Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
California East
4,!:3Ft~ FR, O~ ~ B~,UCE g~ A}3EI~NET"HY JR PA TO 4822131 [~. 02 St. Lu~,ie Count:y Attorney 23,00 Vir,~in:ka Avenue '~:nclos~ pl~as~ £ind a courtesy ~opy o~ ~orres~on~en~e which have no't had an~ re.s~n, se ~rom ~. H,e~s. · , ]F3-r=~::'-~..99e~ iZ:,¢~=.¥',~ FROP~ BRUCE TO August. 20, lg96 4622131 P. 03 · Howard ~..He l~.s, Esq, 900 Eas~ Ocean ~lvd.. ~232 'Stuart, 'Fl 34.99~ Dear Howard~ : Th,~ mm., ming 'I s~oke 'to Gr~ ~og.q~ of Tom Lucido & Ass~iates. .~. ~oggs ,has, re-worked the .si'~e plan to provide for a twenty f~t set ~ck o~, o~ the oa~a.l ~o tho north ~y client gatt Hackle~. is wl.Lli~g to ac~e~t that r~v~$1on to the site ,plan ~ your w~lt w~t,hdr~w t~ei'r pendin~ lawsuit and con~ent to the en~'t~ to & Units ~d prov~s:z,-on for on-,~ite~ retention of .sto~ wa~er) 'at, a 'p~b'llu~ 'hearing before the County ' ' to settle ~onr olient~ oonCern8 Will Be a,c,e~ptabl:e. , TOTFtL P. i~ BOARD OF COUNTY-COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNT.v' FLORIDA · ' ' :,-ETI NG Date- May 21, 1996 Tape: Commissioners Present- Chairman, Sr., Havert L. Fenn, Denny Green, convened: 7- 02 adjourned: 11- 35 po mo '~!iff Barnes; Gary D. Charles, :,en Sattler Others .Present: Tom Ki~ndred, County Administrator; Doug Anderson, Asst. Cou~nty Administrator; Dan McIntyre, County Attorney; Ron Brown, PUblic Works Director; Phil Freeland, Community Development Director; Bill Bla.zak, 'Utilities Dire.ctor; Dennis Murphy, Land Development Manager; .~David Kelly, P' anning Manager; ~Jack Southard, Public Safety Manager; DOn West, County Engineer; Deputy, George .Willi~ams; A. Millie Delgado, Depu~_v Cterk Resolution No. 96-020-/Petition of ~Bart .Hac:kte.y(.l_2.2~19) For consideration before the Board, was staff recommendation to approve t~he resolution finding the =inal Planned Unit Development for Bart' s Bay in substantial conformance with the Preliminary PUD and granting a variance -from r:ke requirements of the Land Development Code, a Final PUD approval and a change in zoning from Hi RD to PUD for a project known as Bart's Bay. * The following persons participating in this issue were sworn in bY the De, puty Clerk. ' Mr. David Kelly, Planning Manager reviewed the issue Mr. Bruce Abernathy Jr., Attorney fcr the petitioner Board on t.his is~sue. , for the Board. addressed the Mr. Greg~ Boggs, La'ndscape Architec5 --or the project Board, s questions. , addressed the Mr. Brett Cutpepper, questions. Culpepper and =~ ~=-pening, addressed the Boards' Mr. Abernathy advised the Board thau problem with the conditions as stated. his client does not have a Mr. Bart Hacktey, petitioner, and advised them of ithe present addressed cos ts he the Board on his request has incurred to this-date. Mr. Brian Kil day, addressed the Board in. opposition to this petition and reviewed R-74-103. Mr.. Nea! Millett, ~address ed the Board in opposition petition and questioned the validation of the vested site Mr. Abernathy, Attorney for the petitioner made his remarks 'and presented an aerial view of the are.a for the Mr. Bria'n Kilday, re-'addressed to this plan. closing record. the Board On-the impoundments. Mr. CM Sanderhall a'ddres sed the Board in opposition project, to this Mr. Brian Proctor, Environmental Specialist this issue. , addressed the Board on Ms the Jane Brooks, representing the Board in opposition.. Conservation Alliance, addressed Mr. William H. Samuel, 'property owner at Coastal Cove, addressed the Board in opposition. Mr. John Reed, Marine Biologist, addressed the Board in opposition. Chairman Barnes addreSsed t~e issue reminding all present that a prior Board in 1'.991 had passed the Ordinance that had a paragraph in it that said "not withstanding, if there was a valid development order, you were then vested,,, this development order does not' have a time limit. If this is passed tonight then there is a.' 2 year limi t. Corn. Green asked a condition be made of the development order that the buffer zone has to be maintained. This is situation that has come back 'to haunt this commission and he cannot see any alterna-tiVe-~.but to approve the petiti.on. Com. Fenn stated that common sense at this .have to' live With something that you do not advi. sed the. Board of the case persons had vestled rights. the "~St. Lucie point dictates totatly agree that wi,th. Com. Sattler recommendati on S e v e n" . He where the court ruled that those He was referring to What is now known as a's ked if it was incumbent to follow staff, s and this would protect the Board. The County Attorney stated that even if staff is 100% wrong and the folks out there are 100% right, it ~oes not necessarily resolve the vested rights issue because there's another level at the court and it i~s his opinion the court would hcld that this project is vested. Com. Barnes asked a condition be aided to read that all required landscaping include, trees, nat~ ye drought tolerant species and Bohia ~rass. Com. Green asked the condition be added regarding all required permits ~be obtained. ~ The COunty Attorney clarified the last condition made by Com. Green, and requested it re'ad, to require the applicant to obtain all applicable permits or easements necessary to construct the project. I t was draft moved by Com. resolution no. Fenn, seconded by Com. Sattler, to approve the 9'6-020~ with a~ n~ .(5) stated conditions; Com. Charles advised the Board' th-- When he first reviewe~d this issue he' had made up his mind-not t,~. support it, however, property owner rights prevail on hi.m and sSnce the County Attorney feels this property is vested, he will vc~e in the affirmative. and; upo~ ...... roll call, motion carried unanimously. %, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION£RS COUNTY ATTORNEY Daniel S. Mclntyre Heather Young ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY James W. Lancaster, Jr. ASSISTANT COUNTY A]-i'ORNEY Renee Clark-Ranich ASSISTANT COUNTy ATTORNEY Howard K. Helms, Esquire 5815 S.E. Federal Highway Stuart, FL- 34997 Bruce Abernethy, Jr., 9'00 Virginia Avenue Fort Pierce, FL 34982 Esquire October 1, 1996 OCT 3-1996 1 COM~'v~UNtl'Y DEVELOPMENT SI. LUCRE COUNTY, FL RE: Bart's Bay - Port Mitigation Project · Gentlemen- _ Enclosed for your information is a copy of a memorandum dated September 23 from County Acquisition A~ent, Belinda Vose, concernin~ the Port Mitigation Project. Please note that the Barr's Bay property is not within the proposed acquisition boundary. Sincerely/ County Atto . DSM/sh Enclosure Copy To- CommissiOner Barnes County Administrator PlanninD ManaDer Port Director Property Acquisition ManaDer HAVERT L. FENN, District No. 1 · KEN SATTLER, District No. 2 · DENNY GREEN, District No. 3 · GARY D CHARLES, SR, District No. 4 · CLIFF BARNES, District No. 5 CoUnty Administrator - Thomas R.L. Kindred 2300 Virginia Avenue · 3rd Floor Admin. Annex · Fort Pierce, FL 34982-5652 ° Phone (561) 462:1415 FAX (561) 462-1440 ° TDD (561) 462-1428 TO' FROM' DATE' PROPERTY ACQUISITION DIVISION MEMORANDUM County Attorney _ Belinda Vose, AcqUisition Agent September 23.., 1996 SUBJECT' Port Mitigation Project Project Update - Status Report There is approximately 151 acres +/- within the mitigation acquisition project. A copy of the map application is attached. proposed port from the permit A parcel lis.ting is also attached for tracking purposes. In regards to Barts Bay, Mr. Hackley does not appear to. own any property within the proposed acquisition boundary to my knowledge and verifying with the property appraisers records. Barts Bay proposed development is located approximately 169.38~ East of the acquisition area. bv cc' Port Director . ! I i I I I I' I · I ; ! i I ; I l.I I ~ L I ~ I - I , ...... l ~ ' I 0 i l I ,' l i l Icl : I '~ : l ~ I · l : I I j I I I J I I i ,t,-t ; I j I~ I I . i.~ I , 1 I I : i/ I Ii i' i, i I I i..'_Ii:: C~ Ii ~ Ii 1~ t.. I I O"l - v.... Ii f'~ ~ ' I ] .... I! c:) .... ! I I I Ii il:" " I: ' I ;' 1 I I I ! . I. :.::.!'.". i. ! ~ :~ ~ .... .... ...:... 9"'-:<:' I :':".'m ~: : :m, [ ":'L:.': ' I :. It !"': 6 '... :':'; I [~R:.:',:7:; [ :'.-: ;[ I i.~.~;:':%':d"::'ll ' '"}L' l I"'.' :: ....... I" I ' , II ; I~ ~ ~ ... : I · ~ Il · I ~~ I ! i I I II .:C~ ~ i I w'll ~ II . : : I ~ I lw~ ' ' I I I .: I ~ I I I I ! I I I I ' I I ~ { I ~ ; I [ I I t : I , t t · r,~ I i'' ~'. ~ I i..:.., r,/3 I t... ~ ! ~ :.....~'t' .'...". ;.' O~ .:'7'r'/.-:':.'' :':i~,.! I ~,, '~:'.".?:.' .:.; .... I ~.../.. -. i~ ~.q cJ.~ .. i OZ '! E,~ ' C~ ' k-il ~.~ -'~I ~ >.t. i r~ I ~' ~ I I~ ~, I ~ I ! I I i I I I I I I I I I I · I !. ~ I ~ I : I-I I I ~ I ~. I I I ! I I I I I I · I ~ 0 ~ , · ~ I I ~ I ~ I 1 I I : - I I I I ~ ~,,-I I .'. I I ~ ' I - I ..... I -...i......!:..i..:, :' ! "'. '!'":': ":: I ,*- : .... ::.; .... I i. [ff'l " ..~: ..... · ...: .... ' ~:: .~ .,' ! I ';2: ..':;:.:::.g;'.:.::'. i ...:.:..-' "! ' ?:"i:':::~::: I ,-',..: :.'. :::: ::::::::::::::::: l ..;.::.'.'..'::E?,!:. I .. ": ,-:..:',~:. !.. ..... . .....¥.....: [ ..... .... ~. '" :3 · . · · : -.. .. i "- .... · :...' : .... · o : 'i 1 . · . !..' '.':... ::. ~ ..-..... ~. '"'I ! ...... '! ' ,' :';.::~:i[::i!/;:I. . ._.:.:. - . .. .. . :- . . ..:.'! · . .. ~ ........ · '.-'-7.:. ..... :.'::?. - .. ..:.... · ! -f::' !' . ...... . · · · , : · · .. .. . : -.':-'-...::,- .... .. · . ./ JACK ISL. AND ADDITION PROPOSED' STRucTUREs i · 1, · ,, }' Nil (",., - ,'......,~,,,.) IN. tn' "1'., ~..,.. ~/,.I1,£ 4t,.,. ' dACK ISLAND ADDITION EX ISTING STRUCTURES -.? // .,,,- -/ ./ .,, · · &' d~p'4'~ · · PE.PPER PARK' EXTENSION PROPOSED sTRucTURES ./ -.I.. m d · .. dl, d~ d4' ' lV',,k v et ~. %v,k.y ..,/ ,/ , · dC) ,) &, p'qp PEPPER PARK EXTENSION E~iSTING STRUCTURES _ h&& d~, C~Ovb, · · ~ 4,1 44 IN THE CIRC~T COURT IN THE NINE~EN~ JUDIC~ CIRCUIT IN AND FOR ST. LUCIE COUNTY NORTH BEACH ASSOCIATION OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY, INC., and IC BRIAN KILLDAY, Plaintiffs, VS. ST. LUCIE COUNTY, and BART HACKLEY, Defendants. TO: Thc .Honorable Cliff Barnes 2300 Virginia Av~ 3rd Floor, Admin. Annex Fort Pierce, Florida 34982 A lawsuit has been filed against you. You have 20 calendar days after this summons is served on you to file a written response to the attached complamt~-"'~"~"~'*"~'~'~~ .......... ~e*~'"~'""~"clefl~ ........ oft his' court. A phone call will not protect you. Your written response, including the case number given above and the names of the parties, must be filed if you want the court to hear your side of the case. If you do not file your response on time, you may lose the case, and your wages, money and property_ may thereaRer be taken without timber warning from the court. There are other legal requirements. You'may want ito call an attorney right away. If you do not know an attorney, you may call an' attorney referral S~rvice or legal aid office (listed in the phone book). ~you choose to file a written response yourself; at the same time you file your written ,response to the eom'you mu~t also mail or take a copy of your written response to.. ~Plaintiff/Plainti~ s Attorney" Inamed beloTM. IMPORTANTE Umed ha sido demandado legalmente. Tiene 20 Dias, contados a partir del recibo de esta notification, para contestar la demanda adjunta, pot escrito, y presentarla ante este tribunal. Una llamada telefonica no lo protegera. Si usted desea que el tribunal considere su defensa, debe presentar ~ respuesta pot escrito, incluyendo el numero del caso y los hombres de las partes interesadas. Si usted no contesta la demanda a'tiempo, pud/ese perder el caso y podria set despojado de sus ingresos y pmPiedades, o privado de sus derechos, sin previo aviso del tribunal. Existen otros requiSitos legaleS. Si lo desea, puede usted consultar a un abogado inmediatamente. Si no conoce a un abogado, puede Hamar a una de las oficinas de asistencia legal que aparecen en la guia tdefonica. Si desea responder a la demanda por su cuenta, al mismo tiempo en que presenta su respuesta antel el tribunal, debera usted enviar pot correo o entregar una copia de sue respuesta a la persona denominada abajo como '~Plaintiff/Plaintiff's Attorney" (Demandante o Abogado del Demandante). ' IMPORTANT O · · e Des p ursmtes judicmares ont ete entreprises contre vous. Vous avez 20 journs consecutifs a partir de la date de l'assignation de cette citation pour deposer une reponse ecrite a la plainte cijointe aupres de ce tribunal. Un simple coup de telephone e~ insuffisant pour vous proteger.. · Vous etes· oblige de. deposer votre., wreponse ecrite, avec mention du numero de dosske c~-dessus et du nome des parties nommees ici, si vous shouhaitez que le tribunl entende votre pas telephones). Si vous choisessez de deposer vouS'meme uae reponse ecrite, il vous faudra egalement, en meme temps que cette formalite, fake laint~laintiff's Attorney" (Plaignant ou a son avocat) nOmmae ci-dessous. Howard I~ H~ims Attorney for the Plaintiffs Florida Bar No. 38539 900 E. Ocean Blvd., Ste. 232 Smart, Florida 34994 (561) 221-7795 To Each Sheriff oft he State: YOU ARE COMMANDED to serve.this summons and a copy of the Complaint in this lawsuit on the. above-named Defendant, DATED on .. [~ c,/. , 1996. JOANNE HOLMAN ' CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT By: Deputy Clerk IN THE CIRCUIT COURT IN THE NINE~EN~ JUDIC~ CIRCUIT IN AND FOR ST. LUCIE COUNTY NORTH BEACH ASSOCIATION OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY, INC., and IC. BRIAN KILLDAY, Plain , VS. JUDGE: '.'. · ST. LUCIE COUNTY, and BART HACKLEY, Defendants. COMP~~T V aint , NORTH BEACH ASSOCIATION OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY, AND I~B~ KILLDAY, through their undersigned counsel sue ST. LUCIE COUNTY and BART HACKLEY and allege: NATURE OF ACTION . 1. TMs is an action for declaratory and injunctive relief under the Gro~ Management Act, Chapter 163, Part II, Florida Statutes (1995), challenging a final development order issued by St. Lucie County for Barr's Bay because the order is inconsistent with the St. Lucie County Comprehensive Plan and materially alters the intensity of use on the property. The r~lief' requested is invalidation oft he development order. BACKGROUN!~_ 2. Defendant, BART HACKLEY, is the owner of a pared of land proposed to be developed as Ban's Bay located in St. Lucie County, Hofida, more particularly described as: 'The Easterly 467.90 feet of the Westerly 637.28 feet of Tract "C" of Coastal Coves, Unit 1, according to the Plat thereof~ as recorded in Plat Book 10, at Page 71, of the public records of St. Lucie County, Florida. Ban's Bay, as approved on May 21, 1996, consists of a six single-family home Planned Unit Development on 1.23 acres total, including setbacks, drainage, and road. The site is on a narrow strip of filled land bordered by a state owned mangrove salt marsh (Aquatic Preserve, Outstanding Florida Waters) to the south and an approximately 40 years old manmade canal with established mangroves on the north. A portion 0fthe property, may consist of illegally filled wetlands. An investigation is being undertaken by the Army C°rp of Engineers and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection to determine whether enforcement will be necessary. The Development Order aflows for storm water discharge through an outflow pipe directly into the Indian River Aquatic Preserve, which is classified as OUtStanding Florida wat'~rs. The plan allows for 71% impervious area with a 13.5 foot setback from the. Indian River Lagoon on the north side and only a 5 to 10 foot setback from the Indian River Lagoon on the south side. STANDING/P/~RTm~e 3. The Plaintiff; .IC BRIAN KiLLDAY, owns property and resides in a single family home located at 923 Jackson Way, Fort Pierce, Florida. The PlaintiWs residence is located across the canal from Ban's Bay. 4. Plaintifl~ NORTH BEACH ASSOCIATION OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY, INC., is a corporation existing under Florida law which represents persons who own property on North Hutchinson Island and in the immediate vicinity ofBart's Bay. . 5. Plaintiffs are aggrieved or adversely affected parties as defined in Section 163.3215, Florida Statutes, because they :or the persons they represent will attfer adverse effects to interests protected or fiuxhered by the adopted St. Lucie County Compreh~~e Plan, as amended, including but not limited to interest related to health and safety, intensities of development, or environmental or natural resources. o These interests are shared in common with other members of the community at large but exceed in degree the general interest, in community good shared by all persons because of the circumstances of the Platn' tit~. 7. Defendant, ST. LIJc~ COI~TY, is a political subdivision of the State of Florida. Through its County Commission, agencies and employees, the County is responsible for implementing the requirements oft. he Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act, Chapter 163, Part II, Florida Statutes (1995'), including the statutory requirement to ensure that all development orders approved by the County, and its agencies and employees, are consistent with its adopted comprehensive plan. 8. Defendant, BART .HACKLEY, is the owner of the property which is the subject of this Suit. Defendant, BART HACKLEY, is the applicant for the Planned Unit Development known as Bart's Bay. · ~--~ ~--'ii_ -~' 9. Plaintiffs-bring this action against the County pursuant to Section 163.3215, Florida Statutes (1995), which authorizes actions for injunctive relief. Venue of this action lies in St. Lucie County because the project is located there and the order was issued by St. Lucie County. ~ LOCAL C~VERNMENT COMPREHENSIVE 10. Chapter 163, Part Il, Florida Statutes, the Local Government ' Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act ("Act"), requires each 'local government in Florida to prepare and adopt a local comprehensive plan containing mandatory elements that address important issues such as land use, traffic circulation, conservation, coastal zone management and the adequacy of fac'flities and infrastructure. 11. After a local government has .adopted its comprehensive x' plan, section 163..3194(1Xa) of the Act requires that all actions taken'by the local government in regard to development orders be Consistent. with the adopted local comprehensive phn. 12. Section 163.3194(3) defines "consistency" as follows: (a) A developm~t or land development regulation shah be consisten with the co' reh, ~e~(il"' sive I ' ' t ~ rap. . p an if the land uses densities or' ' ' ill r . , mtensit~es, and other, aspect of deyelopment permitted by such order or re-mi~ auon', are c~ompat~le with and timber the objectives ,,olicieo cmena enumerated by the local government (b) A development, approved or undertaken by a local government shah be consistent with tile comprehensive plan if the land uses, densities or mtensitxes,, capac~.. :..,,~,or sine, tuning, or other aspects of the development are compatible wl~ or further the objectives, policies, land ut~.es and densities- or intensities in the comprehensive plan and if it meets ~11 other criteria, enumerated by the local government.' 13. The Act provides for citizen enforcement of the consistency requirement. Section 163.3215(1) provides that "any ~aggrieved or adversely affected party" may bring a cml action for injunctive or other relief against ~any local government to prevent the local government "from taking any action on a development order. . which materially alters the use or density or intensity of use'' On the tract °fproPerty in a manner that is nOt consistent with tho. ~,,,~, m~ ~..op,.a ~ocal comprehensive plan. 14. As a condition precedent to seeking jUdicial reliefpursuant to section 163.3215(1), an aggrieved or adverSely affected party must, in accordance with section 163.3215(4), file a verified complaint with the local government. The verified complaint must be filed within thirty (30) days at, er the local government has.taken the allegedly inconsistent action regarding a development order. The local government ~en has thirty (30) days within which to respond to the verified complaint af[er which time the aggrieved or adversely affected party must institute its court action within thirty (30) days. 15. Pursuant to the requirements of the Act, the County adopted the St. Lucie County Comprehensive Plan ('~ ompreh~~e.i Plan"). 16. The parts of the adopted St. Lucie County .Plan, as amended, with which the development order for Bart's Bay as approved on May 21, 1996, are inconstant include but are not limited to the plan provisiOns discussed at public hearings on this applicatiOn before the Board of County Commissioners and Pl~g and Zoning Board, including provisions in the plan which are designed and intended to, and do: A. Ensure a high quality living environment through a mixture of land uses that will .enhance St. Lucie County's natural and manmade resources while minimizing any threat to the · health, safety, and welfare of the county's citizens through incompatible land uses.and environmental degradation. B. Regulate the use of land and water consistent with aH elements of the St. Lucie County Comprehensive Plan, to ensure the compatibility of adjacent land uses and provide for adequate open space. Protect remaining native plant communities within the County. Protect and preserve wetland and upland habitat. Require that necessary environmental assessments be submitted in .writing to the Board of County Commissioners for review prior to their making a determination regarding any proposed development. Iq Require that all. development concepts that propose to impact wetland habitat shall be consistent with all applicable Federal. State and County regulations. L. Provide that existing on-site native upland habitat be incorporated into required site' plans as a part of open space areas, required landscaping or as a part of minimum yard areas so that as much of the identified habitat as is practicable is maintained. M. Eliminate or reduce uses inconsistent with the provisions of the Comprehensive Plan unless otherwise referenced through the vesting of development fights, N. Require a 10' landscaping strip on the perimeter of the property adjacent to public rights-of-way. O. Provide for a storm water drainage and management system that meets existing and future needs of the commtmity. P. Regulate development to protect land use and the functions of natural groundwater recharge areas. Q. Restrict development activities where such activities would damage or destroy coastal resources, endanger human life, and increase public expenditures in areas that are subject to destruction by'natural disasters. Protect, conserve, or enhance the natural resources of the coastal area and the . C. Protect those areas designated for Conservation purposes or that contain other special environmental habitat as identified in the Future Land Use and Other elements of the St. Lucie County Comprehensive Plan. D. Regulate areas subject to seasonal and periodic flooding and provide for drainage and storm water management. E. 'Ensure safe and convenient on-site tra~c flow and vehicle Parking needs. F. Require through the County's Land Development Regulations, that aH new development be compatible with surrounding land uses, both existing and future. G. Conserve open space and environmentally sensitive areas through: 1. The establishment of minimum acreage requirements necessary to support a viable mixed use commtmity proving sttfficient design flexibility to aHoTM innovation and creativity in all forms of planned unity developments. Planned Um't DevelOpments require a minimum often (10) contiguous acres of land under common ownership or control. Thirty-five (35) percent of the gross area of land must be used as parks, recreation areas, marinas, swimming beaches, open space, planting, or other public purposes other than right-of-way, above ground utilities, and parking areas. 2. The establishment of minimum open space standards and ratios of 30% or greater in aH planned unit developments assurances on the part of the developer that such areas will remain as open 'space to protect, existing native habitat, to provide for minimum setback needs from adjacent uses, and to provide active and passive recreational as well as visual amenities. 3. The establishment of provisions ensuring the long term preservation of remaining open spaces. He Protect remaining native plant communities within the County. Protect and preserve wetland and.upland habitat. Require that necessary environmental assessments be sub~¢d in writing to the Board of COunty Commissioners for review prior to their making a determination regarding any proposed development. K~ Require that all development concepts that propose to impact wetland habitat shall be consistent with aH applicable Federal, State and County regulations. L. Provide that existing on-site native upland habitat be incorporated into required site plans as-a part of open space areas, required landscaping or as a part of minimum yard areas so that as much of the identified habitat as is practicable is maintahed. M. Eliminate or reduce uses inconsistent with ~e provisions of the Comprehensive Hah unless otherwise referenced through the vesting of development rights. N. Require a 10' landscaping strip on the perimeter of the property adjacent to public fights-of-way. O. Provide for a storm water drainage and management system that meets existing and future' needs of the community. P. Regulate development to protect land use and the functions of natural groundwater recharge areas. Q. Restrict development activities where such activities would damage or destroy coastal . resources, endanger human life, and increase public expenditures in areas that are subject to destruction, by natural disasters. Protect, conserve, or enhance the natural resources of the coastal area and the environmental, social, and economic benefits atm'buted to them. S. Protect, conserve, or enhance coastal uplands, wetlands, and native plant commmfities within the County. T. Require a no net loss ofexisthg wetlands. 13. Require a minimum fii~ (50) foot buffer zone of native upland and transitional vegetation along rivers, creeks, and estuaries. V. Require prelimina~ site plan information documenting the location and extent of wetlands located on the property. Require a ten (10) square feet per linear foot of wetland buffer zone of native upland edge (i.e., transitional) vegetation maintained around isolated Wetlands on new development sites. W. Require the applicant to submit preliminary,, drainage information that is to be submitted to the South Florida Water Management District. X~ Ye Require the restoration of disturbed wetlands. Protect, conserve, and enhance marine resources. Z. Require comprehensive storm water management, including the use of detention and/or retention. AA. Lessen the adverse effects which adjacent developments might have on managed conse~ation areas and Outstanding Florida Waters. BB. Provide vehicular and pedestrian access to aH public, active, recreation facilities, inclUding beaches and shores. 17. As referenced above, the Comprehensive Hah objective is.to reduce uses inconsistent with the provisions of the Comprehensive Plan unless otherwise referenced through the vesting of development rights. BaR's Bay was not vested. On May 21, 1996, the County Commission unanimously agreed that the project did not conform to the land development code and that it is a '%ad" development. .The Commission voted to approve the project based on County staff's claim that the original 1979 site ~lan was presu~tively vested under section 11 09.03 E. of the Land DeveloPmen~ Code. ' However, sections 11 that "Ia]ny person application for a V~ application fOr a. Vesl 1991. Except as within the required rights." The applicant vested fights was ~ 9.03 A. & B. of the Land Development Code clearly state vested fights to develop property sh~ make Rights Special Use Permit pursuant to ~s Section... An Rights Special Use Permit shall be filed by August 1, in subsection 4 below, failure to file an application ~d ~ constitute an abandonment of any claim to vested to submit said application and therefore the claim to The County' the section to this 'set forth in section 11. Development Order-, unexpired Final approved under such made by.the issue the Vested Rights provisions in Section !1 Use Permit be applied The County's forever is also in Section 11.09.03 F. issued a Vested Rights been required to submit commenced and is Permit would have only development is subject Notwithstanding the development right as letter, Mr. Boggs writes for twelve section 11.09.03 E, and inappropriately applied That section states that "[n]otwithstan~g the criteria 03(C) above, possession ora valid unexpired Final the applicant was not in possession ora valid Order) Shah presumptively vest the development · .. Verification of such approvals or vermits shall :: y, men~t Di[.e,c, to_r. If verified, the Director shall ~ t use ~'enmt. Nothing in this sectiOn nullifies the 9.03 B which req&res that the Vested Rights Special by August 1, 1991. Emphasis added. the applicant's site plan is presumptively vested with respect to the intent of this code as witnessed section states that had Mr. Hackley filed forand~been ~ Use Permit by 1991 as required, he would have reports that would evidence that development has in good faith. The Vested Rights Special Use valid for five (5) years. After that time, the building standards. 11.09.03 F. the applicant waived any purported claim to a vested in Mr. Greg Boggs' letter to Mr. Terry Virta. In the tYl may also note that this property was approved in 1980, which by way ora variance to submit as a P.U.D. in July 1993 has since been abandoned. Furthermore, Land Development Code resolution number 74-103, as amended .8/20/74, states that "[i]f~ at any time during the valid approval periOd for a site plan, majority deVelopment ownership (51 percent or more) changes, approval of the site plan shall be automatically terminated. Said plan autom~tically terminated 'due to.the fact that the m~jority Ownership has changed. MI ~~L~- ~-.~ iTI_~ 18. The Defendants posted a misleading public notice sign. The public was mislead into thinking that Bart: Hacldey was applying for a. "v~ce fi'om Section 6. 02. 02(c)"ofthe St. Lucie County Land Development COde for a 35' setback which lacks 15' of the required 50' setback". In actuality, Bart Hackley applied for and was granted a 13.5 ' setback which lacks 36.5' of the req~ed 50' setback. , 19. Plaintiffs have Completed and .satisfied aH statutory and Other conditions precedent to the filing of.this suit. Pur~~t t° Section 163.3215, Fla. Stat. (1995), Plaintiffs filed a Verified Complaint with St. Lucie County on June 19, 1996. The County rejected the.Plaintit~s claim and filed a response to that effect on or about July 19, 1996. 20. Plaintiffs will be harmed by the Defendants' actions and by the County approving the development order. 21. Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law other than the statutory proceeding contained in-this complaint. · WHEREFORE, Haintiffs request that this Court grant the Plaintiffs a trial de novo on the application fOr development order ofBart's Bay as provided by law, determine that the County's 10 approval of the development order is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan, enjoin the operation oft he development order and rescind its effectiveness, and grant such other relief as is provided by law or that the Court deems appropriate. Respectfiffiy SUbmitted this 19th day of August, 1996. Howard K. Heims Attorney for the Plaint'ffi's Florida Bar No.' 38539 900. E. Ocean Blvd., Ste. 232 Smart, Florida 34994 (561) 221-7795 VERIFICATION STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF ST. LUCIE tq BRIAN KILLDAY, individually and as representative of NORTH BEACH ASSOCIATION OF ST. 'LUCIE COUNt, INC. By: Sworn to (or a~ed) and subseribed before me this 19fl~ day of August, 1996, by I~ BRIAN KILLDAY. Personally known _ .~"~ or produced identification · . · Type of identification produced _:~ ~/~~ ~.. ..... ANNA ROSE NEVILLE MY COMMISSION # CC477359 EXPIRES September 15, 1999 BONBF.0 ~'HRIJ TROY FAIN INSURANCE, 11 BRUCE R. ABERNETHY, JR., P.A. ATTOR NEY AT LAW 900 VIRGINIA AVENUE PROFESSIONAL CENTRE, SUitE 6 FORT PIERCE, FLORIDA 34982 TELEPHONE (561) 4894901 October 24, 1996 Howard K. Heims, Esq. 900 E. Ocean Blvd., Suite 232 Stuart, FL 34 994 Dear Howard: I am writing to you in response to your letter of October 14, 1996, as well as to advise you of certain other relevant matters. In response to your letter dated October' 14, 1996, Dan McIntyre has suggested, and I agree, that there is no mechanism available in the County Zoning Ordinance to suspend or toll the current site plan clock while the court proceedings are' stayed. Notwithstanding that, Mr. Flackley agrees t~ a temporary stay while s.ettlement negotiations are pending. We of course reserve the r.zght to petition the court at any time to lift the stay due to the continuing damage that Mr. Hackley will sustain as a result of the curren-t running of the "clock" on his currently approved` site plan. It is my understanding that Mr. Killday is working with various public agencies to try to coordinate a public acquisition of Mr. Hackley's tract. I have indicated to all parties that Mr. Hackley ~.s willing to sell the property for a fair and reasonable price. While I have discussed Mr. Hackley · s compensation parameters with him and am aware of his requirements, I will refrain from discussing those sales parameters until such time as -- we receive reasonable assurance that a public agency is ready, willing, and able to acquire the property on a timely basis, in which case we will deal directly with the acquisition agency in discussing appropriate terms and conditions. Irt the meantime, in~ an effort to follow through with and imploment, the compromiso proposal wh±ch was proposed to you and your clients some time 'ago, Mr I'Iackle7 on October 23, 1996, filed an application for a major adjustment to his site plan. That application will be considered by the Board of County commissioners at-a future public hearing. A copy of the application and the revised, plan are._.enclosed with this letter for your review with your clients. You will note that the revised site plan proposes the implementation of the compromise position which was previously related to yOu, i.e., reduction in density from 6 units to 4 units, provision for on site water retention, and increase of the canal set back to 20 feet. ~~.., ~)~~...~~ Howard K Heim.s,. Esq- October ~.~, '1996` Page 2 As'I discussed with you before, I believe roposa{ is. an extremely reas~~A that Mr. Hackley's ~cc°mm°date your client~' c_ ~~e c~promise and should ~ oncerns witn respect to this development. We'are of course hopefuI that wit to the'isite nlan ....... ~.2_ ~ .~ . h the major revisio = , ~uu~ u~en~s woulu reconsider the activ~ of the ponding lawsuit and would consider withdrawing same, although we realize that that decision is totally, up to your clients, and we cannot control same. In. any event, I trust that you and your clients will recognize that Mr."Hackley,s actions in going through the time and expense of revising the site plan constitute a good faith effort to amicably resolve the current differences so as to avoid the continued cost of litigation. If you have any questions or comments regarding these matters, please do not hesitate to give me a call. BRA/j lb Enclosures Sincerely, Br~e~nethy, cc: Mr. Bart Hackley (via Telefax, w/o enc-losures) Dan McIntyre, Esq..~.~-- (w/O enclosures) David Kelly (w/o enclosures) Jr. 900 E. Ocean Bivd,, Ste. 232, Stuart, FL 34994 Bruce 1~ Abernethy, Jr., P.A. 900 Virginia~ Avenue Professional Centre, Suite 6 Ft. Pierce, Florida 34952 Dear Mr. Abemethy: TEL. (561) 221-7795 · FAX ' - i...~.~..561, 221-7746 . 'ocr / ""/,. . 0~ober 14, 1996 :. ~'~:.; .,.~'~. COMMUfil~ D[V~LOPMENT ST. LUCtE COUNt, Fk Thank you for your letter of September 20, 1996. I wish to clarify my clients' position with '- respect to the two-year expiration date. The North Beach Association and Mr. KiHday support your client receiving an extension from the county and will assist you in obtaining such. Please let me'know if we can assit you in any way. I apologize if there was a misunderstanding with respec~ to my motion being opposed or unopposed. As the motion states, the parties have stipulated to extend the time for filing papers in this matter, pending the outcome of negotiations between the developer, the reSPondent, and the petitioners. It was: my understanding that the purpose of staying the proceedings was to avoid further costs associated with discovery and litigation. By your letter of September 20, 1996, it is unclear whether Mr. Hacldey ~shes to continue with the court proceedings while negotiations are p .ending. Please confirm your position in this.regard. Again, I would like to thankyou and your client for considering alternatives and an amicable resolution to'this matter. _ Please contact me if you have any questions. Sincerely,- Howard IC He'ni~ HKH/Ig cc: q3~el Mclntyre, 'Esquire Client ZNDIAN RIVER COUNTY S E COU ST. LUCIE BLVD PEPPER PARK PROJECT LOCATION FORT PJ'ERCE INLET RD SON WAY Hi TR. If A il BLK 'T BLK U .BLK V BLK X ",, BLK Y BLK Z JACKSON TR. il AI, BLK T BLK U · BLK V BLK W BLK X BLK Y BLK Z FIRE] STATION PROJE CT LOCATION PEPPER PARK FORT PIERC£ INLEET BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION(ERS September 21, 1993 COMMUNITY 'DEVELOPMENT ADMINISTRATOR TERRY 'L. V1RTA, AICP Mr. Gregory Boggs, as agent for Bart M. Hackley THOMAS LUCIDO& ASSOCIATES, P~4. 1903 S. 25th Street, Suite 100 Fort Pierce, FL 34947 FILE NO, B,4-93.012 Dear Mr,~ Boggs: Co This letter is to confirm that on July 21, 1993, the Board of Adjustment of St. Lucie unty, .Florida, 'approved Resolution 93-21 granting a variance from .the prOvisions of Section 7.01.03(A) of the St. LUcie County Land Development Code, topermit a 1.4 acre Planned Unit Development (PUD) application which lacks 8.6 acres of the minimum 10 acres required for a Planned Unit Development. A copy of recorded Resolution No. 93-21 is enclosed for your information. Sincerely, BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLOR~A Co....lle~en ~ZVa~ho!~Ch.~airr~,~an' ~ ~' CV/dj H: ! WP tCB UR GESS lB OA-DO CS tCONFIRM. RES cc: Community Development Administrator Management Director HAVERT L. FENN, District No. I · JUDY CULPEPPER, District No. 2 · DENNY GREEN, District No. 3 · R. DALE TREFELNER, District No. 4 · CLIFF BARNES, District No. 5 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 34982-5652 · Administrator. (407) 468-159.0 · Growth Management: (407) 468-1553 · Planning: (407) 468-1576 Codes Compliance: (407) 468-1571 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ,13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 42 44 47 48 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT RESOLUTION NO. 93 A RESOLUTION G~NTI V~IANCE FOR CERTAIN P: IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY, File No: BA-93-012 WHEREAS, the Board of Adjustment of St. Lucie County Florida, has made the following determinations: 1.) Gregory Boggs, as agent for Bart M, Hackley, has-applied for a variance from the provisions of Section 7.01.03(A), of. the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, to permit an application for a rezoning, to and development ~of a PUD for six single family homes on a parcel of land which lacks 8.6 acres of the 10 acre minimum requirement for PUD zoning: Coastal 'Coves Unit 1, Tract C, Less the west 169.42 feet and the east 150.00 feet, St. Lucie County, Florida. (Location: North Hutchinson Island.; North of Pepper Park, west of A-1-A North) 2.) On July 21,. 1993, the Board of Adj.ustment held a public hearing on the petition after publishing a notice of such 'hearing in the Port St. Lucie News. on June 30, 1993, and notifying by mail all owners of property within 500 feet of the subject property. 3. ) After consideration of the testimony presented during the ~JUly 21, 1993, 'public hearing, including Staff comments and the standards for granting variances set out in S~ection 10.01.02 of.th'e St. Lucie County Land Development Code, the Board of Adjustment has made 'the following findings of fact: a. The variance requested arises from a condition that is unique and peculiar to the land, structures and buildings involved; as a result of the particular physical surroundingS, the shape or topographiCal, condition of the specific property involved, an unnecessary hardship would result for the owner, lessee, or occupant, as ~o 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 2O 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 3O 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 4O 41 42 43 44 46 47 48 distinguished from a mere inconvenience, if the provisions of Section 7.01.03(A), are literallY enforced; and it is a condition that is not ordinarily found in the same Zoning District, and the condition is created by the regulations of Section 7.01.03(A), of this Code, not by an action or actiOns of the property owners or the applicant. The variance will allow the petitioner to' proceed with the submission of an application to the Community Development Department for a- rezoning to a Planned Unit DeVelopment (.PUD) in order to construct six single family homes on this parcel. The property received site plan approval for 12 multi-family,units in 1979. This approval is .still valid, however, it is no longer consistent with the curre Lt Future Land Use designation of RU and the current allow no site. The residenti~ was previ¢ '.RD zoning district for the parcel. Both would ~ore than 7 single family units on the subject oetitioner wishes to develop the property for 1 purposes, but at a density lower than what )usly approved for that site. b. .The granting of this variance would not impair or injure other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the subject property is located, nor impair an adequate supPly of light or air to adjacent public -streetls, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety, or substantially diminish or impair property.values in the neighborhood. c. The variance granted is the minimum variance necessary to be able to apply under 'the PUD designation. d. The variance desired meets.the general spirit and intent of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code and the St. Lucie County Comprehensive Plan. PUD zoning is often a preferred type of development proposal because the flexible design standards in conjunction with a stricter approval' pro6ess can ~be used~ to protect the natUral features Of the property. The granting of a PUD would allow development of this property in a manner which is consistent with the Code and the Comprehensive Plan instead of implementing existing site.plan apProVal which is no longer consistent with current Code requirements. 0 0 0 '3 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 2O 21 22 23 24 25 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of Adjustment of St. Lucie County, Florida, that Gregg Boggs, as agent for Bart M.. Hackley, be granted a variance from the provisions of Section · 7.01.03 (A), of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, to proceed with submission of a PUD application for the subject Parcel which ].acks 8.6 acres of the minimum 10 acre requirement for PUD zoning. This variance will not be valid for a period-longer than twelve months from the date the resolution is adopted unless PUD/site plan approval is issued prior to the expiration of that twelve month period. After motion and second, the vote on this resolution was as follows: Chairman Colleen Vachon ABSENT Trent Ebner AyE Greg Rosslow AYE Larry Jennings AYE Bob Benton AYE O 0 0 0 O~ . 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED this 21st day of July, SECRETARY 1993. BOARD OF ADJUsT~ // s~. ~uc~ cou~.~Y, ~O~'D~ , H: wp \ HACKLEY. RES APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: 0 0 PUBLIC HEARING . GREGORY BOGGS, as Agent for BART HACKLEY FILE NO. BA-93-008 Petition by Gregory Boggs, as agent for Bart Hackley, for a variance fi-om the Provisions .of SectiOn 7.01.03 (A) the St. Lucie County Land Development Code. Ms. Shewchuk presented staff comments. She stated that the petitioner is requesting a variance which Would allow him to submit an application for the rezoning to a Planned Unit Development (PUD) in order to develop this prope.rty for six single family homes on a parcel with less .than ten acres which .is the minimum requirement for a POD under the current Land Developme~ Code. She added that she ~cluded in the agenda packets a copy of the site plan that was a 6 single family homes as name of Hackley Apartm~ is no longer consistent wit current HIRD..zoning whi{ acre site. ~pi'oved in 1973 and a copy of the conceptional site plan for the ~roposed. The_ property received site plan approval, under the nts for 12 multi'family units. This approval, which is still valid, the current RU land use designation on the property and the 'would not allow no more than 7 single, family units on the 1.4; Ms. Shewchuk stated that' current zoning and land us, more design flexibility with shape with .an available lo family homes'under the no] requirement, the petitionex the access, and the placing. to the County. in addition to bringing the development in compliance with requirements, the PUD designation would allow the petitioner. regard to the developable area. The. property has a.long narr°w width of 115 feet and does not all°w for' developing 6 Single real RS-4 zoning requirements. She added that'under the'P~ would have the flexibility to be more creative with the lot sizes, ~f the homes on the lots, It would also give more review.control Ms. Shewchuk stated that single family homes are family units. She stated th~ ' Lucie CoUnty Land Develo the development of the pro/ current land use.' The PU because the flexible design County can be used to pr maximum potential. ',taft feels that the impacts on public faci~ties'-generated by six ected to be much less than impacts generated by twelve multi- t the proposed variance is consistent with the intent of the St. >ment Code and the Comprehensive Plan since it would bring erty who compliance With the current code, Current zoning, and D 'zoning is often a Preferred type of development proposal mndards in conjunction with a stricter approval process by the ~tect natural features of the property and develop it to its Mr, Greg Boggs, agent for petitioner, appeared before the Board. He stated that Mr. HaCkley could not be present because he resides in PalTM Desert Ca" to make the tri Mr' B . _,~ . . · .~ ._ , lifomla and was unable ~ .~ - , .P...~.. ogg~ passed out p~ctures to. tl~e Board and st ~' tor the Board s ermissio ' _ . . . ..: ated that he is askin . P , n tO subrmt a PUD to. the Coun Co ' ' g was. just before this Board last'' ~ ~.,.~- -~ . '.~ ", ty ~ ~SSlOn, He added that h~ ~ ~ , .~ ~. ., .~ .year-'m, a project oy the name of Whim ; Which he received the Boards ~errhiSsion to .qnh"';, ~,,,.-.. . . . b. rel, Landmgs ' - . - .... ,,,. ,~ PUD. This project ~s s~milar in lot size .BOARD OF ADJij.~' APPROVAL and potential architect style? ti, FFI £ ~[IBJECT TO BOARD OF ADJUS'i'i:?tEN1r A?PROVAL Mr. Boggs stated that unfortunately'the lot width is' 115 feet. In straight zoning it has to be 100 feet of lot length by 75 foot width. In addition to lot size, a50 foot right-of-way is needed, which is not available, ln. order to proceed, the only flexibility currently existing in the code is through a PUD-. He added that would give more flexibility providing an access lane, probably a 25 foot access easement that will allow access out to X-1-A. He stated that Mr. Hackley would abandon his multi family twelve unit approval to go with six single family lots for detached single family residences. :Mr. JenningS stated his concern about the location and width of a necessary utility easement due to the narrow width of the property. · Mr. Boggs replied that 5 feet from the access easement and an additional 5 feet from the front yard would be designated as utility and drainage easement. · Mr. Rosslow asked about 'the location of Whimbrel Landing. Mr. Boggs stated that. it was tract 16, just to the north. · Mr. Neil Miller, 910. Jackson Way, stated that he is against the petition because fr . at the PUD it re uires: ~ ' ~ om lookin ~ · , .. q . 10 acres so the development could be condensed housing' e sp~ ~nd~~e.e.lan.? so~e.wherep!se. He stated that Whimbrel Landings does have-msin°~ll lOts, ouz~ou, out tla:ey do have retention ponds'; however, this development wil1 have no room to put those things in. Mr. Lan. y Stewart s. taed th From information that the,. at they have five condominiums in Phase I, of California East. have,. Mr. Hackley owns the property were-.the X is located. ~rvey, his deed states that some of the property shown under X ~. and Mr. Hackley has no access to his property. Mr. Stewart goes to the south' side Of the highway where the fire station is. Mr. Hackley tried to get an easement for'right-of, way to that property? : Vice-Chairman RoSslow replied as far as he knows, Mr. Hackley has not obtained easement for right-of-way, and stated that Mr. Boggs is 'here 'to ask .that this Board allow him to go for a PUD, and that tiffs Board is not. approving.anything that he has drawn or anything he has done. Ms. Shewchuk stated that staff brought the access issue to Mr Bo s attent' information ha ' . i~ .. .' · gg ion and that the s been forwarded to 1 ~ - .,, ~ ' : . :~ . p anmng staff where the actual PUD will be reviewed Before the place could pro~ess to actual PUD stage, issues sUch as acces ' ' resolved. - s-wail have-to be .. Mr. Stewart asked what is thiS Board looking for .in order to approve or disapprove the variance? Vice-Chairman Rosslow stated that this Board is allowing him to go to the next step. Mr. Stewart stated that personally he is not objecting as long as he is going to do what he says. Ms. Mary Spagnola, 3401 N. A-l-A, spoke next in opposition to the extent of the variance. She also pointed out that there are mangroves on the property, and bkd cages, which all may be destroyed, ' ~t~,.oh ~...~..o.,a,e .~ ,_ ~oanuernor~,hv ff it is34'09 N. A-l'A,zonedStatedfor that he has two urdts in the south buildine.o He wondered w_~ currently twelve units, does it have to go for a PUD rating in order to build sk? What is the difference between the existing zoning and the PUD rating? Ms. Shewchuk answered that the current zoning is RS'4, which means single family 'residential 4 units to the acres. The twelve units come from a site plan approval that he received in 1973 to build twelve units on this property. That site plan is valid so ff he decided/ tomorrow, he can go ahead and'build twelve units. · ~. Sanderhoff asked by switching to PUD, does that invalidate the original agreement? Ms, Shewchuk replied that approval of the PUD would invalidate the existing approval of the twelve un/ts. The new site plan approval 'would replace existing approval, The existing site plan approval is inconsistent with the Current zoning, so replacing the old site plan with something new would make it consistent.with, the current zoning and land use which is RS-4. Mr. Sanderhoff confirmed that the existing zoning was RS-4, and that' the size of the property was 1.36 acres which would aH'ow seven(7) shgle family units. Mr. Sanderhoff asked how many maximum units can be put on the property with the PUD zoning. . Ms. Shewchuk replied, that the applicant was asking for approval of Residences. Single Family V/ce-Chairman Rosslow stated for the record that there were eleven responses which had been received from adjacent property owners regarding the petition. Two were in favor of the petition, eight were not in favor of the. petition, and one had. no opinion on the petition. A-gentleman from the audience stated that he was in the planning office and noticed more than eight (8) letters opposing t~s petition. Ms. Shewchuk stated that aH response notices UNOFFICL L SUBJECT 'TO BOARD, OF ADJUS1'/¥I~'NT AP, PRO~IAL ....... ' ' SUBJECT TO AP.PROVAL. ~ere cou~ted, but s~e would c~ecE t~¢ fi]¢ for t~s letter. ~ead~ no £urthe~ comment j~ £a¥or of or j~ opposJtJo~ to the ~¢fidon, ¥ice-ChaJ~an Ore~ Rosslo~ closed.:' the .pubic potion of t~e heaz~. YJce-C'~akmm~ Ross]ow asked £o~ Board comments. Mr. Benton stated that nersonallv h,~ m....~ .,__, .... . ~ r ~:~ ~ ~. ua~u me mea oecause the dens~tyis being dropped and. that he would rather see Single Family-Residences than multifamily'houses. Mr. Jennings stated that in consideration of the Property owner, this is a uni u He wants to do sOmethin~ ~th his ~,ro-,-,-.-*-. *---- ,-~ -'-'~- '-- . _ .~ _ q e situation. · o, v v,-. ~ om n~ ~s.connnecl oy limits of the property. In - order to gain access with ~s i'oad and put Something on there, it is understandab ' is asking for the PUD The de---:*":'-2' _,__. ~' ....... ,. . le Why he · · . ,,~,ty naa mso oroppea'considerabl from approval is therefore ~ ,.,~...:./;.. :_ ,,_ .... .~: .:. _. Y what the resent , ~ , he io ,,,,. tanny m mvor or neJpmg this situation. P Mr. Ebner stated that it would be to all resident's advantage to allow a PUD, because a PUD is so restricted and t~ere Co~ssioners' review of th will be an oppommiW, to bring up at. the Board of County e PUD all the items that have been-brought up on front of the Board of Adjustment, such,as the easement' for drainage and utilities. He. added that all of this is taken into consideration and makes a very safe develOpment for property valUes and owners. Mr. Ebner stated ~his is much better than building the twelve units, from an Old site plan. Vice-Chairman Rosslow asked' staff for a recommendation. Ms. Shewchuk stated that staff recommends approval, of-this petition. After considering the test comments, and the Standm County Land Development approve the petition of Gre provisions of Section 7.01.0: application fOr a rezoning te six single family homes on fl reqUirement` fo'r.PUD.zoning' motion and upon roll Call' tl~ Vice-Chairman Rosslow approved. ~ony presented during the Public Hearing, including staff. ds of Review as set forth in Section 10'01.00 of the St. Lucie 2ode, Mr. Ebner made a motion that the Board of Adjustment gory Boggs, as agent for Bart Hackley fora variance from the (A) .the St' Lucie County Land Development Code, to Permit and, development. .°f a Planned Unit Development (p~) for parcel of land which lacks 8.6 acres of the 10 acre minimum , based on the. above stated reasons. Mr. Benton seconded the te Board voted unanimously ~n favor of the motion. informed the .agent for the petitioner that his petition had been ATTENTION: .MIKE,. ~WERS · BOB SIGNATURE PLE~E RETURN ~ DIV- SO IT C~ BE ADDED TO T~ . DATE SI YOU. { d e s c.r~i prop .e. rt~: -CALIFORNIA EAST aka BARTLEY HACKLEY ST, LUCIE COUNTY AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLIC NOTICE I, _ , do hereby certify that as Agent for the St. Lucie County Board of Adjustment on the following described property: ~C_ ALI~FOR__N IAi. E~~EY __ HAC_KLEY NORT_H_.OF H__U_TCHI_N_SON IS_LANDL NORTH OF PEPPER ~__PARK .... WES~Q?_A-1-A NOR~ __. ~ _ _ _T_H N~~E_DS TO BE UP B_~ _0_7.-05-9~_) I did on , 19~, erect in a conspicuous place on this property the following notice: PUBLIC NOTICE PUBLIC HEARING OF THE ZONING ORDINANCE ON THIS PROPERTY TO CONSIDER A VARIANCE TO ST LUCIE ~OUNTY LAN~ DEVELOPMENT CODE WILL BE HELD IN THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, 2300 VIRGINIA AVENUE, ROOM 101, (lST FLOOR), FT.PIERCE 9:30 A.M. ON 07-21-93 BEFORE THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT. PETITION IS AVAILABLE IN ROOM 203. Signature Date WAY TR, BLK T ~ . I BLK U BLK V BLK W BLK .X " BLK Y BLK Z DEP~~~' OF COMMUNrIY DEVEI~PME~ BOA 93-012 CALIFORNIA EAST M E M.'O R.A-N D U M TO' FROM - DATE GROWTH MANAGEMENT TECHNICIANS PLANNING & ZONING SECRETARY ~ SUBJECT- POSTING .OF PUBLIC NOTICE FOR PETITION OF ~reg Boggs as agen% for Hackley fOr a varianco from tho provisions of Soctiol 7.01.03(A) of tho St. - Lucie County Land, Development Code,' to permit a 1.24 acre _ 'Planned Unit Development (PUD) application which lacks 8.7'6 acres of the min~um 10 acres required for a Planned unit Development _ THE ABOVE PETITION. IS SCHEDULED FOR PUBLIC HEARING/ ' oN THE FOLLOWING DATE - .~^ - BOARD OF AD~STMENT ................. - .... .. PLANNING & ZONING ' ., BOARD 'OF cOUNTy CO~SSIONERS PLEASE IMPLE~NT THE POSTING OF 'P~LiC NOTICE BY PUBLIC WORKS North 'Hutchinson of A-1-A north) I.sland; North of Pepper Park, west THANK YOU. , H: \wp\tech- s .mere BOARD OF COUNTY COMMI SSION£RS COMMUNITY ADMINISTRATOR TERRY L. VIRTA, AICP ~November 4, 1993 Mr. Ed Brisbois P.O. Box 4146 Ft. Pierce, Fi 3.4948 . Re: BA-9~3-012: Bartley Hackley Dear Mr. Brisbois: This is in regard to your letters sent to Ms.. Vachon as chair of the Board of Adjustment addresSing the above petition. In your firs~ letter, dated July 7, 1993, you express your opinion in opposition to the subject petition'. In your second letter, dated AugUst 1~0, 1993, you~ express concern that your first letter maY not ha~e been presented to the Board. While your package distr in the file with tallied and the Subject information. As the n~mber of a date certain, second letter was so that they may July 7th letter was not part of the agenda to the Board of Adjustment, it has been placed other correspondence, 'and y. our opinion- was .ed to the Board as part of the cover memo for · A copy ~of the cover memo is enclosed for your can see, the last paragraph on the memo shows received from adjacent property owners as of categorizes them by opinion expressed. Your to the Board at their AUgust meeting, aware of your concerns.~ Please feel ree to contact this office anytime if you have any questions or ld like some information. enclosure cc: d of stment HAVERT L. FENN. District No. I · JUDY CULPEPPER, District No. 2 · DENNY GREEN, District No. 3 · R. DALE TREFELNER, District No. 4 · CLIFF BARNES, District No. 5 23.,00 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 34982-5652 Administrator: (407) 468-159.0 · GrOwth Management: (407) 468-1 553 · Planning: (407) 468-1 576 Codes C.ompliance: (407) 468'1571 PUBLIC~ HEARING- - G~GORY BOGGS, as Agent for BART HACKL~ FILE NO. BA-93-008 Petition by Gregory B°ggs, as agent for Bart Hackley, for a variance' from the proviSions of Section 7.0'1.03 (A)the St. Lucie County Land Development COde. Ms. Shewchuk variance which, would Development (PUD) parcel with less than te~ current Land of the sRe plan ~that 6 single family homes name Of Hackley is no longer ' current "H~D zoning acre site. staff comments. She stated that the petitioner is requesting a him to submit an application for the rezoning to a Planned Unit .to develop this property for sb which is the min" imum require~ She added that she included i in 1973 and a copy of the co proposed.,,~',The property received sil ents for'12 'multi'family units. This a the current RU land use designati! would not allow no more than 7 si single family homes on a ~ent for a PUD under the the agenda packets a copy tceptional site plan for the ~ plan approval under the ~proval, which is still valid~ · n on the property and the ~gle family units on the 1,4 Ms. Shewchuk stated t]hat in addition to bringing the development in Compliance With current zoning and land Use the requirements, PUD designation would allow the petitioner more deSign'.flexibility wi~h regard to the developable area. The property has a long narrow shape with an available !ot width of 115 feet and does .not allow for developing 6 single family homes'under the ~ormaI RS'4 zoning requirements. She. added that under the-PUD reqUirement,, the pet~t~oger'would have the.flexibility m be more cremive with the lot sizes, the access, .and the placing of the homes on the 'lots. It would also give more review comrol to the County. Ms. Shewchuk stated single fami!y..homes .are .family .units.' She :'Lucie COunty Land the current land use. because. COunty can be used m~um potential. feels that the impacts, on pubic facilities generated by six to be much less than impacts generated by twelve multi- the proposed variance is consistent with the intent of the St. Code and the Comprehensive Plan since it would bring compliance With' the current code, current zoning,' and zoning is often a Preferred typh of developmem proPOsal standards in conjunctiOn with a Stricter approval process by the protect natural features of the property and develop it to its Mr. Greg Boggs, Hackley could.not be to make the trip. ,Mr. for the Board's was just before this he received the petitioner, appeared before the Board, He stated that Mr. because he resides in Palm Deser~t, California and was 'unable passed out pictUres to the Board and stated that he is asking submit a. PUD to the County Commission. He added that he last-year with a project by the name of Whimbrel Landings which ~ermission to submit for a PUD. This project 'is similar in lot size .SUBJECT T'.') .BOARD OF Ai3.JU~ APPROVAL and .potential arChiteCt stYle?~ BOARD OF AOJu~, APPROVAL Mr' BC~ggs stated.that unfonunately the lot width is 115 feet. In straight zoning it has to be I00 feet of lot length by 75 foot width.. In addition to lot size, a 50 foot right-of-way is needed, Which~ is not available.' .In °rder~ to proceed, the only flexibility currently existing in the code is through a PUD. He added that would give more flexibility providing an access lane, probably a 25 foot easement that will allow access out to A-1-A. He stated that Mr. Hackley would his multi family twelve unit approval to go with six single family lots for detached single Mr. Jennings stated his concern about the location and width of a necessary utility easement due to the narrow width :of the property. Mr..Boggs replied that 5 feet ~om the access easement and an additional 5 feet .from the front yard Would be designated as utility and drainage easement. Mr. Rosslow asked .about' the location of Whimbrel .Landing. Mr. Boggs stated that it was tract 16, just to the north. Mr. Neil Mffier, 910.Jac~on'Way, stated that he is against the petition because frOm looking at the PUD, it requires 10 acres so the development could be condensed housing.in one.spot and' free land somewhere else. He stated that Whimbrel Land'mgs does have small lots, 50X80, but they .do have retention ponds; however, 'this develoPment will have no room to put those, things 'in. Mr. 'Larry 'Stewart stated that '.they 'have five condo~ums in Phase I, of California East. From information-that ~they have, Mr, Hackley owns the property were the X is located. However, according ~to:his :survey, ~s deed states that some of the property shown under X belongs to the common area. and Mr. Hackley has no access m his property. Mr. Stewart stated that his property ~e goes to the south side Of the highway where the fire station~is. Mr. Stewart asked Whether Mr' Hackley tried to get an easement for fight-of-way to that property?' Vice,Chairman Rosslow replied ~as far as he knows, Mr. Hackley has not obtained easement for' right-of, Way, and stated :that Mr. Boggs is here to ask that this Board allow him to go for a PUD, and that this Board isnot approving anything that he has drawn ~or anything he has done. Ms, 'Shewchuk stated.that staff brought the access issue to Mr. Boggs attention and that the information has. been forWarded to planning staff where the actual PUD will be reviewed. Before the place could progress to actual PUD stage, issues such as access will have to be resolved. ~. Stewart'. asked ~what :~is ~this BOard loo~ng, for in order to approve or diSapprove 'the variance? .. 'Vice-Chairman Rosslow ;Stated that this Board is allowing him to go 'to ~the next. step. Mr. Stewart .stated-that personally he is not objecting, as long as he is going to do what he says, Ms. MarY Spagnola, 3401 .N. A-I-A, spoke next'in opposition to the extent of the variance. She also .pointed out that there are .mangroves on the property, and bird-cages, which all .may be destroyed. ~. Marshal Sanderhoff, 3409 N. A-I'A, .stated that he has two units in the south building. He ~wondered why.:if it is currently zoned for tWelve units, does it have to go for a PUD rating in order to 'build six? What is the difference between ~he existing zoning and the -PUD rating? Ms..Shewchuk answered that the current ..zoning is RS-4, which means single family residential 4 units, to the acres. The twelve units .come from a site plan apprOVal that he received in 1973 to build-twelve units on this property. That site plan is valid so if he decided tomorrow, he-can go ahead and build twelve units. Mr. Sanderhoff asked by switching to PUD, does that invalidate the original agreement? Ms. Shewchuk replied that approval of the PUD would invalidate the eXisting .apProval of the twelve .unitS. The new site .plan approval would replace existing approval. The existing site plan" approval is ~inconsistent with the.current zoning, so-replacing the old site plan with something new wOuld make it consistent with the current zoning and land use which is RS-4. Mr. Sanderhoff 'confirmed that 'the existing zoning was RS-4, and that the size of the property was '1.36 acres which would allow seven(7) single family units. Mr, Sanderhoff asked how many maxi'mum units can be put on the property with the PUD zoning. Ms. Shewchuk replied that the applicant was asking for approval of six(6) Single Family Residences. Vice-Chairman Rosslow stated for the record that there were eleven responses which had been received from adjacent property owners regarding the petition. Two were in favor of the petition, eight were not in favor of the petition, and one had no opinion on the petition. A gentleman .from the audience stated that he was in the planning office and noticed more than e, ight (8) letters opposing this Petition. Ms. Shewchuk stated that all response notices L//t/ 0 £?/£/'.,4 L SUBJECT TO '' BOARD OF ADJUSi'r~,,~ENT APPROVAL .were Counted, bUt she WoUld check the file for this letter~ Hearing no fUrther comment in favor of or in opposition to the petition, Vice-Chairman Greg Rosslow ClOsed .the pubic .portion of the hearing. Vice-Chairman Rosslow asked for Board comments. Mr. Benton stated that personally he liked the idea because the density is being dropped and that he would rather see Single Family Residences than multifamily houses. Mr. Jennings stated that in consideration of the property owner, this is a unique situation. He 'wants'to do something with his property but he is confined by limits of the property. In order to gain access with his road and put something on there, it is understandable why he is askh~g for the PUD. density has also dropped considerably from what the present approval is, therefore, is certainly in favor of helping this situation. Mr. Ebner stated that R would be to all resident's advantage to allow a PUD, becaUse a PUD is so restricted and there will be an opportunity to bring up at-the Board of County Commissioners' review of the PUD all the items that have been brought up on front of the Board of Adjustment, such as the easement for drainage and utilities..He added ~that all of this is taken into cOnsid~r~ation and makes a very safe development for property values and owners. Mr.' Ebner Stated this is much better than building the twelve units from an old site plan. Vice'Chairman-Rosslow asked 'Staff for a recommendatiOn. Ms. Shewchuk stated-that staff recommends approval of this petition. After considering the' t~stimony presented during the Public .Hearing, including staff commems,' and 'the Standards of Review as set forth in Section 10.01.00.of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code,. Mr. Ebner made a motion that the Board of Adjustment approve .the petition of Gregory Boggs, as agent for Bart Hackley for a variance from the provisions, of Section 7.01r03 (A)'the St. LUcie 'County Land DeVelopment Code, to permit application for a rezoning to .and development of a l~lanned Unit Development (PUD) for six single a parcel of land which lacks 8.6 acres of the 10 acre. minimum requirement for PUD: based on the above stated reasons. Mr. Benton seconded the motion and upon roll the Board voted unanimously in favor of the motion. Vice-Chairman Rosslow informed the agent for the petitioner that his petition had been approved. 929 Jackson 'Way' Ft. Pierce FL 34949 July 26, 1993 Colleen Vachon, Chairman Board of Adjustment 2300 Vkginia Avenue Ft. Pierce FL 34982-6652 Dear Chairman and C~..unc'~ Members: 'Variance It has come to my attention that a preliminary acceptance was gra~ted to ,B',~ley Hackley to permit a 1 I4 acre Planned Unit Development 'which lacks 8.6 acres of the minimum 10 acres required. The majority of the abutting property owners are in opposition of 'this 'variance. We are akeady 'tolerating 'the highrise 'building~s all along 'the 'beach because of previous variance mistakes of the past administrations, and feel it is time that the present commissioners stop adding to 'these mistakes. We. know oI no other section of St. I.,uc~e County that you 'would grant such a 'variance which allows six residences on 1..4 acres of land. :[tow can you justify this rationalization? Sincerely, Constance M. Fox cc: I'.tavert L. Fenn Judy Culpepper Denny' Green R. I)ale ~IYefelner Cliff Barnes Colleen VachOn Board of Adjustments St.Lucie ~County,Fi.34982 Re: File No. BA-93-012 (Bartley HacklieY) August 10,1993 Dear Ms. Vachon, In regards,to my letter to .you,dated 7/7/93,I would like to know what the deposition of the applied for va- riance,by Mr. Hartley may have been. I~ asked you i~n the 7/7/93 letter to protect the adjacent land owners,and tax ipayers,as to addressing Mr.'Hackleys requests,and also the sensitive surrounding mangroves,and wet lands~that his proposed project,would encroach upon. It was brought to my attention,during t I was not able to a'~?tend',t'hat a question raise of the variance boa.~d,if you had received any position to Mr. Hart~leys variance,and 'that the wasn't corre~ct,and iif the information' that I h you tell me why my letter of 7/7/'93 was not me variance~ board members. As I understand,the request has past,and why. should conditions at the the request,as it was Presented. I know you still have the tereSt in mind,and try to protect e hearing that ,by the members etters,in op-' been 'tUrned down in the site change,to approve tax payers in- 1 i~t t 1 e man, and their rights. Yours truly Ed. Bri sboi s P.O.Box 41 46 .Ft.Pierce, Fi. 34948 (Coastal Cove Unit #1,Lot 26) Colleen Vachon Board of Adjustments St.Lucie County, Fi.34982 Re: File No. BA-93~012 (Bartley Hackl~y) Dear Ms. Vachon, July 7,1993 I oppose any development,of Coastal Cove Unit#1 as the area in question,is a sensitive,hammock,and mangrove preserve,and should be address as such. If the parties related to the variance,can not do with the land ~availible,for their planned development,then the pro- ject should be denied. With the small.strip availible,on the lot,it seems to me,there would be difficulty,to receive a permit to erect a single family dwelling. Not-privy to the planne~' development., as you didn"t send any .plot plan pro3ections al6ng with the .sort term notice,I can only surmise,what may be going on. I can only hope that the people in charge,as you are, will look out for the peoples rights,and try to !protect their interests. Yours truly Ed.Brisbois P.O.Box 41 46 Ft.Pierce,Fi. 34948 (COastal Cove unit#1,Lo't 26) 407'-468-8875 ST.., LUCIE COUNTY VARIANCE ,RESPONSE FO, ~RM please Return TO St. Lucie County Community DeVelopment Administrator 23~00 Virginia Avenue Room 203 Ft. Pierce, FL 3&982 REQUESTED V~IANCE': To ,permi~ ,a 1.&; acre Planned,Uni.~ Development of' ~he minimum !0 acres REGARDING 'THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT: North Hutchinson Island; North of Pepper park. west. of, A-1-A .North If you wish to comment, please_ foil-owing statements and I AM .IN~:FAVOR OF THE RE~ I HAVE ~NO, .OPINION TO THE only one of the three no later than. 7/12/93. . ,~ ,d I certify, that, as of tht ~. ~.~.~-¢el-6W, I am a property, owner Within :500 feet of the re .... =cr~ariance. Name ~.(Piease print ): Address: 'Date: ¢:/¢~ ¢~/ / Please note that fOrms returned without a name ,and address will not be considered.~ File-No. BA-93-012 (GREG BOGGS AS AGENT FOR BARTLEY HACkLe. Y) H: \WP \.BOA-DOCS \BOA. FORM ST- LUCIE,. COUNTY VA ANC . RESPONSE Please Return To $2. Lucie Coun2y Community Development Adminis2ra2or 2300 Virginia Avenue Room 203 Ft. PierCe, FL 34982 REQUESTED vARIANCE: acres REGARDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT.: North Hutchinson Island; Nor2h .of Pe.pDer-,Park.,, Wes.% of ~A-!-A North ' ' ~ ' ' ' - If you Wish to comment, please check only one of the three following statements and return postmarked no' Iater than 7/19-/93. I AM IN FAVOR, _ OF 'THE REQUESTED VARI~CE ............ I AM NOT 'IN FAVOR OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE .... ..... ,, ,_ ~ I.~HAVE .NO ~OPINION, ~ TO THE REQUESTED VARI~CE ............... I certify that, as of tho date shown below, I am a property, owner within 500 feet of the requested variance. .. ' Name (Please Print): Addre s s: Signed:LJ.~; ,~~ PJ.~a~e no~e ~hat: form~ re~'urn~d w~hou~ a n~e and addr~~ ~ill not be cOnsidered. File No. BA-93-012 (G~G~ BO~S AS AGENT FOR B~TLEY H: \WP \BOA-DOCS \BOA. FORM ST. LUCIE COUNTY V ~ARI~CE ~SPONSE 'FORM .Please.Return To St. Lucie County ! COMMUNIT DE ELOPMENI' community Developmen2 Administrator 2300 Virginia 'Avenue Room 203 Ft.. Pierce, FL 34982 REQUESTED' ~VARI~CE' TO Dermit a 1.4 acre Pla_n_ned Unit Developme_-_t ~he ~:L,~',~um 10 acres REGARDING THE PROP" RTy LOCATED AT- ; -, . :, ~ , . · North HU2chinson Island Nor2h of :PePPer Park, We~~ of A-1-A 'North. ' ' ' -' If you. wish to O..omment i. se check only~one of the three following statemen~$ and ~et%lr%apostmarked no ~ter than_ 7/.12/93- I ~ IN. FAVOR OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE ................. · . I AM :~OT IN FAVOR OF THE REQUESTED VARI~CE' . ........ '... · I ~I/'E__ NO'~ OPINION, TO THE ~REQUESTE~ V~I~CE .............. as of the date shown below, I am a property, owner I certify that, within ~:500 feet of the requested variance. Name (Please Print): Address: Signed: Please no~e tha% fo~s returnedw'~thout a name and address will not be onsLdered, File .No BA-93-012 (GREG BOGGS AS AGENT FOR BARTLEY HACKLEY) .- H: \WP \ BOA-DOCS.~ BOA. FORM ST. LUCIE COUNTY VARI~CE, ~ RESPONSE FORI~ Please Re2urn To St. Lucie COun2y Communi2y Developmen2 ,Administra2or i ' 2300 Virg nLa Avenue ROom 203 F~. Pierce, FL 34982 RE QUE $ TED 'VARI~CE: To p rm~t.a '1.4 acre Planned Ual2 Develop_me,+_ acres REGARDING. THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT: Nor%hH. u%ch~nson' . Island;' Nor~'h 'of' Pepper. ~Park., WeSt. of A-I-A 'Nor%h ' If you ~wish to comment., please check only~. One of' the three following .statements and return postmarked no late..~ than.. 7/i2/9~.. I~AM iN. 'FAVOR OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE ' I AM' NOT IN, FAVOR OF 'THE REQUESTED VARIANCE I HAVE NO, OPINION, .. . . _ TO THE REQUESTED VARIANCE .............. that,, as of the date shown below, I am a property, owner ~feet of the requested variance, Name (Please -Print): 'Address: · . Please ~no~e %h'a~ forms re%urned without a name and address will no~ be considered. File-No. BA-93-012 (GREG BOGGS AS AGENT FOR BARTLE¥ · I-i: \WP \BOA-DOCS \BOA.'FORM ST.. LUCIE, COUNTY VARI~CE .RESPONSE FO~ please Return To S2. Lucie County Community Development Administrator 2300 Virginia Avenue Room 203 Ft. Pierce, FL 34982 REQUESTED'VARI~CE:. "'~ 10 acres REGARDING THE PROPERTy LOCATED AT: Nor%h Hu%chinson Island; North of Pepper Park, WeS%'.of A-1-A Nor~h If .'you wish to comment, please check only one of the three following statement,s -and return postmarked no-late~,,~.~ than 7/12/93. I AM ....IN,, FAVOR'i O'F THE REQUESTED VARIANCE .................... I :AM .NOT IN FAVOR .OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE .......... I ~HAVE :No OPINION,, , , TO THE REQUESTED VARI~CE .............. I as of the date shown below, I mn a property, owner of the requested variance, Name (Please Print): Address: Edward H.Brisbois P.O.Box- 4156 , ~t.P±erce~F1. 34948 ,, July 7,1993 Date: 'Please note that forms returned Wi~'hou2 a name and address will no2 be considered. File No. BA-93-'012 (GREG BOGGS AS AGENT FOR 'BARTLEY H: \WP \'BOA-DOCS \BOA. FORM ST ... LUCIE COUNTy VARIANCE ..RE.SpONSE FORM Please RetUrn To St. Lucie Coun2y Community Development Administrator 2300 Virginia Avenue Room 203 F~. Pierce, FL 34982 COMMUNITY ]DEVELOPMEIf[ REQUESTED VARI~CE.: .TO Pe~it'a .1.4 :acre,, Planned Unit Development o: !0 acres .. REGARDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED.AT: Nor%h,~ Hutchinson Island,;, North of iPePDer. Park, west. of A-1-A North If you'wish to. comment, please check only one of the three fOllowing statements and return postmarkod no later than_ 7/19/95. I AM IN: FAVOR' OF THE ~QUESTED VARIANCE ,, , ,. , j .o · · · · · · ,o · · · · · · · · · , ~ ~ . I HAVE NO OPINION. TO THE REQUESTED VARIANCE wit the requested variance. Name (Please Print): Date: _ ,--~ ~:~ ' . Signed: _ / lease no~e ~ha~ fo~s returned w~hou~ a n~e and address will no~ be considered. File No. BA-93-012~ (G~G BO~S AS.AGENT FOR B~TLEY c EY) : of the date shown below, I am a property, owner H' \wP\BoA-DOCS \BOA'FORM ST. LUCIE COUNTY VARIANCE RESPONSE FORM Please Return To St. Lucie County COmmunity Development Administrator 2.300 Virginia Avenue Room 203 F~. Pierce, FL 3&982 !0 acres REGARDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT: North Hutchinson Island} North of Pepper. 'P.ark, WeSt Of A-i~A. North . If .yOu. wish to comment, pi'ease check only one of the three follOwing Statements and return postmarked no later than~ 7/12/95. I AM iN..FAVOR. OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE - · o o · e · · · · e · · o o oo.o I AM NOT'IN FAVOR OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE ......... -... ~/ I HAVE,, ,, ·NO OPINION~ ,,~ TO THE R~QUESTE~ V~I~iCE .............. as of the date shown below, of.the requested varianCe,. Name (:Pi-ease Print ): I am a property, owner Address': Date: Please be .cons forms re2urned wi2hou2 a name and address will not File iNo. BA-93-012 (GREG BOGGS AS AGENT FOR BARTLE¥ H: \WP \BOA-DOCS \BOA. FORM ST.' LUCIE, COUNTY V.ARI~CE..RESpONSE~ FORM Please Return To St. Lucie County COmmunity Development Administrator 2300 Virginia Avenue 'Room 203 Ft. Pierce, -FL 34982 T pe.rm~t a 1.:4 acre Planned Uni2 DevelOpmene ',RTY LOCATED AT: .N..or2~h Hu2chinson: Island.,· Nor2h .. , please check' °nly one of the three and return postmarked no later than, 7/12/93. ~QUESTED VARI~CE OF THE REQUESTED VARI~CE TO THE REQUESTED VARIANCE .............. .X as of the date shown below, of the requeSted variance. : I am a property, owner wi2hou2' ' . a name and' address will not . 'File No. BA-93-01.2 (GREG BOGGS AS AGENT FOR BARTLEY H: \WP \BOA-DOCS\BOA. FORM ST. LUCIE COUNTY V~HIANCE RESPONSE F0~RM Please RetUrn To St. Lucie County Community Develo~men~ Administrator 2300 Virginia Avenue Room 203 Ft..Pierce, FL 3~982 ~.QUESTED VARI~CE To Permit a 1.4 acre Planned ,Unit Developmen_~ .'acres REGARDING THE PROP of. Pepper.. Park, .We If you wish to c following statemen T F vOR ~.RTY .LOCATED AT: North. Hutchinson Island; North vt of A-1-A North omment, please check only one of the 'three :.s and return postmarked no' later than. ,~7/12/93. ,REQUESTED vARIANCE' THE ~QUESTED VARIANCE I ,~HAVE NO OPINION TO THE REQUESTED VARIANCE I C with: 0 as of the date shown below, of the requested variance, I am a property owner Name (Please Print): Date: Please note. t. hat fOrms returned ~ L%.hou2 a name and address will not be considered. File No. BA-93-O12 (GREG BOGGS AS AGENT FOR BARTLEY H: \WP \BOA-DOCS'\BOA. FORM , ucr ,C0UN VARIANCE RESPONSE. FORM . Please 'Return To · S~. Lucie County Community Developmen~ Administrator 23'00 Virginia Avenue Room 203 Ft. Pierce, FL 34982 REQUESTED VARIANCE: To, Pe~it a '1.4 acre'P, la_n_ned .Unit Develop_m_e_n~ of ~.he mln~mlml 10 ~c~s I AM IN,.FAvOR OF THE -REQUESTED VARIANCE I AM~NOT, IN FAVOR, OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE ............ HAVE N° OPIN ON TO THE ~REQUESTED VARIANCE ........ , ...... ! I with REGARDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT: NorthHu~chznson' Island,- North of :PeDDer park, weS~ of A-1-A North .... ' ..... If ..you wish to. comment, please check only 'one of the three following statements and return' postmarked n° later than~ 7/12/93. . . _ that, as of the date shown below, I am a property owner ' ~feet of the 'requested variance~ Address: ~ I . ,~.'lif ~o~-~ _ ._ ~ . Date: Signed: Please :no~e that fo~s ret'urned Without a name and address will not be considered. -File No. BA-93-012 (~~~ BO~S AS AOENT FOR B~TLE~ H: \WP \BOA-DOCS \BOA. FORM ST. LUCIE COUNTY VARIANCE RESPONSE FORM COt~,~UN~TY Please Return To S2. Lucie County Community Developmen~ Administrator 2300 Virginia Avenue Room 203 .Ft. Pierce. FL 34982 REQUESTED VARIANCE: · T permit a,, 1.4 acre Planned U.i% Developmen_% 1,0 acre~ · REGARDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT: North,, . , Hutchinson' , Island;, No-rt_h of PepDer Park,,, west of A-1-A North If you wish to comment, please check only one of the -three fOllowing statement,s and retUrn postmarked no-later than 7/12/9~. I' AM.IN,: FAVOR .OF THE ~ REQUESTED VARIANCE I AM-~,~OT IN FAVOR, ~ OF THE REQUESTED VARI~CE .......... . . . I HAVE: ~No OPINION 'TO THE REQUESTED VARI~CE ' I certify that, as of '.the date Shown. below, I ~ .a property, owner within 50'0. feet ~of the requested variance, N~e (Please Print): J~~~~,~ ~~~~Z ~.. Address': ¢.~0 ~~~~ Date: ~ ~A ~ ' Please no~re that fo~s returned without a fi~e and a~l-not be considered. F~le No. B~-93-012 .(O~O BO~S ~S ~OEN~ FOR ~C~EY) H: \WP \BOA-DOCS \BOA.FORM ST. LUC!E COUNTY VARI~CE RESPONSE, FORM_ Please Return To Si. Lucie County. . COmmunitY Devel°Pment Administrator 2300 Virginia Avenue Room 203 Ft. Pierce, FL 34982 REQUESTED vARIANCE: To Permi~ a 1.4 acre ,Planned U-n-i2 ..Development_ l0 acres 'Developmen% REG ~ARDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT: North utch~nson Island; North H ' ,, e _ of Pe_Dper park., West. of A-1-A.Nor%b If you ~wish to comment, please check only one of the three following statomentS and :return postmarked no- later than ? [1~/93. Z AM IN FAVOR OF THE .REQUESTED VARIANCE ' )~ I AM :NOT .IN FAVOR OF .THE- REQUESTED VARIANCE - , ,~ , i. I :~HA~..NO .OPINION,., ~ ,,_ TO THE ~EQUESTED VARI~CE $ of .the -date shown below, f the requested variance., i am a property_ owner N~e (Please Print):: .... :.~:~./~/~ /,.,~/~/ _~.~?:/~l~~1/~_{.~.~ . Addr e s s: __~/__~-~~ ~~~~~~~~ ]~./~ ~ - Date: Signed.~ 'Please ~o%e ~a.% fo~s be ~ o~s~d'ere4.. File ~- BA-93-~2 (~~~ H: \WP \BOA-DOCS \BOA. FORM BOA MEETING: JULY 21, 1993 HEMORANDUH TO: FROM= DATE: SUBJECT': Agenda Item #1 File~ N~er. BA-93-012 Petition by Gregory' Boggs, as agent for Bart Hackle~ for a variance f~om the provisions of SectiOn 7.01.03~) .of the St uc~e County Land Development Code to permit applic for a rezoning to and development of a Planned nit Development (PUD)' for six single family homes on parcel of land which lacks 8.6 acres of the 10 acre m~n~ s2ze requirement for PUD zoning. LOCATION: EXISTING ZONING: West side of North A-l-A, north of Pepper Park on North HutChinson Island. HIRD (Hutchinson Island-Residential District) EXISTING LAND USE: RU (Residential, Urban - 5 du/ac) pARCEL S I ZE: 1.406 acres PROPOoED USE :' To allow for a Planned Unit DeVelopment of six single family homes on a parcel With less than 10 acres. SURROUNDING.ZONING: HIRD to 'the west, RS-4 to the north, and I (Institutional) to 'the east and south. NO. 0~' · ]. -LETTERS FROM ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS as of: , 7/14/93 RESPONSES: 2 IN FAVOR 8 OPPOSED 1 NO OPINION ATTACHMENTS': 1. Application 2', Excerpt, St. Lucie County Map 3' Location/Zoning MaP 4. Conceptual' Site Plan .Page 2 July 14, 1993 Petition: Bart M. Hackley File No.: BA-93-012 STANDARDS OF REVIEW In reviewing this application for a variance to the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, the Board of Adjustment shall consider and make the following determinations: 1. The variance requested arises from a condition that is unique and Peculiar' to the land, structures and buildings involved; that .the particular physical surroundings, the shape, or topographical condition of the specific property involved would result i~ occupant, as d provisions of that it is a same Zoning D regulations o~ an action or a ~unnecessaryhardship for the owner, lessee, or istinguished from a mere inconvenience, if the Section 7.01.03 (A), are literally enforced; :ondition that is not ordinarily found in the istrict, and the condition is created by the Section 7.0.1.03 (A), of 'this Code, and not by =tions of the property owner or the applicant. The subject parcel is located on the west side of North A-l-A, just north of .Pepper Park. The petitioner is requesting a variance ~hich would allow him to submit an application for the .rez°n~ng tO a Planned ~nit Development. (PUD) in order to develop this proPerty for six single family homes on a Parcel with less than ten acres. The property received site plan approval under the name of Hackley Apartments in June of 1979 for 12 multi family units. This approval is no lOnger consi 'the current RU future land use designation and HIRD zoning ( 4 requirements) which would now allow'no more than 7 si ly units on the site. In addition to bringing the development in cOmpliance with current zoning and density requirements, the PUD designation would give the petitioner more design flexibility with regard to developable area, access planning and preservation of open space. The pro] by a narrow ca~ Park to the wE feet does not six single fam while also pre sufficient op vegetation. ~erty has a long and narrow shape and is bounded ~al to the north, a mangrove preserve and Pepper st and south. The available lot width of 115 allow for developing the' subject property for £1y homes under the standard RS-4 requirements riding access to the houses and providing for ~n space to preserve more of the natural 2. The granting of the variance will not impair or injure other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the subject'ProPerty is located, nOr impair an adequate supply of lightor air tO adjacent public streets, increase the.danger of ~ire' endanger'the public safety, Or Substantially diminish or ~mpair property values within the neighborhood. Page 3 July IL4, 1'993 Petition: Bart M. Hackley File No.: BA-93-012 The granting of this variance is not anticipated to have a significant impact or in j.ure other property or improvements in the neighborhood. The variance will allow for the application of. a PUD.Which has' the potential to enhance the aesthetics of the neighborhood by offOring greater design -flexibility. Impacts on public facilities generated by the proposed six single family residences are expected to be less than impacts generated by the approved twelve multi-family units. 3. The variance granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structures. The requested variance is the minimum variance needed to apply for a rezoning to PUD. 4. The variance desi. red will not be opposed to the general spirit and intent of this Code or the St. Lucie County Comprehensive Plan. The proposed variance is consistent with the'intent of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code and the Comprehensive Plan. PUD zoning is often a preferred type of development proposal because the flexible design standards in conjunction with a stricter approval process can be used to protect the natural features of th~ property. Development along SR A-1-A involves sensitive environmental areas where original landscape should be retained as much as possible. The granting of a PUD would allow development of this property in a manner which 'is conSi, stent with the Code and the Comprehensive Plan instead of implementinq existing site plan approval which is not consistent ~ith current Code requirements. Comment s: The purpose of this request is to allow for the submission of a PUD application for a parcel of land which lacks 8.6 acres of the required minimum size. The petitioner wishes to develop the property for residential purposes, but at a density lower than What was previously, approved for this site. Recommendation Staff recommends approval of this petition. Page 4 July 14, 1993 Petition: Bart M. Hackley File No.: BA-93-012 Suggested motion to approve/deny this variance request: MOTION TO APPROVE.:. AFTER CONSIDERING THE TESTIMONY PRESENTED DURING THE PUBLIC ]~EARING, · INCLUDING STAFF COMMENTS, AND THE STANDARDS OF REVIEW AS SET FORTH IN SECTION 10.01.00 OF THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, I HEREBY MOVE THAT THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT APPROVE THE PETITION OF GREGG BOGGS, AS AGENT FOR BART M. HACKLEY, FOR A VARIANCE FROM THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 7.01.03 (A) , OF THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO PERMIT FOR AN APPLICATION FOR A REZONING TO PUD ON A PARCEL OF LAND WHICH LACKS 8.6 ACRES OF THE REQUIRED TEN ACRE MINIMUM SIZE REQUIREMENT FOR A PUD. MOTION TO DENY: AFTER CONSIDERING THE TESTIMONY PRESENTED DURING THE PUBLIC HEARING, INCLUDING STAFF COMMENTS, AND THE STANDARDS OF REVIEW AS SET FORTH IN SECTION 10.01.0'0 OF T~E ST.. LUCIE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, I HEREBY MOVE THAT THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT DENy THE PETITION OF GREGG BOGGS, AS AGENT FOR BART M. HACKLEY, FOR A VARIANCE FROM THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 7 . 01 . 03 (A) OF THE ST. LUCIE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO PERMIT THE SUBMISSION FOR AN APPLICATION FOR A REZONING TO PUD ON A PARCEL OF LAND WHICH LACKS 8.6~ ACRES OF THE TEN ACRE MINIMUM SIZE REQUIREMENT FOR A PUD, BECAUSE .... (CITE REASON WHY - PLEASE BE SPECIFIC). · Thomas Luciido& Associates, P.A. Land Planning/Landscape Architechzre June 3, 1993 Ms, ~Julia Shewchuk · GroWth Ma~gagement Director St. LuCio: County ~'.P.lanning Department 2300 :Virginia Avenu'e ." Ft. Pie.rce, ~Flodda -34982-5652 -. . .. . · . RE:-Board "of Adjustment.- California East- Our. Ref. # 4281,. .. .'-D'ea~ .jUlia:._. -.. --:Pursuant ':to .sectiOn, io:,0i;:00-:of..the. St: Lucie; coUnty Land Develbpment.;'code,. 'a~,d:,:. on'i!-behallf, of.-Mr, '.aart. M.. Hackley;:.. please. find' e-nclo:sed .th;e:..'fOllowing--"" -' .inf.°rmatioh..~ for":?:the. July .21, t 99.3 Board .' of .Adjustment.meeting:...-~. .- .- '- -"-aPPiicati°n-''-for ,Variance,~.'fr°m--~ the.. PmVisi°ns. of-",tlhe., land :deV.~lopment ~. Code · '.,..:i:cbnce~tUaI .' Site? Pla.n i,.0f i, the ::". pro. pO~Sed, prOject ~.. :..- .. ..--- ,bo:un da-rY and'' -:topographic, survey '- - -~, ~ '. . : S500',00~.:~ap:PliCati0n~;'fee'::..,-.~: ::.:.;~:"~.-:~.... ' . · . · . ' . . - .... . . .. -. _:~ :, ...... : .' . .. . This -'reqUest ' for variance.~.deals !sPecifiCally 'with: 'the minimum.-acreaga..- -'-' requirement..'in 'whiCh-~to ,sUbmit.. a;:development plan"U'nder the"..Planned..Unit.'. Devel°pment.'Z°ni:ng'.standardS-i';The"."Client CUrrently"~'has::an aPpr°ved'Plan 'fOr · . ~elve"-multi,..family~ .-units ~-at'.. 'this.:: locatiOn.: If ~' gra~'~ted :i..the. varianCe,...we -,intend- ,t0.-.filb-.for..develOpment,.plan.-:apPro~vai.. for a six-unitl, single -. familY:-, detaChed-.- .. . - ,pr0'ject;""'""'- ""--"-"' ' ': '" ' .... '" '" · . Please :,.co.nta~ct :me' shOu'~d.~ yoU.., have )any.qubstionS..or. Concerns .reg.ardi'ng' :~this"- application:..___ ,.-.. "...'- ' .. ~- "... ' _.~-. : .- · '','" · : sin~.cere'l~ ' ,.. .. Dire,ctor cc: Mr. Bart F~ckley 506 South Federal Highway 1903 South 25th Street, Suite' 100 Stuart, Florida 34~J~)4 407/220-2100 Fort Pierce, Florida 34947 407/467-1301 ST, LUCIE cOUNTy 'APPUCATiON FOR vARIANcE FROM THE PROVISIONS'"OF THE LAND ~DEVELOPMENT CODE · : 1. APPlicant's Name:. .Greg Boggs A.S.r'A-..(Th0mas rucido & ASsociates) , ApPlicant,.s. Address: 1903~SoUth25thstreetsuite'#202 .... Fort.Pierce~.Florida~34982- . 21.. Legal ~ DeScription. ,: and .',street iAddreSS. 'Of : Parcel: .).~ Please. refer .,;toS.-B0Und a tY ~5 SUrvey · _ , In additiOn, Setback criteria under this zoning claSsification.can not be altered ~ to allow greater useof residential lot.area.The subject sites upland width'°f 115' creates planffin§ hardship .when a¢cotmting for right'of'way .for vehicular access, buildable area. Given the above e,. t site under '~is'straight zoning dassifi~tion, on marketable' State-reasOn,s, why~ this hardship is unique to the owner and why Other property similarly situated ,does .not sUffer from.the same ~hardshiP. ' · " ' - · .. , Is uniq{le, due t° .owner ,desire. to create a lsingle-familyneighb°rhood on land that HiRDlRS-i.-zOning ~reqUirements. surrOunding :has.been. developed as ~ single .family .''' prod .'. · ...... .-. ..... ..- : --" . .. . Stare'teaS°ns WhYthis Variance/Will not be '~Juri°us to-other. prOpertY'and/or ': :---_ ',:'. '- .. . . . · which; the,'subject' prOPert¥~is located. "n°t"be~ inj~°us .ential' u,4es, ::ThiS.' site -~elve. m~ti'famfly' and' aPpg0~ed Under. cu~ent.zon~g:; State :~hy, this varian60 .is~ the:. minimum' that 'wilt'-make poSsible ~a~:reaSonabie ~'. .USe or,headland., ...... :and:.s~uctureS.: . .... ' '; ~-"' ~- ,~- ,: 3,.~.. e '~s~gie 'f~fly °mmv'iV; ::~, ~ , -requke~entsof the " uPOfi ~OroU~ regi~?W ~d aPprov~ bY~ . i~pemit~the' owner to- COns~ct. h~ desired ,program. · ~ xplam-.how t~s .. proposed Variance--~s~cons, stent.~a ae~g~nera! sPirit'0f St. Lude :county 'Land ¢,~evelo.pment'.COd~ and. me 'St. LUde C'omPrehensive'~plam · BY..~i°~g for innovative., and '~e'ative single.family hoUs~g on. the :barrier ,~la~d;~,design optio~ :enco~age charaCter and efficiency Of laYout, and, utilities; ma~:~in~g : enhanc~g,natUral, ~featmeS; Soil' and .water . -, . .conservation;, . Proposed, , Of: nab.e-, and/or, XeriscaPe l~dscape materials; .' ~ ,',, .: ~ '.'-~ , , ._., . . , ~ ,.. . · .. , -,~ .-, , . ,. .. ~. _ , . . 14. maintaining and/or lOwering :of public fac ~ty st,andards (water, sewer, & traffic) and levels of'service. Owner of property, if different from applicant: Name~ Mr. B.aR~ M, Hackley AddreSs:-73.596 ~n.irDriVe, Palm Desert,'. California 92260 ... Phone'Number:' - 619'340,1668 ~ . ., .. 15. ~If apPliCantis ,not the.,proper.ty..owner, eXplain the. applicant's.relationshiP ~to the.. . Land pianningC0nsultafit fOr..oWner. .-.. ..... . , , -. ':... _- " ..'" _..' '~6.:~ ".~gent authorized by. applicant-tO",, represent-the applicant. ~ .. · · ' .-. . _ _ .4.. _ .' : · . ::'AddreSs: ,:I903'S'0uth~ '25th 'Street suite' '#202-F0'~Pierce"Floridai3:1982' - 18.'~- ~PP :,~iit bepre~ared to'; n~wOrthe~ :)qu~On~ ore, have }~. ''~.' "~ "~"" u.es:fi~nS,0n ~m~ behalf fit ~ ~b~e: '. ...... ~ ..... "':::..: .'...:',,": ", ':' .... '-.~ ,: ..; ..~,,,'.,'..,: . ?':l-t.:~-~:':¢.~-' . . '. _ ._, , . ;' +~. ' .; ~ , . , .... -' ·, . ,, : . . : " ' '. ..... ' .· - ' '," .' · "' ....: _. ...... ' .... .. ~ 4. /., ~' ' ........ " " - " :"'. ;.t- " -' , · ,.. *. - · '~' -- ," :~' - ': ' - . . .... ';~, ' ' ]-:,t...- · ' ':';:" :: :-:. : ', ' ..... ; '. ' ....... "' ~.' ,. .. -. . ' , : : ~.-./.~ '..', . . - .. .. ~'' .':.:. (. :' '- · :. ,--' ': .... '- ~ .t~ ~' .~ , ~ ~ ,, · .., :... .~ ~... , ,. .' : ." : ' _ ' . -': -" : .r ~ · ' h. ..: ... . . - ' '.-'- , ':,:i ' . · · " ~.. ' .'.,' ,~_ '' ' ..., , ~ .., 18. Agent auth0rized bY aPPlicant to represent the applicant. Narne: Greg Boggs A'S.L.A. Address: 1903 South 25th :street sUite #100 Fort Pierce, Florida 34982 Phone Number: (407) 467-1301 ~ Please': attach a diagram of the.' Property showing the dimensions. of' the 'lot and all other'dimensiOns necessary t° understand the application, -,.I have been. furnis~~ed a list of the questions to be answered by the apPlicant fOr a Variance ~nd .Will be prepared to answer-these queSt{ons or have my ~agent answer these questions on my behalf at the public hearing. APplicant'~ Signature Date PropertY Owner's SignatUre(s) Date Date . I.NDIAN R{ R COUNTY .PROJECT L 0 CAT I ON ST. LU'CIE PEPPER PARK FORT PIERCE INLET ORANG~ NING ~AIL AGENDA - BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT WEDNESDAY, JULY 21, 1993 / 9:30 A.M. Petition of Greg Boggs as agent for Bartley Hackley for a variance from the provisions of Section .7.0L.O3(A) of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, to permit a 1.4 acre Planne~t Unit Development (PUD)application which lacks 8.6 acres of the minimum 10 acres required for a Planned Unit Development for the following described property: Coastal ~Coves Unit 1, Tract C, Less the west 169,42 feet and the east 150,OO feet (Located: North Hutchinson Island; North of Pepper Park, west of A-1-A north) Please note that all proceedings before the Board of Adjustment are electronically recorded. Ifa .person deCides to appeal any decision made by the Board of Adjustment with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or heating, he will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for sUch purpose, he' may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the prOce, edings 'is made, which, record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is ~to be based. Upon the request of any party to the proceeding, individuals testifying during a hearing will be sworn in. Any ~arty to the proceeding will be granted an opportunity to cross- examine any individual testifying during a hearing upon request. Written comments {'eceived in advance of the public hearing will also be considered. Prior to this public heating, notice of the same was sent. to all adjacent property owners July 6, 1993. Legal nOtice was published in the Port St. Lucie News a newspaper of general circulation in St. Lucie CoUnty, on June 30, 1993. File No. BA-93-012 BARL~F1~ M HACKLEY JR RANDAIff~ L HACKLEY 73-596 AMIR DR PA[~ DESERT 'CA 92260 "A" COASTAL COVE ASSN INC 2901 N AiA FT PIERCE FL 34949 #1, 16 HARRY KORMAN ROBERT & RITA R SWEDROE P O BX 611417 N MIAMI FL 33.261 #2,14, BLK T ILYAS BAWANY 68 E 'WACKER PL STE 800 CHICAGO I.L 60601 BLK U-Z; PEPPER PARK ST'LUCIE COUNTY BCC ROGER POITRAS ANNEX 2300 VIRGINIA AVENUE FT PIERCE FL 34982 #3-5 PERCY MALLISON DIRECTOR DIV OF STATE LANDS, DNR 3900 CY3MbAO~ALTH BLV ROOM 40 TALLAHASSEE FL 32399 #3- 5 BOB .PRZEKOP DEPT NAT RESOURCES DIVISION OF STATE LANDS 4842 SOUTH US HWY 1 FT PIERCE FL 34982 #4 (.FIRE STA #9) ST LUCIE FT .PIERCE FIRE DIST P O B× 3030 FT PIERCE FL 34948 #6 VIVIAN G ST~S RAYFDND E GUTERMUTH 303'5 NE GARDEN TERR PA[~ BAY FL 32905 RESOLUTION ~UST CORP 1600 S FEDERAL HWY FT PIERCE ~FL 34950 #8 KENNETH L JACKSON ET AL C/O KEN JACKSON JR RR 2 BX 532 FARMINGTON NH 03835 # 9 ,UNIT 1 LOT 23 LOUIS & MARY SPERANZA 915 JACKSON WAY FT P!ElRCE FL 34949 #10 CHARLES W & HRT]~IE D STONE 406-1/2 S 5TH ST FT PIERCE FL 34950 #11 LEE EVELYN WALLACE P O ~BX 76 SMITHVILLE TX 78957 #12 SARA J GIBSON 329 DAHL ~ST RHINELANDER WI 54501 #13 INDIAN RIVER TRADING CORP P O BX 673 FT PIERCE FL-34954-- #15 L~O INVESTMENTS INC 233 E WACKER DR #1011 CHICAGO IL 60601 UNITS 1-5 IARRY R ST~T DIANE L ST~T 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNITS 1,2 - C MARSHA~ SANDERHOFF 340.9 N A1A FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 3 ROBERT & KAREN ISHMAN 1423 JACKSON ST HOLL~D FL 33020 UNIT 4 ME~RA SUN. CORP 6211 SW 45 ST DAVIE FL 33314 UNIT 5 · MARY M SPAGNOLA 340,1 NORTH A1A ~T.'PIERCE ~ FL 34949 ~ UNIT 1 ~iY~~ A ANDREA MELi33N 3120 N A1A UNIT 501 FT PIERCE' FL 34949 UNIT 1 L~F 1 GEORGE R & ETHEL M METZ 930 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT BRE/WDA S PFEI FFER 928 JACKSON WAY' FT ·PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 IfYr 3 EUGENE & LAURA CACCAMO 11230 NW 5TH ST PLANTATION FL 33325 UNIT 1 I/)T 4 ' JANE M BROOKS 924 JACKSON NAY FT PIERCE FL 34949' UNIT 1 If~ 5 RONALD A WELLHAM SR SHIRLEY J' WELLHAM 922 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 ~ 6 MURRAY-D a PF~L p ROSENBERG CARL E & JOAN-E ROSENBERG 2376 KENIIA~RTH CLEVELAND HEIGHTS OH 44108 UNIT 1 If)T-7 JAMES H & JUNE L DEKKER 918 JACKSON WAY 'FT PIERCE ~ '34949 UNIT 1 lOT 8 H T & C G SNYDER 916 JACKSON WAY -FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 Ifyr 9 JOSEPH & NORA KNESPLER 914 JACKSON~ WAY' FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 22 BRUCE A & AUDREY M MOYER 5482 BLUE CHURCH RD COOPERSBURG PA 18036 UNIT 1 Ifrr 24 GEORGE. B STALLINGS 917 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 If~ 25 WM H & CAROLYN A SAMUEL 919 JACKSON' WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 IOT 26 EDWDaRD a M~Y BRISBOIS P ~O BX 4146 FT PIERCE FL 34948 UNIT 1 IOT 27 JENNIE H GATZ 923 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 I/Yf 28 PETER & VIVIAN CORBA 5059 N A1A UNIT B906 FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 29 BERTHA PETE~ 927 JACKSON WAY - FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT i LOT 30 JAMES L & CONSTANCE FOX 929 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 31 WILLIAM H POWE~ RR .2 WILSON AV BX' 485 ttARNSBORO NJ 08080 ROADS PROPERTY ACQUISITION DIV ROGER POITRAS ANNEX 2300. VIRGINIA AVENUE FT PIERCE FL 34982 STA~E ROADS FEOT JOHN ANDERsoN 311i S DIXIE HWy STE. 112 MAI~X 122 W PAIi~ BCH FL i~ 3405 GREG ~S,~ A.S.L.A. THOS LUCI~ .& ~S(X2IATES 1903 S 25TH ST STE 20'2 FT PIERCE FL 34947 ~t' LUGiF.. GUUNTV · ST.-~uc,~.cou.'~y BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ,~UBUC ,',E^,,~ JU,:¥':~,., TO wHO~'~<'iT MAY cONcERN: A/'r:COL "Pub. i JuJy 8,. 1993 AGENDA - BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT WEDNE SDA Y, JUL Y 21, 1993 9:30 A.M. Petition of Greg Boggs as agent for Bartley Hackley for a variance from the provisions of Sec~n 7. Ol.03(A) of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, to permit a 1.4 acre Planned Unit Development (PUD) application which lacks 8.6 acres of the minimum 10 acres required for a .Planned .Unit Development for the following described property: Coastal Cove~ Unit 1, Tract C~ Le~ the we~t 169.42 feet and the east 150.00 feet .(Located: North Hutchinson Islan& North of Pepper Park, west of A-1-A north) Please note that all prOceedings before the Board of Adjustment are electronically recorded. If a person decides to appeal any deCision made by the Board of Adjustment with respect to any matter considered' at such meeting or heating, he will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he' may need to ensure that a verbatim record of.the procqedings 'is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Upon the request of any party to the prOceeding, individuals testifying during a heating will be sworn in. Any party to the proceeding will be granted' an' opportunity to cross- examine any individual testifying during a heating upon request. Written comments received in advance of.the public hearing will also be considered. Prior to this public heating, notice of the same was sent to all adjacent property owners July 6, 1993. Legal notice was published in the Port St. Lucie News a newspaper of general circulation in St. Lucie County, on June 30, 1993. File No. BA,93-012 BOARD' OF COUNTY COMt ISSI. ON£RS July 6, 1993 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ADMINISTRATOR TERRY L. VIRTA, AICP In compliance with the provisions of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code you are hereby advised that Greg Boggs as agent for Bartley Haddey has .petitioned the Board of Adjustment for a variance from the provisions' of Section 7.01.03(A) of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, to permit a 1'4 acre Planned Unit Development (PUD) application which lacks 8.6 acres of the minimum 10 acres required for a Planned Unit Development for the following described property: Coastal Coves Unit 1, Tract C, Less the west 169.42 feet and the east 150.00 feet (Located: North Hutchinson Island; North of pepper Park, West of A-I-A North) A public hearing on the petition will be held on Wednesday, July 21, 1993, at 9:30 A.M. in Room 101, St. Lucie County Administration Building, 2300 F~rginia Avenue, Fort Pierce, Florida. All interested persons will be given an opportunity to be heard at that time. Written comments received-in advance of the public hearing will also be considered. Please note that all proceedings before the Board of Adjustment are electronically recorded. If a person decides to aPpeal any decision made by the Board of Adjustment with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes 'the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is 'to be based. Upon the request of any party to the proceeding, indi~duals testifying during a hearing will be sworn in. Any party to the proceeding will be granted an opportunity to cross.examine any individual testifying during a hearing upon request. If you no longer own property adjacent to the above-described parcel, please forward this notice 'to the new owner. If you should have any questions, additional information may be obtained by calling Area Code (407) 468.1586. Sincerely, ~S~..LUCIE coU~~' FLORIDA (~lle6i~ Vaehon, ~haiC~rman ~ FILE NO. BA-93-012 HAVERT L. FENN, DistriCt No. I ® JUDY CULPEPPER, District No. 2 · DENNY GREEN, District No. 3 · R. DALE TREFELNER, District No. 4 · CLIFF BARNES, District No. 5 2300 Virginia Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 34982-5652 Administrator: (407) 468-1590 · Growth Management: (407) 468-1553 · Planning: (407) 468-1576 Codes'Compliance: (407) 468-1571 ., . ];ND;['AN R :E COUNTY ST. PEPPER PARK PROJECT LOCAI'ION FORT P~ERCE INLET JACKS WAY BLK T '~ ..... BL:K U ~' BLK V ~ BLK W ~ BLK X ~ BLK Y BLK Z STATION ST.. LUCIE COUNTY VARIANCE' RESPONSE ~ FORM PleaSe Return To S2. Lucie County community DeVelopment Administrator 2300Virginia Avenue Room 203 Ft. Pierce, FL 34982 REQUESTED 'VARIANCE: .To Permit a 1.4. acre Planned Unit Developmen~_- ~P~) application which lacks 8.6 acres o~ ~he _~.~n~m;;m_. 10 acres reauired for a Planned 'uni~ Development ' RRGARDING THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT: North HutchinSon Island~ North Of Pepper park,.. West. o~ A, 1-A North . following statements and [e Postmarked no later than. 7/12/9:3. I AM IN, FAVOR OF THE REQUESTED VARI~CE I AM NOT 'I,N, FAVOR OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE ......... .... I_HAVE, NO, OPINION, · ~_ TO THE REQUESTED VARIANCE .............. I certify that, as of the date shown below, I am a property, owner within 500 feet of the requested variance' Name (Please Print): Address: Date: Signed: Please n. ote tha2 .forms returned without a name and address will not be considered. F~le No. BA-93-012 (GREG BOC~S AS AGENT FOR~BARTLEY HACKLEY) H: \WP \BOA-DOCS \BOA. FORM ATTENTION: MIKE BOWERS BOB FRANK ?~s S~:~N TO ~ ~U~ UP. IRN A, SIGN CAN BE AE DATE SENT TO 'ROAD DEPT. ~ COPY OF THIS ~ SUE HARTZOG - GROW~ MANAGEMEN< FILE. T, H ,A N K Y O U. ST, LUCIE COUNTY AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLIC NOTICE , do hereby certify that as Agent for the st. Lucie County BOard of Adjustment on the following des~.]:ib_e,d prope, rty: _CALIFORNIA .EAST aka BARTLEY HA'CKLEY · NORTH O,F HUTCHINSON ISLAND; NORTH OF PEPPER . _ PARK, WEST..OF A.-!-A NORTH ~_~NEEDS TO. BE UP BY 07-0,5-93) I di~! on ' ~' $~: , 19 ~, erect in a conspicuous place on this property the following notice- · PUBLIC NOTICE - '~ PUBLIC HEARING O'F THE ZONING ORDINANCE ON THIS' pROpERTY TO CONSIDEr. A WILL BE HELD IN THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, 230~0 VIRGIl IA AVENUE, (IST FLOOR), FT PIERCE 9:30 A.M. ON 07-~-93 BEFg~~~ BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT. PETITION IS AVAILABLE IN ROOM ~~~ .... ~ S i gna tu r'..e Da te ..~ DEP~TMENT OF COMMU~ DEVELOPMENT PLANN~G DEPAR~ MEMORANDUM TO- FROM: DATE - SUBJEC ' ~.: GROWTH MANAGE~NT TECHNICIANS PLANNING & ZONING SECRETARY POSTING 'OF PUBLIC NOTICE FOR PETITION OF: Greg.., Boggs as agen~ .for Bar~ley Hackley for a Var~ance. k~om the Provisions of Section 7.01.03(A) of the St. Lucie County Land Development Code, to,~ Permit a 1.24 acre Pl'anned' Unit DeveloPment (PUD) application which lacks 8.76 n ~ ~ ~acres~-~ ~,t=~°f the minimum 10. acres required for a Planned unit THE ~OVE PETITION IS SCHEDULED FOR PUBLIC HEARING' ON THE FOLLOWING DATE: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ............ . ............ __ ~..~~/_~~ PLANNING & ZONING , . ' BOARD OF coUNTy COMMISSIONERS . . PLEASE. 'IMPLE~NT THE P~oST1NG OF-PUBLic. NOTICE BY PUBLIc. WORKS BEFORE 'AT THE FOLLOWING LOCATION: North H ' ' · "utchinson of A-1-A north) Island; North of Pepper Park, west THANK YOU. H: \wp \ tec h's .mem M E,M O R~A N D U M PLAHN~NG DIVISI;ON TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJ: Belinda V°se, Acquisition Agent Planning& Z~°ning secretary..~~ ~~~ _. Attached pleaSe' find application(s) for · ~ . are schedul-ed for the-" · - meeting. Please 'notify me of the existing amount, of right-of-way in this location and any additional right-of-way the County needs. The staff report will be comPleted-and prepared for mailing ten data prior tO the above scheduled-,meeting. /cb WP \Memo ' s \Belinda.mere cc: File att :. Application DATE:- FROM · - '.' CHARLINE - __M _E .M 0 R A N D 'U H TO¸- SUBJ:. Thank 'You'Very 'Much .... ! -!-: ..... petition. Also, ted petition if LOCATION: . .,. N, PUBA LGALD I S P A- 13 6&~&&& L E G A~L. D E S C R I P T I 0 N Parcel I,.D.: 14'23-802-0003'-010/8 Legal DeSc.: COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1~ TRACT Legal~Desc.: C-LESS W 169.38 FT & LESS THAT Legal DeSC.: PART ASSESSED IN CALIFORNIA EAST Legal DeSC : OR 349-4'39 & LESS AS IN OR Legal/~DeSc.: 393-1907- (1.24 AC) (OR L ~e~Ci: 5'88-2612:801-205) ,aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa&&&&&&&&&&&&&i This Information Is BelieVed To-Be~ Correct At This Time But It Is Subject ~T° Change And IS Not Warranted. Press space bar to continue. i com'i L Nlfv b'ege' i f ACQUISITION DIVISION MEMORANDUM 93-108 TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: roWth Management Director Property Acquisition Director June 14, 1993 BA-93-012 /California COastal Coves Unit 1 East In reviewing the above mentioned Board of AdjUstment, the property proposed for development, according to the Ta~ Assessment Map has no apparent road frontage and may be landlocked. Proof of adequate legal access, should be provided prior to any further action. If you haVe he~~~t~te to attachment cc: Public Director of any questions regarding this matter, please do not contact our .-office.~ WOrks AdministratOr Engineering /zFJo z~ . . oeo- · o O0 0 0 ot, &u*,,IC bUUtli ! ST. LUCIE COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA · JULY 2i, 1993 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: NOTICE is hereby given in ac- cordance with Section 11.00.03 of the St. Lucie County Land Develop. ment Code and .in accordance Wlth the provisions of the St. Lucie Coun- ty Comprehensive Plan, that the fol- .l~wing applicants .have requested that the St. Lucie County 'BOard 6f Adjustment COnsider their request as follows: . , .. 1). 'Petition of Greg Boggs as agent for Bartley Hackley for. a variance from the provisions; of. Section 7,01.03(A) of the St. Lucie County Land .DevelOpment Code, 'to permit a t..4 acre Planned Unit Develop-' ment (PUD) application which lacks 8.6 acres of the minimum 10 aa'es required for .a Planned UnitDevel, for the follow..ing d.escri ..bed' ! .propeR:" ;-./,{!~'~'~ ~' .-- :~, 'c6a~al Coves Unit 1, i-tact c, Less I/ 'the ,west 169.42 feet andthe east '1'50:00 'feet ~ ?,~/''~ ;. (LO~t~.. No~ ,UtC~i,So, ~onU; North of Pepper. Park, west 0.f.~A.T.I- A north) . ...... -- . ' 2j. I~eiti°n Of Fronk thur..for a variance 'from'.Sedlon 7.10.16(Q)(1) of the St. Lud~ '.Co~' ~ L.~nd Development,Code to m, it.:'~ Handicap Ramp which. cr°a~es'4 feet into the 8 l~'side- L°t 'i02'2, Nettles isJ~nd'"' Located~ 9801 S. Ocean Driv~,~l~nZ: ii Sen Beach, FL ; "· '." "~i.{.~ 3)..Petition of' William' WOlsfi;t~-' ~lU:;, 0; th. S~. LUd~.C0u~i,&~lj D~elopment Code, to per~nit::.~jl existing'-house with screen ~Ix~-chi~Jl which locks 1.0 foot.ofthe 15 fc~o~!Jl .re0r yard setback~os required' in 4 zoning for the following 'de-.ii scribed properly: :' ' :'~ - -." Piec®, FL' '-'.:~75.~/,. ¥,' PUBLIC HEARING:~iil I~ .~tration. 'Building,-'t'2300~Vi~gii~l~: as s .oon' thereaft~ a~-'pos~ible; ;.?PURSUANT TO, -Section 286,0105, Florida Stdtufes, .if a I~r. ~n-decides to ap~l,any ded:i sion, made by a board~"agenc~ or COmmiSsion with respect to any mat. ter COnsidered at a meetin~'br ihear- lng, he will need a recbrd of the proc .eedings, and that, for such.pur-i P°se,"he may need a verbafi~ re,! C~d'i'°f the proceedi,gs which' record inCludes the fesfimony! e;~i.,,Ue,~ ,po,. ~. n~': o". ! pea is to be based.'vL,,' ?;,,,.?.~ ST. LUCIE COUNTY, .FLORIDA | /s/COLLEEN VACHON,'CHAIR- · MAN . Pub.~ July 8, 1993_ BOARD OF.COUNTY COMMISSION£RS DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR TERRY L. VIRTA, AICP F A X # (407) 468-1735 DATE: ATTN: TRANSMISSION COVER FORM -HAVERT L F£NN. District No. I e JUDY CULP£PPER. District No. 2 ·-JACK KR1EGER. District No. 3 · R. DALE TREFELNER. District No. 4 · JIM MINIX. District No. 5 County Administrator -- JAMES V. CHISHOLM 2300 Virginia'Avenue · Fort Pierce, FL 34982-5652 DirectOr: (407) 468'1.590 · Building: (407) 468-1553 · Planning: (407) 468-1576 Zoning: (407) 468-1553 · Code Enforcement: (407) 468-1571 PORT ST. LUCIE TELEPHONE NO. (407) 87-8-4898 Re~c e iver. Tr-ansmi~tep ~ Da+..e Time Nod,e ~a9 e s I¢e su 1 'c Transmit Con¢'irmat. ion Report 004 84072214126 S:LC/COMM DEUELO:PMENT Jun 25,93 11 :'37 O1 '33 Norm 02 OK ST. LUCIE COUNTY ,BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA ~ULY 21, 1993 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: NOTICE is hereby given in accordance with section 11.00.03 of 1). Petition of Boggs as agent for Bartle¥ Hackley for a 'variance from 9rovisions of Section 7.01.03(A) of tho St. Lucie County Development Code, to permit a 1.4 acre Planned Unit lopment (PUD) appl~cati0n which lacks 8.6 .acres of the nimum~ 10 acres required ~or a Planned Unit Development r the following described p~Operty': Coastal Coves Uni% i Tract C Less the west 169 42 fee% and ~he eas~ 1~0.'00 fee~' ' ' (Located: North Hutchinson Island; North of Pepper Park, west of A-1-A "north) 2). the folloWing property: Lot 1~02-2, Nettles Island Located: 980.1 S. Ocean Drive, Jensen Beach, FL 3). Petition of William Walsh for a variance from Section 7.04.01 Table 1, of th~ St. Lucie County Land Development Code, to permit an existing house with screen por~h which lacks 1.0 foot of the 25 foot rear yard setback as required in RS-4 · zoning for the following described property: Lot 1 Block 16 Queens Cove Unit I Located: 123 Queen Bess Ct., Ft. Pierce, FL PUBLIC HEARING will be held in Room 101, St. Lucie County Administration Building, 2300 Virginia'Avenue, Fort Pierce, Florida on JUly 21,. 1993 beginning at 9:30 A.M. or as soon thereafter as possible. URSUANT TO Section 286.0105, Florida Statutes, if a person decides to appeal ~!any decisiOn made by 'a board, .agency, or commission 'with.respect'to any matter considered at a meeting or hearing, he will ne~d a recor~ of' the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the O ~ · ~ pr ceedings Ks made, which record includes the testimony and evidence Upon whiCh%he apPeaI is t© be based. BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA / s / COLLEEN VACHON, CHAIRMAN PUBLISH JUNE 30, ~993 FILE .N.~E.,"N.UMBER',~' '"' l ST MEETING DATE~ CALIFORNIA EAST BA-93-012 ' 7-12-93 TO: FOR: GROW MGMT CHECK I NG DIR DATE: 06/ 23/ 93 BY.' 'TO: CHARL INE ATTENTION: MIKE BOWERS ~, ~ BOB FRANK THIS SIGN TO BE PUT 'UP. DATED 'COPY OF THIS TO SUE HARTZOG - GROWTH MANAGEMEN D IT CA.N'BE AD TO THE FILE. T H A N K Y~O U. ST. LUCIE COUNTY AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLIC NOTICE I,. , ' , do herieby certify that as Agent for the St,, LUcie County Board of Adjustment on the following .des~r. ib-e_d, pr.ope_rty :~ CALIFORNIA EAST aka BARTLEY HACKLEy' .... NORTH. ~O~.,HUT'CHIN'SON 'ISLAND; NORTH 0F PEPPER (NEE S T~[~.~BE UP~ BY ,0.7-05,93) i~l,i I did on r 19 erect in a conspicuous place on this property the following notice: · PUBLIC NOTICE PUBLIC ~HEARI,NG 'OF' , ORDINANCE ON THIS' T,~E ZONING pROpERTY TO CONSIDER A VARIANCE TO Sw LU~IE COUNTY LAND,~DEVELOPMENT ~OD? WILL BE HELD IN THE'BOARD OF ~DJUSTHENT. PETXT~N ~S ~V~XL~B~E ~N ROO S ig natur.~ ~ Date .-. BLT TR. J Y STATION BLK W ~ BLK X ~' BLK Y '~ BLK Z ~ Thomas Lucido& Associates, P.A. Land PlanningtLandscape Architecture. June 3, 1993 Ms. Julia' Shewchuk .GroWth Man,agement -~ DireCtor St. kUcie: CoUnt:y-.pla~nning 'DePart~ment 23'00 'Virginia, Avenue Ft. Pierce, ~FlOrida: ,:'3498.2-5652~,· _. . -._ ,RE'~ Board; Of' Adj,uStment' California '.East._ Our 'Ref.'- # 4281, . ;, ' ...- . ,'-i · : .' '..~. ' ' J-I-aUi ' ' ar 'De · i ? ; ·, ..- . . -- ... ~ , - ..,. - .. _ ,..: . - " ' " '": ;~' ~ ' ' ' " ' i - ' .~ ': 1PursUant 't° secti°n/,.i'01,'01110'01 °f~.'~,.thest;. Lucie.: County. Land~',"Develb'pment.,!Code,., ... "..and,-,, on ;behalf` of':M.~,.: (Bart::~M,,i~-!~.Hackley);::; Pl'ease i. fi.nd 'enClosed, .. -',informati0n' fOr:i,'the ,~ JUICY., 21:,'1993 .Board-'.of, Adju,stment.m?eeting: ..... . - . - , · ' :..~.apPliCation.:'~f°rl 'i'.variancei:i;(ifrom.:.the 'provisliO-ns: ;of the .':land"i,dev-~l°pment:. -/::'b°'undarY',i'and'.:.topograPhi~C:Su~ey.:.,-.:'.''' :'--: '-~...:. ~':' '_ ~": ".- .: ::. i: ...'. '~i.; 1903 SoUth 25th Street sUite 100 . Fort Pierce, Florida 34947 407/467-1301 -- s!n.'cereli, ...... Director ..." . -. ., · . cc:. Mr. Bart Hfl~ck'ley . , 506 South' Federal Highway Stuart, Florida' 34994 ....... - -,: .:":!:'::'-"~':. :.:L--:': · .. :-."': ,..,- :' ,:':.-':-. .... :h :'_..~.',- · -This_-:reqUest :: f°.r .v~rianCeii..i,d'eals isPeCifiCaliy :'with the':, min:im6m :~ ~a'creage:.~':..':::'. reqUirement in iWhi. Ch.~:to submit~ a ::developm.ent'i.~Plan :Under, .the..:Pla:nned:u,niti; DeVelopme!.~t.-. z~n`.in:g~::`~sta:n`dards~:~h~c~ient:~curr~nt~y`!:.has;~!an~:~.~app~;~edp~an~' !for' ' -/ twelve' ,mUlti.-,:fa-mily..?~,units.'~iati' .this,::'.: ioCatiOni.; ..,,'If '" granted .';!th'e::... varia:nce,:::., i.:WO ::::,ii~te.~id":,:'~. !:~ ... , -,., :,.: ,, r._..;-. ~.. ''I'-P' ~ P an. approval,:for:..a s~x- u.n~t.'-.' s~'n~ 'le ..f ...... .~' ..... '. '"i~ .... --' :,.'-:.." ..~- - ' '" 'nrni~_f:: , ",...-. '~'.'.'-,:,.'." ~ ~' ::'"'-" .... "'".-'~' ?,~"",:' ~: ~.'~ · .... : ' '."' ?','. °' ,' '"';'"':'" '~'"'-":'"'"":'""" :~" · '-i~-~.~ .~,~v~.e .' · ~ , -": '..,'. ' --: ',"':':: , '-' ...... ~.," '' "'' :,:"~. ' ,': :. ' .' : "', -,- ' ' '"-' ::-':'.' "' .:, ~" ': :-" !'~ ' ";~,~ ' *-',,- '-" - '-' :'" -- · ,~ - · , '~,~ .: : '. .; - · : · _' , ' ' , - '. ' ' .' ' ." . :.'-- .:F -~ .,' "~" .' % ,~ · ' - - ~: ' ' . - ' : .. :" .- .' ' - ' - ' ~ , ,.. , ." -' ' ' - . ' , - ;' ' ., .:" -" ~ - '.' . -' -. - ' ' ............ ........ · .... : ', ' .... ' - '-' .... '" ".'" ' ":-'".'-~, ;' :,~', '.'. .... - :", ,:' .'- --:: i: ~' ..'. :, '.";-. ~,.".-,':,.:"' "-' i: ' Please :.contaCt:)me: :shOuld;..:yo.u,.:. have :.any:questions',..or,'.:icOn'Cerns :;reghrd[ng !ithiS~'!'~: ;,i _ ST. LUCIE COUNTY . APPLICATION FOR vARIANcE FROM THE PROVISIONS OF THE. LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE 'o. ~' · ! .. ~, Application Fe.e; $500. .. . I. APPlicant's Name:. ·, ~ . , Greg. Boggs. A.S.L'A. (Thomas~ Lucido & AsSociates) \ . ApPlicant's Address: 1903 SoUth 25th street, Suite #202 Fort Pierce,. Florida 34982 "' "Applic:ant's.Ph0ne Number: .(~I07)i 467-13'01 .2.. ::Leg~lDescription:.` ,. and Street Address Of parcek iPleaSe refer., to Boundary.sUrVey - '. _.3. ~ ParcelSize:. 1.406 acres ' .., . . .:4: :..i proper~ Taxi, Di~ . . ~.~$ ~ . ~i. . , ", · ,: , ' . ~.. .. _ ~ . ' ,'NUmber:. 802,0005,010/8- - for ~elve..multi-family units. Thecurrent zoning)claSSification to dences ~at.this!Ocation is RS-4, "' .-,'-,.., ~-' ~oSed on,the0~er-.bY ~iS'Ordinance~-.-'." . i~.- ' : ;creates-plannin 'hardshi , on,his:,','.- ', r ,~e.- .; .e~& --a-- · a "; .' '- /' ''. ;~i ·" " 'O ,lllIIlttng tactor on':excerclsmg U:D. z0ning'clasSification:;~::.. · -. of 1o~ s~es'.and dimensional.. ~d alloWedunderP~U,D. -- land;, planning' on iand ',... ,learea, access"" -' ' ' ' '; . ~ . 9~ n addlhon, setback cnterm under.~ ~ ZOn~g---- --- -- -. ,., ,, ,,i . , . .. . , -m dass.fication:can,,o,.~e~a~,erea to allow: creates 11,: .State r~mi ~is'~V will :not:increase~ traffic, '" the: danger,°f-fire,:~or impair. , ,.. property,-... '~' -' ::the:neighborhood:in:· WhiChi~the:!subjectplrop,el~.ty located.,-. · ":' ~.',., ,~--- ..~: .... -~,.-~ . The 'single'familY ~eSidenfi~l:!devel°p~~ntwhi~hShb~d(i::':~: 1'2, :- state 'why this .,variance .is: the': minimuTM 'that will.:, make.possible ' 'Use:°f'"fl~'~' iand'bUildini i}"* nd ': 's t~UctUreSi" "'"'"" ~:" '""~' :;~ ~ i' "" '~'' :""' '" ~ :;':" .i:::~ ~: ~':.:i' '"' '"': :.~: )'. -:The' variance is:the)rain ~"a.m!'required t°.Create .asingl'e deVelOpment :criteria 'stated. ~,the P.U-D: reqUire~ents of the C~de, allows, for. altemahve, des: ,~:~.,~:.,:__~_. :_; :,,~..:.,...~.~_:...~gn.: .ut~:. ~,ount stat/'~(~ ~o; ' ' 'is i '' ...... ' '"" "'-" " ..... ' ' .... '. :' ":' '-'- .' ..: .... Y: :..:.~ '~:. :,...:..~ ::,: .:.~: mm:. s. on,.perm~tthe owner .to:construct his':deSi, red ,program; : 13, Explain how ,this.Proposed variance is' consistent With the.general, spiri~,0ftiie.'~'. St'LUCie County Land"Devel°pment-C°de 'and .the SL LUcie c~mprehenSive.Plan, -BY ., all0Wing ' for · . ..... I ' ~ ' ' ~ '- '" · · ' .... ' ' and creahve single famll housin on' '" island '~ . . '-.~ - y g ~ the barner.-~- u .... .. ,~. , ~, ,,.. 'enc°urage character and'efficiency Of layOUt, and:: · hhhes; mamtainin§ conservation; '~ Of native and/or' XeriscaPe landscape materials; ~ ~ ;- .. . · . . . ~. .. ..... ~ , . . · : ~ . . . · .. net residential bUildable area. Given the above ject site ~der th~s straight zonm. g da.sslficatlon, , ~:ment PIan under P.U'D, z°n. ing -WilI ,a.H°w fleXibilitY,-., access-~tandards to Create a s gte family,.ma~cetabie.. . , , ., , State..reas°ns why~s hardship is. unique to .the owner, and why Other,proPerty". similady situated~ does~ not sufi:er~fr0TM the same hardshiP2.: ,.. ".~ :. ':':'..' '~': .. :~ Is desire to~ create a' single-famaY.nei§hb°rhooa on land~that' . s' ' . _~oningreqUirements.'surroUndin~ ... land, to the' ~ tmdar characteristics:has :been developed ' as single family --. State reas0n;.why,t~s :~ariance Will not be 'injurioUs .to-0the~, Property .and/or ~ : improvementS:in',' theneighb°i~hOod-in which,,'ithe'-:SUbjec~ Pr°Perty is~iocated :.. ~The'gr~nt~ng°;t '~i~ ' '-'~ 'tCe Wffi nOt-be:in~mS°~s'as...~the~.pr~per~ in,this/~ ~:: i~nn~me, dia~e:.~i¢ii i' [ ~ :atproved °r haS.similarresidenti~l:n~eS;:This.%"-.~:~, ~.., .-' ' -- '" ": '"i'".":": · ~ '~ ~ ,- ' '.:': '.--. ;' , ., .-'.-.. '.~ . ,. ..-: .... .-.'~, .... '!.. :.o.,_~,, ,- /:._ '. ".'"~ :. ~s.boundedh,.t ~ ~ r .alconstra ........... . ' ...... ..--'.'~ -'. ..... ."'- ........ ....-..:...:~..:. ...... Y~ :~ :.: , _ .~ . mts, afin er-c. alto. ~ .... : ..~ :~ -.- ,-:.- .:~ , ........~-. ,~,, ~ .~ ... ... .... g ....~ .. the north.and alarge ,.. ,.... mangrove;'wetl~ ,~ , ~ sou~,'To ~' ""'"' '"'"' :'""'"' ':' ........ ~ ..... '"'-~ .... ' .... :'"' ~' "-' · _..~: :' .. . ' .... :;..,, ~, ~., -the-west,hes-'suni]~ und 'v- :- .' ' ' ' : ~-'.'~ ': .... :., c---"' ' .:'-:'" ';-:' ', J' "..' ' :P...~.,~;.p_arce!s.havmg .~_.on~ge 0n.:aman, made::~ ~ PhOne N~ber:!i: ~,. · : : proPertY Sh°wing.~the dimenSions 0f~the-i°t and ..all '.:Uhders~and tl~-'~-a~Pli'cati6n; '~-'- ~ ... ' -~- ~ ': alist0f.the questions to-be:anSwered'bY the Prepared' to ~anSWer . my ;behalf..at. the~pUblic hearing; .. · ,. · . . . . Property O wrier s Signature(s) -'Dhte · .. . : ,,~ ,, . .-. _ , · -, ! i7:.' ' :Please.attaCh other "d~mensi0ns" necesm my age,nt,afisWei;/th%e maintaining and/or lOwering of'public facility standards (water, sewer, & traffic) and evels ~of service. · : 14. ~ Owner~of proPerty': if' different from aPPlicant: Bart M. Hackley . ., Name~ Mr. . . . _ ' : Address: '73-596 Am~ Drive, palm Desert, California 92260 · ., Phone Number:' .. 619~340,1668 · · .. . , ,. 15.~'.'__ _~_If aPPlicant is.not the. Pmper~,:oWner' explain .the applicant, s relationship to the ~ Land,planning conSul~nt forowner' , - . -- _ . ~ .. ~, uthorized by.applicant'm-rePresent the applicant. ~. . -. _ . ~Name:, GregB0ggsA'$.LA~ ,~.. -. '~ ..-.. - . . - .;. . - . ,. , . _ . Address: 1903 S°Uth't~$th street Suite ~#202 Fort Pierce, ,Florida 34982- '..~: ..~ -' ~ '~ · - : _. , ~: ~... - 16. t7. Agent authorized by applicant to repreSent ~ aPplicant. Name: Greg Bo~s A.S.L.A. ddress, 1903 South 25th Street Suite #100 Fort Pierce, Florida 34982 Phone Number: (407) 467-1301 -" , Please, attach a diagram of the property showing the dimensions of ,the lot and all other qimensions necessary to understand the application. .I have been furnished a :list of the questions to.be answered by the aPplic~nt for a varianCe and will be prepared to answer these questions or have my agent ansWer..these qUestions on my behalf at the'PUblic hearing. Applicant's Signature Date- · Property Date · . FILE COPY ,St. Lucie County. BUILDING DEPARTMENT City of Ft. Pierce City of Port St. Lucie EXPLANATION ,REC'D White. Customer Canary- FORT PIERCE, RECEIPT N° 62561 TOTAL AMT. R ' ~ (~' (~ 0 - EC D $__ File Copy ACCOUNT NUMBER . · i THOMAS' ~LUCIDO & ASSOCIAT '~rS P.A. 506 SOUTH FEDERAL HIGHWAY STUART, FLORIDA 34994 407.220.2100 FAX: 407.223.0220 1903 SOUTH 25TH STREET SUITE 100 FORT PIERCE, FL 34947 407.467.1301 FAX: 407.467.1303 Han. p..cLJ~eTl/' Mail Client Pickup UPS Express Mail Spec Books Signed & Sealed Submittal Package ,, '~" ~:~ 16,.' Agent authorized by applicant torepresent the applicant. ., ~ .' · -. Greg Bo§gs A.S'L.A :,, , .... · :~'~ .... ~:', ,Name: : . AddresS: ~ 1903 South 25th street Suite #100 Fort Pierce, Florida 34982 Phone Number: (40.7)~ 467'1301 . ' .- , Please ~attach a diagram of the property showing the dimensiOns of the lot and ail other dimensions necessary to understand the application. 18. · · . ~I haVe been furnished a list .of the questions to be answered by the ~ ppltcant fora variance will be prepared to answer these questions or have my agent answer these uestions on my behalf atthe public hearing. , ApPlicant's'- Si gna ture ., Date '-' ~ Property Owner's signature(s) ' Date Date . . . , :. ,FILE COPY BUILDING DEPARTMENT City of Ft. Pierce o St. Lucie County RECEIVED { EXPLANATION REC'D RECEIPT N'°- 6 2 5 61 City of POrt St. Lucie t. Lucie Vill~~ FORT PIERCE,FLORID 19/~-,..~ TOTAL AMT. REC'D $ White - Customer - File Copy BARLETT M HACKLEY JR RAND~ L HACKLEY 73-596 AMIR DR PAI~ DESERT CA 92260 COASTAL COVE ASSN INC 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE FL 34949 #1, 16 HARRY KORMAN ROBERT & RITA R SWEDROE P O BX 611417 N MIAMI FL 33261 #2,14, BLK T ILYAS BAWANY 68 E WACKER PL STE 800 CHICA~ IL 60601 BLK U-Z; PEPPER PARK ST LUCIE COUNTY BCC ROGER POITRAS ANNEX 2300 VIRGINIA AVENUE FT PIERCE FL 34982 #3-5 PERCY MALLISON DIRE~R DIV OF STATE LANDS, DNR 3900 COMMONWE~TH BLV RO2~ 4£ TALLAHASSEE FL 32399 #3-5 BOB PRZEKOP DEPT NAT RESOLIRCES DIVISION OF STATE LANDS 4842 SOUTH US t~5~ 1 FT PIERCE FL 34982 #4 (FIRE STA #9) ST LUCIE FT .PIERCE FIRE DIST P O B× 3030 FI' PIERCE FL 34948 VIVIAN G STEVENS RAYMOND E GUTERMUTH 3035 NE GARDEN TERR PAI/~ BAY FL 32905 #~7 RESOLUTION TRUST CORP 1600 S FEDERAL HWY FT PIERCE ~ 34950 #~8 KENNETH L JACKSON ET AL C/O KEN JACKSON JR RR 2 B× 532 FARMINGTON NH 03835 #'!;9 ,UNIT 1 ~ 23 LOUIS & MARY SPERANZA 915 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 #1'0 CHARLES W & HETTIE D STONE 406-1/2 S 5TH ST FT PIERCE FL 34950 #11 LEE EVELYN W~CE PO BX 76 SMITHVILLE TX 78957 #12 SARA J GIBSON 329 DAHL 'ST RHINELANDER WI 54501 #13 INDIAN RIVER TRADING CORP P O BX 673 FT PIERCE FL 34954 #15 LUGANO INVESTMENTS INC 233 E WACKER DR ~1011 CHICAGO IL 60601 UNITS 1-5 LARRY R STEWART DIANE L STEWART 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNITS '1,2' C MARSHALL SANDE~OFF 3409 N A1A FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 3 ROBERT & KAR~ ISHMAN '1423 JACKSON ST HOLLYWOOD FL -33020 UNIT 4 ME~RA SUN CORP 6211 SW 45 ST DAVIE FL 33314 UNIT 5 , MARY M ~PAGNOLA 3401 NORTH A1A FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 TRACT A ANDRFA MEI/DN 3120 N A1A-UNIT 501 FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 1 GEORGE R & ETHEL M METZ 930 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 ~ 2 BRENDA S PFEIFFER 928 JACKSON WAY FT pIERCE FL 34949 UNIT i'IOT 3 EUGENE & LAURA CACCAMO 11230 NW 5TH ST PLANTATION FL 33325 UNIT 1 LOT 4 JANE M BROOKS- 924 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 5 RONALD A WELLHAM SR SHIRLEY J WELLHAM 922 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LfYr 6 MURRAY D & PF3%RL P ROSENBERG CARL E & JOAN-E ROSENBERG 2376 KENIIA~RTH CLEVEIAND HEIGHTS OH 44108 UNIT 1 LOT 7 JAMES H & JUNE L DEKKER 918 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL '34949 UNIT 1 LOT 8 H T & C G SNYDER 916 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 .LOT 9 JOSEPH & NO1~3% KNESPL~ 914 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 IDT 22 BRUCE A & AUDREY M MOYER 5482 BLUE CHURCH RD COOPERSBURG PA 18036 UNIT 1 LOT 24 GEORGE B STALLINGS 917 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 25 WM H & CAROLYN A SAMUEL 919 JACKSON WAY F£ PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 26 EDW~ & MARY BRISBOIS P O BX 4146 FI' PIERCE FL 34948 UNIT 1 ~ 27 JENNIE H GATZ 923 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 ~ 28 PETER & VIVIAN CORBA 5059 N A1A UNIT B906 FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 .If~ 29 BERTHA PETE~ 927 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 LOT 30 JAMES L & CONSTANCE FOX 929 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE FL 34949 UNIT 1 I//r 31 WILLIAM H POWELL RR 2 WILSON AV BX 485 BARNSBORO NJ 08080 COUNTY ROADS PROPERTY ACQUISITION DIV ROGER POITRAS ANNEX 2300 VIRGINIA AVL'-NUE FT PIERCE FL 34982 STATE ROADS FDOT JOHN ANDERSON 3111 S DIXIE HWY STE 112 MAIItK)X 122 W PAI2~ BCH FL 33405 GREG BOCK~s, A. $. L.A. THOS LUCIDO & ASSOCIATES 1903 S 25TH ST STE 202 FT PIERCE FL 34947 MAST REQUEST ("A" ) I.D. (1423-802-0003-010/8 HACKLEY, BARLETT M JR HACKLEY~ RANDALL L 73-5 96 AMIR DR PALM DESERT, CA 92260-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09'26 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- TRACT ~-LESSAssESsEDW~169'38 FT & LESS THAT QR 349-439 & LESS AS IN OR ~93-1907- (1~.24 AC) (OR ~88-2612:801-205) LD ID NO. ~ARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 0000 DATE SOLD 04/01/88 CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = I IMP SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 01 DISQ SAL * ASSESSED = · EXEMPTION = · TAXABLE = O588 2612 14/23S 02COUNTY YES 124930 124930 124930 -EXEMPTIONS .......................................... NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 09:35:02 am1 MAST ST. REQUEST ( "A" ) I.D. (1423-802-0002-000/8 i COASTAL COVE I ASSN INC 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:34 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) ~1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESc COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- THAT PART TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT NWLY COR OF SD TRACT B RUN SELY ALG W LI OF SD TRACTS B & C S 21 DEG 39 MIN E 220.56 FT,TH W 42.10 FT,TH S 115 FT TO S LI OF SD OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. ..... EXEMPTIONS D.O.R. CODE 0300 DATE SOLD 08/17/92 V CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 100 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0803 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 2989 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23L SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 235000 C QUAL/CODE * LASS. USE = 01 DISQ SAL J* ASSESSED 235000 · EXEMPTION~ = · TAXABLE = 235000 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0 ! Frmt I !Page I Wrap I i ! ! Poll 109:35:45 amI INQ ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL & ASSESSMENT ( ) EQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1423-802-0002-000/8 ] 06/15/93 09:34 GAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:COASTAL COVE I ASSN INC SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/34S/40E STAL COVES-UNIT 1- THAT PART TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT NWLY OF SD TRACT B RUN SELY ALG W LI OF SD TRACTS B & C S 21 DEG 9 MIN E 220.56 FT,TH W 42.10 FT,TH S ].15 FT TO S LI OF ~D TRACT ,TH E ALG SD S LI 87.75 FT,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 109 ET ~ N 68 21 MIN E 10 FT,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 32.99 FT,TH E 85-o0 T,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 16.98 FT,TH N 68 DEG 21 MIN E 48 FT TO E I OF SD TRACT B,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W ALG SD ELI 162.29 FT TO Y COR OF SD TRACT B,TH W 150 FT TO POB-~SS COASTAL cOV~ (OR 803-2989) .................. ~ ~ THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED. 101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE 109:36:08 amI INUMIV4-26tC3 MAST~ ST. REQUEST ( ~ ) I.D.(1423-440-0006-000/6 KORMAN, HARRY SWEDROE, ROBERT & RITA R P O BX 611417 N MIAMI,FL 33261-0000 LUCIE COUNTY' PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10'29 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 N 200 FT OF S 968 FT OF FRACT SE ]_/4 LYG E OF A1A (3.39 AC) (OR 214-114:580-2961) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CLASS. SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV V VAC SALE QUAL/CODE 01 DISQ SAL CODE 0000 USE CODE DATE SOLD 03/01/88 SALE AMT 100 23 O.R. BOOK 0580 34S O.R. PAGE 296]. 40E MAP ID 14/23N 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. * LAND (MARKET) = 243810 * IMPROVEMENT - * CLASS USE = * ASSES ED = 243810 = 243810 * EXEMP' ION * TAXABi E .... EXEMPTIONS ....................... NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** Poll t10:30:30 amI MAST ST. REQUEST ( ~ ) * I.D.(1423-440-0008-000/0 BAWANY, ILYAS 68 E WACKER PL STE 80.0 CHICAGO,IL 60601-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:29 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 N 100 FT OF S 768 FT OF FRACT SE 1/4 LYG E OF A1A (1.70 D.O.R. CODE 0000 DATE SOLD 07/25/90 V CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 100 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0702 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 0412 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23N SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. AC) OLD ID NO o PARENT ID (OR 702-412) VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 121910 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS~ USE = ~ 02 MOR TH 1 * ASSESSED = 121910 · EXEMPTION = NO. * TAXABLE , = 121910 .................. EXEMPTIONS ................. ~ ............... NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** Poll 110:31:31 amI MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-803-0001-000/4 BAWANY, ILYAS 68 E WACKER PL STE 800 CHICAGO, IL 60601-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:04 ) PAGE (0t) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... PLAT OF BLOCKS T-U-V-W-X-Y-Z OF NORTH BEACH .BLOCK T (OR 702-4.12) D.O.R. CODE 0000 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423803 LOAN VACANT/IMPRV V VAC SALE QUAL/CODE 02 MOR TH 1 OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. ................... EXEMPTIONS DATE SOLD 07/25/90 V SALE AMT O.Ro BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID TAX AUTH. NOTES LENDING INSTo 100 0702 0412 14/23S 02COUNTY YES * LAND (MARKET) = 117350 * IMPROVEMENT = * CLASS~ USE = * ASSESSED = 117350 * EXEMPTION = * TAXABLE = 117350 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 01 F mti [ I ! poll !~0:05:39 amt [~~1v4.26[03 REQUEST ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:04 I-D.(1423-803-0002-000/1 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ST LUCIE COUNTY LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... PLAT OF BLOCKS T-V-W-X-Y-Z- OF NORTH BEACH BLOCKS U-V-W-X-Y-Z & AREA E OF SD BLKS AS IN~ OR 223-2071 (10.32 AC) (OR 420-2203,2204) OLD ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 8200 DATE SOLD 12/01/83 CLASS. USE CODE iSALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0420 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 2204 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423803 NOTES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 1369130 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 01 DISQ SAL * ASSESSED = 1369130 * EXEMPTION = 1369130 PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = ...... EXEMPTIONS .................................... SL CO 1369130 NOT'H: W' C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0[Frmtl iPageI ! I Poll [10:05:58 am[ I Nu~llv4.261c3 MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) REQUEST (!#3 ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 11:44 I.D.(1425-220-0001-000/1 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) TR INT IMP TRUST FUND 3305 N A 1 A CTY ST LUCIE COUNTY-LESSEE- DoO.R. CODE 8200 DATE SOLD -PEPPER PARK- ~ CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 25 O.R° BOOK TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/25N SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND MARKET) = 1932000 · IMPROTEMENT = 325380 QUAL/CODE * CLASS, USE = · ASSESSED = 2257380 · EXEMP?ION = 2257380 · TAXABLE = EXEMPTIONS ......................................... NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS.SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 25/26 34 40 GOVT LOT 1 IN SEC 25 & GOVT LOT 1 IN SEC 26 ALL LYG E OF A1A (20.36 AC) (LEASE AGR #3370) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. STATE FL 2257380 T01Frmtl iPage I Wrapl I I ! !11:46:13 amI MAST ST. REQUEST ( ~ ) I.D. (1426-1~11-0001-000/9 TR INT IMP TRUST FUND ST LUCIE COUNTY-LESSEE- -PEPPER PARK- LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 3595 N A1A CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 10:07 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 26 34 40 THAT PART OF GOVT LOT 1 IN SEC 26 MPDAF:BEG INT WLY R/W SSR A1A & N LI SD SEC 26,TH W ALG SD N LI 200 FT,TH S 250 FT,TH E 300 FT M/L TO WLY R/W SR A1A,TH NWLY ALG SD R/W 267 FT OLD ID NO. ~ PARENT ID NO. ................... EXEMPTIONS SL CO 302970 QUAL/CODE 8600 26 34S 40E 0053 * LAND * IMPROVEMENT * CLASS. USE * ASSESSED DATE SOLD SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID TAX AUTH. NOTES LENDING INST. (MARKET) = * EXEMPTION = , TAXABLE = 14/25N 02 COUNTY 145520 157450 302970 302970 NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01FrmtI INQ REQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1426-111-0001-000/9 ] LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:TR INT IMP TRUST FUND SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE= 26/34S/40E 26 34 40 THAT PART OF GOVT LOT 1 IN SEC 26 MPDAF:BEG INT WLY R/W SSR A1A & N LI SD SEC 26,TH W ALG SD N LI 200 FT,TH S 250 FT,TH E 300 FT M/L TO WLY R/W SR A1A,TH NWLY ALG SD R/W 267 FT M/L TO POB (1.43 AC) (FIRE STA #9) (LEASE AGR #3370) ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL & ASSESSMENT ( ) 06/15/93 10:11 * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED. 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE T01Frmt{ I pageIwrapl I I !10:13:21 ami INUMIV4-261C3 MAST REQUEST ) I.D. (1425-220-0002-000/8 TR INT IMP TRUST FUND ST LUCIE COUNTY-LESSEE- -PEPPER PARK- LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 11:45 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 25/26 34 40 GOVT LOT 1 IN SEC 25 & GOVT LOT 1 IN SEC 26 ALL LYG W OF AiA-LESS TO FIRE STA #9 SIiTE IN NE COR (11.85 AC) (LEASE AGR #3370) D.O.R. CODE 8200 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 25 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV QUAL/CODE OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. ....................... EXEMPTIONS STATE FL 216140 DATE SOLD SALE ANT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID 14/25N TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. * LAND (MARKET) = 193590 * IMPROVEMENT = 22550 * CLASS. USE = * ASSESSED = 216140 * EXEMPTION = 216140 * TAXABLE = NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0tFrmtI MAST REQUEST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) ) * PARCE'L MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 11:47 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) I.D.(1426-120-0001-000/7 STEVENS, VIVIAN G GUTERMUTH, RAYMOND E 3035 NE GARDEN TERR PALM BAY, FL 32905-0000 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC 26 34 40 GOV LOT 2-LESS W 10 AC- ( 29.50 AC) (OR 616-2663:774-572) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SALE ANT 100 SECTION 26 O.R. BOOK 0774 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 0572 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/26X SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 14750 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 02 NOR TH 1 * ASSESS,ED = 14750 · EXEMPTION = · TAXABLE = 14750 ............... EXEMPTIONS 9900 DATE SOLD 01/10/92 V *** THIS NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0tFrmti Poi1111:48:29 amt MAST ST. REQUEST ) I.D.(1423-802-0002-200/0 RESOLUTION TRUST CORP 1,600 S FEDERAL HWY FT PIERCE,FL 34950-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:38 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT SE COR TR C,TH RUN WLY ALG S LI TR C 150 FT,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 109 FT,TH N 68 DEG 21 MIN E 10 FT,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 32.99 FT,TH OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 0800 DATE SOLD CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = · IMPROVEMENT = 141000 QUAL/CODE * CLASS~ USE = · ASSESSED = 141000 · EXEMPTION = 1423-802-0002-020/4 SPLIT * TAXABLE = 141000 ...................... EXEMPTIONS ........................... 14/23S 02COUNTY YES NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED T01FrmtI INQ REQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1423-802-0002-200/0 ] LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:RESOLUTION TRUST CORP SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/34S/4 E COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT E COR TR C,TH RUN WLY ALG S LI TR C 150 FT,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 109 FT,TH N 68 DEG 21 MIN E 10 FT,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 32.99 FT,TH ELY 87.60 FT,TH N 21 DEG 39 MIN W 16.98 FT,TH N 68 DEG 21 MIN E 48 FT TO W R/W LI A1A,TH SELY ALG SD R/W LI 182 FT TO POB-LESS UNITS 1,2.3~4 & 5- (0 47 AC) (OR 753 447) ......... ~" ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL & ASSESSMENT ( ) 06/15/93 09:39 * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED. 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE TO I Frmtt l page I wrapl I I I 109' 40:45 ami MAST REQUEST I.D.(1423-802-0003-000/5 JACKSON, KENNETH L MOATES, FRANCES N FOREMAN, BETTY A C/O KEN JACKSON JR RR 2 BX 532 FARMINGTON,NH 03835-9731 ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- W 169.38 FT OF TRACT C (OR 240-2028: 546-2353) ST . LUCIE COUNTY ERTY A~,PRAISER THAN-PRO FUNC ( ) PROPEL MAST 06/15/93 10:22 ) * PARC ER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) D.O.R. CODE 0000 DATE SOLD 04/01/87 CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0546 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 2353 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 48240 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS, USE = 01 DISQ SAL * ASSESSED 48240 · EXEMPTION~ = · TAXABLE = 48240 OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. .............................. EXEMPTIONS ................ NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** MAST REQUEST ( ~ ) I.D.(1423-440-0013-000/8 SPERANZA, LOUIS & MARY 915 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 {Page{Wrap{ { { Poll {10:24:15 am{ {NUMIV4.26{C3 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY. APPRAISER THAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:23 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST 0000 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 FROM SW COR TRACT C COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1,AS IN PB 10-71 RUN N 25 FT 'FOR POB,TH W 100 FT,TH N 90 FT,TH E 100 FT,TH S 90 FT TO POB (OR 399-1761) SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV V VAC SALE QUAL/CODE 00 QUAL SAL 23 34S 40E 0053 * LAND * IMPRO~ * CLASS * ASSES OLD ID NO. * EXEMP~ PARENT ID NO. ' * TAXAB~ ............................. EXEMPTIONS ............ DATE SOLD 04/01/83 SALE AMT 12000 O.R. BOOK 0399 O.R. PAGE 1761 MAP ID 14/23N TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES LENDING INST. MARKET) = 9480 EMENT = USE = ED = 9480 'ION = 0E = 9480 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0{Frmt{ {Page {Wrap{ Po11110:24:45 am! I NUMlV4. 261C3 MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-440-0014-000/5 STONE, CHARLES W & HETTIE D 406 1/2 S 5 ST FT PIERCE,FL 34950-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:23 ) PAGE (0i) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ---'- 23 34 40 FROM SW COR TRACT C COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1,AS IN PB 10-71 RUN N 25 FT,TH W 100 FT FOR POB,TH N 90 FT,TH W 100 FT,TH S 90 FT,TH E 100 FT TO POB D.O.R. CLASS. SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV QUAL/CODE OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. ................. EXEMPTIONS CODE 0000 USE CODE 23 34S 40E 0053 * LAND { * IMPROX/rEMENT * CLASSi USE * ASSESSED E XEMP~ I ON * TAXAB~E DATE SOLD SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID TAX AUTH. NOTES LENDING INST. MARKET) = 14/23N 02 COUNTY 9480 9480 9480 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** REQUEST ( I.D.(1423-440-0015-000/2 WALLACE, LEE EVELYN P O BX 76 SMITHVILLE,TX 78957-0000 Poll !10:25:24 am! COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:24 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) D.O.R. CODE 0000 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV * LAND V VAC SALE * IMPRO' QUAL/CODE * CLASS 00 QUAL SAL * LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 FROM SW COR TRACT C, COASTAL COVE- UNIT 1 AS IN PL BK 10-71,RUN N 25 FT,TH W 200 FT FOR POB,TH N 90 FT,TH W 125 FT,TH S 90 FT,TH E 125 FT TO POB (OR 345-719) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. .... EXEMPTIONS ................. DATE SOLD 11/01/80 SALE AMT 20000 O.R. BOOK, 0~345 O.R. PAGE 0719 MAP ID 14/23N TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. MARKET) = 11850 EMENT = USE = ED = 11850 = 11850 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtl t PagelWrapl I i Poll 110:25:46 amI I NUMtV4.26 IC3 MAST REQUEST ~ ) I.D.(1423-440-0016-000/9 GIBSON, SARA J 329 DAHL ST RHINELANDER,WI 54501-0000 J~ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 11:49 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) D.O.Ro CODE 0000 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 FROM SW COR TRACT C COASTAL COVE-UNIT 1,AS IN PL BK 10-71 RUN N 25 FT,TH W 325 FT FOR POB,TH N 90 FT,TH W 125 FT,TH S 90 FT,TH E 125 FT TO POB (OR 697-502) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. LOAN VACANT/IMPRV * LAND V VAC SALE * IMPRO' QUAL/CODE * CLASS 01 DISQ SAL * ASSESi · EXEMP' · TAXABi .............................. EXEMPTIONS .................. DATE SOLD 06/].1/90 V SALE AMT 100 O.R. BOOK 0697 O.R. PAGE 0502 MAP ID 14/23N TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. MARKET) = 11850 ZEMENT = USE = :ED = 11850 'ION = ,~E = 11850 *** T.~LIS INFO IS NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS IEVED ~CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0tFrmtI IPagelWrapl i i t Po1111'1:50:i44 amt t NUMIV4'261C3 REQUE ( * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 11:49 I.D. (1423-440-0009-000/7 BAWANY, ILYAS 68 E WACKER PL STE 800 CHICAGO, IL 60601-0000 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 N 200 FT OF S 768 FT OF FRACT SE 1/4 LYG W OF A1A-LESS S 170 FT OF E 845 FT AS MEAS ALG S LI- (4.64 AC) (OR 702-412) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) D.O.R. CODE 0000 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0'053 SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV * LAND ( V VAC SALE * IMPROV QUAL/CODE * CLASS. 02 MOR TH 1 ~* ASSESS · EXEMP~ 1423-440-0009-000/7 SPLIT * TAXABL .......... EXEMPTIONS ............ DATE SOLD 07/25/90 V SALE AMT O. R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID TAX AUTH. NOTES LENDING INST. .~ARKET ) = EMENT USE D ON 100 0702 0412 14/23N 02COUNTY YES 15390 15390 15390 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 00SVOiD ACCT T01Frratl IPagelWrap[ ! ! ! Poll 111:51:~2 ami iNUM;V4.261C3 MAST ST. REQUEST (~) I .D-(1423-440-0012-000/1 INDIAN RIVER TiRADING CORP P O BX 673 FT PIERCE,FL 34954-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 14:11 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 BEG ON S LI OF SEC AT PT 875.03 FT W OF W R/W OF A1A,TH CONT W ON S SEC LI TO E SIDE OF ARTIFICIAL WATERWAY,TH FOLLOW SD WATERWAY IN NWLY DIRECTION,TH ELY DIRECTION TO PT OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. ............. EXEMPTIONS D.O.R. CODE 0000 DATE SOLD CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. SUBDIVISION NOTES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = QUAL/CODE * IMPROVEMENT * CLASS. USE * ASSESSED * EXEMPTION * TAXABLE 14/23N 02COUNTY 13160 = 13160 = 13160 NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtl IPagelWrapt i I P°11102:13:03 Pm! tNUMtV4-261C3 INQ ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL & ASSESSMENT ( ) REQUEST [#14 ] PARCEL ID [1423-440-0012-000/1 ] 06/15/93 14:11 LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:INDIAN RIVER TRADING CORP SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/34S/40E 23 34 40 BEG ON S LI OF SEC AT PT 875.03 FT W OF W R/W OF A1A,TH CONT W ON S SEC LI TO E SIDE OF ARTIFICIAL WATERWAY,TH FOLLOW SD WATERWAY IN NWLY DIRECTION,TH ELY DIRECTION TO PT 115 FT DUE N OF POB,TH S TO POB SHOWN ON PLAT OF COASTAL COVES-UNIT NO 1- PL BK 10-71-LESS E 450 FT OF N 90 FT- * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED. 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE Poll 102:13:26 pm! tNUMIV4-261C3 MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1 ~40-0018-000/3 LUGANO INVESTMENTS~ INC 233 E WACKER DR #1011 CHICAGO,IL 60601-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:27 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) D.O.R. CODE 0000 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S 40E 0053 RANGE LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 23 34 40 N 170 FT OF S 738 FT OF SUBDIVISION FRACT SE 1/4 LYG W OF A1A & E OF LOAN N/S LI 845 FT W OF A1A AS MEAS VACANT/IMPRV ALG S LI OF PARCEL (3.16 AC) (OR V VAC SALE 828-207) QUAL/CODE 01 DISQ SAL OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. DATE SOLD 01/27/93 V 100 0828 0207 14/23N 02COUNTY YES SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID TAX AUTH. NOTES LENDING INST. MARKET) = __ USE :ED ION E * LAND * IMPRO * CLASS = * ASS = * EX = 14~23-440-0009-000/7 SPLIT * TA = ....... EXEMPTIONS ........................ 93950 93950 93950 NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** ~AST (~ ST LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) EQUEST ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 10:27 I.D. (1423-4;~40-0007-000/3 KORMAN, HARRY SWEDROE , ROBERT P O BX 611417 N MIAMI,FL 33261-0000 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... 23 34 40 N 200 FT OF S 968 FT OF FRACT SE 1/4 LYG W OF A1A (5.91 AC) (OR 214-114) ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 0000 DATE SOLD CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. SUBDIVISION NOTES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND .(MARKET) - · IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS~ USE = · ASSESSED = · EXEMPTION = · TAXAB~ = -EXEMPTIONS ................. ~ ............ 14/23N 02COUNTY YES 126940 126940 126940 NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0 ! Frmt i !page i Wrap I I I Poll i10:29:22 amI INUMtV4-261C3 MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0002-010/1 STEWART, LARRY R & DIANE L 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:35 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PiROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- THAT PART TRACTS B & C KNOWN AS COASTAL COVE I UNIT i MPDAF: OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 05/28/92 V CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0793 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 0708 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23L SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = I IMP SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 47000 QUAL/CODE * CLASS USE = 0]. DISQ SAL * ASSESSED = 47000 · EXEMPtiON = 1423-802-0002-000/8 SPLIT * TAXABLE = 47000 .............................. EXEMPTIONS ........................................ NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0tFrmt! MAST REQUEST ( ) I .D. ( 1423-802-0002-020/4 STEWART, LARRY R & DIANE L 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY~ PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:36 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNI~T 1- THAT PART TRACTS B & C KNOWN AS COASTAL COVE I UNIT 2 MPDAF: OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.OoR. CODE 01.00 DATE SOLD CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK TOWNSHIP 34S OoR. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = · IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = · ASSESSED = · EXEMPTION = 14/23L 02COUNTY YES 47000 47000 1423-802-0002-010/1 SPLIT * TAXABLE = 47000 ............ EXEMPTIONS .................................. NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 9005VOID FOR THIS ACCT T01Frrati [PagelWrap[ I I Poll 109:38:08 amt MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0002-030/7 STEWART, LARRY R & DIANE L 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09'37 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- THAT PART TRACTS B & C KNOWN AS COASTAL COVE I UNIT 3 MPDAF: OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 0100 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN VACANT/IMPRV * LAND · IMPRO' QUAL/CODE * CLASS · ASSES · EXEMP' 1423-802-0002-010/1 SPLIT * TAXAB ---EXEMPTIONS ................. DATE SOLD SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID 14/23L TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. MARKET) = ~EMENT = 47000 USE = IED = 47000 ?ION = ~E = 47000 . NOT: H: W' C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 9005VOID FOR THIS ACCT T0tFrmtl tpagelWrapt i I i Po11-109:38:52 am! MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0002-040/0 STEWART~ LARRY R & DIANE L 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:37 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- THAT PART TRACTS B & C KNOWN AS COASTAL COVE I UNiT 4 MPDAF: OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 0100 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN VACANT/IMPRV QUAL/CODE * LAND * IMPROVEMENT * CLASS. USE * ASSESSED * EXEMPTION 1423-802-0002-010/1 SPLIT * TAXABLE ..... EXEMPTIONS ......................... DATE SOLD SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID TAX AUTH. NOTES LENDING INST. (MARKET) = 14/23L 02COUNTY YES 47000 47000 47000 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 9005VOID FOR THIS ACCT T01Frmtl iPage I Wrapi I I Poll 109: 39:14 amt MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0002-050/3 STEWART, LARRY R & DIANE L 2901 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:38 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- THAT PART TRACTS B & C KNOWN AS COASTAL COVE I UNIT 5 MPDAF: OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.R. CODE 0100 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN VACANT/IMPRV QUAL/CODE 1423-802-0002-010/1 .............. EXEMPTIONS ..... * LAND (MARKET) * IMPROVEMENT * CLASS USE * ASSES ED * EXEMP ION SPLIT * TAXAB E DATE SOLD SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID TAX AUTH. NOTES LENDING INST. 14/23L 02COUNTY YES 47000 47000 47000 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** Po11109:39:58 amI I NUMIV4. 261C3 MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0002-210/3 SANDERHOFF, C MARSHALL 3409 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C'MPDAF:BEG AT SE COR TR C,TH RUN WLY ALG S LI TR C 95.27 FT,TH DUE N 109.78 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 ) PAGE (01) OF 3409 N A1A CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV I IMP SALE QUAL/CODE 00 QUAL SAL TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 09.39 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 0100 DATE SOLD 01/31/92 V SALE AMT 52500 23 O.R. BOOK 0775 34S O.R. PAGE 2071 40E MAP ID 14/23S 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY 1423802 NOTES YES LENDING INST. * LAND (MARKET) = * IMPROVEMENT = * CLASS. USE = * ASSESSED = 47000 47000 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = 25000 PARENT ID NO. 1423-802-0002-200/0 SPLIT * TAXABLE = 22000 ...................... EXEMPTIONS .................................... i R HMSTD 25000 NOT:H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01FrmtI INQ REQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1423-802-0002-210/3 ] LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:SANDERHOFF, C MARSHALL SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/34S/40E COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT SE C©R TR C,TH RUN WLY ALG S LI TR C 95.27 FT,TH DUE N 109.78 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 FT,~TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC E 20.70.FT,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 67.89 FT,TH S 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC WI 20.35 FT,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 8.00 FT,TH S 00 DEG 18 MIN 58 SEC W 0.35 FT TO POB (UNIT 1) (OR 775-2071) IPageIwrapl ! [ Poll [09:41:31 am! [NUMtV4.261C3 ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL i& ASSESSMENT ( ) 06/15/93 09:40 * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT 'WARRANTED. 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE T01Frmtt l vageiWrap] [ [ i Poll t09:41:43 amt MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0002-220/6 SANDERHOFF, C MARSHALL 3409 N A1A FT PIERCE, FL 34949-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:40 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT SE. COR TR C,TH RUN WLY ALG S LI TR C 87.35 FT,TH DUE N 89.75 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 OLD ID NO. D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV I IMP SALE QUAL/CODE 00 QUAL SAL 0100 DATE SOLD 01/31/92 V * LAND (MARKET) * IMPROVEMENT * CLASS.. USE * ASSESSED * EXEMPTION TAXABLE SALE AMT 52500 23 O.R. BOOK 0775 34S O.R. PAGE 2056 40E MAP ID 14/23S 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY 1423802 NOTES YES LENDING INST. 47000 47000 PARENT ID NO. 1423-802-0002-200/0 SPLIT * = 47000 EXEMPTIONS ......................................... NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtl IpageIWrapt I ! Po11109:42:31 amI I NO lV4.261C3 INQ REQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1423-802-0002-220/6 ] LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:SANDERHOFF, C MARSHALL SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/34S/40E COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT SE COR TR C,TH RUN .WLY ALG S LI TR C 87.35 FT,TH DUE N 89.75 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC E 19.65 FT,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 8.00 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC E 0.35 FT,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 75.09 FT,TH S 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC W 19.65 FT,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 8.00 FT,TH S 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC W 0.35 FT TO POB (UNIT 2) (OR 775-2056) ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL & ASSESSMENT ( ) 06/15/93 09:41 * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED. 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE . T01Frmtl i~age I Wrapl i ! 109: 42:41 amt INUMIV4-261C3 MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0002-230/9 ISHMAN, ROBERT & KAREN 1423 JACKSON ST HOLLYWOOD,FL 33020-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:41 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT SE COR TR C,TH RUN WLY ALG S LI TR C 79.43 ET,TH DUE N 69.72 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 ET,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. 1423-802-0002-200/0 SPLIT * TAXA] .............................. EXEMPTIONS ................ D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 01/31/92 V CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 52500 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0775 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 2054 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTHo 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = I IMP SALE * IMPROV' EMENT = 47000 QUAL/CODE * CLASS, USE -= 00 QUAL SAL * ASSESSED = 47000 · EXEI. PTION = ~E : 47000 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0 ! Frmti INQ REQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1423-802-0002-230/9 LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:~SHMAN, ROBERT SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/34S/4~E~ COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACTS B & C MPDAF:BEG AT SE COR TR C,TH RUN WLY ALG S LI TR C 79.43 ET,TH DUE N 69.72 FT~TO ~OB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 ET,TH N 00 DEG 13 ~IN 58 SEC E 19.65 ET,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 8.00 ET,TH N ~0 DEG ].3 MIN 58 SEC E 0.35 ET,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 75.0~ ET,TH S 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC W 19.65 ET,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 ~EC E 8.00 ET,TH S 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC W 0.35 FT TO POB (UNIT 3) (OR 775-2054) tpage]wraPl I ! i roll 109:43:30 am! INUMlV4.26tC3 ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL & ASSESSMENT ( ) ] 06/15/93 09:42 * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED. 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE Poll 109:43:40 am! MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:42 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0002-240/2 MEDORA SUN CORP 6211 SW 45 ST DAVIE,FL 33314-0000 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC COASTAL COVE-UNIT 1- A PART OF TRACT C MPDAF:FROM SE COR OF SD TRACT C RUN W ALG S LI OF SD TRACT C 71.51 FT,TH tN 49.69 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. D.O.Ro CODE 0100 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN VACANT/IMPRV QUAL/CODE * EXEMP ]-423-802-0002-030/7 SPLIT * TAXAB * LAND !MARKET) * IMP~'' ~O~EMENT '~ U * CLASS; SE * ASSESSED ~ION DATE SOLD SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID 14/23S TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. = 47000 = 47000 = 47000 .............................. EXEMPTIONS ........................................ NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmt! INQ REQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1423-802-0002-240/2 LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:MEDORA SUN C RP SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/34S/4! E COASTAL COVE-UNIT 1- A PART OF TRACT C MPDAF:FROM SE COR OF SD TRACT C RUN W ALG S LI OF SD TRACT C 71.51 FT,TH N 49.69 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 75.09 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 SEC E 19.65 FT,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 0.2 SEC W 8.0 FT,TH N 0 MIN 58 SEC E 0.35 FT,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 75.09 F 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC W 19.65 FT,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SE~ FT,TH S 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 W 0.35 FT TO POB (UNIT 4) (0.03 631-1347) I PagelWrapl I I ! 109:44:131 ami I NUMIV4'261C3 ST. LUCiE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL ASSESSMENT ( ) ] 06/15/93 09:43 IN 58 DEG 13 ,TH S E 8.0 ) (OR * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE ' 109: 44:40 amI INUMIV4-26tC3 MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 3401 N A1A CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0002-250/5 SPAGNOLA, MARY M 3401 N A1A FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACT C MPDAF:FROM SE COR TRACT C RUN WLY ADG S LI TRACT C 71.60 FT,TH DUE N 29.34 FT TO POB,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 67.09 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC E OLD ID NO. TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 09:43 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 0100 23 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN VACANT/IMPRV * LAND I IMP SALE QUAL/CODE 00 QUAL SAL * PARENT ID NO. 1423-802-0002-040/0 SPLIT * ............................. EXEMPTIONS .................. R HMSTD 25000 DATE SOLD 09/29/92 V SALE AMT 57000 O.R. BOOK 0809 O.R. PAGE 1263 MAP ID 14/23S TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. (MARKET) = = 47000 = 47000 = 25000 = 22000 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0tFrmti IPage t Wrapl f ! Po11109:45'28 am! INUMIV4-261C3 INQ REQUEST [ ] PARCEL ID [1423-802-0002-250/5 LGAL - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OWNER NAME:SPAGNOLA MA~Y M SECTION/TOWNSHIP/RANGE = 23/31S/40E COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- PART OF TRACT C MPDAF:FROM SE COR TRACT RUN WAY ALG S LI TRACT C 71.60 FT~TH DUE N 29.34 FT TO P~B,TH 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E 67.09 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SE~~ E 20.35 FT,TH N 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC W 8 FT,TH N 00 DEG 13 MIN SEC E 0.35 FT TO C/L WALL,TH S 89 DEG 46 MIN 02 SEC E ALG SD 75.09 FT TO END OF SD WALL,TH S 00 DEG 13 MIN 58 SEC W 20.70 TO POB (UNIT 5) (0.03 AC) (OR 809/1263) ST. LUCIE COUNTY REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL & ASSESSMENT ( ) ] 06/15/93 09:44 58 C/L FT * THIS INFORMATION IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE & NOT WARRANTED. 8101 NO FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE Po11109:45.38 amI INUMIV4-261C3 MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0001-000/1 MELLON, ANDREA 3120 N A1A UNIT 501 FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:45 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UiNIT 1- TRACT A (OR 822-1481) D.O.R. CODE 0000 DATE SOLD 12/16/92 V CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 115000 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0822 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 1481 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTHo 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 107900 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 00 QUAL SAL * ASSESSED~ = 107900 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION~ PARENT ID NO. * TAXA~LE-~ = 107900 ............................ EXEMPTIONS ................ ~I ........................ NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T'01Frmtl IPage I Wrapl I I MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0004-000/2 METZ, GEORGE R & ETHEL M 930 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 Poll 109: 47:49 amI LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 930 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 09:46 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 1 (OR 519-1309) 0100 23 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN 0023298381 VACANT/IMPRV * LAND DATE SOLD 10/01/86 SALE AMT 35000 O.R. BOOK 0519 O.R. PAGE 1309 MAP ID 14./23S TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. 9007 (MARKET) = 55210 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT 77380 QUAL/CODE * CLASS.~ USE = 00 . = OLD ID NO. * EXEM~iTION'~ = 25000 * - .. - ........................ ~XEMP'TIONS ................. = .................... R HMSTD 25000 NOT:H:R EXEMPT STATDS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BDT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE A~D ~OT ~ARRA~TED *** 109: 48:21 ami MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0005-000/9 PFEIFFER, BRENDA S 928 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 2 (OR 549-2558) LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 928 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE 0100 CLASS. USE CODE SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 34S RANGE 40E SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN 500020120970 VACANT/IMPRV * LAND I IMP SALE * QUAL/CODE * CLAS TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 09:47 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) DATE SOLD 07/01/87 SALE AMT 105000 O.R. BOOK 0549 O.R. PAGE 2558 MAP ID 14/23S TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. 4050 (MARKET) = 56700 = 49150 USE = 00 QUAL SAL * ASSE ED = 105850 OLD ID NO. , EXEMpTIoN = PARENT ID NO. , TAXABLE = 1 0 5 8 5 0 ............................... EXEMPTIONS ................. L ....................... NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED TO IFrmt MAST REQUEST ( I.D. (1423-802-0006-000/6 CACCAMO, EUGENE & LAURA 11230 NW 5TH ST PLANTATION, FL 33325-0000 IPagelWrapl i ! i ST. LUClE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER 109:48:58 amI INmqlv4.261c3 TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:47 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT I- LOT 3 (OR 697-10.84) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. 0000 ) PAGE (01) OF 926 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 68000 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0697 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 1084 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND MARKET) = 56700 I IMP SALE * IMPRO~ EMENT = QUAL/CODE ~ CLASS USE 00 QUAL SAL * ASSES ED · EXEMP! ION · TAXABIE ............. EXEMPTIONS ................. DATE SOLD 06/14/90 V 56700 = 56700 NOT:H: W: C: M: *** THIS INFO I° EXEMPT STATUS ~ BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS' SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED T0 I Frmt [ I age I Wrapi i i 09: 49:06 amI I mU lV4. 261c3 MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0007-000/3 BROOKS, JANE M 924 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE, FL 34949-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 924 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 09:47 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 4 (OR 357-2871: 708-0697 ) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. VACANT/IMPRV V VAC SALE QUAL/CODE 01 DISQ SAL 0100 DATE SOLD 09/11/90 V SALE AMT 23 O.R. BOOK 0708 34S O.R. PAGE 0697 40E MAP ID 14/23S 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY 1423802 NOTES YES LENDING INST. * LAND (MARKET) 57330 * IMPR)VEMENT = 66710 * CLAS USE = * ASSE SED = 124040 * EXEM TION = 25500 * TAXA ILE = 98540 ............................. EXEMPTIONS ....................................... R HMSTD 25000 WIDOW 500 NOT'H oR W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmti !page I Wra'Pt I i I 109:50:02 am! I NUMIV4- 261C3 REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0008-000/0 WELLHAM, RONALD A SR WELLHAM, SHIRLEY J 922 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:48 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 922 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 05/25/89 V CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 67000 SECTION 23 O.Ro BOOK 0639 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 1664 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNiT 1- LOT 5 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES 639-1664) LOAN LENDING INST. 0138 VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 57960 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 74380 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 00 QUAL SAL * ASSESSED = 132340 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = 25000 PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 107340 .............................. EXEMPTIONS ......................................... R HMSTD 25000 NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO I'S BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtt !Page I Wrapt I I 09' 50:11 am! I NUMIV4.26 IC3 I.D.(1423-802-0009-000/7 ROSENBERG, MURRAY D & PEARL P ROSENBERG, CARL E & JOAN E 2376 KENILWORTH CLEVELAND HEIGHTS,OH 44108-0000 MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) REQUEST ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:48 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 920 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 04/20/90 V CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 167000 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0689' TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 0178 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 6 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES 689-0178) LOAN 0000016140 LENDING INST. 8053 VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 57960 I IMP SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 54950 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 00 QUAL SAL * ASSESSED = 112910 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 112910 .............................. EXEMPTIONS ................................. NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 109'51:12 amI MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) REQUEST ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:49 I.D.(1423-802-0010-000/7 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) DEKKER, JAMES H & JUNE L 918 JACKSON WAY CTY 918 JACKSON WAY D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 11/01/82 FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0387 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 2676 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 7 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES 387-2676) LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 58590 I IMP SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 83570 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 01 DISQ SAL * ASSESSED = 142160 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = 25000 PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 117160 ............................. EXEMPTIONS ......................................... R HMSTD 25000 NOT:H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** Poll 109:51:22 amI INUMtV4-26 IC3 MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0011-000/4 SNYDER, H T & C G 916 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:50 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 916 JACKSON WAY CTY DoO.R. CODE 0100 CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 100 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0546 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 0199 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 58590 ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 8 (OR 202-980:546-199) DATE SOLD 05/01/87 I IMP SALE * I ~ MPROVEMENT UAL/CODE * CLASS. USE 1 DISQ SAL * ASSESSED OLD NO. * PARENT ID NO. , TAXABLE ............................. EXEMPTIONS ........................ 40290 98880 25000 73880 R HMSTD 25000 NOT'H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01FrmtI MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0012-000/1 KNESPLER, JOSEPH & NORA 914 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE, FL 34949-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:51 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 0100 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 9 (OR 598-2673) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. ) PAGE (01) OF 914 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV V VAC SALE QUAL/CODE 00 QUAL SAL 23 34S 40E 0053 1423802 * LAND * IMPRO~ * CLASS * ASSES~ * EXEMP9 * TAXABI .............................. EXEMPTIONS .................. R HMSTD 25000 DATE SOLD 08/01/88 SALE AMT 60000 O.R. BOOK 0598 O.R. PAGE 2673 MAP ID 14/23S TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. MARKET) = 58590 tEMENT = 93640 USE = ED = 152230 ION = 25000 E = 127230 NOT:H:R W: C- M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** 109: 52:31 am! MAST ST. REQUEST ( ) I .D. ( 1423-802-0024-000/8 MOYER, BRUCE A & AUDREY M 5482 BLUE CHURCH RD COOPERSBURG,PA 18036-0000 LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 913 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 09:51 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 0100 LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 22 (OR 830-523) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. DATE SOLD 03/01/93 V SALE AMT 148000 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0830 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 0523 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 62300 I IMP SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 49560 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE 00 QUAL SAL * ASSESSED = 1]_1860 · EXEMPTION = · TAXABLE = 111860 EXEMPTIONS NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** Po11109:55:41 am! MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) REQUEST ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:54 I.D.(1423-802-0025-000/5 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) SPERANZA, LOUIS D & MARY J 915 JACKSON WAY CTY 9].5 JACKSON WAY D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000' CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 23 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES 248-971) LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 62300 · IMPROVEMENT = 57390 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = · ASSESSED = 119690 · EXEMPTION = 25000 · TAXABLE = 94690 .............. EXEMPTIONS ......................................... 25000 NOT:H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. R HMSTD TO]Frmti ipage t Wrapi I I ! 09:55:50 ami MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0026-000/2 STALLINGS, GEORGE B 917 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * ) PAGE (01) OF 917 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.Ro CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN VACANT/IMPRV QUAL/CODE ...... LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 24 OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. ............................. EXEMPTIONS R HMSTD 25000 TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) 06/15/93 09:54 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 0100 23 34S 40E 0053 1423802 * LAND !~MARKET) * IMPROVEMENT * CLASS USE * ASSE ED * EX ION * TAXAB E DATE SOLD SALE AMT O.R. BOOK O.R. PAGE MAP ID 14/23S TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES 'YES LENDING INST. = 62300 = 65190 = 127490 = 25000 = 102490 NOT:H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01FrmtI MAST REQUEST ( I.D. (1423-802-0027-000/9 SAMUEL, WILLIAM H & CAROLYN A 919 JACKSON WAY FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 I PagelWrapl I I I Poll 109:56:54 ami I NUMIV4'261C3 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) ) * PARCEL hiPSTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:55 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 12.5 (OR 684-1816) OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. 919 JACKSON WAY CTY D.O.R. CODE CLASS. USE CODE SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SPECIAL DIST SUBDIVISION LOAN 29283225 VACANT/IMPRV V VAC SALE QUAL/CODE 00 QUAL SAL R HMSTD 25000 0100 23 34S 40E 0053 1423802 * LAND ( * IMPROV * CLASS. * ASSESS * EXEMPT * TAXABL ....... EXEMPTIONS .................. DATE SOLD 03/28/90 V SALE AMT 55000 O.R. BOOK 0684 iO.R. PAGE 1816 MAP ID 14/23S tAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES 5ENDING INST. 0047 ~ARKET) = 62300 EMENT = 56480 USE = ED = 118780 [ON = 25000 93780 NOT: H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtl I Page I Wrapi I ! 109:57:03 amI MAST REQUEST ( ) I.D. (1423-802-0028-000/6 BRISBOIS, EDWARD & MARY P OBX 4146 FT PIERCE, FL 34948-0000 ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:55 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) 921 JACKSON WAY CTY LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... COASTAL COVE-UNIT 1- LOT 26 (OR 530-2023) SPECIAL DIST 0053 SUBDIVISION 1423802 LOAN 00022121535 D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 02/01/87 CLASS. USE CODE SALE ANT 88000 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0530 TOWNSHIP 345 O.R. PAGE 2023 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/235 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY NOTES YES LENDING INST. 0106 = 62300 = 47590 * LAND (MARKET) * IMPROVEMENT * CLASS. USE * ASSESSED * EXEMPTION * TAXABLE OLD ID NO. PARENT ID NO. VACANT / IMPRV I IMP SALE QUAL/CODE 00 QUAL SAL R HMSTD 109890 25000 84890 ................... EXEMPTIONS ......................................... 25000 NOT'H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS *** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtl IPageiWrapl I I P°11109:58:07 ami INUMIV4'261C3 MAST ST. COUNT APP AIS TRAN-P O UNC REQUEST ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:56 I.D.(1423-802-0029-000/3 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) GATZ, JENNIE H 923 JACKSON WAY CTY 923 JACKSON WAY D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 CLASS. USE CODE SALE ANT SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK' TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 27 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES 201-2788) LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 62300 · IMPROVEMENT = 50370 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = · ASSESSED = 112670 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = 25500 PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 87170 .............................. EXEMPTIONS ......................................... R HMSTD 25000 WIDOW 500 NOT'H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T0 i Frmt t iPage i Wrap I i I ! [09:58:15 am[ INUMIV4-261C3 MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) REQUEST ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:57 I.D.(1423-802-0030-000/3 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) CORBA, PETER & VIVIAN 925 JACKSON WAY CTY 5059 N A1A UNIT B906 D.O.R. CODE 0000 DATE SOLD 06/12/89 V FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 66000 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0641 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 1338 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1-LOT 28 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES 641-1338) LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 56070 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 00 QUAL SAL * ASSE~S~SED = 56070 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 56070 .............................. EXEMPTIONS ......................................... NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtl !pagelWrapl I I 109:59:15 ami MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) REQUEST ( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:57 IOD.(1423-802-0031-000/0 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) PETERLA, BERTHA. 927 JACKSON WAY CTY 927 JACKSON WAY D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 05/01/72 FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 6600 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0202 TOWNSHIP 34S O.Ro PAGE 1668 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT 29 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES 20~2-1668) LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 62300 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 62690 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 01 DISQ SAL * ASSESSED = 124990 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = 25500 PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 99490 .............................. EXEMPTIONS ......................................... R HMSTD 25000 WIDOW 500 NOT:H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED T01Frmtl irage I Wrapl ! ! Poll 109: 59:23 amI INUMlV4-261C3 MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNC ( ) REQUEST ~( ) * PARCEL MASTER SCREEN * 06/15/93 09:58 I.D.(1423-802-0032-000/7 ) PAGE (01) OF 1 TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) FOX, JAMES L & CONSTANCE 929 JACKSON WAY STY 929 JACKSON WAY D.O.R. CODE 0100 DATE SOLD 03/01/87 FT PIERCE,FL 34949-0000 CLASS. USE CODE SALE AMT 125000 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0533 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 1954 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ...... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTH. 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT~ 3'0 (OR SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES 533-1954) LOAN 0440006232241 LENDING INST. 9162 VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 56070 I IMP SALE * IMPROVEMENT = 78560 QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = , 00 QUAL SAL * ASSESSED = 134630 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = 25000 PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 109630 ............................. EXEMPTIONS ......................................... R HMSTD 25000 NOT:H:R W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** T01Frmtl IPageiWrapl I ! P°11110:00:21 ami INUMIV4'261S3 MAST ST. LUCIE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER TRAN-PRO FUNS ( ) I.D.(1423-802-0033-000/4 ) PAGE (01) OF i TAX YEAR(C) 1993 VOID Y/N(N) POWELL, WILLIAM H 931 JACKSON WAY CTY 2 0000 03/0 /72 BARNSBORO,NJ 08080-9631 CLASS. USE CODE SALE ANT 5400 SECTION 23 O.R. BOOK 0200 TOWNSHIP 34S O.R. PAGE 2901 RANGE 40E MAP ID 14/23S LEGAL/PROPERTY DESC ..... SPECIAL DIST 0053 TAX AUTHo 02COUNTY COASTAL COVES-UNIT 1- LOT '31 SUBDIVISION 1423802 NOTES YES LOAN LENDING INST. VACANT/IMPRV * LAND (MARKET) = 57190 V VAC SALE * IMPROVEMENT = QUAL/CODE * CLASS. USE = 00 QUAL SAL * ASSESSED = 57190 OLD ID NO. * EXEMPTION = PARENT ID NO. * TAXABLE = 57190 ............................... EXEMPTIONS .................................. NOT:H: W: C: M: EXEMPT STATUS · ** THIS INFO IS BELIEVED CORRECT BUT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE AND NOT WARRANTED *** [10:00:30 am! I NOMIV4.261C3