The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutCasai, AndrewBOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION£RS DEVCLOPMCNT COORDINATOR J GARY AMENT July 18, 1986 Mr. Andrew Casai 1848 N.W. Treasure Point Stuart, Florida 33494 Dear Mr. Casai: Please be advised that on Tuesday, June 24, 1986, the Board of County Commissioners denied your petition for the rezoning of property located on the north side of White City Road and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive intersection. Sincerely, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER ST LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Havert L. Fenn, Chairman HLF/kj Enclosure HAVERT _ FENN. Dis[rict No I · E E. GREEN District NO. 2 · JACK KR~IEGER. District No. 3 ° R. DALE TREFELNER Distr,ct No 4 · JIM MINIX Distnct NO 5 County AcJministra~or WELDON B. LEWIS 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce. FL 33482-5652 ® Phone (305) 466-1100 Cooroinator: Ext. 316 * Building: Ext. 344 · Plannit]g: Ext. 316 · Zoning: ExT. 336 · Code Enforcement; Ext~ 317 REso .o o so. s -12 A RESOLUTION DENYING A PROPOSED CHANGE PROP~.RT~ IN S~. ~UCI~- COUNTY ~ ~LORIDA 769477 WHEREAS, the Board of COunty Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida, has made the following determinations: 1. Andrew CaSai presented a petition for a change in zoning f=om RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) 'to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the property described as follows: Lot 8 & 9, Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 (Located-on the north side of White City Road and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive Intersection). 2. The St. Lucie County Planning and Zoning Commission, held a public hearing on the petition, after publishing notice at least fifteen (15) days prior to the hearing and notifying by mail owners of property within five hundred feet (500') of the subject property, and has recommended that the Board deny the hereinafter described request for change in zoning classification from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the property described above. 3. On June 24, 1986, this Board held a public hearing on the petition, after publishing a notice of such hearing in the Fort Pierce News Tribune on June 4, 1986, and notifying by mail all owners of proPerty within 500 feet of the subject property. 4. The proposed change in zoning classification would be in violation of the commercial locational requirements as identified in the St. Lucie County Growth Management Policy Plan. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of -County Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida: The petition for a zoning change filed by Andrew Casai is hereby denied. After motion and second, the vote on this resolution was as follows: ATTEST: CLERK Chairman Haver~t L. Fenn Vice-Chairman Jim Minix Commissioner R. Dale Trefelner Commissioner E. E. Green Commissioner Jack Krieger Aye Aye Aye Aye PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED this 24th day of june, 1986. ~Om~D O~ COUm~ S'~. ~-i .: . .,.- . ~.' .. . ...5 ' i.~, ~-' ,/~,/, COUI~¥ AT'r0~¥ 769477 '86 JUL -8 A8:38-- ROGEi',: ST. LUg:. °" 506 452 E, O0~ RESOLUTION NO. 86-126 A RESOLUTION DENYING A PROPOSED CHANGE IN THE ZONING CLASISIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROPERTY IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA 769477 WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida, has made the following determinations: 1. Andrew Casai presented a petition for a change in zoning from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the property described as follows: Lot 8 & 9, Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 (Located-on the north side of White City Road and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive Intersection)- 2. The St. Lucie County Planning and Zoning Commission, held a public hearing on the petition, after publishing notice at least fifteen (15) days prior to the hearing and notifying by mail owners of property within five hundred feet (500') of the subject property, and has recommended that the Board deny the hereinafter described request for change in zoning classification from RS'2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the property described above~ 3. On June 24, 1986, this Board held a public hearing on the petition, after publishing a notice of such hearing in the Fort Pierce News Tribune on dune 4, 1986, and notifying by mail all owners of property within 500 feet of the subject property. 4. The proposed change in zoning classification would be in violation of the commercial locational requirements as identified in the St. Lucie County Growth Management Policy Plan. NOW, THEREFORE', BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida: The petition for a zoning change filed by Andrew Casai is hereby denied. After motion and second, the vote on this resolution was as follows: Chairman Havert L. Fenn Vice-Chairman Jim Minix Commissioner R. Dale Trefelner Commissioner E. E. Green Commissioner Jack Krieger Aye Aye Aye Aye Aye PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED t!his 24th day of June, 1986. ATTEST: CLERK BOARD OF ST. LUCIE /~, COUNTY ATTORNEY 769477 '86 OUL-8 A8:38~ ROGEr-: ' ' 506 452 600~ Date:: 3une 24, 1986 Tapes: 1, 2, ~ and 4 convened: 9:06 a.m. adjourned: 5:57 p.m. Curators. Present: Ha~ert L. Fenn, Chairman, 3ira Minix, Vice-Chairman, E. E. G~een, 3ack K~ieger, R. Dale Trefelner ewis Co nty Administrator, Daniel Mclntyre' :: 3eld°n~-B-.y-L-~- ~k~Circuit Court, Ma~k Bagg~tt,. ~Y.A~nS~ ..... ~sis~nt County Assistant County Others Presen~ County Attorn~ Engineer, O. 9 Coordinator, Assistant Co~ Dennis Murphy~y Assistant Planner, Tom Zades, Deputy Sheriff, Bouchet, Depu~. Cierk (Com. Trefelner was ~ot present during discussion and vote of Agenda items I through ~ and arrived du~ing discusslion of Agenda item 4.) · - ndrew Casai for a change in zoning from RS-2 (f) Pet~t~_on_.of .A ___,,.. o~ to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood).fo~ ~ize ;~R~ ~i~ ~t~ ~v~O~ kS ZDd~e~ v°ef iWn~tres eCc~tiy°nR-°ad' and 200 feet west °T Bruce Abe rnethy, Esq-, on behalf of Indian River Estates Homeowners Association, appeared before the Board and requested that petition for zoning be denied. ro used ch nge in zoning ciassification wouid be in Staff sta~,ed that _t_h_e~p~ ~c~ loca~6nal requirements as identified in the violation of the uu,,,,,~c-~ St. Lucie County Growth Management Rolicy Plan. of Staff, 't was moved by Com. Minix, seconded by Based on the comments . in ro used change in R.esolutzon~No. 86-126 deny g P P Com. Gte'-~n, to.. ad.o.pt '_-~ .~k ~Ave referenced property, and, upon roll zoning classiTzcat~on o[ ~,,~ ~ - call, mo~animously carried. ' RESOLUTION NO. 86-126 A RESOLUTION DENYING A PROPOSED CHANGE IN THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROPERTY IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA WHERE~S, the Board of County Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida, has made the f011owing determinations: 1. Andrew Casai presented a petition for a change in zoning from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the property described as follows: Lot 8 & 9, Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 a(LOcated on the north side of White City Road nd 200 feet west of Whit~ ~" ~ ad and Silver Ce~ ~i~ The St. ning Commission, ~ ~I~I~~.Ci~~~ ishing notice at held a.~public heari '~ nd notifying by least '.~ifteen (15) mail owners of pro~ - (500') of the Board deny the subject property,, a --------- /~ classification hereinafter describe IN (Commercial, from RS-2 (Resident'~ Neighborhood) for 3. On June 24, £986~-~iS Board held a public hearing on the petition, after publishing a notice of such hearing in the Fort Pierce News Tribune on June 4, 1986, and notifying by mail all owners of property within 500 feet of the subject property. 4. The proposed change in zoning classification would be in violation of the commercial l~cational requirements~_ as identified in the St. Lucie County Growth Manageme~ Policy Plan. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT R~$OLVED by the Boa rd of County Commissioners of St. Lucie County,~ Florida: The petition for a zoning change filed by Andrew Casai is hereby denied. After motion and second, follows: the vote on this resoluti°n was as Chairman Haver~ L. Fenn XX Vice-Chairman Jim Minix XX Commissioner R. Dale Trefelner XX Commissioner E. E. Green XX Commissioner Jack Krieger XX PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED this 24th day of June, 1986. BOARD OF COUlffY COF~I$$IONERE ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA CLERK CHAIRMAN APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: COUNTY ATTORNEY N ~'~5 B&O~W~N R~D '19 PETITION OF ANDREW CASAI TO CHA~6E ZONING DISTRICT FROM ~.S-2 TO CN N % PETITION OF ANDREW CASAI TO CHAN6E ZONING DISTR~CT FROM RS-2 TO CN AGENDA - BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS TUESDAY JUNE 24, 1986 1:30 P.M. Petition of Andrew Casai for a change in zoning from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family- 2) to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the following described property: Lot 8 & 9, Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 (Located on the north side of White City Road and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive Intersection). Prior to this public hearing, notice of the same was sent to all adjacent property owners. If it becomes necessary, these public hearings may be con- tinued from time to time. Please note that all proceedings before the Board of County Commissioners are electronically recorded. Any person who decides to appeal ~ny action taken by t~e Board of County Commissioners at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose ma~ need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA /s/ Havert L. Fenn, Chairman 17 t! · % % N ". PETI'ITI~O~ OF /~#D~W CASAI 2-.-3G-~0 RS-2 RS-3 BLUE GREEN RS-ii ORANGE-~. RH-5 BROI~ ~ CN RED ~ BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION6RS DC V LOPMC NT COORDINATOR J. GARY AMENT June 3, 1986 The Planning and Zoning Commission recommended to the Board of County Commissioners denial of the petition of Andrew Casai from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) for a chang in zoning to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the following described property: Lot 8 & 9, Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 (Located on the north side of White City Road and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive Intersection). The Board of County Commissioners will hold a public hearing on this petition at 1:30 P.M. on Tuesday, June 24, 1986, in Room 101, St. Lucie County Administration Building, 2300 Virginia Avenue, Fort Pierce, Florida. All interested persons will be given an opportunity to be heard at that time. Please note that all proceedings before the Board of County Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida, are electronically recorded. Any person who decides to appeal any action taken by the Board of County Commissioners at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. This notice is being sent to all adjacent property owners. If you should have any questions, additional information may be obtained by calling Area Code 305, 466-1100, Extension 359. Very truly yours, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA ~er~t ~~~irman HAVERT L. FENN, District No. I · E. E. GREEN, District No. 2 · JACK KRIEGER, District No. 3 · R. D,~-E TREFELNER, District No. 4 · JIM MINIX, District No. 5 Counly Administrator - WELDON B. LEWIS 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 33482-5652 ® Phone (305) 466-1100 Coordinator: Ext. 398 · Building: Ext. 344 · Planning: Ext. 316 · Zoning: Ext. 336 · Code Enforcement: Ext. 317 Andrew Casai 1848 N.W. Treasure Point Stuart, F. 33494 OTHER PROPERTY OWNERS NOTIFIED A Robert Quinn 3490 Pine Est Dr. Orchard Lake, Mi. 48033 Alley General Development Corp. 1111S. Bayshore Dr. Miami, Fi. 33131 IRE-Unit 4, Tract A, Lots 1,5,6,21,26,27 & 30 Savannah Assoc., Ltd. P.O. Box 2111 Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33454 Lot 4 & 28,IRE-Unit 4,Tr.A Peter & Victoria Jurczyk 5610 Hickory Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fl. 33482 Lot 29,IRE-Unit 4, Tr.A Joseph & Audrey Trementozzi- 69 Randolph St. Canton, Ma. 02021 Lot 2 & 3 So. Bell Tel. & Tel. Co. c/o Dist.'Staff Mgr.-Taxes 20 A53, So. Bell Center Atlanta, Ga. 30375 Lot 7 Jack & Margaret Myer 416 Achille Rd. Havertown, Pa. 19083 Parcel 1 Albert A. Nemeth 1870 Ocean Way Vero Bch., Fi. 32963 Parcel 2 Fred R. Morgan,II 3055 S.E. Pine Valley Rd. Port St. Lucie, Fi. 33452 Parcel 3 Robert J. Lowe 12 Sovereign Way Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33449 Blk. 33,Lot 1 Sally Hakes 5912 Cassia Dr. Ft. Pierce, FI. 33482 Blk. 33, Lot 2 Ivan & Katherine Harber 3510 Hatcher St. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33450 Blk. 33,Lot 3 & Pt. Lot 4 David & Linda Wilson 4606 Magnolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Pt. Lot 4 & 5 Horace & Dorothy Glover 4608 Magnolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Pt. Lot 5, Lots 6 & 7 W.A. & Louise Johnson 4610Magnolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Blk. 34, Lot 1 & 2 John & Frances Nucelli 219 Huntington Dr. Vincentown, N.J. 08088 Blk. 34, Lot 3 Edna Morrell 816 Kearney Ave. Arlington, N.J. 07032 Blk. 34, Pt. Lot 4 Jerry Albritton 4601 Magnolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 '~X~o Unit 4,Blk 34,Pt.Lot 4 Arthur & Annette Lessard, et al 4603 Ma§nolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fl. 33482 Patrick & suzette'Hood 4100 Glades Rd. Ft. Pierce, Fl. 33450 ,I.R.E. ~a~t 4,Blk. 34, Lot 6 ':'~ John & Judith Ryaeska 124Hazak St. Ft. Bragg, N.C. 28307 Lot 7 Richard & Sylvia Huff 4609 Magnolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, FI. 33482 Lot 8 & 9 Lloyd & Betty Brooks 4611 Magnolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fl. 33482 Lot 10 Thomas & Margaret Walton 4703 Magnolia Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fl. 33482 Lot i1 Juel R. Irons Box 112 Coker Creek, Tn. 37314 Lot 12 & 13 Marie Plankinton c/o Rogers, Hoge & Hills 90 Park Ave. New York, N.Y. 10016 Lot 14 & 15 Walter Autenrieth c/o Vita Autenrieth 7344 S.E. Redbird Cir. Hobe Sound, Fl. 33455 Lot 16 Grace R. Scott P.O. Box 463 Bridgeport, N.Y. 13030 Lot 17,18 & Pt. Lot 19 Thomas A. Marco 4706 Palmetto Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Pt. Lot 19 Gary W. Zanello 4700 Palmetto' Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Lot 20 Daniel & Georgette Newfield 4610 Palmetto Dr. Ft. Pierce, FI. 33482 Lot 21 Zelma Willson, et al. 2808 60 Ave. W. Bradenton, FI. 33507 Lot 22 & 23 'Richard & Judith Hightower 4604 Palmetto Dr. Ft. Pierce, FI. 33482 Blk. 37, Lot 1 & 2 Billy & Margaret Webb 739 Altura Port St. Lucie, Fi. 33452 Blk. 37, Lot 24 John & Leana Schwartz 1112 Sunrise Blvd. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33450 Unit 5,Blk. 3,Lot 25 & 26 Robert & Julie Kelly 605 E. Midway Rd. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Unit 5,Blk. 26,Lot 1,2,3 & 4 Robert & Mary Hall 1502 Seaway Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fl. 33449 Unit 5,Blk. 26,Lot 5 & 6 _ Brown Johnson, Jr. P.O. Box 1365 Ft. Pierce, Fl. 33454 Blk. 26, Lot 7 & Pt. Lot 8 Robert & Judy Moulton P.O. Box 3492 Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33454 Pt.-'Lot 8,9 & 10 Ardem Peck,. et al. 705 E. Midway Rd. Ft. Pierce,. Fi. 33482 I.R.E. Unit 5, Blk. 26, Pt. Lot 8,9 & 10 Sharon Quercioli 208 Hassell Rd. Hoffman Est.,-Il. 60195 I.R.E. Unit 5, Blk. 26,Lot 11 Arpad Rajki, et al. 10200 S. A1A #301 Jensen Bch., Fi. 33457 Lot 37 & 38 Douglas & Susan Reeder 4801 Silver Oak Dr. FT. Pierce~ Fl. 33482 Lot 39 John E. Hawkins 4809 Silver Oak Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Blk. 27, Pt. Lot 1,2 & 3 Robert & Diane O'Neal 903 Scott St. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Blk. 27, Pt. Lot 1 & 2 Steven & Sandra Becraft 4105 Roenker Ln. Virginia Bch., Va. 23455 Blk. 27, Pt. Lot 2 & 3 Alfred & Susan Zeller 4804 Silver Oak Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 Blk. 28,Lot 1,2,3 & 4 Carson & Sophie Sutton 6450 Cramlane Dr. Clarkston, Mi. 48016 Blk. 28, Lot 5,6 & 7 Jerry & Pauline Pinto 218 S.E. 9th St. Hallendale, Fi. 33009 Blk. 28 Lot 8 Eliga &~ Elaine Collison 900 E. Scott Dr. Ft. Pierce, Fi. 33482 THE NEWS TRIBUNE Published ~even Days A Week Fort Pierce. St. Lucie County, Florida STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF ST. LUCIE Before the undersigned authority personally appeared James J. McMillen or Kathleen K. LeClair, who on oath ' ' ' ' ' r o says that he, she ~s Publ~sher, Pubhsher s Secrete y f The News Tribune, a daily newspaper published at Fort Pierce in St. Lucie County, Florida; that the attached petition hearing copy of advertisement, being a ................................ · Casax ~n the matter of ................................................... was published in said newspaper in the issues of .......... 6/4/86 Affiant further says that the said News Tribune is a newspaper published at Fort Pierce, in said St. Lucie County, Florida, and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said St. Lucie Count.v. Florida, each day and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Fort Pierce. in said St. Lucie County, Florida, for a period of one year next pre- ceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement: and affiant further says that he has neither p.ald nor promised any person, firm or corpora- tion any ~iscount, rebate,, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publid~ition in the said newspaper. Sworn t~ and Subscribed b~fo~e me ~ ~ 4t?i-- da Of JUN ' .-~ This ................. ~Y ~,' . ............ 1986- ~ A.D./7 ............... ~ -'~ .............. · ....................... , .... ' kS/ ...... .r ...... ~.~ =f:}till. i GENERAL [NS. UND. NOTICE NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Board of County Commissioners in and for St. Lucie County, Florida, will at t:30 P.M. on Tuesday, June 24, 1986, in Room 101, St. Lucie County Administration Building, 2300 Virginia Avenue, Fort Pierce, Florida hold a public hearing on: Petition of Andrew Casai for a change in zoning from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for the following described property: Lot 8 & 9, Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 (Located on the north side of White City Road and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive Intersection). All interested persons will be given an opportunity to be heard at this time. Please note that all proceedings before the Board of County Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida, are electronically recorded. Any person who decides to appeal any action taken by the County Commissioners at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. If it becomes necessary, these public hearings may be continued from time to time. Dated this 30th day of May, 1986. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LCUIE COUNTY, FLORIDA /s/ Havert L. Fenn, Chairman PUBLISH: JUNE 4, 1986 1-255 PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA MINUTES - MAY 22, 1986 PUBLIC HEARING: Petition of Andrew Casai for a change in zoning from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) to CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) for property located on the north side of White City Road, and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive intersection. STAFF COMMENTS: County Staff has completed its review of this petition, and finds, at this time, it must recommend against this requests. The reasons for this recommendation are as follows: 1. Specific policies within the Growth Manage- ment PoliCy Plan indicate that Neighborhood Commercial development should only take place in those areas that afford a reasonable clustering of uses. Strip or spot rezonings within resi- dential areas should be avoided. 2. Staff has consistently recommended against the introduction of any commercial zoning along this portion of East Midway Road in order to preserve as much of the residential character of the area as .possible. Mr. Sciturro asked if anyone was present to speak for the petition. Dennis Murphy said: Mr. Chairman, and members of the Board, Mr. Casai was sent notice of this hearing. He also received Staff's comments, which is normal procedure. However, all those letters and notices were returned, "Address Unknown" The address was the one given us by Mr. Casai on his petition application. Our office has not been contacted by Mr. Casai, or anyone representing him. Mr. Terpening asked Krista Storey, Assistant County Attorney, if it was permissible to hear the petition without the Petitioner being present. Krista Storey said that it was the Petitioner's choice to attend, or not to attend the hearing. That since the Planning Staff had advertised the petition and hearing date in the newspaper, attempted to notify the .Petitioner by letter with the inclusion of Staff's Comments; that all notice requirements had been fulfilled. Ms. Storey said that she didn't see any reason why the Board should not hear the petition. TO: FROM: DATE: SUB3ECT: Petition # 2 MEMORANDUM Planning and Zoning Commission Planning Administrator /~/ May 14, 1986 Petition of Andrew Casai for a Change in Zoning from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2 d.u./ac) to ON (Commercial, Neighborhood) LOCATION: EXISTING ZONING: PROPOSED ZONING: EXISTING G.M.P.P. LAND USE: PROPOSED USE: PARCEL SIZE: SURROUNDING ZONING: SURROUNDING LAND USE: FIRE PROTECTION: WATER/SEWER SERVICE: Northeast corner of East Midway Road and Magnolia Drive, Indian River Estates RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2 d.u./ao) CN (Commercial, Neighborhood) RL (Residential, Low) The Petitioner proposes to construct a small stationery and gift shop. 1.11 acres RS-2, RS-3, RS-4, PM-5, and CN To the West and South of this site is Indian River Estates, a developing single family subdivision. To the East is an approved Site Plan for Silver Oak Apartments. The commercial property farther to the East is vacant. White City Fire Station is approximately 3/4 mile West of this site. No public services are currently available to this site. CC: COMMENTS: County Staff has completed its review of this Petition finds, at this time, it must recommend against this request. reasons for this recommendations are as follows: and The 1. Specific policies within the Growth Management Policy Plan indicate that Neighborhood, Commercial development should only take place in those areas that afford a reasonable clustering of uses. Strip or spot rezonings within residential areas should be avoided. 2. Staff has consistently recommended against the introduction of any commercial zoning along this portion of East Midway Road in order to preserve as much of the residential character of the area as possible. County Attorney Andrew Casai 2 MEMORANDUM TO: County Administrator iCounty Commission FROM: DATE: SUBOECT: iPlanning Administrator Sune 17, 1986 iRezoning Petition of Andrew Casai from RS-2 to CN On Tueisday, 3une.24, 1986, you will be asked to review a Rezoning P~tition on behalf of. Andrew Casai for property on East Midway Roadi and'Magnolia Drive. On Thursday, May 22, 1986, this Petition was presented to the Rlanning and Zoning Commission for review. A~ this.meeting, no one came forward to speak on behalf of this P~tition. Notice of this hearing was sent to the Retitioner. However, it was returned due to an insufficient address. The address used was that indicated on the application. At this hearing, a Petition was submitted by the residents of Indian River Estates containing 43 signatures, as well as, another Petition reportedly containing 356 signatures opposing this Retition. At this meeting,~ the Rlanning and Zoning Commission i voted unanimously to recommend denial of this Retition. iAttached you will find copies of the original Staff Report onthis item .and the minutes of the May 22, 1986 meeting. GMS/DJM/lg cc: County Attorney Press/Public 1 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION6RS DCV£LOPMCNT COORDINATOR J. GARY AMENT June 3, 1986 The Planning and Zoning Commission recommended to the Board of County Commissioners denial of the petition of Andrew Casai for a change in zoning from RS-2 (Residential, Single Family - 2) to CN (Commercial, ~Neighborhood) for the following described property: Lot 8 & 9, Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 (Located on the north side of White City Road and 200 feet west of White City Road and Silver Oak Drive Intersection). The Board of County Commissioners will hold a public hearing on this petition at 1:30 P.M. on Tuesday, June 24, 1986, in Room 101, St. Lucie County Administration Building, 2300 Virginia Avenue, Fort Pierce, Florida. All interested persons will be given an opportunity to be heard at that time. Please note that all,proceedings before-{he Board of County Commissioners of St. Lucie County, Florida, are electronically recorded. Any person who decides to appeal any action taken by the Board of County Commissioners at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. This notice is being sent to ~all adjacent propert~ owners. If you should have any questions, additional information may be obtained by calling Area Code 305, 466-1100, Extension 359. Very truly yours, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Havert L. Fenn, Chairman kj ~ ~ County Administrator - WELDON B. LEWIS 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 33482-5652 · Phone (305) 466-1100 Coordinator: Ext. 398 · Building: Ext. 344 · Planning: Ext. 316 · Zoning: Ext. 336 · Code Enforcement: Ext. 317 ~e: L~% .~8 ~ #9 ~lock #82 Indian River Ear,tee Unit . Pl~uing Md Eoning Commission: ~2. 'J. J. Sci%~rro ( Chairmen ) Dear Sirs: ~i~ is to state our case of how we feel about ~hie ~pot zoning ~ection. We object strenuously beceu~e ,~. rea~on for peopleb~uy~ng' home~ in this location to be~n with and this spot Zoning would ~et a very If ~ne i~ granted %here would certair~y be others emma along ~nd o~e thi~ we-Bo ns% need i~ ~u i~teted ~ore or co~ercial location on whm%ever lo% they may decide in ~he middle o£ all the he~e~ an~ regimen,rial apace. Since there i~ an area z%ipulated for,, so~mercial pur~o~e~ on the plat why would wave.ut them b~ilding all over muir re~identi~l ~rea. ~e are being serviced very satisfactorit,.- y with our ne~ T~n - South Plaza ~hepping area and ~nother one ~oon %o be finished on Federal Hi.way ~outh of ~idwey Reed. there. :~fier a zoni~ charge he could put one of m~,many~ .tn~ng~ and we really do not ~ed or want any of them in %he very heart of ~' residential ~eetion. ~e a~k that thi~ property remain re~i~enti~ %hebecaUSev~tue~eaeof sli%tle~ . ~pot~.. zo~ng ~eas have a bad ~ffect by low-ring area. ur~~ng reaid~nti~ properties and ~11 ~urro'~uding Gentlemen, pteaee give ~our ~erious coneideration %o the needs of the me~y residen%~ o£ ~Aian River E ~'staie~.~ Thank You. May 12, 1986 Planning and Zoning Commission St. Lucie County, Florida 2300 Virginia Avenue Fort Pierce, Florida 33482-5652 Dear Mr. Sciturro: Attn: Re: J- J. Sciturro, Chairman Change in Zoning Request - Lot 8 & 9 Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 We own and reside in our home located at 4703 Magnolia Drive, Indian River Estates - Lot 10, Unit 4, Block 34. We bought this property and built our home here because of the country atmosphere and because it was a RESID£NTIA[ ONlY AREA. We do not want, let me repeat, DO NOT WANT, the above subject property rezoned for business of any type. The new shopping plaza located shopping plaza to be completed this at Midway Road and U.S. I and the new Street which will house a Publix, Wafall a short distance south of Easy ]green's and other strip shops ~ore than takes care of our neighborhood needs. If rezoning continues as it is being requested, and more and more of these small shopping strips are built, soon each household will have its own ]ittshopping plaza! We d__qo notneL~_or want the rezoning of this property in question. WE WANT THIS AREA TO STAY RESIDENTIAL AS THE HOME OWNERS THOUGHT IT WOULD BE AND EXPECTED IT TO REMAIN. Very truly yours, Thomas E. Walton Margaret H. Walton 4703 Magnolia Drive Fort Pierce, Florida 33482 ~lay 12, 1986 Board of County Commissioners St. Lucie County, Florida 2300 Virginia Avenue Fort Pierce, Florida 33482 Gentlemen: Re .- Change in Zoning Request - Lot 8 & 9 Block 33, Indian River Estates Unit 4 We own and reside in our home located at 4703 Magnolia Drive Indian River Estates - Lot 10, Unit 4, Block 34. , We bought this property and built our home here because of the country atmosphere and because it was a RESIDENTIAL ONLY AREA. We do not want, let me repeat, DO NOT WANT, the above subject property rezoned for business of any type. The new shopping plaza lo .- ~opp!ng plaza to be com, l:+~c~d at Mldwa~ Road and U.S. I . ~reet which Will hou~ ['~¥.~"'~ ~all a snort distance ~,,+~n~t~e new than takes c,~: ~ ^..~= ~.r??l~, ~a/green's and n~h~. ~Y~? ~ ~asy · --~ ~, uur neighborhood nee~ ~ ~_~,,~- ~r~p ShOps more ~s being requested, and more and more of--'these~' smal]rez°n~ngshoppingC°ntinUeSstripsaS are it built, soon each household will have its own little_ shopping plaza! We d__~o not_ need or want the rezoning of this property in question. WE WANT THIS AREA TO STAY RESIDENTIAL AS THE NOllE OWNERS THOUGHT IT WOULD BE AND EXPECTED IT TO REMAIN. Very truly yours, Thomas E. Walton Margaret H. Walton 4703 Magnolia 'Drive Fort Pierce, Florida 33482 BLOCK 33, /90AD iNTERsECTiON CN 'ICOMA{ERCI~L NEIGHBORHooD).~ ,' .. ' ,~ ADDREss PETITION 0F OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, -OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF ~AGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) TO CN (COM51ERCIAL NEIGHBORH00D) . ! / NAS~E (PRINT) ! ADDRESS / SIGNATURE WE, TI~I~ UNDI~RSIGN~ID, OBJECT 70 THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE BLOCK 33,~ INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF :lt/IAGNOLIA DRIVE WHITE ¢I%'"/ ROAD' INTERSEC~TiON) PRONI RS-Z(RESIDENTIAL.SING~ FANILY 2) CN (C 0NIIkIERCIAL. NEIGHBORH 00D ). NANIE (PRINT) ADDRESS // NAME ( I~R IN T ) ADDRESS CN (C OM~RC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS WE,~ THE UNDERSiGNED~ OBJECT' TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND BLOCK 33, INDIAN RiveR~ ESTATEs UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLiA DRivE AND, WHITE CITY ROAD INTERsECTioN) FROM RS-2(RESiDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) T0 CN (COMMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE ~PETITION OF.. 'OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FRON RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY CN (C 0NM~ERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NA~E PETITION OF OBJECTORS, WE, THE OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING C~RANGE OF LOT' BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA WHITE CITY ROAD FR0~ RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY CN (C0~4N~RC ~AL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS gm WE, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING .CHANGE OF LOT BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER 0F NAGNOLIA DRIVE WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM R-S-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) CN (C 0M51ERC IAL NE IGHB'ORH00D ) . NANE (PRINT) ADDRESS y PETITION OF oBjEcToRs. E, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT T0 THE PROPOSED_ ZONING CHANGE OF LOT BLOCK 33, iNDIAN RIVER ESTATES uNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF ~GNOLIA WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS PETITION OF OBJECTORS WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2 (RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). PRINT NAME ADDRESS SIGNATURE CN (COM~ERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). N~,~E (PRIN~') ADDRESS PETITION 0F OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJEOT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING 0HANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE 00RNER OF ~AGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C05~MERC IAL NEIGHBORHOiOD). NA~E (PRINT) I ADDRESS SIGNATURE ~ETITI()N OF 0BJECTORS. .___ WE,, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND W ' H1TE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C 0N~fERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NAN[E (PRINT) ADDRE$S ~ ...... oe SIGNATURE PETITION OF. OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33,' INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD: INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . ! NAME (PRINT) I ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS__. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF L0T 8 AND g, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 21) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORH00D). WE. THE- UNDERSIGNED, OB~CT' TO' THE PROPOSE~D ZoNiNG C~NGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK ZNDiAN~ RivER: ESTATES UNIT 4 (NEi CORNER OF ~GNOLIA DRIVE AND' WHITE CITY RO~D~ INTERSEOTION) FROM RS~2(RESiDENTIAL SINGI~ FAMILY 2~) TO CN { COMMERC IAL~ NEiGHBORHooD ). NA~ (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE .PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE CN (COMN~RCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT ADDRESS , pETITION OF. OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED_ ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C 0MMERC IAL NEIGHBORH00D). NANE (PRINT) ADDRESS i SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FRON RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C 0MMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE ¸6. .PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS ISIGNA TURE .PETITION OF. OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C 0M~iERC IAL NE IGHBORHOOD ) . NANE (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE ..PETITION OF. OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND g, BLOCK D3, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF Fk~GNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO ~E PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAM-ILY 2) TO CN (C 0MMERC IAL NE I GHBORHOOD ) . PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMNERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE ,LFid Z2 WE, THE UND BLOCK 33, Ii WHITE CITY CN (C 0MMERC I PETITION OF. OBJECTORS. ERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, 1DIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND {OAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO %L NEIGHBORHOOD) . NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FA~4ILY 2) TO CN (C 0~45tERC IAL NE IGHBORHOOD ) . NANIE (PRINT) ~-- ADDRESS SIGNATURE P~TITION ~ ~0F. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER 0F mGNOLIA DRIVE AND c~ (c o~:~A~ .~o~ooO ). NAN[E (PRINT) ADDRESS ti I SIGNATURE , OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C 0MNERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8~AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS'2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN(COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHLTE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMNERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NA~IE (PR IN T ) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. k WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE O~LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA ~DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . ~~IGNATURE PETITION OF. OBJECTORS__ WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FRON RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) TO CN (COM~tERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NAY~E (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE ge PETITION OF. OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) CN (C 0M~IERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NANE (PRINT) ADDRESS PETITION OF. OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COM~4ERC IAL NEIGHBORH00D) . NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF 0BJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF FAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMNNERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS ! SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF ~GNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) TO CN (C 0MNERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NAS~E (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE m PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). (PRINT)' ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTA~S UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT) Y?ot ADDRESS ~ SIGNATURE ~'~, ~'~ ., PETITION OF OBJECTORS,_ WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C 0MMERCIAL NEIGHBORH00D) . ! NA~E (PRINT) i ADDRESS PETITION OF .OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FRO5{ R-S-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) TO CN (CONNERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NA~IE (PRINT) ADDRESS I SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN(COMN[ERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAME (PRINT)- ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING~CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C OMNERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NAS~E (PRINT) ADDRESS i SIGNATURE e ~ETITION OF OBJECTORS__ WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN(COM~ERCIAL NEIGHBQRHOOD). NA lVlE (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FRON RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C OMMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD ) . NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE .6, WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, .INDIAN RI~R ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE COPd~ER OF MAGNOLIA DR [VE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD) . NA~tE (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FRON RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) TO CN (C 0NNERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD ) . NAN[E (PRINT) ADDRESS i SIGNATURE f PETITION OF OBJECTOR'. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMNERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NMVIE (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. WE,~ THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FRON R-S-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) T07~ (C OML~ERC ILL NEIGHBORHOOD~ ). NANE ADDRESS SIGNATURE ~ETITI.0N OF OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C 0MMERC IAL NEtGHBORH00D) . NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS I SIGNATURE PETITION OF OBJECTORS. E, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE cORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AN~ ~ WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FANILY 2) TO CN (CONMERC IAL NEIGHBORH00D) . NA~ (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE OO L 6, PETITION OF. OBJECTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM R-S-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (C OMMERC IAL NEIGHBORHOOD). NA~E (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE / PETITION OF OBJECTORS. '~rE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE OF LOT 8 AND 9, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF NAGNOLIA DRIVE AND WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS-2(RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2) TO CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORHOOD) · NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS SIGNATURE PETITIONi OF oBjEcTORS. WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT TO THE PROPOSED ZONING, BLOCK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER 0F INTERSECTION) FR0~4 RS-2 (RESIDENTIAL S NA~ ADD2ESS WE, THE PROPOSED. ZONING CHANGE OF LOT B!0CK 33~ INDIAN RIVER ESTATES UNIT 4 (NE CORNER OF MAGNOLIA 1 WHITE CITY ROAD INTERSECTION) FROM RS.2(RESIDENTiAL CN (COMMERCIAL NEIGHBORH00D). NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS L~ BLOCK 33, WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, OBJECT'TO THE PROPOSED B~CK 33, INDIAN RIVER ESTATES uNiT 4 (NE CORNER OF 1 WHITE CITy FRO~ RS-2(RESIDEN.TIAL S CN (C~0~ERC IAL NE IGHBORHOOD ) , NAME (PRINT) ADDRESS ,/ ADDRESS May 14, 1986 Board of County Commissioners 2300 Virginia Avenue Ft. Pierce, Florida 33482-5652 Attention: ~r. J. J. Sciturro, Chairman Dear Sirs: Subject: Andrew CasaiTs Petition for Change in Zoning from R$-2 to CN P~,~ > Lots 8 & 9, Block 33 Indian River Estates, Unit 4 With refer.ence to the above, as owners of residential P~. Lot~5, ~o~ B~Y~w~emy wife Louise and I a~e definitely opposed to Mr. Casai~s petition for such a change. To grant such a drastic change in the zoning law would not only violate St. Lucie County's growth and policy plan, but would definitely decrease our property value as well as all other taxpayer,s property values within the neighborhood. Therefore, why should one taxpayer be allowed to substantially increase the value of his property(just recently acquired) and as a consequence adversely affect the value of so many Single residence property owners? In my opinion, to grant such a request would be outright discrimination. Therefore~ prior to making a decision relative to such an important matter, we request that each of you vote with the,thought in mind as to how you would vote should this same situation be happening in your own back yard or within your neighborhood. We regret that we cannot be present at the public hearing Thursday, May 22, 1986 to personally voice our opposition to Mr. Casai~s unreasonable request, but due to our being out of town on that date, .it will be impossible to attend the meeting. Therefor, we request that this letter be read during the meeting and be in- cor~or~,d~_ .... into all future meetings concerning this matter. ~ ~ ~-~,your cooperation. RETURN RECEIPT REQUES2ED Sincerely yours, Taxpayers, Pt. Lot 5, Lots 6 & 7 4610 Magnolia Drive Ft. Pierce, Florida 33482