florida Registration #54977 \1II11lit,!,r` a _} �• 54979 STATE OF ONA o�� 3985 Steve Reynolds Blvd., Building A, Norcross, GA 30093 • (770) 923-1122 •. FAX (770) 923-0099 0 / f7 (�� --- Certificate Completion Service Provided: HVAC system cleaning (Duct system only) Date Completed: 2/22/10 Cleaning Address: 7960 Saddlebrook Drive, Pt. St. Lucie, Fl. 34986 Contractor: 'Atlantic Air Conditioning & Heating, Inc. 3079 SE Waaler St. Stuart, Fl. 34997 About our HVAC System Cleaning: Stanley Steemer is an active member of NADCA. The National Air Duct Cleaners Association is the only organization that provides certification to HVAC cleaning contractors around the world. We follow their policies, procedures and standards in all residential and commercial applications. NADCA.com is a great resource if you or your customers want to research this industry. Stanley Steemer is also a licensed mechanical contractor in the State of Florida (# CMC014066). Scope of Work: The work involved the removal and disposal of particulates from the HVAC supply and return systems. We utilized appropriate agitation tools, compressed air, and negative pressure- all passing through a HEPA filter. We mechanically cleaned all main trunk lines and branch duct runs. All lined duct work and flexible duct was cleaned with compressed air, non -aggressive agitation devices along with contact vacuuming. The cleaning also included the wiping down and cleaning of all registers and diffusers, as well as, HEPA vacuuming ceiling tiles adjacent to diffusers, but none were present. Our HVAC System Cleaning Equipment: We utilized the Nikro SL4000 Dual Blower Air Duct Cleaning Systems. You can find these at Nikro.com and search by "SL4000" if you would like to see their specifications. This collection unit meets and exceeds NADCA cleaning standards. If there any further questions please feel free to contact me, Brad Hunsucker Stanley Steemer of South Florida Director of Franchise Operations 561-994-0064- office 561-719-5565- cell STAN;LXEY cxTEEMER� !Elk - AIR ,D*T CQrw�a �o_� Stanley Steemer of South Florida 2085 S. Congress Ave., Delray Beach, Fl. 33445 =�1 ' (561-994-0064-Office) (561-819-0339-Fax) or (1-800-Steemer) 1 �� The HvpLlnspectwn, MdtRemnLe ..,I ke:iefnlian M_4.Iig Atlantic Air Conditioning & Heating, Inc. 3079 SE Waaler Street Stuart, FL 34997 (772) 287-6144 (phone) (772) 287-9124 (fax) LIC# CAC010873 March 5, 2010 To Whom It May Concern: RE: 7960 Saddlebrook Dr Port St. Lucie, FL 34986 Atlantic Air Conditioning employed the services of Stanley Steemer of South Florida to clean all ducts at above residence 2/22/2010. Lewis Rochester Atlantic Air Conditioning & Heating, Inc. -Pam: usa P += M. waszro NY COIuIMISSfON # DD59 047p EXPIRES: August 30 BondedThruAbtary10 P UrNwrifers Code Compliance Division 2300 Virginia Avenue Ft. Pierce, FL 34982 Phone: (772) 462-2172 Fax: (772) 462-6443 http://www.stlucieco.org/public works/permitting.htm http://ai rs.slcfl.vetrol.com/AIRSweb.php BUILDING PERMIT Issued: 02/09/2010 Conf # 651 Permit #: SLC- 1001-0178 Job Location: 7960 SADDLEBROOK DR City: PORT ST LUCIE Permit Type: Building (Miscellaneous) Page 1 Job Description: REMOVE AND REPLACE CHINESE DRYWALL THROUGHOUT THE HOUSE AND REPAIR ANY ELECTICAL , PLUMBING & HVAC THROUGHOUT THE HOUSE. [ NO STRUCTURAL WORK OR DUCT REPLACEMENT ] Subdiv: Saba[ Creek Phase 2 Lot: 77 Block: Parcel: 3321-502-0026-000/4 Setbacks Left: Right: Front: Rear: Zoning: AR-1 Number of Units: 1.00 Floors: 1 Buildings: 1 Square Footage: 0.00 Minimum Floor Elevation: Flood Map: 283F Flood Zone: X Elev: Contractor EDWARD J. BOROWY FLORIDA BUILDING & REMODELING (561) 487-8686 3500 NW BOCA RATON BLVD STE 614 BOCA RATON, FL 33431 Property Owner ARIF SHAKOOR 8740 BALLY BUNION RD Property Owner ELMA SHAKOOR PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34986 8740 BALLY BUNION RD PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34986 (863) 697-2277 (863) 697-2277 Permit holder acknowledges through acceptance of this permit that separate permits must be obtained as required by the Florida Building Code including those for all electric, plumbing, mechanical, roofing and structural work. Further, he/she acknowledges responsibility to comply with all requirements of the 2007 Florida Building Code and the St Lucie County Land Development Code. Issuance of this permit may be appealed to the St Lucie County Board of Adjustment by an aggrieved party by filing a notice of appeal with the St Lucie County Growth Management Director within thirty (30) days of the issuance of this permit in accordance with St Lucie County Land Development Code, Section 11.11.00., Appeals. Building Permits shall expire and become null and void if work authorized by such Building Permit is not commenced, having called for and received a satisfactory inspection, within six (6) months from the date of issuance of the permit, or if the work is not completed within 18 months (permit by contractor) or 24 months (permit by owner) from the date of issuance of the Building Permit in accordance with St Lucie County Land Development Code Section 11.05.01 (A)(2). NOTICE: In addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in the records of this county, and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as water management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies. s:553.79(10), F.S. WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. s:713.135 (1)(a), F.S. Christopher Lestrange Building Official Date JOSEPH Z. SMITH ms�fRK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT - SAINT LUCIE COUNTY FILE # 3431885 'e`-300K 3163 PAGE 1070, Recorded 01/20, D at 11:55 AM AFTER RECORDING -RETURN TO: F —1 PERMIT NUMBER: L Thh %gam Ir rr..rnvJ lur rrrnrAmc Infra hi- D I rig NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT J The undersigned hereby given notice that improvement will be made to certain real property, and in accordance with Chapter 713, Florida statutes the following information is provided in the Notice of commencement. 1. DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY (Legal description and sheet address) TAX FOLIO NUMBER: L -( SIm SUBDIVISION BLOCK TRACT' LOT_2.7- BLDG UNIT 11 Sr, dle brooV- Dr. T4 S,4-. W tl le . FL 2. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENT: 3. OWNER INFORMATION: a. Name 'br c. interest in d. Name and address offee simple titleholder (if other than owner)_ 4. CONTRACTOR'S NAME, ADDWS AND PHONE NUMBER; 3 5 is � iULt�3 a ctti'td�vt�31 � I� 1. r� 15 5, SURETY'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER AND BOND AMOUNT: 6. LENDER'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER: 0 7. Persons within the State of Florida designated by Owner upon whom notices or other documents maybe served as provided by Section 713.13 (lxa) 7., Florida Statutes: NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER: A 8. In addition to himself or herself, Owner designates the foll to receive a copy of the Lienor's Notice as provided in Section 713.13 (1)(b), Florida Statutes: / NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER: f F 9. Expiration date of notice of commencement a expiration d4Le is 1 year from the date of recording unless a different date is specified) 20. Signature of Owner or Print Name and Provide Signatory's Tltle/Office Owner's Authorized OfticerlDireetnr/Partner/Managcr State of Florida County of F L The far instrument was acknowled d before me this l.�T� day Z— of 0. YL t t r"(1 20 1 D Byas (Printed p of p signing above) (Type of authority... e.g. Owner, officer, trustee, attorney in fact) For ```````t4%tt'9OH mttq�r��i % (Nac of p atf of whom instrument was executed) Personally Knoy� l pr�tt ( following type of ID: tr AL�"�a.;�a:.*�t'tszeo-z(e-58-9r8 0 ,,,fie Jok�� (Printed N e of Notary c) (SIgnTturcAfNot=y Public) _ �•t tlOP�f$e�..F.' �� Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing and that the belief (section 92.525, Florida Statutes). of my knowledge and Signature(s) of Owner(s) or Owner(s)' Authorized Ofiicer/DirectorlPanner/Manager who signed above: By:C. By P-1 ,4-I,,n,n ornanoo n r .ml Signature) Printed Name) STATE OF ST LUCIE. ORMA Till I OMF 0 E1ORI hip1OR THIS PS A OF TN; CLERK ST. LUCIE COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTMENT �P BUII.DING PERMIT SUB -CONTRACTOR AGREEMENT St. Lucie County Contractor Certification Number: U -Q SJ State of Florida Certification Number (lf applicable): Ciiq" 3 ffl-(a,&,G fi- caf-lnq, 1-nC - have agreed to be the (Company Name/Individualgame) h U'- sub -contractor for F(d r, Lca d . - �"'ad e(,a) , _�:-o C . (Type of Trade) (Primary Contractor) for the project located at -7 q& D SGZd d ( ehtWlc.. � r ) .PSL (Project Street Address or Property Tax ID #) It is understood that, if there is any change of status regarding our participation with the above mentioned project, I will immediately advise the Building and Zoning Department of St. Lucie County by personally filing a Change of Contractor notice. (Form: SLCCDV No. 004-00) BUSINESS QUALIFIER (Name of the Individual shown on the Contractor's License) ORIGINAL SIGNATURES ARE REQUIRED � zer,2�_ ko 4 R 0C_h SIG ATURE PRINTRA—ME DATE Business Name: &fl 0_n f,(, i'`I C-* 14 Cat-fnn , -> hC , Address:�q S�CcCtIQ Sfi-• City/State/Zip: S C( 1` .4. : 3.4Y II: Phone: �% �7z- a K`� �'(o (1 f email:y �tfi�, f,ccte inc •CUM nVffCF, TT.VF, ONLY: ` PERMIT # ISSUE DATE Consumer Consumer Consumer Consumer Form ID Confirmatic Transactioi Transactioi Rebate Ste FL 34997 .7.72E+09. 1209104633 ' 493847 11/9/2009 WEB . FL 34994 7.22E+09 ' • 1209104629 493794 11/9/2009 WEB FL 34996 7.72E+09 1209104637 506322 12/7/2009 WEB FL 34996 7.72E+09 1209104636 506292 12/7/2009 WEB FL 34996 7.72E+09 1209104634 506268 12/7/2009 WEB FL 34996 7.72E+09 1209104635 506283 12/7/2009 WEB FL 34996 7.72E+09 1209104630 493882 11/9/2009 WEB JOSEPH E. SMITH, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT — SAINT LUCI;)LINTY FILE # 3431885 0 IOK 3163 PAGE 1070, Recorded 01/20/' I at 11:55 AM AFTER RECORnumuTIIRN TO: r— PERMIT NUMBER: L 1'hi.sparr I. re..rrrnl !nr nrnrJinc Info I tt i- o vis NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT The undersigned hereby given notice that improvemeat will be made to certain real property, and in accordance with Chapter 713, Florida atamta the following information is provided in the Notice of commencement. 1. DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY (Legal description and street address) TAX FOLIO NUMBER: Z.-L( Sid z OQ42L 0 00/i,-- SUBDMSION BLOCK TRACT N LOT_?- UNIT I t — a l e bro O D r, 4 5•P, Lu ri v. F L. 2. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENT: =V +? rot 0V- ?,-e n61/a:h;M 3. OWNER INFORMATION: a. Name I r # A•l rs . A ri -P 5 ha 6n r b.Address raO 54c1SUGi]YnpJe_ b., �• l�tnri f _ interest prop- �b n - property— d. Name and address offec simple titleholder (if other than owner) 4. CONTRACTOR'S NAME, ADD S AND PHONE NUMBER: 1=1 iidi 6 13d 8 %1r10 Ee(f1 aL{t C .�h=�D iUll� ►3acCt_-BI[l� 1�LN��nt�L�ra. n, �i. 3� 31 5. SURETY'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PRONE NUMBER AND BOND AMOUNT: 6. LENDER'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER: .mil 7. Persons within the State of Florida designated by Owner upon whom notices or other documents may be served as provided by Section 713.13 (lxa) 7., Florida Statutes: NAME, ADDRM AND PHONE NUMBER: c E. In addition to himself or herself, Owner designates the fall to receive a copy of the Lienor's Notice as provided in Section 713.13 (1)(b), Florida Statutes: NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER: 9. Expiration date of notice of commencement o expiration is 1 year from the date of recording unless a different date is specified) 20 Signature of Owner or Print Name and Provide Signatory's Title/OMce Owner's Authorized Officer/Dirertar/Partner/Manager State of Florida County of F L , ^,` T The for mstrumrrrt was ecknowled d before me this !� 1 day of _ ..1 0. Y1(14+((( 20 10 BY as hu)y�2( (Printed of p r signing above) (Type of authority... e.g. Owner, officer, trustee, attorney m fact)) Fer(Name of p alf of whom instrument was executed) Personally Kno*%' -kp0/following type of ID: r ba Jokefl_z (Printed Na6e of Notary c) (8Ign&urcy Notary Public) Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing and that the � best of my knowledge and belief (section 92.525, Florida Statutes). ►Ntl 11N11N�\ Signature(s) of Owncr(s) or Owner(a)' Authorized Officer/Director/PartuerNsriagerwho signed above: By: By P-L S f"t ate, ovranoo76tm mat Signature) ted Name) �arE ST LUCIE Fo r}r1 41, 7 0 EIORI OR rH,S IS A OF; N. j , CLERK ST. LUCIE COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTMENT a BUILDING PERMIT SUB -CONTRACTOR AGREEMENT St. Lucie County Contractor Certification Number: 2 (m i State of Florida Certification Number (If applicable): 0 d 03 7 K,tf— PlvM`, rh have agreed to be the (CoAipany Name/In ividual Name) �, it JBtit%Gl sub -contractor for IA�. ,�a��a.�✓ (Type of Trade) (Primary Contra tor) p A for the project located at 7460 SRO�r a /3paa K �a , PST ST, l ,m4j E 33 z t - 50 z— no 2 6 (Project Street Address or Property Tax ID #) It is understood that, if there is any change of status regarding our participation with the above mentioned project, I will immediately advise the Building and Zoning Department of St. Lucie County by personally filing a Change of Contractor notice. (Form: SLCCDV No. 004-00) BUSINESS QUALIFIER (Name of the Individual shown on the Contractor's License) ORIGINAL SIGNATURES ARE REQUIRED SIGNATURE PRINT NAME DATE Business Name: %yle pko,q ri Address: 5G L, City/State/Zip: ksov �/ rL y 3�y11� Phone: Ulf- 411S =G770 OFFICE USE ONLY: email: 81ze'lz ®�:y�G ID p -�, ST. LUCIE COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTMENT IC'ti�:l BUILDING PERMIT SUB -CONTRACTOR AGREEMENT St. Lucie County Contractor Certification Number: State of Florida Certification Number (If applicable): (J�// 0 ,.T;dc-s have agreed to be the (Company Name/Individual Name) sub -contractor for r^. ,8474,01AI4 AtInoa0L (Type of Trade) (Primary Contra tor) # p for the project located at 7440 SAW-EgOluaK -DR. fOAT ST, Lurte 33Zt - 5oZ-e�o26'�a% (Project Street Address or Property Tax ID #) It is understood that, if there is any change of status regarding our participation with the above mentioned project, I will immediately advise the Building and Zoning Department of St. Lucie County by personally filing a Change of Contractor notice. (Form: SLCCDV No. 004-00) BUSINESS QUALIFIER (Name of the Individual shown on the Contractor's License) YORIGAL SIGNATURES ARE REQUIRED J �// L9 PRINT NAME DATE Business Name: Address: City/State/Zip: Phone: gig Ai /2 riE �i �°ory1elh o Ac�� Fe- 33 0�V /��'�O !y ' / y�— email: �L��CO ��,%�/G OFFICE USE ONLY: PERMIT # ISSUE DATE i �T STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD (850) 487-1395 1940 NORTH MONROE STREET TALLAHASSEE FL 32399-0783 KRIEGEL, PATRICK KREG ELECTRIC INCORPORATED 3799 N.E. 12TH AVENUE POMPANO BEACH FL 33064 Congratulitionsl With this license you become one of the nearly one million Floridians licensed by the Department of Business and Professional Regulation. Our professionals and businesses range from architects to yacht brokers, from boxers to barbeque restaurants, and they keep Florida's economy strong. Every daywe work to improve the way we do business in order to serve you better. For information about our services, please log onto www.myfloridalicense.com. There youcan find more information about our divisions and the regulations that impact you, subscribe to department newsletters and learn more about the Department's initiatives. Our mission at the Department is:- License Efficiently, Regulate Fairly. We constantly strive to serve you better so that you can serve your customers. Thank youfor doing business in Florida, and congratulations on your new license! DETACH HERE 0 BROWARD COUNTY LOCAL BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT 115 S. Andrews Ave., Rm. A-100, Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301-1895 - 954-831-4000 VALID OCTOBER 1, 2009 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 2010 DBA: Receipt # 181-0155186 Business Name: KREG ELECTRIC INC Business Type: Owner Name: % PATRICK KRIEGEL ELECTRICAL CONTR 149-ZC-86 Business Location: 3799 NE 12 AVE Business Opened: 06/25/85 POMPANO BEACH 33064 Business Phone: (000)78 , 104 � State Coun Cery,,Rgg: 1-; 85CME977X T Erxe�mp#ion Code NON EXEMPT ff thiplgyees' Professionals Rooms A Seat For Vending Bus- iness-Onfy timtior.,f nn��r,�ne�•_ _�. ... q ry �landina,Tune Tax Amount Transfer F4'ija Ni F 4 g �sa. .�r01enal ' tY 6lor Y R � n H Co le ion Cost Total Paid 27.00 $ 27.00 PAID 08/05/09 7707992.0001 27.00 THIS RECEIPT MUST BE POSTED CONSPICUOUSLY IN YOUR PLACE OF BUSINESS THIS BECOMES A TAX RECEIPT This tax is levied for the privilege of doing business within Broward County and is non -regulatory in nature. You must meet all County and/or municipality WHEN VALIDATED planning and zoning requirements. This Business Tax Receipt must be transferred when the business is sold, business name has changed or you have moved the business location. This receipt does not indicate that the business is legal or that it is in compliance with State or local laws and Mailing Address: regulations. KREG ELECTRIC INC % PATRICK KRIEGEL 3799 NE 12 AVENUE POMPANO BCH FL 33064 2009 - 2010 'Yd'.:.au c.»x x.... Y,..a-u.zx+,-... a. ait.: =.-.... �" �. .,:. .i+.rrc m'.•m..-i....w+.:..,..... ..... Ir i' ��.._.:��_�. . ..� .. ... ._ .._ _. .. ... ... _.... .. .... ... .... max. ... -.. ._...� .� �. ....._. ..., .,.-...� ��. .. .. .. ._._.. .. ... .. ..... .._� JOSEPH E. SMITH, •RK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT — SAINT LUC: 'RUNTY FILE N 3431885 (.. _DOK 3163 PAGE 1070, Recorded 01/20, —0 at 11:55 AM AFrER RECOPMr-RETM TO: 7 PERMIT NUMBER: IJ hna %pare 1., renrn'nl for Into nrarJme ltfOl- plQg NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT The undersigned hereby given notice that improvement will be made to certain real property, and in accordance with Chapter 713, Florida statutes the following information is provided in the Notice of commencement. 1, DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY (Legal description and street address) TAX FOLIO NUMBER: 9L;—i m x- =L-L�o 0 0 /-4- SUBDIVISION BLOCK TRACT' LOT�yBLDG UNIT l yL nod 11 e b rc co D Y% P4 s4-. L.i. n 0 . F L^ 2. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENT: 3. OWNER INFORMATION: a. Name I r d. Name and address offee simple titleholder (if other than owner)_ 4. CONTRACTOR'S NAME, ADD S AND PHONE NUMBER; 35trp A W Baca }az.-Nlid 41,f4 c. interest in 315 5. SURETY'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER AND BOND AMOUNT: Pr 6. LENDER'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER: 7. Persons within the State of Florida designated by Owner upon whom notices or other documents may be served as provided by Section 713,13 (Ixs) 7., Florida Statutes: / NAME, ADD"M AND PHONE NUMBER: 8. In addition to himself or herself, Owner designates the fell +wn�t� to receive a copy of the Lienor's Notice as provided in Section 713.13 (1)(b), Florida Statutes: / NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER: 9-Expirafiondawcfnotic4cefcommencementktlocxpiradend cis 1 year from the date of recording unless a different date is specified) 20 Signature of Owner or Print Name and Provide Signatory's Title/Office Owner's Authorized Officer/Director/Partner/Manailer State of Florida County of F L '' ^^y The for instrument was ucklimvled d before me this 2D day of .Sa rt LlA, t { 20 1 D B)' as i�11�'11.2i (Printed of p signing above) (Type of authority... e..g'. Owner, officer, trustee, attorney m fact) For (Na me of p alf of whom instrument was executed) Personally Kaov�p�l1yrp0 � ( allowing type of ID: r Aac21Je ,,,0 t)Ok e r .' (Printed Nahe of Notary c) (Signature(SignZinAf Notary Public) ,_ 1P.Htt) o7 Linder penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing and that the belief (section 92.525, Florida Statutes). S7-b0-2/8-58-9/8 0 best of my knowledge and Signutorr(s) of Owners) or Owner(s)' Authorized Officer/Direaor/P}Wner/�tManager who signed�}above: By. By (J� 4— SH4-- A4ksz an araonro7,,- dst Signature) ted Name) STATE ST LUCLF F OR16A kA OMW �nrSAUAI OR I)" TS A OFTH T ; CLERK IS l •��m. \ �; f ■ When you submit your building permit application fob a new single-family residence or duplex, you should use the following checklist to determine if your application submittal is complete. Only complete applications filled out with ink can be accepted for processing. Building Permit, ►� 1 A completely filled out building permit application must Application be submitted, including all required information. The application must be signed by the applicant and notarized. Notice of Commencement `� 1 A recorded Notice of Commencement for all construction with a value exceeding $2,500 has to be submitted at time of building permit application. Construction Plans 2 sets All proposed construction must be accurately shown on the v plans including but not limited to electrical wiring, plumbing, heat/air-conditioning, gas piping, windows and doors. The minimum plot size for these plans is 8 '/2 . by 11 inches - maximum size is 24 by 36 inches. Both sets of plans need to be signed and sealed by a Florida registered engineer and include truss plans. Both sets of plans must be stamped by the Health Department, if a septic permit is required. Please contact our Code Compliance Division at 772-462-1553 for more construction information. , Surveys 2 Surveys are required for all building permits involving a primary structure, and for all accessory structures with a construction value exceeding $10,000. All copies must be stamped by the Health Department if a septic permit is required. Please see our survey requirement sheet for specific requirements. The surveys must be signed Wsealed by a registered Florida surveyor. Lot Splits tilt, Any parcel or parcels not meeting the minimum Non Conforming Lots of requirements of the lot size and dimensional requirements Record (NCLOR) must be reviewed by the Zoning Department. Any division of property not subject to Site Plan review through the Growth Management Department will require review by the Zoning Department. Please contact 772-462-1553. Subcontractor Agreement 1 each One subcontractor agreement with original signature is •Copy �•cF.dSE �i� ouT' required for each subcontractor on the job., The building �irfSue�y�E permit cannot be issued until it has been determined that .E�E�isrTon all subcontractors are properly licensed and registered. The use of unlicensed contractors is strictly prohibited. Energy Calculation Form 2 Both forms must bear the original signatures of both the Manual J's NI 2 creator and contractor. Wind Load Calculation la 2 This form must be signed/sealed by a Florida registered Form engineer. FILE 1 Y 5 tR Rimkus Consulting Group, Inc. A MEN 6360 Northwest 5th Way, Suite 101 :ass Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33309 Munn ■■■■ (954) 351-2500 Telephone ■■■■ ■'■' (954) 351-0051 Facsimile Certificate of Authorization No. 8301 Report of Findings r ...,..M -7777, SHAKOOR RESIDENCE CHINESE DRYWALL DAMAGE EVALUATION Law Firm File No. 12678 RCG File No: 4145038 Prepared For: DERREVERE & HAWKES 470 COLUMBIA DRIVE, BUILDING B WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 33409-1949 Attention: MR. MICHAEL STEVENS Ben J. Teague, P.E. Florida Reg. Eng. No. 69549 Principal Consultant Daniel W. Bridge, Ph.D., CIH, CEP y Principal'Consultant September 11, 2009 I TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Introduction .............................................................................................. 1 11. Conclusions ........................................................................................... 3 Ill. Discussion ............................................................................................. 4 • Description • Interview • Observations • Laboratory Results • Analysis IV. Basis of Report .................................................................................... 10 V. Attachments ......................................................................................... 11 A. Photographs B. Laboratory Test Results and Chain of Custody C. CVS September 11, 2009 • Section i INTRODUCTION It was reported on April 9, 2008 by Arif Shakoor, MD, that abnormal blackening of the electrical wiring, air conditioning coils, and plumbing components appeared to be related to the drywall, which was reportedly imported from China. The Shakoor residence was located at 7960 Saddlebrook Drive in St. Port Lucie, Florida. The concern was that the Chinese drywall had emitted sulfide gases, which caused the damage. Rimkus Consulting Group was retained to investigate the cause and origin of the reported air conditioning problems. On July 13, 2009, Ben J. Teague, P.E. performed a walk-through inspection of the residence and collected two wipe samples of surface deposits on the copper tubes of the evaporator in the air handling units (AHU) and one bulk sample of drywall from the downstairs interior stairwell. Mr. Teague additionally photographed the residence. The collected copper wipe samples were submitted to an independent laboratory accredited by the American Industrial Hygiene Association's Laboratory Accreditation Program (EMSL Analytical, Inc., in Westmont, New Jersey) and the bulk sample was submitted to Dixie Services, Inc. in Houston, Texas, for identification and quantification of possible contaminants. Messrs. Teague and Bridge evaluated the laboratory results received from EMSL and Dixie Services. Mr. Michael B. Stevens, Esq. of Derrevere, Hawkens & Black sent two bulk drywall samples on August 25, 2009 to the Ft. Lauderdale Rimkus office for additional laboratory testing. Laboratory results were reported from Dixie Services, Inc. on September 3, 2009. This report was prepared for the exclusive use of The Law Firm of Derrevere & Hawkes, and was not intended for any other purpose. Our report was based on the r u.49 ixj -' ST 3s ', y 1 y i tz rho 1 F September 11, 2009 Page 1 RCG File No. 4145038 t . information available to us at this time, as described in Section IV, Basis of Report. Should additional information become available, we reserve the right to determine the impact, if any, the new information may have on our opinions and conclusions and to revise our opinions and conclusions if necessary and warranted. r. September 11, 2009 Page 2 RCG File No. 4145038 Section 11 t CONCLUSIONS 1. A portion of the gypsum drywall used to construct some of the interior of the residence was from China. 2. The outdoor air and building moisture sources were identified as possible sources of gases causing the sulfur -like odor in the home. a. There was no evidence of any indoor combustion such as stove flames nor a report of a surrounding fire event in the neighborhood. b. There was no evidence of significant building moisture sources such as plumbing or roof leaks;- however, the shallow groundwater used to water the lawn had a very strong sulfur smell. 3. The sulfur -like odor in the residence appeared to be off -gassing of sulfurous gases from the drywall. Sulfur -contaminated gases from well water from the shallow groundwater well located outside of the house did not enter the home. 4. The blackened household copper and silver -based items, as well as copper evaporator coils in the AHUs, appeared to be caused by reaction with sulfurous gases in the residence. September 11, 2009 Page 3 RCG File No. 4145038 Section III DISCUSSION L_: Fl. h41. .. ic..+....:C.. .... .. .. _..�0:... �:..�... ,:., u1Cw��v's.�� i. ~. :t�4.0 a•.�''�?;.Ga�'._... �¢_. .. �._' � .. _.. _. ,h v.. "��>�..' _ w1 Description The residence was a two-story, single-family residence (Photograph 1). The exterior walls consisted of concrete masonry units finished on the outside with painted cementitious stucco. The interior walls were wood -framed and overlain with gypsum drywall. The floors of the residence were concrete slab -on -grade overlain with ceramic tile, hardwoods, or carpet. The roof was of wood -framed construction overlain with . concrete tiles. The front elevation of the residence was assumed to face east. According to St. Lucie County Appraiser records, the residence was constructed circa 2006. Interview On July 13, 2009, Dr. Shakoor was interviewed for the purpose of gathering relevant information about the damage. According to Dr. Shakoor: • Dr. Shakoor advised us that one of the managing doctors in his office was on retainer for the Chinese drywall firm "KNAUF" 6 o He was not aware of any fire events in the neighborhood, or in any nearby residence. • The air conditioning evaporator coils were black and he reported that the electrical wiring in the wall, although properly sized and installed in a well - designed system, appeared to be darkening at an abnormal rate. • There were other indicators of chemical reaction problems which included tarnishing of copper and silver -based decorative objects. .��rs"7'i"r.'�,"�41y�S�f�r��,i':e�s�.+�F' ��,�'�`�i�'Q,+ Ky ,�.^'"xy S�i :r{� �.F �'.'t,se��•-�v. .r �a^'� r��. `S '�,., �u ra>yti �Y�. ..3 »-e-j`ztiJ 'S.+a4�.. .r1 Ptak' iit i`�Fr fi:[ �y ty.•f �' i ' }t� �f v .i. �.1 i �.. 5ha ?a �.,f. r. �tSfi.'� rev''.la 't2� ,...•ti�Y.' > g�r[f^•'} {'� §� .,t�.lw`' fi'. .I„ � L � .y f t,,p, r 1 t � 4� n h $�,� �,: - S✓�' - �y t i ^a' c f '` r, to+{r„3y. nkf ,r,Y.t.r',l ia�}'w1:vScf 1_"• 0M,��'Y.tit September 11, 2009 Page 4 RCG File No. 4145038 y � 1 • There was a shallow well from which he watered the lawn, which .contained sulfur -contaminated water. General Observations During the course of our site investigation, the following was observed: C The residence had a sulfur -like odor. • The thermostat was set at 76 degrees Fahrenheit and the relative humidity averaged 53 percent (%). The outside air temperature was 88 degrees Fahrenheit and 66% relative humidity (Photograph 2). • The air conditioning systems were direct expansion R22 refrigerant, split system with a condenser located on the outside of the residence and the AHUs were located on both floors of the residence. • The AHUs were sized to accommodate the residence. There was no condensate dripping beneath the AHUs. Removal of the cover to the evaporator coils from the AHUs indicated that the coils were covered with darkened material. The other copper piping inside the AHUs was abnormally dark for being in service for only two years (Photographs 3 through 5). A wipe sample 0 was collected from the air conditioner evaporator coils on each floor. • A further check for moisture stains around the residence indicated that there were no other moisture sources. At the time of this inspection, there were no observed leaks in the laundry room and dishwasher. There was no leaking faucet. The toilets appeared to flush properly. • Non -insulated copper wire was found to be black -colored when an,outlet on the first floor and the electrical switch in the garage were exposed by removing the cover plates (Photographs 6 and 7). �•, t '31k �+y,; �'n > " f >�� .dd�.'� j'�, c.y. ) - �Y 1 v' < " .Si f i +,SL^`P'iir iai�i'i L 7t-s�.� q'"'tc t +t s� j 3 wi. a r �, 1V� t7'-!,s {, (`Js92�. 1- 'Kcu a t •-Y .k °1v [r. fr• L i 4F h7 'na , Y � y. a:i � ,st rt,yr '.1 k:t 'i.l�'i 5� -4 �' 'Y".��. �i K:c� .�,}{a.r"' s _.... 4'� r � '1ry r.:•'}..... � s s K 5 �. _. ._.__...�..� ' I September 11, 2009 Page 5 RCG File No. 4145038 • The unpainted side of the attic�drywall was exposed. We found stenciling on the unpainted side of the ceiling drywall which was not legible and we could not determine the manufacturer (Photographs 8 and 9). • Drywall found on the interior wail cavity of the downstairs interior stairwell was exposed to find stenciling on the piece which read: 100% recycled paper and sag resistant (Photograph 10). • The copper pipes to the water heater were darkened (Photograph 11). 0 The two well pumps were located on the west side of the garage. Investigation of the water from both the deep well potable water for interior use and the shallow well for landscaping use confirmed that the shallow well had a very strong sulfur smell, but the water for the residence did not (Photograph 12). Laboratory Results An analysis of Material/Sulfur-based Compounds was performed by EMSL Laboratory. The elemental analysis by Energy Dispersive X-ray (EDX) indicated the presence of copper and sulfur as major components of sample X-1-S. EMSL concluded that the material in the sample was found to contain copper -based particles, most likely as copper sulfide and possibly, copper oxides. Results of the analysis are presented in Table A. I Table A: Mineral Composition YIO I.cy�r lTle FxwlGl°`IGJ Aek�11d_U; CDA 1 I:�ri �rlwp:5ni^rf:i.cntrrcn.,l rs��a."ds 'V_s.rp5.: �.u.n :: 1: 171::I1t. pMX: i ,.V.r Pcl i:. ^wulpw5`w.IH:.°-iwa1, CD.+a 14'.46f r-D!, Components found in the wipe samples by SEM/EDX (the components of regular environmental dust such as calcite, gypsum, clays, and quartz were not included). X- Ray Diffraction (XRD) analysis for confirmation of presence of copper sulfides and/or R -i ''�'�+F��'� ��3:�`wtxX ,t "i Ati��'� i °�" I t lar t�r`sr�,n ��ra f✓Ph tr�;w�ii �t� �7 �f Y r%. v��s i x *s �t.r.;'`� �I v iµ .!.°yFn F� •i' `s„�'+ v r Z.. J4 .� o Jry. _...'�: .... � :}: .... .. _ _ _. _ .. September 11, 2009 Page 6 RCG File No. 4145038 oxides in the samples was not performed because not enough material was extracted from the wipes sent for analysis. 1984 4-1 0 U 0 Sample X-1-S Cu Cu S Ca 0 C Cu Ca 0.000 keV 10.230 3:44:04 PM 07-17-09 20kV 35 Degree Figure 1. EDX elemental spectrum of particles found in sample X-1-S showing the presence of copper (Cu) and sulfur (S), most likely as copper sulfides. Sample B-1-S, collected by Rimkus, was sent for analysis for Sulfide gases using an d environmental chamber at the Dixie Services laboratory. Samples B-2-S and B-3-S collected by Mr. Michael B. Stevens were sent to Rimkus for the same testing at Dixie Services, Inc. Reportedly, these samples were collected from the Shakoor residence. The results of the analysis are presented in Table A. r"e. ,4i'.✓w` o- .: ... 3k'�.4.�_SY_....c!.:>e�ix:�.t�.:*��l.�: azea 9•:....,._:.;. �.;. �..::.a/,_.�rJ<.b .�ui�... _e, ._. ...__� a_'....r..... 5�...y ,`.. _.. __....._•.' --•.c..�..::..:..` September 11, 2009 Page 7 RCG File No. 4145038 1 Table A: Off -Gassing From the Dixie Environmental Control Chamber Sample B-1-S Shakoor Reference' P 483 Hydrogen sulfide by Jercrne 631-X, ppm 0.0�1 40.001 P 4$D Carbons I sulfide. v-Ppm < O:aS S 0.05 Hydrogen sulfide, v-ppm < 0.05 --0.05 'Carlwn disulfide v rn Sample B-1-S Dated: July 22, 2009 Sample B-2-S 1_ I Shakoor Reference (P 483 hydrogen sulfide by Jerome° 631-X,_pp 2.7 I < 0.001 ;P 480 iCarbonyl sulfide, v-ppm I < 0.05 < 0.05 (Hydro en sulfide, v-ppm I 0.64 j < 0.05 . ;Carbon disulfide, v-ppm I < 0.05 ; < 0.05 f Sample B-2-S Dated: September 3, 2009 Sample B-3-S I_Shoor I Reference' P 483 H drogen sulfide by Jerome''' 631_X�pprn I a.aa8 ► < 0.001 P 480' Carboni I sulfide, v-per _ I < 0-05 _I_< 1].05 — Hdrogen sulfide, v-pprrn I < O.05 Carbon disulfide. v-ppm I < 0.05 I < r]-r;5 Sample B-3-S Dated: September 3, 2009 *A reference sample of painted drywall, obtained from +20 year on -site structure, was also tested. Based on the gas chromatograph (GC) method (P480), carbon disulfide and carbonyl sulfide were not detected .for the suspect drywall or for a negative control of U.S. made drywall supplied by the laboratory. The method detected 640 ppb of hydrogen sulfide for Sample B-2-S. Based on the water hydration method, and the Jerome detector (P483) the laboratory off -gassing of hydrogen sulfide was 0.001 ppm (equal to 1 ppb) for Sample B-1-S; 2.7 ppm (equal to2700ppb) for Sample B-2-S; and 0.008 ppm (equal to 8 ppb) for Sample B-3-S. The US made sample had no detectable hydrogen sulfide detected by the Jerome meter. 1111-211-1171"imm. ).L'::."`dSaL��-d`iYAwi�L......_�..._S1wL•.y. i..-....lvi-%.—n[."�... J✓..-..1'�U•...�.�GS. �: M .._i....w. ...Y%�.LS.CsSS�W _. L. r-.:.1 •...t..•4-.. ✓l�..uti� September 11, 2009 Page 8 RCG File No. 4145038 1 After water hydration, the .Shakoor samples, as well as the positive control of exemplar Chinese drywall, had no strong sulfur odor according to the laboratory. The negative control samples did not present an identifiable odor. Analysis Based on the observations collected at the residence, the interview with Dr. Shakoor, and the laboratory results, it is concluded that abnormal characteristics of the metals exist in the coils of the AHUs and the electricity distribution system in the residence. Based on our evidence, it appears that the source for chemical elements to participate in such reaction is in the gypsum drywall used to construct a portion- of the interior of the residence. Some of the gypsum drywall was reportedly imported from China. The ceiling drywall had an unknown manufacturer's stenciling. The drywall used to clad some of the interior walls was labeled as sag resistant. Sag resistant gypsum board is a US patented product, number 3853689, and generally it is manufactured in the USA. The outdoor air and building moisture sources were noted as possible sources of gases causing the sulfur -like odor in the home. High sulfur shallow well water of the residence was found, but there was no evidence of sulfur gases from this water entering the home. There was no evidence of any indoor combustion process such as stove flames, or homeowner's report of any surrounding fire event in the neighborhood. 0 Visual inspection of the water points of use indicated no evidence of leaks, or any significant building moisture sources such as plumbing or roof leaks intruding into the house. The tap water in .the home did not emit sulfur -like odors,. only the 'exterior shallow well water used for landscaping. The reported sulfur -like odor in the residence appeared to be off -gassing of sulfurous gases from Chinese drywall. The darkening of the copper evaporator coils in the AHUs was caused by reaction with these sulfurous gases from the Chinese drywall. Ff4k't September 11, 2009 Page 9 RCG File No. 4145038 Section V BASIS OF REPORT 1. An on -site inspection of the Shakoor residence was performed by Ben J. Teague, P.E. on July 13, 2009. 2. Ben J. Teague, P.E., interviewed Dr. Shakoor, the owner. 3. Ben J. Teague, P.E., collected a sample from the copper evaporator coils in the AHU and a bulk sample of gypsum board in the downstairs stairwell of the residence. 4. Mr. Michael B. Stevens, Esq. of Derrevere, Hawkens & Black sent two bulk drywall samples to the Rimkus office for additional laboratoryt testing on August 25, 2009. Laboratory results were reported from Dixie Services, Inc. on 26 August 2009. 5. Ben J. Teague, P.E., and Dan Bridge, Ph.D., CIH, CEP reviewed laboratory results received from EMSL Analytical and Dixie Services Labs. 6. Measurements and photographs were taken and reviewed by Ben J. Teague, P.E. 7. American Industrial Hygiene Association, Odor Thresholds for Chemicals with b A Established Occupational Health Standards 1989. 8. Handbook of Environmental Data on Organic Chemicals, 2nd Ed. 1983. 9. A review of St Lucie County Property Appraiser records retrieved on August 5, 2009, from http•//www.stiucieco.co/web/detail. l._,}�Y"�'lr>%�f .r�i� fir. "i, F .. f' L"-., l ffjC'ritt 5(3 3�/ t� ��If" a�,i,�� t�i i�ti"�' F�i �� r i�r Y; � ,C• - �'�.i 7iVv#'�'..0 j It � 1, 11 �=fsr� � e. 4,r i' ,� ., .� ,, d• - � try ��.�f,i, xbt'�r'w`"J .'" �'', k fr �. '! � ias t- R �l r�y, %fix r,..� ati' °. k� .e„t s t e f trr.._r •� F:�:��.9�:.C.7+i✓.£�. a�� S.Li1...S;.._:-,. _:..�C`!'�i'A CG ...,:.�..' {:..�!..,.ei.:.�.��'s.,.,•....�..>_..<.'_..s...r_t}._......_. ... _..rt.Y,.�i. .ns-�._.. f,. s. _.. _.... _ _.. ;. _.......T._t.......:. September 11, 2009 Page 10 RCG File No. 4145038 1 - Section VI ATTACHMENTS - A. Photographs B. Laboratory Test Results and Chain of Custody C. CVs �y,,7 •Pi J��Y�1 J� IIfI�V�'^jHr 1lSYyi ni(�� r ,s,-f %n � i � J�.�1 }'li l Yf li�! )l ( TY: 11.1..`Kf TtY Sj''! t ��'!� �� September 11, 2009 Page 11 RCG File No. 4145038 Section VI ATTACHMENT A w Photographs Photographs taken during our inspection, which were not included in this report, were retained in our files and are available to you upon request. qvQi ". September 11, 2009 RCG File No. 4145038