Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCarter, L C & WesleyBOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION£RS July 15, 1988 DCVCLOPMCNT DIRCCTOR Mr. Charles L. Hendley Agent for L. C. and Wesley Carter 1500 Delaware Avenue Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 Dear Mr. Hendley: This letter is to confirm that on June 2~ County Board of County Commissioners denJ and Wesley Carter for a change in zoning Single Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Resid~ 11 du/ac) for property located 150 ft. n( ft. east of North 25th Street. A copy of recorded Resolution No. 88-199 in format ion. Sincerely, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Jack Krieger, Chairman dcm Enclosure HAVERT L. FENN, District No. t · JUDY CULPEPPER, District No. 2 · JACK KRIEGER, District No. 3 Coun~ Administrator - WELDON B. L 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 34982-565; Director: Ext. 398 · Building: Ext. 344 · Planning: Ext. 316 · Zonin 1988 the St. Lucie ed the petition of L.C. from RS-4 (Residential, ntial, Multiple Family - ~rth of Avenue Q, 1300 is enclosed for your · Pt- DALE TREFELNER. District .No. 4 · JIM MINIX, District No. 5 EW1S , · Phone (407) 466-1100 g: Ext. 344 · Code Enforcement: Ext. 294 RESOLOTIONNO. SS-Z9§~O; FILE NO.: RZ-88-015 A RESOLUTION DENYING A PROPOSED C ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF CERTAIN ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORI WHEREAS, the Board of County Commis County, Florida, has made the following der MANGE IN THE OPER'I~/ IN ~ioners of St. Lucie erminations: 1. L. C. & Wesle~ Carter presented a petition for a change in zoning from RS-4 (Residential, Single Family - 4 du/ac) to RM- 1! (Residential, Multiple Family - 11 du,'ac) for the property -described as follows: FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE ~1/4 OF THE ~ 1/a RUN NORTH 150 FEET FOR THE PO~T OF BEGINNING, THENCE C_ONTINUENO~TH 136 FEET, THENCE 200 FEET, THENCE ]EGINNING; ALL OF RA~NGE 40~, SI. LL'CIE ft. ens~ of N. 25_th ~-EAST 300 FF~ET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE EAS? SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POINT OF WHICH LAND LS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TO~SHIP 35S COUNTY~ FLORIDA. (Location: 150 ft. north of A~emue Q, 1300 2. The St. Lucie County P&anning a held a public hearing on the petition, afte least fifteen (15) days prior to the hea: mail owners of property within five hundr~ subject property, and has recommended fha hereinafter described request for change in Single Family Family - 11 du/~ from RS-4 (Residential, (Residential, -Multiple described above. 3. On June 28, 1988, this Board hel( the petition, after publishing a notice oJ Fort Pierce News Tribune on June 8, 1988, ~d ~orcing COmmission, ~ ,publishing notice at Ting and notifying by .~d feet (500') of- the t the Board deny the zoning classification 4 du/ac) to RM-11 ) for the property a public hearing on  uch hearing in the notifying by mail OR ~ A~TEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE cOUNTY. FLORIDA ~RREC~NESS: 593 ~1755 RS-4 RM-11 I U R-3 - BLUE PURPLE ORANGE GREEN - B~(DWN (FT, PIERCE) 4- 55-40 ®! PETITION OF L.C. CARTER & WESLEY ~CARTER BY A~ENT: CHARLES L. H~NDLE~Y FOR A CHiANGE IN ZONING CLASSIFIOATION FROM RS-4 TO RM-11 RM - BLUE SCHOOL - ORANGE (FT, PIERCE) RL - GREEN (FT. PIERCE) 4- RM F' PETITION OF L.C. CARTER & BY AGENT: CHARLES L. FOR A CHANGE IN ZONING C FROM RS-4 TO RM- LEY CARTER NDLEY IFICATION Date: June 28, 1988 Tape: #1 - #3 Commissioners Present: Havert L. Fenn; Oudy Culpepper; 3im Mini~ BOARD OF COUNTY COMMIS I Ni~~ ST. LUCIE COUNTY~ ~ REGULAR MEETIN~_.~ convened: '9:15 a.m. Chairman Oack ; Krieger Vice-Chairman ~; R. Dale Trefelner Others Present: Weldon Lewis, Count Storey, Assistant County Attorney; Development Director; Dennis Murphy, Susan Broom, Library Director; Rick Uts Pat Clute, Personnel Director; Walter Sm Sheriff's Office; Jane C. Marsh, Deputy Administrator; Krista ~ry Virta, Community anning Administrator; Purchasing Director; and Lauran Hazellief, rk (c) L. C. and Wesley Carter Reference was made to memorandum from addressed to the Board, dated June 24, L. C. and Wesley Carter, (by Agent: Change in Zoning from RS-4 (Residential / to PM-11 (Residential, Multiple Family / \/ The following were present to speak to Francenta Mims, Kayte E. Simpson, Reba and Charles Hendtey, on behalf of the pe Com. Fenn reminded the Board this is recently being discussed in regard to 17th Street and 21st Street. Com. Fenn problem that needs to be considered is t egress, since there is not a dedicated r at the present time; also, the 8card was Utilities Authority/City of Fort Pierce to that area unless there is an agreemen It was moved by Com. Fenn, seconded b . Resolution No. 88-199, based on the c and, upon roll call, motion carried unan lanning Administrator, 8, subject "Petition of les L. Hendley) for a ingle Family - 4 du/ac) i du/ac)". s issue: .. .. swell, Clarence-Olrden, tioners. e same area that was ving of Avenue Q from so stated that another matter of ingress and~ dway into ~hat property dvised that Fort Pierce s denied water service to annex into the City. Minix!, to deny outlined above; COMMISSION REVIEW: JUNE 28, 1988 TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: AGENDA ITEM: 12 - FILE NO.: RZ-88-( RESOLUTION NO.: RZ-I MEMO RAND County Administrator County Commission Planning Administrator June 24, 1988 199 Petition of L. C. and esley Carter, (by Agent: Charles L. Hendley) fo] a Change in Zoning from RS-4 (Residential, Singl ~Family - 4 du/ac) to RM- 11 (Residential, MultiPlelFamily - 11 du/ac) On Tuesday, June 28, 1988, you will be asked to review a petition on behalf of L. C. and Carter for a change in zoning from RS - 4 to RM - 11 for located]approximately 150 feet north of Avenue Q, along east side of North 21st Street. On Thursday, May 26, 1988, the St. ucie County Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearin~ on this matter and voted unanimously to-forward this per'rioS to the Board of County Commissioners with a recommendation ofld~nial. Staff concurs with this recommendation in that if grantgd, this change in zoning would represent a spot zoning pqtentiatly permittihg an incompatible use of land within· an otherwise homogeneousi area. Attached you will find a copy of t~e_original s~aff report on this matter and the minutes of the Pla~n~ng and Zoning Commission meeting. Consistent with Board polic~,attached you will find a copy of Draft Resolution No. 88-199, w~ich would grant approval to thiS proposed change in zoning. How~r, both CoUnty staff and the Planning and Zoning Commission commend denial of Draft Resolution 88-199. June 9.4, 1988 Page 2 L. C. & Wesley Carter RZ-88-015 If you have any questions know. matter, please let us CONCURRENCE: Terry L./Virt-a Development Director ~Daniel S~ McIntyre County Attorney DJM/DS/meg CARTER2(DiO) cc: Asst. Co. Admin. - Kindred County Attorney Charles Hendley Commission Secretary Press/Public AGENDA - BOARD'o~ COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Petition of L. C. and Wesley Cart Hendley, for a change in zoning from Family- 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residenti du/ac) for the following described pfc FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE I/& OF '~ FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE CON'~ EAST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENC! SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POI~ WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSH] COUNTY ~ FLORIDA. (Location: 150 ft. north of Avenue Q, Street ) If it becomes necessary, these pu contihued from time to time. Please note that all proceedings Commissioners are electronically recor to appeal any decision made by the Boa with respect to any matter considered he will need a record of the proceedin purpose, he may need to ensure that a proceedings is made, which record incl evidence upon which the appeal is To b of any party to the proceeding, indivi hearing will be sworn in. Any party t granted an opportunity to cross-examin during a hearing upon request. Prior to this public hearing, not all adjacent property owners June 7, 1 published in the News Tribune, a newsp in St. Lucie County, on June 8, 1988. B( S' TUk AY JUN~ 28, 19~8 1:30 P.M. er, by Agent: Charles L. S-4 (Residential, Single 1, Multiple Family - 11 perty: HE NW I/4 RUN NORTH 150 INUE NORTH 136 FEET%~HENCE E~ST 200 ~EET, THENCE T OF BEGINNING; ALL OF P 35S, RA~NGE" 40E, ST. LUCIE 1300 ft. east of N. 25th blic hearings may be before the Board of County ~ed. If a person decides rd of County Co~missioners mt such meeting or hearing, gS, and that, for such ~erbatim record of the a~es the testimony and based. Upon the request R~als testifying during a the proceeding will be any individual testifying ce of the same was sent to )88. Legal notice was of general circulation OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Jack Krieger, Chairman NO. RZ-88=015 PLANNING AND ZONING LOCAL PLANNING ST. LUCIE COUNTY, Ft MINUTES BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Mabel Fawsett Sciturro, Patricia King, Robert Carma Russakis, and Ralph Flowers. BOARD MEMBERS ABSENT: J. P. Terpening OTHERS PRESENT: Krista Storey, Assistan Virta, Community Development Director; Administrator; Donna Scanlon, Assistant Assistant Planner; and Dolores Messer D~MISSION 3ENCY ,ORIDA PRESS ATTENDANCE: None. TAPES: 1, 2o & 3 DATE OF HEARING: MAY 26, 1988 TIME: 7:00 P.M. PUBLIC }{EARING: Petition of L.C. and Wesley Carter, by for a change in zoning from RS-4 (Resi~ du/ac) to RM-!i (Residential, Multiple property located approximately 150 ft. the east side of North 21st Street. Mr. Charles Hendley presented the peri- project would nor have an effect on thc mentioned there is a housing shortage There was no public comment in favor o atricia Ferrick, Joseph Jo Ann Allen, Jim excused, conflicT. t County Attorney; Terrv ennis J. MurDhy,~ . Plannin~ Planner; Roy Skorzewsk~ Secretary. Agent: Charles L. Hendiey, eNtial, Single Family - 4 Family - 1! du/ac) for north of Avenue Q, aton9 i~n. Mr. Hendley said nvironment. He also n that area. :he petition. Mr. Bob Mimms, a resident for 24 years gave the Board a petition with 90 sign~ concerns involved a possible decrease _increase in crime. The long term home area are in opposition to the change i that multi-family units would cause mo~ the residents would be short-term. He his neighborhood to remain close-knit, dents. .He felt the element of resid'en units couJd threaten the existing safe atmosphere. Mrs. Reba Carswell expressed her desir~ he, mc~, ~o remain quiet. She ..:c;:~e Lq; ~arden City Elementary Scho~.l 21st St. and Avenue P, ~res in opposmtion. The property value and an ]ers that live in the :onmng. Mrk Mimms felt dmsturbance, and that [pressed his desire for ~_ngle family unit res~- iving in multi-fami!v secure neighborhood [or the subject ne~ghboF-- st]b if~ct [)F¢~r~e ~ L ,., S M~. }{endiey felt that the assumption that all mu!ti-family dwell- ~ .Lnco~LrecL . ~]e ~g units become slum or drug infested a~eas ~'- ~ ~ ~ owners of the project will screen possible renters. Mr. Russakis determined tha~ the propose9 project could have approximately 24 units. / / Regarding S~aff comments, Mr. Murphy s%i~ Staff recom3nended against the requested change in zoning_ Although it is consms- tent with the land use plan, eva!uatio~ Of it regarding the Standards within the GMPP find Policie~ 23 and 28 inconsistent The proposed rezoning could be considere~ a spot zonmng wz~nzn an otherwise homogeneous area consisting cf single family homes. ~ . fro, Mr. Murphy rep] ied In response to quest±oninc by Mr Scit that Lot 9 on the overview is zoned In t%tutional and is utilized as a cemetary. v~r of or in opposition to .s~d the public portion ,cf Hearing no further public comment ~n f the petition, Vice Chairman Fawsett c!c the hearing. After considering the testimony present lng, including Staff comments, and the in Sect ion 5.3.300, sro Lucie County Z¢ made a motion that the Planning and Zo; that the St. Lucie County Board of Cou~ petition of L.C. and Wesley Carter for RS-4 (Residential, Single Family - 4 d tiai, Multiple Family- il du/ac) beca zoning and is inconsistent with Polici( Mr. Russakis seconded the motion, and ~ voted unanimously in favor of the mot~.~ Vice Chaizman Fawsett informed the pet. petition will be forwarded to the Boar< with a recommendation of denial. e( during the pubt~c hear- Si andaPds of Review as set n~.ng Ordinance, Mr. Carman i~g Commission recommend tlr Commissioners deny change in zonina front a 'ac) to RM-!i (Resid~en- s~.~ it would represen~ spot. s #23 and #28 of the GMPP. p,)n roll call, the Board n t loner's agent that the pf Coun[y Commissioners TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: M E M O R AN E Planning and Zoning Co~ .Planning Administrator May 19, 1988 Petition of L. C. and Charles L. Hendley) RS-4 (Residential, 11 (Residential, Multi Agenda Item: File Number: # 2 RZ-88-015 U M Carter (by Agent: a Change in Zoning from Family - 4 du/ac) to RM- Family - 11 du/ac) LOCATION: EXISTING ZONING: PROPOSED ZONING EXISTING LAND USE PARCEL SIZE: PROPOSED'USE: SURROUNDING ZONING: SURROUNDING LAND USE: FIRE/EMS PROTECTION: Approximatel, along the Street. RS-4 (Resi du/ac) RM-11 (Reside 11 du/ac) RM (Medium Development) 2.25 acres To construct' development. St. Lucie Cou City of Ft. P Primarily the south an west is the School and t cemetery. Ft. Pierce approximately 50 ft. north of Avenue Q, ;t side of North 21st ial, Single Family - 4 ~ntial, Multiple Family - Density _ Residential multi-family residential ,: RM-11, ~S-4, I & U : R-3 family residences to east. Directly to the ~rden City Elementary the north is a private Ltral Fire Station .5 miles awiay. is May 19, 1988 Page 2 WATER/SEWER SERVICE: Petit File Water and Sew in this area. ion: No.: Carter, L.C. & Wesley RZ-88-015 mr facilities are available STANDARDS FOR In reviewing this application Official Zoning Atlas, the Planning consider and make the following amendment to the Zoning Commission shall me Whether the proposed any applicable portions The proposed change opposed to either the Lucie County Ordinance. is in conflict with this Ordinance; :oning is not generally .rit or intent of the St. e Whether the proposed all elements of the Management Policy Plan; The proposed change consistent with the Policies of the St. Luc Policy Plan. Whether and the exter amen~ent is incon~l~ proposed land ~ses; The proposed change in the future land use ma' in the St. Lucie Couni is consistent with ;. Lucie County Growth zoning is generally ~esidentiall Development County GroWth Management ~t to which the proposed 3tent with existing and zoning is consistent with ss for this area contained iy Growth Management Policy Plan. en Whether there have ~e changed require an amendment, / There does not appear t0 be any $~ in the character of theimmediate support the increase i this property. conditions that any significant change area that would developmen~ intensity on May 19, 1988 Page 3 Carter, L.C. & Wesley Peti$ign: File No.: RZ-88-01§ Whether and the amendment would facilities, and the proposed amendment of such public limited to facilities, water schools, and emergenc~ The proposed an excessive demand on area. to which the proposed in demands on public to the extent to which exceed the capacity .es, including but not .on facilities, sewage )1¥, parks, drainage, facilities; not expected to create ic facilities in this 6. Whether and the amendment would resul impacts on the natural The proposed rezoning i any adverse impacts on this area. Staff is environmental to which the proposed in significant adverse anticipated to create natural environment in aware Of any unique ics on this site. Whether and the amendment would result ~svelopment pattern, negative effects on The proposed amendmeD' with future land use Growth Management Polit would establish an family development single family use. Whether the proposed conflict with the harmony with the Ordinance; and The proposed rezoning conflict with the pub2 due to its possible zone in an otherwise to which the proposed an orderly and logical identifying any pattern; generalll¥ consistent of the $~. Lucie County' Plan for~his area, but ated pockelt of multiple an area o~ predominate amendment would be in ic interest, and is in ~e and interest of this can be considered in interest in this area, Leration as a "spot" ~neous area. Suggested motion to approve/deny this change in zoning MOTION TO APPROVE: AFTER CONSIDERING THE TESTIMONY HEARING, INCLUDING STAFF COMME REVIEW AS SET IN SECTION 5.3.30 ORDINANCE, I HEREBY MOVE THAT COMMISSION RECOMMEND TO THE S' COUNTY COMMISSIONERS GRANT APPR( C. AND WESLEY CARTER-FOR A 'CH (RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE FAMILY 4 D~ MULTIPLE FAMILY 11 DU/AC). MOTION TO DENY: AFTER CONSIDERING THE TESTIMONY HEARING, INCLUDING STAFF COMME REVIEW AS SET IN SECTION 5.3~30 ORDINANCE, I HEREBY 'MOVE THAT COMMISSION RECOMMEND THAT THE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DENY THE P CARTER FOR A CHANGE IN ZONING SINGLE FAMILY - 4 DU/AC) TO R~ FAMILY 11 DU/AC) BECAUSE; (Re ENTED DURING THE PUBLIC AND THE STANDARDS OF 3, ST. LUCIE COUNTY ZONING THE PLANNING AND ZONING . LUCIE COUNTY BOARD OF To TITION .NGE IN ZONING FROM RS-4 ~/AC) TO ~-1~ (RESIDENTIAL ~RESENTED DURING THE PUBLIC ~TS, AND THE! STANDARDS OF ~, ST~ LUCIE COUNTY ZONING THE PLANNING AND ZONING ;T. LUCIE COUNTY BOARD OF ZTITION OF L.C. AND WESLEY FROM RS-4 [(RESIDENTIAL, -11 (RESIDENTIAL, ~JLTIPLE ~fer Comments~ May 19, 1988 Petit Page 4 File COMMENTS The petitioners are proposing to dE for multiple family uses. As mentioned is classified under the County's for medium intensity development uses. surrounding areas, the existing family homes. The introduction of a at this time on a isolated parcel· to a primar~ roadway, could be zoning. The current property themselves to a logical expansion of Citing the potential of incomp inconsistency with Policies #23 and Growth Management Policy Plan, petition be forwarded to the Board of recommendation of denial. Attached you will find a copy of in forwarding this petition to the If you have any questions on this know. ion: Carter, L.C. & Wesley No.: RZ-88-0t5 ~velop the subject property the subject property Management Policy-Plan in review of the use is detached single :iple family designation, County standard access an application of spot ohs and uses do not lend zoning district. ible Uses and specific of the St. Lucia County :ommends that this CommisSioners with a ~le motions for your use of County Commissioners. please let m~ office DJM/DS/mg~ CARTERI(DS) County Attorne~ Charles L. Hendle¥ ~AGENDA - PLAd~NING ~D ZONING CO~ISSION Petition of L. C. and Wesley Carter, Hendley for a change in zoning from RS-4 Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residential, du/ac) for the following described FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE 1/4 OF FEET FOR~THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE CONTIi EAST 300 FEET, T~ENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POINT WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP COUNTY, FLORIDA. (Location: 150 ft. north of Avenue Q, 130 Street. ) Please note that all proceedings befo: Zoning Commission are electronically reco: cides to appeal any decision made by the Com~aission with respect to any matter con or hearing, he will need a record of the for such purpose, he may need to ensure t the proceedings is made, which record inc2 evidence upon which the appeal is to base( any party to the proceeding, individuais hearing will be sworn in l Any party to t granted an opportunity to cross-examine ar during a hearing upon request. Prior to this public hearing, notice all adjacent property owners May 4, 1988. published in the News Tribune, a newspape in St. Lucie County, on May 5, 1988. FII THU~. 3AY MAY '~6, 1988 7:00 P.M. by Agent: Charles L. (Residential,i Single Multiple Family - 11 1/4 RUN NORTH 150 NORTH 136 FEET, THENCE 200 FEET, THENCE BEGINNING; ALL OF RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE ft. east of N. 25th e the Planning and .-de.d. If a person de- ~lanning and Zoning ~idered at suCh meeting ;roceedings, and that, ~at a verbatim record of .udes the testimony and . Upon the request of estifying during.a ~e. proceeding will be ~y individual testifying f the same was sent to Leqal_ notice was of general Circulation E NO. RZ-88-O15 U - G'~cE N R- 3 - BROWN PIERCE 4-55-40' il I AVENUE Z PETITION OF L,C, CARTER BY AGENT: CHARLES FOR A CHANGE IN ZONING FROM RS-4 TO & WESLEY CARTER HENDLEY ASSIFICATiON Ii SCHOOL RL ORANGE (FT. PiERCE~ - GREEN (FT. PIERCE) R P N. 25 PETITION OF L.C. CARTER & BY AGENT: CHARLES L FOR A CHANGE IN ZONING C FROM RS-4 TO RM ~SLEY CARTER !ENDLEY ;StFICATION 1 Charles l,. Hcndlov 1500 Delaware Ave. Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 ~arold & Mae Holtsbe~g .. Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 i~'o s 1 ~.,v Car~ ~r 106-3] 155 .~t'ree Jamaica, NY 331 OTHER PROPERTY ~ 4 6 Ft. Pierce Utilii P.O.'Box 3191 Ft. Pierce, FL 7 Kenneth Drummond 1204 N. 25 St. F't. Pierce, FL 3,4947 American Legion c/o 'Sherman L. Th< 1706 N. 15 St. ERS NOTIFIED ils Auth. 4 48 #171 3, 5 School Board of SLC 2909 Delaware Ave. Ft. Pierce, FL 34~47 9 Sarah's Memorial Garda:n% 728 Avenue D Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 12 - ]Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 Rheute!ia C. Oliver t400 N. 22 St. Birmingham, AL 35234 16 Lottie Carter Joyce Williams 2530 Seltzer St. Philadelphia, PA 19132 19 Leroy & Cynthia Matthews Christine Tucker (EST) 1910 Ave. Q Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 Ft. Pierce, FL 34! -i,4, 20 -Charles & Ethel-Mat Christine Tucker ) 2006 Ave. Q Ft. Pierce, FL ~'49}0 17 Vernon Dixon 2221 Juanita Ave. Ft. Pierce, FL 349. 21 Wil/a M. Tucker Christine Tucker (ES 1810 Ave. Q Ft. Pierce, FL 3495 2006 Ave, Q Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 15 - George & ..Dorothy Walker 2002 Ave. Q Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 18 Gwendolyn Matthews Christine Tucker (EST) 2006 ~Aveo Q Ft. ?lerce, FL 34950 RooseveJ t Hat!on 9808 Empir~ Avo. Cleveland, OH 441ils 2 '~, _ 4, 26 .... '25 Hal lie M. Houston P.O. Box 683 Cocoa, FL 34923. Claud C. >lar!on P.O. Box 399 Princess Ann~, 28 29 I109 Ave, E Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 P.O. ~Box 673 Ft. Pierce, >7 City Roads City of Ft. Pierce 500 Boston Ave. Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 oc ]433 609 00[! 000i5 oo FT ~Pt'ERCE, Ft ~1~ N ~? ST ~ P~E~CE~ FL 34~47-~61~ ~O~F~TS~ R&~Y L 2404 eO~ OOZ2 00015 GO : THOI"P SON~ wlCI [' 2~0~ cog LAUCE~D~LE~ FL 3~11-2867~": h~ ........... f ...... ~ .... 0~ 00~/7 O0 :~ 2~04 609 0~ 001~ CO 0035 O00J9 OO '~, 2~0. ~q 0036 OI CO : ~ FT ¢l~Cf~ F! ~-20e7 2~C4 ~Oq GCC~ CCC/] FCSELY, GEC~GE £ %P~EPt, F FT PIERCE, FL 24~50-2Cq~ ~IC3 ~¥ o F? PI~cE~ FL CCI? CCC/7 0021 CCC/8 2~04 60~ CC24 COCiq cc I: OC Z~O~ eO~ 2¢0~ 60q Oe4 :00/~ DO ' 2005 ~V P FT ~Z~CE, ~[ 3~Q5%-ZO03 ?¢C~ 6~3 CC~ 00018 O0 FT rIFPCF~ ~{ )4~50-?006 FT FTI~CF,'Ft ?~¢ ) F1C3 ~ 17 ~T ~ILLT~c, iA)ICE ~LBFKT '' t~;c¢ AY - f? O0 . 2~C~ ~lO 00~7 COOl4 C~ C3 CF F~C4 (:]3 CC?? CCC/~ CCC/2 OF CERTAIN PROPERTY IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY. FLORIDA WHEREAS, the Board of County/ issioners of St. Lucia County, Florida, has made the foll~ ~ations: 1. L. Co and Wesley Carter, p ~sented a petition for a change in zoning from RS-4 (Residential Single Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residential, Multiple Family 11 du/ac). 2. The St. Lucia County Planni held a public hearing on the petition, least fifteen (15) days prior to the mail owners of property within five h sub3ect property, and has recommended hereinafter described request for from RS-4 (Residential, Single Fami. (Residential, Multiple Family - 11 described below. and Zoning Commission, publishing notice at ~aring and notifying by feet (500') of the the Board de~ the .n zoning classification - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 ) for the property 3. On June 28, 1988, this Board ~ld a public hearing on the petition, after publishing a notic~of such hearing in the Fort Pierce News Tribune on June 8, 1988, and notifying by mail all owners of property within 500 feet o~ the sub3ect property. 4. The proposed zoning change is Lucia County Growth Management Policy P1 standards of review set out in Section County Zoning Ordinance. NOW. THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED k Commissioners of St. Lucia County, Florid A. The Zoning Classification for th follows: FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE I/40F~THE 1 FEET FOR T~E POINT OF BEGINNING, T~ENCE CONTiNUI F~%ST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE EA~ SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 509 FEET TO POINT O} WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4 TOWNSHIP 3~ COUNTY, FLORIDA. ' (Location: 150 ft. north of Avenue Q 130 Street ) · c9nsistent with the St. a~_ and has satisfied the 5.3.300 of the St. Lucie F the Board of County a: ~t property described as w 1//~ RUN NORTH i50 ~ORTH 136 FEET, THENCE ;. RA~'~GE 40E, S;T, LUCIE ft. east of N. 25th owned by L. C. and Wesley Carter, changed from RS-4 (Residential, Sine (Residential~ Multiple Family - 11 du B. The St. Lucie County Commun hereby authorized and directed to caus the Official Zoning Map of St. Lucie notation of reference to the date of a~ · After motion and second, the vot follows: and the same is hereby, ly - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 ). Development Director is changes to be made on Florida, and to make of this resolution. this resolution was as Chairman Jack Krieger Vice-Chairman Havert L. Fenn Commissioner R. Dale Trefeln, Commissioner Judy Culpepper Commissioner Jim Minix XX XX XX XX XX PASSED A~D DULY ADOPTED this 28th of June, 1988. ATTEST: ATTEST: BOARD ST. BY: COMMISSIONERS COUNTY, FLORIDA TO FORM AND : ATTORNEY AGENDA - BOARD OF COUN~Y COMMISSIONERS T~ JUl 1.- Petition of L. C. and Wesley Carter, Hendley, for a change in zoning from RS-4 Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residential, M du/ac)~ for. the following described propert FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE 1/4 OF THE N% FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE CONTINUE EAST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE EAS1 SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POINT OF WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 35. ESDAY {E 28, I9~8 3OP.M. o~Agent: Charles L. (Residential, Single ultiple Family - ll- i i/4 RUN NORTH 150 NORTHT- 136 FEET, THENCE ., RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA. - ' (Location: 150 ft. north of Avenue Q, 130< Street ) If it becomes necessary, these public continued from time to time. Please note that all proceedings bef< Commissioners are electronically recorded to appeal any decision made by the Board with respect to any matter considered at he will need a record of the'proceedings, purpose, he may need to ensure that a vet! proceedings is made, which record include evidence upon which the appeal is to be b of any party to the proceeding, individua hearing will be sworn in. Any party to t granted an opportunity to cross-examine a during a hearing upon request. Prior to this public hearing, notice all adjacent property owners June 7, 1988 published in the News Tribune, a news in St. Lucie County, on June 8, 1988. ST. /s/ ft. east of N. 25th hearings may be re the Board of County If a person decides f County Commissioners uch meeting or hearing, n a d that, for such )atim record of the the testimony and 5sed. Upon t~he request ls testifying during a h~ proceeding will be ny individual testifying of the same was sent to · Legal notice was of general circulation OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY FLORIDA cck Krieger! Chairman RZ-88-015 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION(ERS June 7, 198.8 In compliance with the provisions of the Or.dinance you are hereby advised that L. Agent: Charles L. Hendley, have petitione, Commissioners for a change in zoning from Single Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residel - 11 du/ac) for the following described pi FROM "THE R 6F' TH'E~ NE' 1/4 OF THE FEET FOR THE POINT THENCE CONTIN EAST'300-FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE E SOU~H 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POINT WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP COUN_TY~ FLORIDA_, (Location: 150 ft. n~orth of Avenue Q, 130£ Street ) The Board of County Commissioners will ho] this petition at 1:30 P.M. on Tuesday, Jut St. Lucie County Administration Building, Fort Pierce, Florida. All interested pert opportunity to be heard at that time. The erect multi-family dwelling units. Please note that all proceedings before t~ Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florid recorded. If a person decides to appeal Board of County Commissioners with respect sidered at such meeting or hearing, he wi proceedings, and that, for such purpose, ~ that a verbatim record of the proceedings includes the testimony and evidence upon ~ be based. Upon the request of any party t individuals testifying during a hearing wi party to the proceeding will be granted an examine any individual testifying during a If it becomes necessary, these public hear from time to time. If you no longer own property adjacent to parcel, please forward this notice to the should have any questions, additional info by calling Area Code 305, 466-1100, Extens Sincerely· BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST.~L~U~C/E ~O~NTY, ~qRIDA Jack Krieger, ~hairman FIL HAVERT L. FENN, District No. I · JUDY CULPEPPER District No. 2 · JACK KRIEGER. District No. 3 · R. County Administrator - WELDON B. LEWIS 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 34982-5652 · P Director: Ext. 398 · Building: Ext. 344 · Planning: Ext..316 · Zoning: E~ D6V LOPM6NT DIR6CTOR Lucie County Zoning and Wesley Carter· by he Board of County '.-4 (Residential, Lal, Multiple Family )erty: NW 1/4 RUN NORTH 150 UE NORTH 136 FEET, THENCE ~ST 200 FEET, THENCE DF BEGINNING; ALL OF ~, RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE ft. east of N. 25th d a public hearing on .e 28, 1988 in Room 101, 2300 Virginia Avenue, ons will be given an petitioners wish to s Board of County · are electronically ny decision made by the to any matter con- 1 need a record of the e may need to ensure is made, which record hich the appeal is to o the proceeding, 11 be sworn in. Any pportunity to cross- earing upon request. ings may be continued the above-described new owner. If you rmation may be obtained ion 344/41. NO. RZ-88-015 )n~~LI IREFELNER,(407) 466District11N°'0~4 · JIM MINIX, District No. 5 23, 24, 26 Hallie M. Houston P.O. Box 683 Cocoa, FL 34923 28 Robert & Inez Lawrence 1109 Ave. E Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 25 Claud Co Marion P.O~ Box 399 Princess Anne, MD 2185 29 E Z E Inc. P.Oi. Box 673 Ft. Pierce~ FL 34954 J~C. Boston 1808 Ave° Q Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 City Roads City of Ft. Pierce 500 BOston Ave. Ft. Pierce~ FL 34950 Charles L. Hendley 1500~ Delaware Ave° Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 1 Harold & Mae Holtsberg ~ River Dr. 805, - Indian Ft~ 'Pierce, FL 34950 ~Ke~r~!eth Drummond 25 st. Fti--, Pierce, FL 34947 Matthews Ave. Q ~ierce, FL 34950 telia C. oliver 0 N. 22 St. 'ham, AL 35234 ~tie Carter Williams Seltzer St. [ladelphia, PA 19132 roy & Cynthia Matthews Tucker (EST) :istine L0 Ave. Q Pierce, FL 34950 pRg~pERTY OWNERS NOTiF A LoC° Carter Wesley Carter 106-21 155 Street Jamaica, NY 33114 OTHER PROPERTY OWNERS N~ 2, 4, 6 Ft. Pierce utilities A P.O. Box 3191 Ft. Pierce, FL 34948 American Legion Post c/o Sherman L. Thomas 1706 N. 15 St° Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 11 Miriam Carter 1810 N. 21 St. Ft. Pierce, FL 3495 14, 20 Charles & Ethel Matt christine Tucker (ES 2006 Ave. Q ° 5 Ft. Pierce, FL 049 17 Vernon Dixon 2221 Juanita Ave. Ft. Pierce, FL 349 21 )TIFIED the '.171 ews T) 0 ~6 witla M. Tucker christine Tucker (SST) 1810 Ave. Q Ft. Pierce, FL 34~50 3, 5 school Board of SLC 2909 Delaware Ave. Ft. Pierce, FL 34947 9 Sarah's Memorial Gardens 728 Avenue D Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 12 L.C. Carter Ethel M. Matthews 2006 Ave. Q Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 15 George & Dorothy Walker 2002 Ave. Q Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 18 Gwendolyn Matthews Christine Tucker (EST) 2~06~Ave. Q FL. Pierce, FL 34950 22 Roosevelt Marion 9808 Empire Ave. Cleveland, OH 44108 2404 60g 0038 OOC;O JENSFN BCH~ Fl 3A957-3754 ~ 2A0% 609 00~1 0001~ ~T pI~RCE~ 2'404 ~tLLIN' 2007 A FT 2404 609 .) 240~ 60g OO~ 000~I ELL~ FT PIER 609 O0 O0 24~~ 609 0039 000/? WOODS~ B~RBARA (ROS) 2002 2404 6Oq 0042 00011 C~RA O0 24CA .~Cg 004C CCC/7 CC FALL~ ROSC~'E ~ EOIE m 20C4 ~V R FT PIERCE, FL 24950-2C67 2404 609 0043 CCO/~ Oe OA¥I~ RUBY__ REED; BARBARA 2010 AY P ~L FT PIER~E~ , ~4950-20~7 FIGGERS, REY ~T PIERCEs FL 34946-1306 2404 609 004~ CCCtO 0C ~MS* JANICE ALBERT P E~ FL ~4g50-2~66 00 ~ FL 34950-2066 FT PIEiRCE~ Ft 34950-2066 2404 610 0027~C00t4 O0 IC~ARO J JR [ ~LEASF ST FL -24950-2026 O0 2404 (10 004~ 00011 )l)MS~ FRANCENIA 2103 ~V ~ 2404 ~13 0027 CCCl3 CO t I(~LIE F O0 I 2A~4 613 00q3 CO011 1~04 N 19 Sl q-'~Fl PIERCEs, FL q~4950-2006 O0 CC 613 OOA, 6 C0012 ~PTIST CHURCH CC O0 t814 O0 C g 8~TTYE J ~xxxxxxx×xxxxxxxx×yx×xxxx) ¥.',xxxxxxxxxxx×xxx××xxxxxx> ,,xx~Xxxxxxx~xxxxxxxx××xxxxxx ixxx~xxxxxxxxxxxXxxxx~xxx×xx ~xxxx~xxxxxxXxx×xxxxxxxxxxxx ~xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx×xxxxxx~x (xxxxx××xxxxxxxxx~×xx×x~xxxx PL FI. ~.L A Mr, XX XXX)~ XXXI(X)~ ×X~)XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX~XX×XX~ '~y~XXXX~XXXX~XXXXXX~×XXXXXXXX~ [X~XXX~XXXXX~XXXXXXXX~XXXXxxxxx~xx~ CC iTOq N 72 ST F? PIE~E~ FL ~g50-2C~1 O0 24C4 609 0008 COOlt CC o© O0 O0 O0 TH~MA$~ MARY ~ (CDNT)j FT PIERCE~ FL 34976-ZCB7 ~4~4 609 2tO&-A¥ P 609 0021 710 N 21 ST CC OC RTA O0 WEBSTER, BESSIE ~O~ SEA,RAPE ~ IERC~, FE 24g82-7132 ~09 0030 C0014 CC CC 609 O0 CC O~S :S O0 ~' 24t n PIERCE~, FL 3~970-Z067 )6 609 0031 C0013 OC HtNGTDN~ ROEYA LINOER PIERCE, FL 34~50-Z067 CC NOTICE NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Board of COunty Commis- sioners in and for St. Lucie County, Florida, on Tuesday, June 28, 1988, in Room 101, St. L' istration Building, 2300 Virginia Avenue, For hold a public hearing on: Petition of L. C. and Wesley Carter, by Hendley, for a change in zoning from RS-4 ( Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residential, Mult du/ac) for the following described property: will at 1:30 P.M. cie County Admin- IPierce, Florida Agent: Charles L. dential, Single le Family- 11 FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE 1/4 OF THE NW ./4 RUN NORTH 150 FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE CONTINUE N~ EAST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE EAST SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POINT OF BI WHI~H LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 35S, COUNTY, FLORIDA .... - ~ (Location: 150 ft. north of Avenue Q, 1300 f~ Street) All interested persons will be given an heard at this time. Please note that all proceedings before Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida, recorded. If a person decides to appeal any Board of County Commissioners with respect t~ sidered at such meeting or hearing, he will proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he that a verbatim record of the proceedings is includes the testimony and evidence upon whi be based. Upon the request of any party to individuals testifying during a hearing will party to the proceeding will be granted an o examine any individual testifying during a h If it becomes necessary, these public b continued from time to time. Dated this 6th day of June, 1988. BOARD OF ST. LUCI~ /s/ Jack PUBLISH: JUNE 8, 1988 )RTH 136 FEET, THENCE !0O FEET, THENCE '~GINNING; ALL OF RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE east of N. 25th opportunity to be the Board of County ire electronically decision made by the any matter con- eed a record of the nay need to ensure made, which record ~h the appeal is to the proceeding, be sworn in. Any pportunity to cross- earing upon earings may COUNTY COMMI~ equest. e ;SIONERS ~OUNTY FLORIDA K~ieger i Chairman We, The undersigned and Avenue To not to be fez may cause a decrease in valu er[me area. We the v6nue 0 r use ult into'a high Lange. · crime a'rea. We ,venue and A ve~ 'crime area; Wet ,.( ~etween Avenue 0 mily use ~ a high We, The Undersigned hereby request that and-Avenue T, not to be rezoned t, may cause a decrease in value of property crime area. We the property OWners protest I area, between `Avenue ,. Multi-family use .to a high and Avenue T, not 1 may cause a decrease in crfrne area~. We the property owners protest' the between A venue'C) Multi-family use into a high We, The undersigned hereby reques~ tha~ o and Avenue T, not ~o be rezoned to multi_famii may cause a decrease in value of crime area, We the r P operty OWners protest~ area, between .Avenue 0 'family use in£o a high e. PLANNING AND ZONING CO~ LOCAL PLANNING AGE ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FI MINUTES BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Mabel Fawsett, Sciturro, Patricia King, Robert Carman, Russakis, and Ralph Flowers. BOARD MEMBERS ABSENT: J. P. Terpening - OTHERS PRESENT: Krista Storey, Assistan Virta, Community Development Director; Administrator; Donna Scanlon, Assistant Assistant Planner; ahd Dolores Messer, PRESS ATTENDANCE: None. TAPES: 1, 2, & 3 DATE OF HEARING: PUBLIC BEARING.- MAY 26, 1988 Petition of L.C~ MISSION NCY ORIDA a~ricia Ferrick, Joseph Jo Ann Allen, Jim excused, conflict. t County Attorney; Terry ennis J. Murphy, Planning Planner; Ray Skorzewski, ecretary. ~ and Wesley Carter, by Agent: Charles L. H~ndley, for a change in zoning from RS-4 (Residential, Single Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residential_ MultiDl~ Family _ 11 du/ac) for property located approximately 150 ft. north of Avenue Q, the east side of North 21st Street. Mr. Charles Hendley presented the petitioni Mr. Hendley said the~'~3'~ pro~ect would not have an effect on the ~nvironment' He also mentioned there is a housing shortage in that area. There was no public comment in favor of petition. Mr. Bob Mimms, a resident for 24 years gave the Board a petition with 90 si( concerns involved a possible decrease in increase in crime. The long term home, area are in opposition to the change in z that multi-family units would cause more the residents would be short-term. He e~ his neighborhood to remain close-knit, dents. He felt the element of residents i units could threaten the existing safe an~ atmosphere. Mrs. Reba Carswell expressed her desire f. hood to remain quiet. She also felt the close_to Garden City Elementary School. Mr. Hendley felt that the assumption that lng units become slum or drug infested ar~ owners of the project will screen possibl~ Mr. Russakis determined that the' proposed approximately 24 units. let St. and Avenue P, s in opposition. The operty value and'an s that live in the lng. Mr. Mimms felt st6rbance, and that eased his desire for le family unit resi- ring in multi-family secure neighborhood the subject neighbor- property is too multi-family dwell- is ~ncorrect. The s. :oject could have Regarding Staff comments, Mr. Murphy said against the requested change in zoning. tent with the land use plan, evaluation Standards within the GMPP find Policies The proposed rezoning could be considered otherwise homogeneous area consisting of In response to questioning by Mr. Scitur ~( that Lot 9 on the overview is zoned Inet as a cemetery. :aff recommended :hough it is consis- .t regarding the 28 inconsistent. spot zoning within an .gle family homes. Mr. Murphy replied ional and is utilized Hearing no further public comment in few the petition, Vice Chairman Fawsett close, the hearing. f or in opposition to he public portion of After considering the testimony presented lng, including Staff comments, and the eta in Section 5.3.300, St. Lucie County Zonin made a motion that the Planning and Zoning that the St. Lucie County Board of County~ petition of L.C. and Wesley Carter for a c] RS-4 (Residential, Single Family - 4 du rial, Multiple Family - 11 du/ac) because zoning and is inconsistent with Policies # Mr. Russakis seconded the motion, and upon voted unanimously in favor of the motion. Fawset~t~i~fbrmed the petiti~ [ be forwarded to the Board of a reCor~mendation. ~.._~of denial.. the public hear- of Review as set ,ce, ~r. ICarman sion r~commend sioners de~y the in zoning f~om to RM-11 (Residen_ would represent spot and #28 of the GMPP. )11 call, the Board "s agent t~at the ,unty C~mmissioners Agenda Item: File Number: # 2 RZ-88-015 MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: LOCATION: EXISTING ZONING: PROPOSED ZONING EXISTING LAND USE PARCEL SIZE: PROPOSED USE: SURROUNDING ZONING: SURROUNDING LAND USE: FIRE/EMS PROTECTION: Planning and Zoning Commission Planning Administrator May 19, 1988 Petition of L. C. and ~ Charles L. Hendley) for RS-4 (Residential, Singl~ 11 (Residential, Multipl~ msley Carter (by Agent: a Change'in Zoning from Pamily - 4 ~u/ac) to RM- Family - 11 du/ac) Approximately 50 ft. north along the ~t side of Street. RS-4 (Resident du/ac) RM-11 (Reside~ 11 du/ac) RM (Medium Development) 2.25 acres To construct~ a development. ial, Single :ial, Multipl Density multi-family of Avenue Q, North 21st Family Family - Residential residential St. Lucie County: RM-11, RS-~, I & U City of Ft. Pierce: R-3 Primarily sing e family residences to the south and Directly to the west is the den City Elementary School and to north is a private cemetery. Ft. Pierce Cen ral Fire Station is approximately 3. miles away. May 19, 1988 Page 2 Petit File WATER/SEWER SERVICE: Water and Sew in this area. STANDARDS FOR R~ In reviewing this application fo~ official zoning AtlaS, the Planning a] consider and make the following determj '3. Whethe~ the proposed amc any applicable portions he p~oposed change in oppose~ to either the st 'LUcie ~ounty Ordinance. Whethei: the proposed amE all el.,merits of the Manage The consiS Polici~ Policyl Whethe: amendm proposE tent Policy Plan; ~oposed change kent with~ thel ~s of the St, Luci Plan. and the ext~ mt~ is inconsi land uses; The pr( posed change in : the future land use maps in th~ St. Lucie County Plan. Whetheril there have been requirei an amendment; T here does not appear to in the i~haracter of the supPortll the increase in this property. Carter, L,C, & Wesley RZ-88-015 ~ri facilities are available ~ proposed amendment to the ~di zoning commission shall .nations: n~ent is~ in conflict with o~ this ordnance; zloning ils ~ot generally ~irit ~r intent of the St. 'ndment isi consistent with ti Luciei C0unt¥ Growth .n zoning i!s generally ~e!sidential Development County Growth Management ~o which the proposed · nt with existing and :oning is consistent with ior this area contained Growth Management Policy Changed !con, litions that be any significant change .~mediate.ares that would development intensity on May 19, 1988 Page 3 e Peti File Whether and the exten amendment would resul facilities, and whether the proposed amendment of such public facili' limited to transporta facilities, water sul schools, and emergency [] :ion: Carter, L.C. & Wesley No.: RZ-88-015 t to which the proposed t in demands on public or to the extent to which ould exceed the capacity ies, including, but not ~ion facilities, sewage )ply, parks, drainage, edical facilities; The proposed developmen~ is not expected to create an excessive demand onpUblic facilities in this area. Whether and the extent ~to which the proposed amendment would result in significant adverse ~vtronment impacts on the natural ~ ; . The proposed rezoning-isnot! anticipated' to create any adVerse impacts on ~he natural environment in this area. Staff is rLot aware of any unique environmental characteri;tics on this site. Whether and the extent amendment would result development pattern, spe negative effects on such The proposed amendment with future land use mapl Growth Management Policy would establish an isol family development in single family use. to which the proposed n an orderly and logical =ifica11¥ identifying any pattern; iS generall~consistent the St. Lucie County lan for this area, but ed pocket of multiple area of predominate Be Whether the proposed conflict with the publ: harmony with the purpos Ordinance; and The proposed rezoning ha conflict with the public due to its possible con~ zone in an otherwise homo~ imendment would be in lc interest, and is in e and interest of this s can be considered in ~interest ih this area, ~i~eration as a "spot" ~eneous area. May 19, 1988 Page 4 COMMENTS Petition: Carter, L.C. & Wesley File No.: RZ-88-015 at this time on a isolated parcel, lack to a pr/mary roadway, could be cons/de: zoning. The current property conftgura~ themselves to a logical expansion of tk citing the potential of incompa inconsistency with Policies #23 and #21 Growth Management Policy Plan, Star petition be forwarded to the Board of ~ recommendation of denial. The petitioners are proposing to develop the sub3ect pro err for multiple family uses. As mention~ -= ........ P Y is classified under the Count~-'s GrA-I~ .... 3 ~ property for = uwun management p medium intensit devel Dman A. _ , olicy Plan Y o=_~_t uses_~uwever, an review of the surrounding areas, the existing dominste use is detached single family homes. The introduction of a multiple family designation, ing County standard access red an application of spot :iOns and uses do not lend is zoning d/strict. tible uses and specific of the St. Lucie County recommends that this )unty Commissioners with a ~ple motions for your use [ f County Commissioners. e~, please let my office Attached you will find a copy of s~ in forwarding this petition to the Boar~ If you have any questions on this mat~ know. DJM/DS/mg CARTERi[DS) cc: County Attorney Charles L. Hendley MEMORAND TO: County Administrator FROM: Planning Administrato]~ DATE: May 25, 1988 SUBJECT: Request for Hearing Date Please place on the agenda for Tuesday, for permission to advertise the followi on the date set forth: BCC HEARING DATE: JUNE 28, 1988 M June 7, 1988, a request g petitions for hearing 1. Petition of William L. Boll for a CDnditional Use Permit to operate a Group Care Home in an AR- (Agricultural, Residential - 1 du/ac) Zoning Distr ct. Petition of L. C. and Wesley Carter, by Agent: Charles L. Rendley, for a change in zoning fro~ RS-4 (ResidEntial, Single Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residential, ~ultipie Family - 11 du/ac). . 3. Petition of Pitch and Putt, Inc. fox a Conditional Use Permit to operate a Go-Cart Track ii a CG (Commercial, General) Zoning District. Petition of Westside Veterans AssocJ in zoning from AR-1 (Agricultural, I (Institutional). Petition of Custom Aviation, a Div~ ation, Inc. for a change lesidential - 1 du/ac) to ion of Coastal Flight Center, for a Major Adjustment to an Approved Conditional Use Permit for construction of a building for aircraft storage in U (Utility) Zoning District. dcm AGENDA - PLANNING AND ZONI~ COMMISSION Petition of L. C. and Wesley Carter, by Hendley for a Change in zoning from RS-4 (Re Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Residential, Mui du/ac) for the following described property: FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE 1/4 OF THE N~ FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE CONTINUE EAST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE EASI SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POINT OF WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 35S COUNTY, FLORIDA. (Location: 150 ft. north of Avenue Q 1300 fi Street. ) ' Please note that all proceedings before Zoning Commission are electronically recorde cides to appeal any decision made by the Plat Commission with respect to any matter consid~ or hearing, .he will need a record of the pro, for such purpose, he may need to ensure that the proceedings is made, which record include evidence upon which the appeal is to based. any party to the proceeding., individuals test hearing will be sworn in. Any party t.o the p: granted an opportunity to cross-examine any ii during a hearing upon request. Prior to this public hearing, notice of tl all adjacent property owners May 4, 1988. Lee published in the News Tribune, a newspaper of in St. Lucie County, on May 5, 1988. FILE N( !HURSDAY '26, 198~' P.M. Agent: Charles L. sident ial, Single NORTH 136 FEET, THENCE 200 FEET, THENCE BEGINNING; ALL OF RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE · east of N. 25th he Planning and If a person de- ling and Zoning red at such meeting eedings, and that, a verbatim record of s the testimony and Jpon the request of [fying during a ~oceeding will be ~dividual testifying Le same was sent to ~al notice was general circulation RZ,88-015 OF COUNTY COMMISSIONCRS ~pril 27, 1988 DCVCLOPMCNT DIRCCTOR Charles L. Hendley Agent for L. C. and Wesley Carter 1500 Delaware Avenue Ft. Pierce, FL 34950 Subject: Posting of Public Notice for Pel Wesley Carter for a change in zoning from Planning and Zoning Commission hearing wi2 The Board of County Commission hearing wiJ 1988. Dear Mr. Hendley: In accordance with the requirements of Se, Lucie County Zoning Ordinance, you are he~ to Room 201, St. Lucie County Administrat Virginia Avenue, Ft. Pierce, Florida, duri ;ition of L. C. and RS-4 to RM-11. The .1 be held May 26, 1988. .1 be held June 28, tion 5.1.100(5), St. eby directed to report on Building, 2300 ng normal business hours to receive the required public notic~ informational signs for the above requested public hearing. T~ese notices are to be conspicuously posted on the subject property. In addition to the above cited signage, yo~ with the appropriate affidavit forms to be Lucie County Planning and Zoning Commissio] ginia Avenue, Room 201, Fro Pierce, Florid~ than five (5) days prior to the scheduled For your reference information, enclosed p Section 5.1.100(5), St. Lucie County Zonin¢ have any questions on this matter, please County Planning and Zoning Secretary at (3 344/41 and reference the file number found Sincerely, Terry Hess Planning and Zoning Director TH/DJM/dcm Enclosure HAVERT L. FENN District No 1 ® JUDY CULPEPPER. District No. 2 · JACK KRIEGER. District No. 3 · R. County AOministrator - WELDON B. LEWIS ] will be furnished submitted to the St. Secretary, 1300 Vir- t, 34982-5652 no later ~earing. .ease find a copy of ~ Ordinance. If you ontact the St. Lucie 5) 466-1100, Ext. below. [LE NO. RZ-88-015 _E TREF£LNER. District No. 4 e JIM MINIX District No..5 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce~ FL 34982-5652 o Phc ne (407) 466-1100 Director: Ext. 398 · Building: Ext. 344 · Planning: Ext. 316 ® Zoning: Ext. 344 · Code Enforcement: Ext. 294 petitioner for an Aaendaent te the County on the following described p : ST. LUCZE COUNTY ' · t FIDAVIT OF p IC NOTICE· Charles L. 'Hendley ' (please print) , do hereby certify that as Official ZOning Atlas of St. Lucia FROM THE SOUTHWEST CORNER'OF THE NE 1/4 FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE EAST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, T SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TO~ COUNTY, FLORIDA. ~operty: OF THE I~ i/~ RUN NOR?H ]50 CONTI~E NOaTH ~36 FEE?, THENCE [ENC~ EAS? 200 YEET~ THENCE POINT OF BEGINNING; ALL OF ~SHIP 35S, RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE I did on May 16 19 8 _, _, erect ~n a conspicuous lace r - P on this p operty the following notice: ~ .. NOTICE / YOu are hereby aOviseO thAe / ~0' tO .:' · u t.. ~u,,z.g czasstrice Y ~~e .f~r re~.lew tn the v~r inia ~v --~,v o,,u &ool~ O~v~ ' __ .g enue, Ft. Pierce. FIO~-- .__,__9 ~lon, 2JOO -ours. - --*---, uu~zng ~0~1 ~usine$~ S~orn and SubscribeO Before me this 16th Day of _May ~,~. State of · ST. L~ · , AFFXDAVZ?'O Petitioner for an Amendment to the County on the following described pi FROH THE SOUTI~ST CORNER OF THE NE CZE COUNTY r PUSLZC NOTZcE Offlcl&l Zoning Atles o? St. Lucle roperty: ' OF THE NI~ 1/4 RUN NORTH 150 FEET.FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING. CONTINUE NORTH 136 FEET, THENCE EAST-300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, EAST 200 FEET. THENCE SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POINT OF BEGINNING; ALL OF ~HICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, -COUNTY, FLORIDA_. 35S. P~GE 40E, ST. LUCIE I did on _/~a¥ 1'6 , 19 this property the followtn9 notice: erect in a conspicuous NOTII You are hereby advised that petitioned C mm ss the St. Luc . lo~.s for a Change la no , cucle Count-~m ' p ~ ,l- Avenue F~. Y ~nistg~. ion Bu P ., la R a ~J~-i,- . Pierce, Florida.~:,_~ 2]00 Vlt~ ~-~.uze ~ot revlee I .~: ueve~onme ~ e ....... n ~,,~ orrllce -uu, Pt. Pierce. FIn ~- ~ff~ng uzvlslon hours ...... Sworn and Subscribed Before me this l~tb. Day of ~a-...~.V_~, 198__8. My Commis. slon Expires: ~!~ary P~,,'bLM g~a~:e o~ ,r-~o?;da at Large ~Y Cor~mlss]on E~-~: es Now t6, 199] J~OJ~ cci .... thrta _Huckleberry_ _ & AssocJat.eA Agent ~ ~ Ch~rle'.~ L. Hendley 1500 Oelaware Avenue Fo~t Rie~cb, FL 34950 (305) 4614840 ST. LUCI£ COUNT Petition for change to the Offi St-. Lucie Cot :zoning on~y: $300 .~ mbined (P,A.& Rez.)$500 ..__ clal Zoning Aries of ~nty Ca~ter / L.C.'Ca~te~ & ldesle Petlt£oneg's Name: ., * Petitioner'S Add~ess: ~~~: ~ Petit:Loner's Phone N Property Tax I.D. Number: 2404 2130002~304 ~ - ReQuested Zontng: RM-11 ~ _ P~esent Zoning: p~esent G.M.P.P- DesignatiOn: Is an AmenOment to the G~owth Managemen. Po[[cy Plan being requested? No: ~/[f yes, what ~s Amen0ment to? Yes: ~ B~[eftY Oesc~Ibe t~"e ~eason fo~ this ~.~ uested Rezonlng Change: ~ ,. dwell~ng units B~lef~Y desc~tbe" the folIO.[ng: ~pattble with exlst[ng land uses ¢oposed Amendment co ~ove the neighborhood u~t~ the (a) How [s the p. T~ tn the a~ea:  Leese puOl~c fact'~it~es ~n this a~eal ~f no ~apact. ts expected~ P state The~e a~e no:"ant~c~Pated ~mpac~s exp~ c~ed because ~he~e a~e no public ~nat ace the.an~lCl~ate~"~3 effect: Is expected, please state (d) Will the p~oposed Amendment zesult in an orO~e~ly and loaical development pa.tte~n? ~If the Petitione~ is not the owne~ of the p~ope~ty~ please explain ~elow and 9ire the owner's name an~ aO~ ess. ]one~"s Signature Oate ~ignatu~e ' ' Oate Please note the ~equi~ements o~ Sectio ~.1.100(~), St. Lucie County Zoning Oz~lnance. The Peti'tionez shall ~etu~n the attache~ Affidavit to Room 2~1, St. Luc[e County ~dminist~Tation bUilding no late~ than five days p~%o~ to the scheduled public ~eazing~+ STAFF USE ONLY: Date Received~ _ ~-'~ I' Date Authorized fo~.-Revie~: - Hea~ing, ,Schedule: . P~anning and Zoning: AffiOavit Received: Board of County Commissioners: Affidavit Received.: Comment: Receipt No.: Result: Result: SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST~ 500 FEET TO PC WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNS COUNTY, FLORIDA. FROM THE SOUTHWEST~CORNER OF THE NE 1/40 THE NW 1/4 RUN NORTH 150 FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE CqNTINuE NORTH 136 FEET, THENCE EAST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCE EAST 200 FEET, THENCE INT OF BEGINNING; ALL OF HIP 35S, RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE -Charles L. Hendley 1500 Delaware Avenue Port Pierce, PL 34950 (305)4614840 ST. LUCIE COl Petition for Change to the O* St. Lucie Petitioner's Name: Petitioner's Address: L.C. Carter & Wes 106-21 155 Streel Petitioner,s Phone Number: 718-297-2! Legal Description of Parcel (indicate st From the S.W. corner of the NE ~ of the NW ~ run Rezonin9 only: $300 Combined (P.A.& Rez.)$500 INTY 'flcial Zoning Atlas of *ounty ey Carter , damica, N.Y. 33114 48 feet address ~f known): No~ch 150 Feet for the Point o£ beqinninq, there continur North 136 Feet, thence East 300 ft. thence East 200 ft., thence South 286 ft., thence West 500 Ft. to Point of B ginning; all of which land is situated in Section 4, Township 35, Range 40, St. Lucie COunty, Florida. Parcel size (express in acres): 2.25.Acres., Property Tax I.D. Number: 2404 21300020~ Present Zoning: RS-4 ,~ Present G.M.P.P. Designation: RN Is an Amendment to the Growth Management Yes: No: ____2L If yes, what is Briefly describe the reason for this req The Petitioner's desire to erect multi-family d~ Briefly Oescribe the following: (a) How is the proposed Amendment compa in the area: The~proposed will inprovE (b) (c) erection of multi-family dwelliness. What are the anticipated impacts , public facilities in this area? If state why. There ar_ e_~no anticipated impacts expected . _~acilities in this area What are the anticipated effects on result of this Amendment? If no eff why. __There are no anticipated effects ... there will not effected b.y the establishm~ )04 tequested Zoning: RM-11 Policy Plan being requested? [mendment to? lested Rezonin9 Change: _ ~e!ling units [lble with e~istin9 land uses the neighborh~d with the f the proposed Amendment on no impact is expected, please because there are no public bhe natural e~nvironment as a ect is expected, please state .n~_~he n.atural e~vironment becasue ,"t of multi-family ,dwei, lings (d) Will the proposed Amendment result development pattern? ¢~/-~-~-7(/~. / ~I? the Petitioner is not the owner below and give the owner's name and addr in an orderly and loqical~ of the property, please explain ess. INPORTANT NOTICE: Pet i>i~ner~s S~a(ure Please note the requirements of Sectio Zoning Ordinance. The Petitioner shall to Room 201, St. Lucie County Administ: five days prior to the scheduled public STAFF USE ONLY: Date Received: Date Authorized for Review: Hearing Schedule: Planning and Zoning: Affidavit Received: Board of County Commissioners: Affidavit Received: Comment: Date Date n 5.1.100(5), St. Lucie County return the 9ttached Affidavit 7ation building no later than hearing. File No.: Check No.: Receipt No.: Result: Result: -% BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION£RS May 4, 1988 DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR In compliance with the provisions of the St. Lucie County Zoning Ordinance, you are hereby advised that I. C. and Wesley Carter, by Agent: Charles L. Hendley., have petitioned the Planning and Zoning Commission for a change in zoning Single Family - 4 du/ac) to RM-11 (Resid 11 du/ac) for the following described pr FROM THE SOUTHWEST'CORNER OF THE NE 1/4 OF T FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE CONT EAST ~300'. FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THENCt ~SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO POIN~ WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP COUNTY,_ FLORIDA. (Location: 150 ft. n'orth of Avenue Q, 13( Street ) The first public hearing on the petition P.M. on Thursday, May 26, 1988, in Room Administration Building, 2300 Virginia Florida. All interested persons will be be heard at that time. Please note that all proceedings before Commission are electronically recorded. appeal any decision made by the Planning from RS-4 (Residential, ential, Multiple Family - operty: OF BEGINNING; ALL OF 35S, RANGE 40E, ST. LUCIE )0 ft. east of N. 25th will be held at 7:00 01, St. Lucie County enue, Fort Pierce, given an opportunity to e Planning and Zoning f a person decides to with respect to any matter considered at he will need a record of the proceedings, purpose, he may need to ensure that a vet proceedings is made, which record include evidence upon which the appeal is 'to be b~ ~e . of any party to the Droce~n~ · · ...... ~, ~nUlVlGua. ~ res' ' hearing w~ll be sworn in Any ~=~ ....... t~fy~ng ' ~ ~L~ LU [ ro granted an opportunity ~ ...... ' 9~ p ceedzng uuz~ng a nearing upon request. // If you no longer own property adjacent to th:e above,de: parcel, please forward this ngt'ice to the .ew owner. petitioners propose to erect multi-family welling uni your information a copy of the RM-11 zonin is enclose, If you have any questions, additional info nation may by calling Area Code 305, 46:6-1100, Extens on 344/41. Sincerely, PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION ST. LUCIE COUN~Y,'FLORIDA J- ~?- Terpening?Chairman FI] HA~RT L. FENN, Distri~ No. 1 · JUDY CULPEPP£R, District No. 2 · JACK KRIEGER, District No. 3 · R. Coun~ Administrotor - WELDON B. LE%VIS 2300 Virginio Avenue ® Fo~ Pierce. FL 34982-5652 ® p Director: Ext. 398 · Building: Ext. 344 · Plonning: Ext. 316 · Zoning: nd Zoning C~mmission uch meeting Or hearing, ~nd that, fo~ such ~tim recordof the the testimony and ~e request during a will be testifying ;cribed 'he s. For e obtained NO. RZ-88-015 TREFELNER, District No. 4 · JIM MINIX. District No. 5 >ne (407) 466-1100 344 · Code Enforcement: Ext. 294 NOTICE NOTICE IS HEREBy GIVEN t'hat the Plannin~ and Zonin~ C~)mmis_ Sion for St. Lucie County, Florida, Will at 7:00 P,M on Thurs_ day, May 26, 1988, in Room 101, St. Lucie Coun :y Administra.:ion BUildinq, 2300 Virginia Avenue, Fort Pierce, F. ' Public hearinu on: Petition of L. C. and Wesley Carter, by A Hendley, for a Chan~e in z · Family _ 4 dU/a~ ~ onln~' from RS-4 /~ '- ~, co RM 11 ' . ~esid OU/ac) f~ (Residential, ~* <ne fOllowin~ describe~ PrOperty. FROM THE SOUTH FEET FO ~,,~ _ WEST CORN _ ,2..~z~ 286 FEr~ ~f~Nu~ NORT, , ~j' THENC~ ~_,~HE ~ oCreet) ~u ~t. north o~--~ . _ _ ~ ~o, r AVenue Q, 1300 ft. eas ZoninPlease nOte that all PrOCeedin9s before the P1  C°~iss/°n are electronically recorde~. ~Cide to appeal any decision mafle by the Planning C°~issi°n With respect to any matter COnsidered at o~ hearing, he ~iil need a record of the PrOceedings fc Such PUrPose, he may need to ensure that a verbat th6 PrOceedinUs is made, Which recor~ includes the te evi ence Upon Which the appeal is to be based. UPon of ny Party to the PrOCeeding, individuals testifyin~ hea: in~ Will be Sworn in. Any Party to the ~ran~ ed an Opportunity to Cross-examine duri: ~ a hearin~ Upon request, any individual J~f these Public hearinps may it becomes necessary, tinue from time to time. D~ted this 2nd day of 'May, 1988. PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSioN ST. LUCIE COUNTy, FLORIDA /s/ j. p. PUBLISH: ~ 5, 1988 Terpenin9' Chairman DATE PEZI%ION CO~ENT S~ ~ET ? Charles L. Hendley : 1500 Dblaware Avenue Fort Eierc~, FL 34950 (305)4614840 , ~'A'~'~~ Petition for Change Petitioner's Name: Petitioner's Address: LUCIE COl to the · St. Lucie L.C. Carter & Wes] 106-21 155 Stree Petitioner's Phone Number: 718-297-2! Legal Description of Parcel (indicate st ~h~ S w ~ ..... ~nf the NW ~ run Pa~ceZ S~z6 (express tn ac~es). 2.25 Ac~ · Property Tax l.O. Numbe~: ,2404 ,21300020, P~eseflt Zoning: _RS-4 P~esent G.M.P.P. Designation: __ RN Is an Amendment to the G~owth Management Yes: No: ~/If yes, what Briefly describe the reason for this-req -Th~ti~±oner' ~ d~s~to ~multi-£amily d~ Briefly descrlOe the following: (a) How is the proposed Amendment comp~ in the area: The p=oposed will ~prow _erection o£ multi-£amily dwelliness. ~ ~hat are the anticiPated impacts puOlic facilities in this area? If state why. .There. are no anticipated imp.acts expected Rezoning on. ComDined (P ~TY 'flclal Zonir Ounty .ey Carter ~ ,, Jan~ica, N. Ly: $300 ~__ ,A.& Rez.)$500 Atlas of reef address if known)= North 150' Feet for thh~e~L~e of -Emit 300 ft. ~ilenc~ East 200 ~ginnzng; al o w zc *s 3itu~",~ ~on~y, Florida. f )04 ~equested Zon Policy Plan tmenOment to? ~ested Rezoni ~elling units (b) (c) fac,ilities in this area ~hat are the anticipated effects'~o~' result of,..this AmenOment? If no ell w~y. _There are no anticipated e~£ects ~,,~rc wi3~ not ~ffect~d_b~ th~ eatsblishm, tlble with e the neighborhc ~eing requested? ~9 Change: ~lstin9 land uses od with the ~f the proposed Amendment on no impact isexpected, please because there qre nQ.public ~he natural environment as a 'ect is expected, please stgte ~n the natural ~nvironment bccc~e. the proposed Amendment result~n an orderly and l_ogical developmen, t pattern? _¢~7q"~7~7~. G./~O~/ ~/.//J ~>O &/~T2~ the Petitioner is not the owner ~ an~ 91ye the owner'S name and addr~ )f the property, please explain !SS. !I4PORTANT NOTICE: ¢~Petiti(~ner's Signat~ re Date gnature Date Please note the requirements of Se~ 5.1.100(5), Zonin9 Ordinance. The Petitioner shall the a' to Room 20.1, St. Lucle County Administration build1 flve days prior to the scheduled public ~earing. STAFF USE ONLY: Date Received~ Date Authorized for Review: Hea~ing-Sche. d~le: Plannin9 and Zonin9: Affidavit Received: Board of County Commissioners: Affidavit Received: Comment: St. Lucie County .tached Affidavit ng no late~ than Flle No.: ~-~:~-~)/~ Check No.: /0 cZ ~._ Receipt No.: / ~ ~ ~. ~ Result: Result: FROM'THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NE 1/4 Of FEET FOR THE POINT OF BEGINNING, THENCE C~ EAST 300 FEET, THENCE NORTH 150 FEET, THO SOUTH 286 FEET, THENCE WEST 500 FEET TO P~ WHICH LAND IS SITUATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNi COUNTY, FLORIDA. THE NW 1/4 RU~ NORTH 150 )NTINUE NORTH i~6.FEET, THENCE ~CE EAST 200 FE~T, THENCE )INT OF BEGINNING; ALL OF HIP 35S, RAiqGE 40E, ST. LUCIE